A guest-worker state? The declining power and agency of migrant labour in Australia

Abstract

This article presents an historical and comparative analysis of the bargaining power and agency conferred upon migrant workers in Australia under distinct policy regimes. Through an assessment of four criteria – residency status, mobility, skill thresholds and institutional protections – we find that migrant workers arriving in Australia in the period from 1973 to 1996 had high levels of bargaining power and agency. Since 1996, migrant workers’ power and agency has been incrementally curtailed, to the extent that Australia’s labour immigration policy resembles a guest-worker regime where migrants’ rights are restricted, their capacity to bargain for decent working conditions with their employers is truncated and their agency to pursue opportunities available to citizens and permanent residents is diminished. In contrast to recent assessments that Australia’s temporary visa system is working effectively, our analysis indicates that it is failing to protect temporary migrants at work.

JEL Codes: J24, J61, J83

Keywords

Guest workers immigration policy industrial relations migrant workers

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Afonso

Devitt

(2016) Comparative political economy and international migration. Socio-Economic Review 14(3): 591–613.

Anderson

(2010) Migration, immigration controls and the fashioning of precarious workers. Work, Employment and Society 24(2): 300–317.

Australian Bureau of Statistics (2019) Overseas arrivals and departures, Australia. Cat no 3401.0. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

Baird

(2010) Stronger, Simpler, Smarter ESOS: Supporting International Students – Review of the Education Services for Overseas Students (ESOS) Act 2000. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

Baker

Sloan

Robertson

(1994) The Rationale for Australia’s Skilled Immigration Program. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Bureau of Immigration and Population Research.

Baldwin-Edwards

(2011) Labour immigration and labour markets in the GCC countries: national patterns and trends. LSE Global Governance Research Paper. London: London School of Economics.

Bauder

(2006) Labor Movement: How Migration Regulates Labor Markets. New York: Oxford University Press.

Bauder

(2008) Citizenship as capital: the distinction of migrant labor. Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 33(3): 315–333.

Berg

Farbenblum

(2017) Wage Theft in Australia: Findings of the National Temporary Migrant Work Survey. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Migrant Worker Justice Initiative.

10.

Birrell

(1984) A new era in Australian migration policy. International Migration Review 18(1): 65–84.

11.

Birrell

(1998) Skilled migration policy under the coalition. People and Place 6(4): 37–51.

12.

Blainey

(1975) The Tyranny of Distance: How Distance Shaped Australia’s History. 2nd ed. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Macmillan.

13.

Boucher

(2019) Measuring migrant worker rights violations in practice: the example of temporary skilled visas in Australia. Journal of Industrial Relations 61(2): 277–301.

14.

Boucher

Davidson

(2019) The Evolution of the Australian System for Selecting Economic Immigrants. Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute.

15.

Campbell

Tham

(2013) Labour market deregulation and temporary migrant labour schemes: an analysis of the 457 visa program. Australian Journal of Labour Law 26(3): 239–272.

16.

Cangiano

Walsh

(2014) Recruitment processes and immigration regulations: the disjointed pathways to employing migrant carers in ageing societies. Work, Employment and Society 28(3): 372–389.

17.

Carr

(2017) Speech on the Migration Legislation Amendment (2017 Measures No. 4) Regulations, 5 December. Senate Official Hansard. Canberra Commonwealth of Australia, pp. 9734–9735.

18.

Castles

(1988) Australian Public Policy and Economic Vulnerability. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.

19.

Castles

(1985) The guests who stayed – the debate on ‘foreigners policy’ in the German Federal Republic. International Migration Review 19(3): 517–534.

20.

Castles

(1986) Temporary worker programs: mechanisms, conditions, consequences. International Migration Review 20(4): 761–778.

21.

Clibborn

(2015) Why undocumented immigrant workers should have workplace rights. Economic and Labour Relations Review 26(3): 465–473.

22.

Clibborn

(2018) Multiple frames of reference: why international student workers in Australia tolerate underpayment. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Epub ahead of print 12 April. DOI: 10.1177/0143831X18765247.

23.

Clibborn

(2019) It takes a village: civil society regulation of employment standards for temporary migrant workers in Australian horticulture. UNSW Law Journal 42(1): 242–268.

24.

Clibborn

Wright

(2018) Employer theft of temporary migrant workers’ wages in Australia: why has the state failed to act? Economics and Labour Relations Review 29(2): 207–227.

25.

Collins

(1988) Migrant Hands in a Distant Land: Australia’s Post-War Immigration. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Pluto Press.

26.

Committee for Economic Development of Australia (CEDA) (2019) Effects of Temporary Migration: Shaping Australia’s Society and Economy. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Committee for Economic Development of Australia.

