Looking for European solutions. Trade unions in Central and Eastern Europe striving for cross-border solidarity

Abstract

German

French

This article deals with the dilemmas faced by trade unions from Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) in the context of their relations with western European (EU-15) unions and the European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC). The issue of cross-border solidarity is re-examined, taking into account its historical meanings as well as current developments under the pressures of globalisation and EU integration. The article analyses key factors affecting East–West trade union relations – different views within the ETUC, discontinuities in European social dialogue, challenges faced by European works councils and the uncertain future of transnational company agreements. Major dilemmas CEE unions cope with vis-à-vis their western counterparts are outlined. The question of how to achieve a common interest platform for trade unions from Central and Eastern Europe and from western Europe is raised, followed by a suggestion that ‘downward convergence’ in industrial relations is bringing the two regions closer.

Keywords

Trade unions Central and Eastern Europe ETUC European social dialogue European Works Councils transnational company agreements

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adamczyk

(2011) Dla kogo europejskie rady zakładowe? Dialog. Pismo dialogu społecznego 2: 17–22.

Adamczyk

Surdykowska

(2016) European Framework Agreements – an under-appreciated opportunity for trade unions to escape the trap of globalisation. In: Carby Hall

Rycak

(eds) Trade unions and non-union employee representation in Europe: the current state of play and prospects for the future. Warsaw: CH Beck, pp. 328–339.

Adamczyk

(2018) Inside the trade union family: the ‘two worlds’ within the European Trade Union Confederation. European Journal of Industrial Relations 24(2): 179–192.

Banyuls

Haipeter

Neumann

(2008) European Works Council at General Motors Europe: bargaining efficiency in regime competition? Industrial Relations Journal 39(6): 532–547.

Bernaciak

(2016) Polish trade unions and social dumping debates: between a rock and a hard place. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 22(4): 505–519.

Biagi

(1999) The role of social partners in Europe: from dialogue to partnership. Comparative Labour Law and Policy Journal 20(3): 485–496.

Bieler

Erne

(2015) Transnational solidarity? The European working class in the eurozone crisis. In: Panitch

Albo

(eds) Transforming classes, Socialist Register. London: Merlin Press, pp. 154–178.

Bohle

Greskovits

(2012) Capitalist diversity on Europe’s periphery. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Breitenfellner

(1997) Global unionism: A potential player. International Labour Review 136(4): 531–555.

10.

Compa

(2001) NAFTA’s labor side agreement and international labor solidarity. In: Waterman

Wills

(eds) Place, Space and the New Labour Internationalism. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, pp. 147–163.

11.

Czarzasty J (ed.) (2014) Rokowania zbiorowe w cieniu globalizacji: rola i miejsce związków zawodowych w korporacjach ponadnarodowych. Warsaw: Scholar.

12.

Czarzasty

Mrozowicki

(2018) Is a new paradigm needed? A commentary on the analysis by Sławomir Adamczyk. European Journal of Industrial Relations 24(2): 193–199.

13.

Degryse

(2011) European Social Dialogue: State of Play and Prospects. Brussels: OSE.

14.

Degryse

Tilly

(2013) 1973–2013: 40 Years of History of the European Trade Union Confederation. Brussels: ETUI.

15.

ETUC (2017) For a common strategy on low and minimum wages (Resolution 15–16 March). Available at: https://www.etuc.org/sites/default/files/document/files/etuc_resolution_for_a_common_strategy_on_low_and_minimum_wages_en_1.pdf (accessed 3 April 2020).

16.

ETUC (2016) Roadmap on Transnational Company agreements: Progressing towards an Optional Legal Framework (Resolution, 8–9 June). Available at: https://www.etuc.org/sites/default/files/document/files/etuc_resolution_roadmap_on_transnational_company_agreements_en.pdf (accessed 3 April 2020).

17.

ETUI and ETUC (2019) Benchmarking Working Europe. Brussels: ETUI.

18.

