Wage differentials between conventional firms and non-worker cooperatives: Analysis of evidence from France

Abstract

The aim of this article is to investigate the wage differentials between conventional firms and non-worker cooperatives, which has seldom been done in the literature to date. Using French administrative data, the determinants of these wage differentials are analysed. This investigation is carried out across all industries and is then repeated for the banking industry. Taking all industries into account, conventional firms offer lower wages than cooperatives. Most of this pay gap is explained by differences in the characteristics of the employees, jobs and companies. If the focus is narrowed to firms in the banking industry only, it becomes clear that conventional firms pay higher wages than cooperatives but that this gap is explained solely by differences in characteristics. However, their impact is weakened somewhat by differences in the value attributed to these characteristics, which work in favour of employees in cooperatives.

Keywords

Non-worker cooperatives conventional firms wage differential France banking industry

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akella

Greenbaum

(1988) Saving and loan ownership structure and expense-preference. Journal of Banking and Finance 12: 419–437.

Barlett

Cable

Estrin

et al. (1992) Labor managed cooperatives and private firms in North Central Italy: An empirical comparison. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 46(1): 103–118.

Becchetti

Castriota

Tortia

(2013) Productivity, wages and intrinsic motivations. Small Business Economics 41: 379–399.

Ben-Ner

Ellman

(2013) The contributions of behavioural economics to understanding and advancing the sustainability of worker cooperatives. Journal of Entrepreneurial and Organizational Diversity 2(1): 75–100.

Bisault L (2012) L’échelle des salaires est plus resserrée dans l’économie sociale. Insee Première 1390, February.

Blinder

(1973) Wage discrimination: Reduced form and structural estimates. Journal of Human Resources 8(4): 436–455.

Bonin JT, Jones DC and Putterman L (1993) Theoretical and empirical studies of producer cooperatives: Will ever the Twain meet? Journal of Economic Literature 31(3): 1290–1320.

Boose

(1990) Agency theory and alternative predictions for life insurers: An empirical test. The Journal of Risk and Insurance 57(3): 499–518.

Bossler

Schild

(2015) The employment structure of cooperative banks – A test of institutional hypotheses. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 87(1): 79–92.

10.

Burdin G (2013) Equality Under Threat by the Talented: Evidence from Worker-Managed Firms. Working paper n. 694. Universita di Siena, Siena, Italy.

11.

Burdín

Dean

(2009) New evidence on wages and employment in worker cooperatives compared with capitalist firms. Journal of Comparative Economics 37(4): 517–533.

12.

Clemente

Diaz-Foncea

Marcuello

et al. (2012) The wage gap between cooperatives and capitalist firms: Evidence from Spain. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 83(3): 337–356.

13.

Cook

(1994) The role of management behavior in agricultural cooperatives. Journal of Agricultural Cooperation 9: 42–58.

14.

Coop FR (2016) Panorama sectoriel des entreprises coopératives. Available at: http://www.entreprises.coop/images/documents/outilscom/panorama2016/coopfr-panorama-2016-web.pdf (accesseed March 2016).

15.

Dimaggio

Powell

(1983) The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Journal of Sociology 48(2): 147–160.

16.

Doeringer

Piore

(1971) Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis, Lexington, MA: Heath.

17.

Fama

Jensen

(1983a) Separation of ownership and control. The Journal of Law and Economics 26(2): 301–325.

18.

Fama

Jensen

(1983b) Agency problems and residual claims. The Journal of Law and Economics 26(2): 327–349.

19.

Feng L and Hendrikse G (2009) CEO compensation in cooperatives versus publicly listed firms. Contributed Paper prepared for presentation at the International Association of Agricultural Economists Conference, Beijing, China, 16–22 August.

20.

Feng L and Hendrikse GWJ (2012) Chain Interdependencies, Measurement Problems, and Efficient Governance Structure: Cooperatives versus Publicly Listed Firms. European Review of Agricultural 39(2): 241–255.

21.

Fonteyne W (2007) Cooperative Banks in Europe – Policy Issues. IMF Working Paper 07/159, International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC USA.

22.

Gorton

Schmid

(1999) Corporate governance, ownership dispersion and efficiency: Empirical evidence from Austrian cooperative banking. Journal of Corporate Finance 5: 119–140.

23.

Gueslin

(1998) L’invention de L’économie Sociale, Paris: Economica.

24.

Gurtner

Jaeger

Ory

J-N

(2002) Le statut de coopérative est-il source d’efficacité dans le secteur bancaire? Revue D’économie Financière 67(3): 133–163.

25.

Hansmann

(1999) Cooperative firms in theory and practice. The Finnish Journal of Business Economic (LTA) 4: 387–403.