27.

Committee to Advise on Australia’s Immigration Policies (1988) Immigration: A Commitment to Australia. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

28.

Cooper

Ellem

(2008) The neoliberal state, trade unions and collective bargaining in Australia. British Journal of Industrial Relations 46(3): 532–554.

29.

Crock

(1998) Immigration and Refugee Law in Australia. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Federation Press.

30.

Crock

(2001) Contract or compact: skilled migration and the dictates of politics and ideology. Georgetown Immigration Law Journal 16(1): 133–154.

31.

Daley

(2019) Immigration and wage growth. Discussant paper presented at Reserve Bank of Australia Conference on Low Wage Growth, Sydney, NSW, Australia, 4–5 April. Grattan Institute. Available at: https://www.rba.gov.au/publications/confs/2019/pdf/rba-conference-2019-brell-dustmann-discussion.pdf (accessed 30 November 2019)

32.

Dauvergne

(2016) The New Politics of Immigration and the End of Settler Societies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

33.

Dauvergne

Marsden

(2014) Beyond numbers versus rights: shifting the parameters of debate on temporary labour migration. Journal of International Migration and Integration 15(3): 525–545.

34.

Davies

ACL

(2014) Migrant workers in agriculture. In: Costello

Freedland

(eds) Migrants at Work: Immigration and Vulnerability in Labour Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 79–97.

35.

Deegan Review (2008) Visa Subclass 457 Integrity Review: Final Report. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Department of Immigration and Citizenship.

36.

Department of Home Affairs (2018a) Changes to the Working Holiday Maker visa program, 7 November. Available at: https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/news-subsite/Pages/2018-Nov/working%20holiday%20maker%20visa%20program.aspx (accessed 14 October 2019).

37.

Department of Home Affairs (2018b) Working Holiday Maker visa program report, 31 December. Available at: https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/research-and-stats/files/working-holiday-report-dec-18.pdf (accessed 14 October 2019).

38.

Department of Home Affairs (2019a) Australian Migration Statistics, 2017–18. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

39.

Department of Home Affairs (2019b) Historical Migration Statistics. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

40.

Department of Home Affairs (n.d.-a) Condition 8104 and 8105 – Work Restrictions. Available at: https://immi.homeaffairs.gov.au/visas/already-have-a-visa/check-visa-details-and-conditions/see-your-visa-conditions?product=500# (accessed 14 October 2019).

41.

Department of Home Affairs (n.d.-b) Condition 8202 – Meet Course Requirements. Available at: https://immi.homeaffairs.gov.au/visas/already-have-a-visa/check-visa-details-and-conditions/see-your-visa-conditions?product=500# (accessed 14 October 2019).

42.

Department of Immigration and Border Protection (2014) Filling the Gaps: Findings from the 2012 Survey of Subclass 457 Employers and Employees. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

43.

Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2007) Response to the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Employment, Workplace Relations and Workforce Participation Inquiry into Workforce Challenges in the Australian Tourism Sector. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

44.

Doyle

Howes

(2015) Australia’s Seasonal Worker Program: Demand-Side Constraints and Suggested Reforms. Washington, DC: World Bank Group.

45.

Dufty

Martin

Zhao

(2019) Demand for Farm Workers: ABARES Farm Survey Results 2018. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Department of Agriculture.

46.

Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) (2016) Report of the Inquiry into the Wages and Conditions of People Working Under the 417 Working Holiday Visa Program. Canberra, ACT: Commonwealth of Australia.

47.

Ferguson

Sherrell

(2019) Overseas Students in Australian Higher Education: A Quick Guide. Parliamentary Library Research Paper. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Parliament of Australia.

48.

Fitzpatrick

(1940) A Short History of the Australian Labour Movement. London: Allen & Unwin.

49.

Geddes

(2003) The Politics of Migration and Immigration in Europe. London: SAGE.

50.

Goldring

Landolt

(2013) Producing and Negotiating Non-Citizenship: Precarious Legal Status in Canada. Toronto, ON, Canada: University of Toronto Press.

51.

Goodwin

Maconachie

(2007) Unpaid entitlement recovery in the federal industrial relations system: strategy and outcomes 1952–95. Journal of Industrial Relations 49(4): 523–544.

52.

Gordon

(2006) Costello rules out importing islanders. The Age, 5 July, p. 6.

53.

Gregory

(2015) The two-step Australian immigration policy and its impact on immigrant employment outcomes. In: Chiswick

Miller

(eds) Handbook of the Economics of International Migration, Volume 1. Oxford: Elsevier, pp. 1421–1443.

