In this article, I draw on case study evidence to assess different aspects of the representativeness of European Works Councils. First, I consider how representativeness is framed by external sources of legitimation, such as the legal framework and the founding agreements. Second, I examine the internal legitimacy that can be derived from their membership. Third, I explore the reciprocal construction of legitimacy through linkages with local employee representation structures. Finally, I discuss their role in relation to trade unions and the further Europeanization of industrial relations.
AlesEDufresneA (2012) Transnational collective bargaining: Another (problematic) fragment of the European multi-level industrial relations system. European Journal of Industrial Relations18(2): 95–105.
2.
BéthouxÉ (2004) Les comités d’entreprise européens en quête de légitimité. Travail et Emploi98: 21–35.
3.
Da CostaIPulignanoVRehfeldtUTelljohannV (2012) Transnational negotiations and the Europeanization of industrial relations: Potential and obstacles. Transfer18(2): 123–137.
4.
De SpiegelaereSJagodzinskiR (2016) European Works Councils and SE Works Councils in 2015: Facts and Figures. Brussels: ETUI.
5.
DølvikJE (1999) An Emerging Island? ETUC, Social Dialogue and the Europeanisation of the Trade Unions in the 1990s. Brussels: ETUI.
6.
DorssemontFKerckhofsP (2015) Linking Information and Consultation Procedures at Local and European Level. Dublin: Eurofound.
7.
DufourCHegeA (2010) Légitimité des acteurs collectifs et renouveau syndical. Revue de l’IRES65: 67–85.
8.
HalevyNBersonYGalinskyAD (2011) The mainstream is not electable: When vision triumphs over representativeness in leader emergence and effectiveness. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin37(7): 893–904.
9.
HannD (2010) The continuing tensions between European Works Councils and trade unions: A comparative study of the financial sector. Transfer16(4): 525–540.
10.
HegeA (2000) La représentativité syndicale, sa reconnaissance, son renouvellement. Chronique internationale de l’IRES66: 113–123.
11.
HegeADufourH (1995) Decentralization and legitimacy in employee representation: A Franco-German comparison. European Journal of Industrial Relations1(1): 83–97.
12.
HegeADufourCKahmann (2016) La loi du 20 août 2008 et les fondements de la représentation syndicale. Revue de l’IRES87(4): 95–123.
13.
HertwigMPriesLRampeltshammerL (2009) European Works Councils in Complementary Perspectives. Brussels: ETUI.
14.
HertwigMPriesLRampeltshammerL (2011) Stabilizing effects of European Works Councils: Examples from the automotive industry. European Journal of Industrial Relations17(3): 209–226.
15.
HoffmannJHoffmannRKirton-DarlingJRampeltshammerL (2002) (eds) The Europeanisation of Industrial Relations in a Global Perspective: A Literature Review. Dublin: European Foundation.
16.
HymanR (1997) The future of employee representation. British Journal of Industrial Relations35(7): 309–326.
17.
JacquierJP (1996) Les Chemins possibles du comité d’entreprise européen. Droit Social12: 1081–1085.
18.
JagodzinskiR (2012) European Works Councils and transational company agreements - balancing on the thin line between effective consultation and ovrestepping competences. In: SchömannIJagodzinskiRBoniGClauwaertSGlassnerVJaspersT (eds) Transnational Collective Bargaining at Company Level. A New Component of European Industrial Relations?Brussels: ETUI.
19.
KerckhofsP (2006) EWC Facts and Figures. Brussels: ETUI.
20.
KerckhofsP (2007) Evaluating the development of European Works Councils: An analysis of case study evidence. PhD Thesis, Manchester Business School, Manchester.
21.
KerckhofsP (2015) European Works Council Developments before, during and after the Crisis. Dublin: Eurofound.
22.
KittnerM (1997) Arbeits- und Sozialordnung. Cologne: Bund Verlag.
23.
KotthoffH (1994) Betriebsräte und Bürgerstatus. Wandel und Kontinuität betrieblicher Mitbestimmung. München und Mering: Rainer Hampp Verlag.
24.
KrögerS (2013) Creating a European demos? The representativeness of European Umbrella Organisations. European Integration35(5): 583–600.
25.
LecherW (1999) Resources of the European Works Council: Empirical knowledge and prospects. Transfer5(3): 278–301.
26.
LecherWNagelBPlatzerHW (1999) The Establishment of European Works Councils: From Information Committee to Social Actor. Aldershot: Ashgate.
27.
LecherWPlatzerHWRübSWeinerKP (2002) European Works Councils: Negotiated Europeanisation, between Statutory Framework and Social Dynamics. Aldershot: Ashgate.
28.
Lo FaroA (2012) Bargaining in the shadow of ‘optional frameworks’? The rise of transnational collective agreements and EU law. European Journal of Industrial Relations18(2): 153–165.
