Depoliticization and responsibilization are two frameworks that have contributed substantially to the analysis of state-society-economy relations under neoliberalism. They have also presented some limitations. The depoliticization literature has not looked into policymakers’ active allocation of responsibility for economic outcomes to individuals. The Foucauldian responsibilization literature has largely overlooked who construct(s) the responsibilization governing technique and the political process through which this technique is produced. I argue that synthesizing the two frameworks can overcome these limitations and improve our ability to analyse the current state of the neoliberal project. I illustrate my argument by analysing the case of a governmental Financial Education Department in Israel. The department was established as a depoliticizing tool in a context of a popular protest that re-politicized economic policy. Its main concern was constructing financially responsible subjects. As political circumstances changed, political support waned and the department stagnated, although it never diminished.
AtkinsonAMessyFA (2013) Promoting financial inclusion through financial education: OECD/INFE evidence, policies and practice. OECD Working Papers on Finance, Insurance and Private Pensions 34. Available at: dx.doi.org/10.1787/5k3xz6m88smp-en (accessed 18 September 2017).
2.
Avigur-Eshel A (2018) Encouraging action in the private sphere: Demand-side practices in the depoliticization of economic policy in Israel. Politics & Policy 46(1): 84–109.
3.
Avigur-Eshel A (forthcoming) Speaking to the outraged: Discursive responses of policy elites to social unrest over economic issues. DOI: 10.1080/19460171.2018.1463857
4.
Bar-Dagan H (interview) (2016) Head of Financial Education Department. Interviewed by author, Jerusalem, 7 December.
5.
BarnettCClokePClarkeNet al. (2011) Globalizing Responsibility: The Political Rationalities of Ethical Consumption.
Oxford:
Wiley-Blackwell.
6.
BerryCHayC (2016)
The great British ‘Rebalancing’ Act: The construction and implementation of an economic imperative for exceptional times. British Journal of Politics and International Relations18(1): 3–25.
7.
BevirM (2011)
Governance and governmentality after neoliberalism. Policy & Politics39 (4): 457–471.
8.
Breger BushS (2016)
Risk markets and the landscape of social change. International Journal of Political Economy45(2): 124–146.
9.
BrownBJBakerS (2013) Responsible Citizens: Individuals, Health and Policy under Neoliberalism.
London:
Anthem Press.
10.
BurnhamP (2001)
New labour and the politics of depoliticisation. British Journal of Politics and International Relations3(2): 127–149.
11.
Calcalist (2011) Start learning: The Ministry of Finance prepares a comprehensive program for promoting financial education. Calcalist, 28 November. Available at: www.calcalist.co.il/money/articles/0,7340,L-3553358,00.html (accessed 18 September 2017) [Hebrew].
Central Bureau of Statistics (Israel) (2012) Financial Literacy Survey: Knowledge, Opinions and Behavior in Financial Issues. Available at: www.cbs.gov.il/www/hodaot2012n/25_12_297b.doc (accessed 18 September 2017) [Hebrew].
ClarkeC (2015)
Learning to fail: Resilience and the empty promise of financial literacy education. Consumption, Markets & Culture18(3): 257–276.
16.
Committee for Socio-economic Change (2011) Towards the Shaping of a More Just Israeli Society Available at: www.teammanuel2011.org.il/general/fullreport (accessed 18 September 2017) [Hebrew].
17.
EitanY (interview) (2016) Deputy Head of National Economic Council. Interviewed by author, Jerusalem, 14 December.
18.
EtzioniA (2018) Happiness Is the Wrong Metric: A Liberal Communitarian Response to Populism.
Springer. DOI: 10.1007%2F978-3-319-69623-2
19.
FilcDDavidovitchN (2009) A critical analysis of choice in health: The Israeli case. In: ECPR joint sessions, Lisbon, Portugal, 14–19 April.
20.
FilcDRamU (2017)
The 14th of July of Daphni Leef: Class and social protest in Israel. Capital & Class41(1): 69–90.
21.
Financial Education Department (2012) National Strategy for the Promotion of Financial Education in Israel. Available at: news.neemanim.co.il/Uploads/Docs/5596.pdf (accessed 18 September 2017) [Hebrew].
22.
FinlaysonA (2009)
Financialisation, financial literacy and asset-based welfare. British Journal of Politics and International Relations11(3): 400–421.
23.
FlindersMBullerJ (2006)
Depoliticisation: Principles, tactics and tools. British Politics1(3): 293–318.
24.