26.

Hueth

Marcoul

(2009) Incentive pay for CEOs in cooperative firms. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 91(5): 1218–1223.

27.

International Labor Organization (2013) Statistics on cooperatives, room document 6. In: Nineteenth international conference of labour statisticians, Geneva, Swiss, 2–11 October.

28.

Jeantet

(2006) Economie Sociale. La Solidarité au Défi de L’efficacité, Paris: La Documentation Française.

29.

Jensen

Meckling

(1976) Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure. Journal of Financial Economics 3: 305–360.

30.

Jossa

(2009) Alchian and Demsetz’s critique of the cooperative firm thirty-seven years after. Metroeconomica 60(4): 686–714.

31.

Juvin

(2005) Les restructurations bancaires en Europe: Les banques coopératives. Revue d’économie Financière 78(1): 181–206.

32.

Kopel

Marini

(2014) Strategic delegation in consumer cooperatives under mixed oligopoly. Journal of Economics 113: 275–296.

33.

Kroll

Wright

Theerathorn

(1993) Whose interests do hired top managers pursue? An examination of select mutual and stock life insurers. Journal of Business Research 26: 133–148.

34.

Leete L (2006) Work in the nonprofit sector. In: Steinberg R and Powell W (eds) The Nonprofit Sector Research Handbook. 2nd ed. New Haven: Yale University Press, pp.159–179.

35.

Lerman Z and Parliament C (1991) Financing of growth in agricultural cooperatives. Staff Paper 91-33. Department of Agriculture and Applied Economics, University of Minnesota, Saint Paul, Minnesota.

36.

Mäkinen

Jones

(2015) Comparative efficiency between cooperative, saving and commercial banks in Europe using the frontier approach. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 86(3): 401–420.

37.

Mester

(1993) Efficiency in the savings and loan industry. Journal of Banking and Finance 17: 267–286.

38.

Miller

(1941) Wages and hours in consumers’ cooperatives in Great Britain and the United States. Quarterly Journal of Economics 55: 294–305.

39.

Novkovic

(2008) Defining the cooperative difference. Journal of Socio-economics 37: 2168–2177.

40.

Oaxaca

(1973) Male-female wage differentials in urban labor market. International Economic Review 14(3): 693–709.

41.

Oaxaca

Ransom

(1999) Identification in detailed wage decomposition. Review of Economics and Statistics 81(1): 154–157.

42.

Ory

J-N

Lemzeri

(2012) Efficiency and hybridization in cooperative banking: The French case. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 83(2): 215–250.

43.

Pencavel

Pistaferri

Schivardi

(2006) Wages, employment, and capital in capitalist and worker-owned firms. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 60: 23–44.

44.

Pencavel JH (2012) Worker Cooperatives and Democratic Governance. Discussion Paper Series. Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit no. 6932, Bonn, Germany.

45.

Pérotin V (2012) The performance of worker cooperatives. In: Battilani P and Schroeter H (eds) A Special Kind of Business: the Cooperative Movement 1950–2010… and Beyond. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 195–221.

46.

Pérotin

(2014) Worker cooperatives: Good, sustainable jobs in the community. Journal of Entrepreneurial and Organizational Diversity 2(2): 34–47.

47.

Preston

(1989) The nonprofit worker in a for-profit world. Journal of Labor Economics 7(4): 438–463.

48.

Rasmusen

(1988) Mutual banks and stock banks. The Journal of Law and Economics 31(2): 395–421.

49.

Roelants B, Hyungsik E and Terrasi E (2014) Cooperatives and Employment: A Global Report. CICOPA (Brusells, Belgium) and Desjardins Group (Lévis, Canada).

50.

Siversten

(1996) Governance issues seen from a management perspective. Review of International Co-operation 89(4): 34–36.

51.

Smith SC and Rothbaum J (2013) Cooperatives in a Global Economy: Key Issues, Recent Trends, and Potential for Development. IIEP-WP-2013-6. Institute for International Economic Policy, Bonn, Germany.

52.

Vitaliano

(1983) Cooperative enterprises: An alternative conceptual basis for analyzing a complex institution. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 65(5): 1078–1083.

53.

Ward

(1958) The firm in Illyria: Market syndicalism. American Economic Review 48(4): 566–589.

54.

Yun

M-S

(2005) A simple solution to the identification problem in detailed wage decomposition. Economic Inquiry 43(4): 766–772. with Erratum in Economic Inquiry 2006; 44(1): 198.

55.

Zamagni

(2012) Interpreting the roles and economic importance of cooperative enterprises in a historical perspective. Journal of Entrepreneurial and Organizational Diversity 1: 21–36.