54.

Groutsis

(2003) The state, immigration policy and labour market practices: the case of overseas-trained doctors. Journal of Industrial Relations 45(1): 67–86.

55.

Hammar

(1985) European Immigration Policy: A Comparative Study. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

56.

Hardy

Howe

(2009) Partners in enforcement? The new balance between government and trade union enforcement of employment standards in Australia. Australian Journal of Labour Law 22(3): 306–336.

57.

Hawkins

(1991) Critical Years in Immigration: Canada and Australia Compared. 2nd ed. Montreal, QC, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press.

58.

Hollifield

Martin

Orrenius

(2014) Controlling Immigration: A Global Perspective. 3rd ed. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

59.

Holton

Sloan

(1994) Immigration policy – intake and settlement issues. In: Wooden

Holton

Hugo

, et al (eds) Australian Immigration: A Survey of the Issues. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Bureau of Immigration and Population Research, pp. 280–333.

60.

Howe

(2019) A legally constructed underclass of workers? The deportability and limited work rights of international students in Australia and the United Kingdom. Industrial Law Journal 48(3): 416–446.

61.

Howe

Clibborn

Reilly

, et al. (2019) Towards a Durable Future: Tackling Labour Challenges in the Australian Horticulture Industry. Adelaide, SA, Australia: University of Adelaide.

62.

Hugo

(2004) A New Paradigm of International Migration: Implications for Migration Policy and Planning in Australia. Parliamentary Library Research Paper. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Parliament of Australia.

63.

Hunter

Bagshaw

(2017) ‘A new frontier’: the little-known alternative to the 457 foreign worker visa. Sydney Morning Herald, 2 September. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/a-new-frontier-the-littleknown-alternative-to-the-457-foreign-worker-visa-20170901-gy8p0j.html (accessed 30 November 2019).

64.

Junankar

Mahuteau

(2005) Do migrants get good jobs? New migrant settlement in Australia. Economic Record 81(s1): S34–S46.

65.

Jupp

(2007) From White Australia to Woomera: The Story of Australian Immigration. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

66.

McGovern

(2007) Immigration, labour markets and employment relations: problems and prospects. British Journal of Industrial Relations 45(2): 217–235.

67.

Mares

(2016) Not Quite Australian: How Temporary Migration Is Changing the Nation. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Text Publishing.

68.

Markus

Jupp

McDonald

(2009) Australia’s Immigration Revolution. Sydney, NSW: Allen & Unwin.

69.

Martin

(2003) Managing Labour Migration: Temporary Worker Programs for the 21st Century. Geneva: International Labour Organization.

70.

Messina

(2007) The Logics and Politics of Post-WWII Migration to Western Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

71.

Minister for Home Affairs (2016) Upcoming change to the subclass 457 visa (Media release), 16 November. Available at: https://minister.homeaffairs.gov.au/peterdutton/2016/Pages/457-visa-changes.aspx (accessed 14 October 2019).

72.

Mitchell

Arup

Howe

, et al. (2001) Employment protection and employment promotion: the contested terrain of Australian labour law. Public Law and Legal Theory Working Paper. Melbourne: University of Melbourne.

73.

O’Donnell

Mitchell

(2000) Immigrant labour in Australia: the regulatory framework. Centre for Employment and Labour Relations Law Working Paper. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: University of Melbourne.

74.

Papademetriou

Sumption

(2011) Rethinking Points Systems and Employer-Selected Immigration. Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute.

75.

Parkin

Hardcastle

(1994) Immigration policy. In: Parkin

Summers

Woodward

(eds) Government, Politics, Power and Policy in Australia. 5th ed. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Longman Cheshire, pp. 429–446.

76.

Patty

(2019) Promise of training with luxury hotel group entraps visa workers. Sydney Morning Herald, 7 July. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/business/workplace/promise-of-training-with-luxury-hotel-group-entraps-visa-workers-20190620-p51ziq.html (accessed 30 November 2019).

77.

Penninx

Roosblad

(2000) Trade Unions, Immigration and Immigrants in Europe, 1960–1993. New York: Berghahn Books.

78.

Quinlan

Lever-Tracy

(1988) Immigrant workers, trade unions and industrial struggle: an overview of the Australian experience, 1945–85. Economic and Industrial Democracy 9(1): 7–41.

79.

Quinlan

Lever-Tracy

(1990) From labour market exclusion to industrial solidarity: Australian trade union responses to Asian workers, 1830–1988. Cambridge Journal of Economics 14(2): 159–181.

80.

Reilly

(2012) Protecting vulnerable migrant workers: the case of international students. Australian Journal of Labour Law 25(3): 181–208.