ETUC, UNICE, CEEP (2001) Joint contribution by the social partners to the Laeken European Council (7 December). Available at: http://resourcecentre.etuc.org/linked_files/documents/Declaration%20-%20Laeken%20summit%20EN.pdf (accessed 3 April 2020).

19.

Eurostat (2019) Employment in foreign controlled enterprises. Available at: https://appsso.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/nui/show.do?dataset=egi_em1&lang=en (accessed 3 April 2020).

20.

Galgóczi

(2003) The impact of multinational enterprises on the corporate culture and on industrial relations in Hungary. SEER-South-East Europe Review for Labour and Social Affairs 6(1/2): 27–44.

21.

Gallin

(2000) Trade Unions and NGOs: A Necessary Partnership for Social Development (No. 1). Geneva: United Nations Research Institute for Social Development.

22.

Gardawski

(2009) Świat pracy a fordyzm i postfordyzm. In: Gardawski

(ed.) Polacy pracujący a kryzys fordyzmu. Warsaw: Wyd. Naukowe Scholar, pp. 52−64.

23.

Ghigliani

(2005) International trade unionism in a globalizing world: a case study of new labour internationalism. Economic and Industrial Democracy 26(3): 359–382.

24.

Gradev

(2005) Social Dialogue and Trade Unions in Enlarging Europe: Losers among Winners? In: Dimitrova

Vilrokx

(eds) Trade Union Strategies in Central and Eastern Europe: Towards Decent Work. Geneva: ILO, pp. 229–264.

25.

Henning

(2015) Not dominant but existent: Involvement of trade unions from EU member states in European trade union federations. In: Landgraf

Pleines

(eds) Interest Representation and Europeanization of Trade Unions from EU Member States of the Eastern Enlargement. Stuttgart: Ibidem Press, pp. 73–112.

26.

Hilary

(2014) European trade unions and free trade: Between international solidarity and perceived self-interest. Globalizations 11(1): 47–57.

27.

Hyman

(1991) Trade unions and the disaggregation of the working class. In: Regini

(ed.) The Future of Labour Movements. London: Sage, pp. 150–168.

28.

Hyman

(2002) The international labour movement on the threshold of two centuries; agitation, organisation, bureaucracy, diplomacy. Paper presented at the workshop ‘The International Labour Movement on the Threshold of Two Centuries’, Stockholm, 24–25 October 2002.

29.

Hyman

(2005) Shifting dynamics in international trade unionism: agitation, organisation, bureaucracy, diplomacy. Labor History 46(2): 137–154.

30.

Hyman

(2011) The elusive search for trade union revitalisation. Paper presented at the seminar ‘Revitalisation of trade unions in Poland in the European context’, Jabłonna, 24 May 2011.

31.

Iankova

Turner

(2004) Building the New Europe: western and eastern roads to social partnership. Industrial Relations Journal 35(1): 76–92.

32.

Jagodziński

(2011) EWCs after 15 years—success or failure? Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 17(2): 203–216.

33.

Köhler

González Begega

Aranea

(2015) Three decades of European works councils: a quantitative evaluation. Warsaw Forum of Economic Sociology 6(1(11)): 49–74.

34.

Lendvai

(2004) The weakest link? EU accession: Dialoguing EU and post-communist social policy. Journal of European Social Policy 14(3): 319–333.

35.

Leonardi

Pedersini

(2018) Multi-Employer Bargaining Under Pressure: Decentralisation Trends in Five European Countries. Brussels: ETUI.

36.

Levinson

(1972) International Trade Unionism. London: Routledge.

37.

Mählmeyer

Rampeltshammer

Hertwig

(2017) European works councils during the financial and economic crisis: Activation, stagnation or disintegration? European Journal of Industrial Relations 23(3): 225–242.

38.

Meardi

(2002) The Trojan Horse for the Americanization of Europe? Polish industrial relations towards the EU. European Journal of Industrial Relations 8(1): 77–99.

39.

Meardi

(2012) Social Failures of EU Enlargement: A Case of Workers Voting with their Feet. New York: Routledge.

40.