29.
MansbridgeJR (1999) Should blacks represent blacks and women represent women? A contingent ‘yes’. Journal of Politics61(3): 628–637.
30.
MansbridgeJR (2003) Rethinking representation. American Political Science Review97(4): 515–528.
31.
MarginsonPSissonK (2004) Industrial relations and European integration: Patterns, dynamics and limits of transactionalisation. In: LecherWPlatzerHW (eds) European Union: European Industrial Relations?London: Routledge, pp. 81–117.
32.
MarginsonPGilmanMJacobiOKriegerH (1998) Negotiating European Works Councils: An Analysis of Agreements under Article 13. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
33.
MisK (2015) Europäische Betriebsräte in Polen: Ein Weg zur Europäisierung nationaler und betreiblicher Arbeitsbeziehungen?Baden-Baden: Nomos.
34.
MoureauMA (2001) L’implication de travailleurs dans la société européenne. Droit Social11: 967–976.
35.
MüllerTPlatzerHW (2003) European Works Councils: A new mode of EU regulation and the emergence of a European multi-level-structure of workplace industrial relations. In: KellerBPlatzerHW (eds) Industrial Relations and European Integration. Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 58–84.
36.
MüllerTRübS (2007) Coming of age: The development of a collective identity in European Works Councils. In: WhittallMKnudsenHHuijgenF (eds) Towards a European Labour Identity: The Case of the European Works Council. London: Routledge, pp. 198–213.
37.
OffeCWiesenthalH (1985) Two logics of collective action. In: OffeC (ed.) Disorganized Capitalism: Contemporary Transformation of Works and Politics. Cambridge: Polity Press, pp. 170–220.
38.
PlatzerHWRübSWeinerKP (2001) European Works Councils: Article 6 agreements, quantitative and qualitative developments. Transfer7(1): 90–113.
39.
SapuleteSVan den BergA (2015) Works Council effectiveness in subsidiaries of MNCs during reorganizations: Case study evidence from the Netherlands. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/0143831X15586436
40.
SchömannIJagodzinskiRBoniGClaewaertSGlassnerVJaspersT (2012) Transnational Collective Bargaining at Company Level: A New Component of European Industrial Relations. Brussels: ETUI.
41.
SegrestinD (1980) Les communautés pertinentes de l’action collective: Canevas pour l’etude des fondements sociaux des conflits du travail en France. Revue française de sociologie21: 171–203.
42.
SnookJCWhittallM (2012) From ‘the best kept company secret’ to a more proficient structure of employee representation: The role of EWC delegates with a managerial background. Economic and Industrial Democracy34(2): 355–378.
43.
SobczakA (2012) Ensuring the effective implementation of transnational company agreements. European Journal of Industrial Relations18(2): 139–151.
44.
SpiesDCKaiserA (2012) Does the mode of candidate selection affect the representativeness of parties?Party Politics20(4): 576–590.
45.
StirlingJTullyB (2004) Power, process and practice: Communications in European Works Councils. European Journal of Industrial Relations10(1): 73–89.
46.
TelljohannV (2007) Interest representation and European identity: A two-fold challenge of European Works Councils. In: WhittallMKnudsenHHuijgenF (eds) Towards a European Labour Identity: The Case of the European Works Council. London: Routledge, pp. 150–168.
47.
TimmingA (2010) Dissonant cognitions in European works councils: A comparative ethnomethodological approach. Economic and Industrial Democracy31(4): 521–535.
48.
TimmingAVeersmaU (2007) Living apart together? A chorus of multiple identities. In: WhittallMKnudsenHHuijgenF (eds) Towards a European Labour Identity: The Case of the European Works Council. London: Routledge, pp. 41–54.
49.
VossE (2006) The Experience of European Works Councils in New EU Member States. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications.
50.
VossE (2015) Unilever EWC case study. In: KerckhofsP (ed.) European Works Council Developments before, during and after the Crisis. Dublin: Eurofound, pp. 33–36.
51.
WaddingtonJKerckhofsP (2003) European Works Councils: What is the current state of play?Transfer9(2): 322–339.
52.
WhittallMKnudsenHHuijgenF (2009) European Works Councils: Identity and the role of information and communication technology. European Journal of Industrial Relations15(2): 167–185. Available at: http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0959680109103605
53.
WhittallMKnudsenHHuijgenF (2007) Towards a European Labour Identity: The Case of European Works Councils. Ondon: Routledge.
54.
ZachertU (1993) Tarifautonomie zwischen Wirtschaftsliberalismus und Wiederentdeckung des Individuums. WSI-Mitteilungen45(8): 481–488.
55.
ZiltenerPGabathulerH (2016) When do European Works Councils become useful to employees? Lessons learned from the Alstom/Switzerland case. Transfer22(4): 1–14.