FlindersMWoodM (2015) Depoliticisation governance and the state. In: FlindersMWoodM (eds) Tracing the Political: Depoliticisation, Governance and the State.
Bristol:
Policy Press, pp.1–20.
25.
FosterEAKerrPByrneC (2014)
Rolling back to roll forward: Depoliticisation and the extension of government. Policy & Politics42(2): 225–241.
26.
GaborDBrooksS (2017)
The digital revolution in financial inclusion: International development in the fintech era. New Political Economy22(4): 423–436.
27.
GadasiN (Interview) (2016) Ex-head of Financial Education Department. Interviewed by author, Jerusalem, 23 November.
28.
GieslerMVeresiuE (2014)
Creating the responsible consumer: Moralistic governance regimes and consumer subjectivity. Journal of Consumer Research41(3): 840–857.
HaOtzar Sheli [my treasure] (n.d) Available at www.haotzarsheli.mof.gov.il (accessed 18 September 2017) [Hebrew].
33.
HayC (2004)
The normalizing role of rationalist assumptions in the institutional embedding of neoliberalism. Economy and Society33(4): 500–527.
34.
HayC (2007) Why We Hate Politics.
Cambridge:
Polity.
35.
HaywardCLukesS (2008)
Nobody to shoot? Power, structure and agency: A dialogue. Journal of Power1(1): 5–20.
36.
KettellS (2008)
Does depoliticisation work? Evidence from Britain’s membership of the Exchange Rate Mechanism, 1990-92. The British Journal of Politics & International Relations10(4): 630–648.
37.
KingdonJW (2011) Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies.
Boston:
Longman.
LangleyP (2007)
Uncertain subjects of Anglo-American financialization. Cultural Critique65(1): 67–91.
42.
LemkeT (2001)
‘The birth of Bio-Politics’: Michel Foucault’s lecture at the Collège de France on neo-liberal governmentality. Economy and Society30(2): 190–207.
43.
MamanDRosenhekZ (2011) The Israeli Central Bank – Political Economy, Global Logics and Local Actors.
New York:
Routledge.
44.
MandelkernR (2015)
What made economists so politically influential? Governance related ideas and institutional entrepreneurship in the economic liberalisation of Israel and beyond. New Political Economy20(6): 924–942.
45.
MarronD (2014) ‘
Informed, educated and more confident’: Financial capability and the problematization of personal finance consumption. Consumption, Markets & Culture17(5): 491–511.
46.
Ministry of Finance (2011) Finance minister announced today the establishment of a Financial Education Department in Israel. Press release. Available at: mof.gov.il/releases/documents/2011-3077.doc (accessed 18 September 2017) [Hebrew].
RoseNO'MalleyPValverdeM (2006)
Governmentality. Annual Review of Law and Social Science2: 83–104.
53.
RosenhekZShalevM (2014)
The political economy of Israel’s ‘Social Justice’ protests: A class and generational analysis. Contemporary Social Science9: 31–48.
54.
SarigO(interview) (2017) Ex-Head of Capital Markets, Insurance and Savings Division. Interviewed by author, Herzliya, 1 June.
ShalevM (1998)
Have globalization and liberalization ‘normalized’ Israel’s political economy?Israel Affairs5 (2-3): 121–155.
58.
ShamirR (2008)
The age of responsibilization: On market-embedded morality. Economy and Society37 (1): 1–19.
59.
State of Israel (2005) Enhancement of competitiveness and reduction of concentration and conflict of interest in Israel’s Capital Market Law. Available at: www.knesset.gov.il/Laws/Data/law/2024/2024.pdf (accessed 18 September 2017) [Hebrew].
60.
TalshirG (2014)
The social protest from the perspective of the Israeli democracy’s crisis: Between economy, politics and identity. Politika23: 5–46.
Van der ZwanN (2014)
Making Sense of Financialization. Socio-Economic Review12(1): 99–129.
63.
WatsonM (2010)
House price Keynesianism and the contradictions of the modern investor subject. Housing Studies25 (3): 413–426.
64.
WilliamsT (2007)
Empowerment of whom and for what: Financial literacy education and the new regulation of consumer financial services. Law & Policy29(2): 226–256.
65.
WillisLE (2017)
Finance-informed citizens, citizen-informed finance: An essay occasioned by the international handbook of financial literacy. Journal of Social Science Education16(4): 16–27.
66.
WoodM (2015)
Depoliticisation, resilience and the Herceptin post‐code lottery crisis: Holding back the tide. British Journal of Politics International Relations17(4): 644–664.