Moody

(1997) Workers in a Lean World: Unions in the International Economy. London: Verso Books.

41.

Muir

(2018) Drawing positive lessons from the presence of ‘the social’ outside of EU social policy stricto sensu. European Constitutional Law Review 14(1): 75–95.

42.

Müller

Platzer

(2003) European works councils: a new mode of EU regulation and the emergence of a European multi-level structure of workplace industrial relations. In: Keller

Platzer

(eds) Industrial Relations and European Integration – Trans- and Supranational Developments and Prospects. Aldershot, UK; Burlington, VT: Ashgate, pp. 58–84.

43.

Müller

Platzer

Rüb

(2010) Transnational company policy and coordination of collective bargaining: New challenges and roles for European industry federations. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 16(4): 509–524.

44.

Müller

Vandaele

Waddington

(eds) (2019) Collective Bargaining in Europe: Towards an Endgame. Brussels: ETUI.

45.

Munck

(2002) Globalisation and Labour. London: Zed.

46.

Myant

(2010) Trade Unions in the Czech Republic. Brussels: ETUI.

47.

Nölke

Vliegenthart

(2009) Enlarging the varieties of capitalism: The emergence of dependent market economies in East Central Europe. World Politics 61(4): 670–702.

48.

Pernicka

Glassner

Dittmar

(2017) When does solidarity end? Transnational solidarity during and after the crisis–the GM/Opel case revisited. Economic and Industrial Democracy 38(3): 375–399.

49.

Rapacki R (ed.) (2019) Diversity of Patchwork Capitalism in Central and Eastern Europe. London; New York: Routledge.

50.

Royle

Cavallini

Gold

Senatori

(2016) The effects of national institutional contexts and the recast directive on the European Works Council at UniCredit. European Journal of Industrial Relations 22(2): 115–130

51.

Sapir

(2006) Globalization and the reform of European social models. Journal of Common Market Studies 44(2): 369–390.

52.

Saward

(2010) The Representative Claim. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

53.

Scharpf

(2010) The asymmetry of European integration, or why the EU cannot be a ‘social market economy’. Socio-Economic Review 8(2): 211–250.

54.

Schmalz

Ludwig

Webster

(2018) The power resources approach: developments and challenges. Global Labour Journal 9(2): 113–134.

55.

Seelinger

(2019) Trade union politics as a countermovement? A Polanyian perspective. Culture, Practice & Europeanization 4(1): 5–23.

56.

Schmitter

Streeck

(1981) The organization of business interests: A research design to study the associative action of business in the advanced industrial societies of Western Europe. Discussion Paper IIM/LMP 81/13. Berlin: IIM/LMP.

57.

Streeck

(1997) Neither European nor works councils: a reply to Paul Knutsen. Economic and Industrial Democracy 18(2): 325–337.

58.

Surdykowska

(2016) Social dumping or a lack of willingness to establish common social standards? The Case of European Transnational Road Freight Transport. In: Perulli

(ed.) L’Idea di diritto del lavoro, oggi. In ricordo di Giorgio Ghezzi. Milan: Wolters Kluwer/CEDAM, pp. 159–169.

59.

Tholen

(2017) Labour Relations in Central Europe: The Impact of Multinationals’ Money. Aldershot, UK; Burlington, VT: Ashgate.

60.

Trappmann

(2013) Fallen Heroes in Global Capitalism: Workers and the Restructuring of the Polish Steel Industry. Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan

61.

Van der Linden

(2016) Global labour: a not so grand finale and perhaps a new beginning. Global Labour Journal 7(2): 201–210.

62.

Vaughan-Whitehead

(2003) EU Enlargement Versus Social Europe? Uncertain Future of the European Social Model. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

63.

Waddington

(2011) European Works Councils. A Transnational Industrial Relations Institution in the Making. New York; Abingdon: Routledge.

64.

Waterman

(2001) Globalization, Social Movements, and the New Internationalism. London; New York: A&C Black.

65.

Zahn

(2017) New Labour Laws in Old Member States: Trade Union Responses to European Enlargement. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.