81.

Reilly

Howe

van den Broek

, et al. (2018) Working holiday makers in Australian horticulture: labour market effect, exploitation and avenues for reform. Griffith Law Review 27(1): 99–130.

82.

Roach Review (1995) Business temporary entry: future directions. Report by the Committee of Inquiry into the Temporary Entry of Business People and Highly Skilled Specialists. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

83.

Robertson

Runganaikaloo

(2014) Lives in limbo: migration experiences in Australia’s education–migration nexus. Ethnicities 14(2): 208–226.

84.

Ruhs

(2013) The Price of Rights: Regulating International Labor Migration. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

85.

Salter

(1978) Studies in the Immigration of the Highly Skilled. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Australian National University Press.

86.

Sargeant

Tucker

(2009) Layers of vulnerability in occupational safety and health for migrant workers: case studies from Canada and the UK. Policy and Practice in Health and Safety 7(2): 51–73.

87.

Senate Education and Employment References Committee (2016) A National Disgrace: The Exploitation of Temporary Work Visa Holders. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

88.

Sherrell

(2019) Migration–permanent and temporary visa trends. Briefing Book: Key Issues for the 46th Parliament. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Parliament of Australia, pp. 128–131.

89.

Sloan

Kennedy

(1992) Temporary Movements of People to and from Australia. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Bureau of Immigration Research.

90.

Sumption

(2019) Is employer sponsorship a good way to manage labour migration? Implications for post-Brexit migration policies. National Institute Economic Review 248(1): R28–R39.

91.

Tan

Richardson

Lester

, et al. (2009) Evaluation of Australia’s Working Holiday Maker Program. Adelaide, SA, Australia: National Institute for Labour Studies.

92.

Tavan

(2004) The dismantling of the White Australia policy: elite conspiracy or will of the Australian people? Australian Journal of Political Science 39(1): 109–125.

93.

Toh

Quinlan

(2009) Safeguarding the global contingent workforce? Guestworkers in Australia. International Journal of Manpower 30(5): 453–471.

94.

Toner

(2018) A tale of mandarins and lemons: creating the market for vocational education and training. In: Cahill

Toner

(eds) Wrong Way: How Privatisation and Economic Reform Backfired. Carlton, VIC, Australia: La Trobe University Press, pp. 59–84.

95.

Treasury/Department of Home Affairs (2018) Shaping a Nation: Population Growth and Immigration over Time. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.

96.

Underhill

Rimmer

(2016) Layered vulnerability: temporary migrants in Australian horticulture. Journal of Industrial Relations 58(5): 608–626.

97.

Vasta

(2005) Theoretical fashions in Australian immigration research. Centre of Migration, Policy and Society Working Paper. Oxford: University of Oxford.

98.

Velayutham

(2013) Precarious experiences of Indians in Australia on 457 temporary work visas. Economic and Labour Relations Review 24(3): 340–361.

99.

Walsh

(2014) From nations of immigrants to states of transience: temporary migration in Canada and Australia. International Sociology 29(6): 584–606.

100.

Walzer

(1983) Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality. New York: Basic Books.

101.

Watson

Buchanan

Campbell

, et al. (2003) Fragmented Futures: New Challenges in Working Life. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Federation Press.

102.

Woolfson

Fudge

Thörnqvist

(2014) Migrant precarity and future challenges to labour standards in Sweden. Economic and Industrial Democracy 35(4): 695–715.

103.

Wright

(2012) Immigration policy and market institutions in liberal market economies. Industrial Relations Journal 43(2): 110–136.

104.

Wright

(2015) Why do states adopt liberal immigration policies? The policymaking dynamics of skilled visa reform in Australia. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 41(2): 306–328.

105.

Wright

Clibborn

(2017) Back door, side door, or front door: an emerging de-facto low-skilled immigration policy in Australia. Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal 39(1): 165–188.

106.

Wright

Constantin

(2020) Why recruit temporary sponsored skilled migrants? A human capital theory analysis of employer motivations in Australia. Australian Journal of Management. Epub ahead of print. DOI: 10.1177/0312896219895061

107.

Wright

Groutsis

van den Broek

(2017) Employer-sponsored temporary labour migration schemes in Australia, Canada and Sweden: enhancing efficiency, compromising fairness? Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 43(11): 1854–1872.

108.

Yea

Chok

(2018) Unfreedom unbound: developing a cumulative approach to understanding unfree labour in Singapore. Work, Employment and Society 32(5): 925–941.

109.

Zou

(2015) The legal construction of hyper-dependence and hyper-precarity in migrant work relations. International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations 31(2): 141–162.