In this modern era, investigating the factors influencing energy intensity is a valuable area of research. Although numerous studies have explored the influence of macroeconomic variables on energy intensity, limited research has addressed its asymmetric effects. Recognizing the significance of asymmetries, this study investigates the non-linear impacts of urbanization, industrialization, financial development and education on both aggregate and disaggregate energy intensity in Pakistan. This study utilized data for the period 1972–2022 and followed a relatively new estimation technique: the non-linear autoregressive distributed lag model. The empirical outcomes demonstrated that urbanization and industrialization have a constructive influence on aggregate and household energy intensity, while their impact is adverse in the case of industrial sector energy intensity. The financial development confirmed a constructive influence on both household and industrial sector energy intensity, while its impact was found to be the opposite in the case of aggregate energy intensity. Education exerts a constructive influence on disaggregate energy intensity in the industrial sector and on household energy intensity, while there is an adverse relationship in the case of aggregate energy intensity. These findings suggest that to reverse the rising trend of energy intensity, it is crucial to focus on enhancing basic infrastructure in rural areas and adopting energy-efficient production techniques. Besides this, sound financial systems in the industrial sector and improving education levels also diminish energy intensity and enhance production under the current status quo of the Pakistan economy.
AbbasiK. R., HussainK., RadulescuM., & OzturkI. (2022). Asymmetric impact of renewable and non-renewable energy on the industrial sector in Pakistan: Fresh evidence from Bayesian and non-linear ARDL. Renewable Energy, 187, 944–957.
2.
AkalM. (2016). Modeling of energy intensity in Turkey. Energy Sources, Part B: Economics, Planning, and Policy, 11(9), 807–814.
3.
AliS., UllahH., AkbarM., AkhtarW., & ZahidH. (2019). Determinants of consumer intentions to purchase energy-saving household products in Pakistan. Sustainability, 11(5), 1462.
4.
AllenD. E., & McAleerM. (2021). A nonlinear autoregressive distributed lag (NARDL) analysis of the FTSE and S&P500 indexes. Risks, 9(11), 195.
5.
AltayB., & TopcuM. (2015). Relationship between financial development and energy consumption: The case of Turkey. Bulletin of Energy Economics (BEE), 3(1), 18–24.
6.
ApergisN., & CoorayA. (2015). Asymmetric interest rate pass-through in the US, the UK and Australia: New evidence from selected individual banks. Journal of Macroeconomics, 45, 155–172.
7.
AydinC., & EsenÖ. (2018). Does the level of energy intensity matter in the effect of energy consumption on the growth of transition economies? Evidence from dynamic panel threshold analysis. Energy Economics, 69, 185–195.
8.
BazK., XuD., AmpofoG. M. K., AliI., KhanI., ChengJ., & AliH. (2019). Energy consumption and economic growth nexus: New evidence from Pakistan using asymmetric analysis. Energy, 189, 116254.
9.
BelloumiM., & AlshehryA. S. (2016). The impact of urbanisation on energy intensity in Saudi Arabia. Sustainability, 8(4), 1–17.
10.
BildiriciM. E., & TurkmenC. (2015). Nonlinear causality between oil and precious metals. Resources Policy, 46, 202–211.
11.
BilgiliF., KoçakE., BulutÜ., & KuloğluA. (2017). The impact of urbanisation on energy intensity: Panel data evidence considering cross-sectional dependence and heterogeneity. Energy, 133, 242–256.
12.
BrechlingV., & SmithS. (1994). Household energy efficiency in the UK. Fiscal Studies, 15(2), 44–56.
13.
BrockW. A., ScheinkmanJ. A., DechertW. D., & LeBaronB. (1996) A test for independence based on the correlation dimension. Econometric Reviews, 15(3), 197–235.
14.
BrownR. L., DurbinJ., & EvansJ. M. (1975). Techniques for testing the constancy of regression relationships over time. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B: Statistical Methodology, 37(2), 149–163.
15.
ChenZ., & ZhouM. (2021). Urbanization and energy intensity: Evidence from the institutional threshold effect. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 28, 11142–11157.
16.
CrenshawE. M., & JenkinsJ. C. (1996). Social structure and global climate change: Sociological propositions concerning the greenhouse effect. Sociological Focus, 29(4), 341–358.
17.
DickeyD. A., & FullerW. A. (1979). Distribution of the estimators for autoregressive time series with a unit root. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 74(366a), 427–431.
18.
DuanR., ShenT., LiC., FatimaN., & AnserM. K. (2021). Estimating the determinants and spatial effects of electricity intensity in China. Energy Strategy Reviews, 35, 100651.
19.
ElliottR. J., SunP., & ZhuT. (2017). The direct and indirect effect of urbanization on energy intensity: A province-level study for China. Energy, 123, 677–692.
20.
EmirF. (2022). Do financial development and industrialization intensify energy consumption in Turkey?Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 29(29), 44558–44572.
21.
EwingR., & RongF. (2008). The impact of urban form on US residential energy use. Housing Policy Debate, 19(1), 1–30.
22.
FangW. S., MillerS. M., & YehC. C. (2012). The effect of ESCOs on energy use. Energy Policy, 51, 558–568.
23.
GuangF., HeY., WenL., & SharpB. (2019). Energy intensity and its differences across China’s regions: Combining econometric and decomposition analysis. Energy, 180, 989–1000.
24.
JonesD. W. (1989). Urbanization and energy use in economic development. The Energy Journal, 10(4), 29–45.
25.
JonesD. W. (1991). How urbanization affects energy-use in developing countries. Energy Policy, 19(7), 621–630.
26.
KehoY. (2016). What drives energy consumption in developing countries? The experience of selected African countries. Energy Policy, 91, 233–246.
27.
KhanM. A., & AbbasF. (2016). The dynamics of electricity demand in Pakistan: A panel cointegration analysis. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 65, 1159–1178.
28.
KhanS., & MajeedM. T. (2023). Toward economic growth without emissions growth: The role of and industrialisation in Pakistan. Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 13(1), 43–58.
29.
KomalR., & AbbasF. (2015). Linking financial development, economic growth, and energy consumption in Pakistan. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 44, 211–220.
30.
KwakwaP. A. (2017). Electricity consumption in Egypt: A long‐run analysis of its determinants. OPEC Energy Review, 41(1), 3–22.
31.
LiK., FangL., & HeL. (2018). How urbanisation affects China’s energy efficiency: A spatial econometric analysis. Journal of Cleaner Production, 200, 1130–1141.
32.
LiM., LiL., & StrielkowskiW. (2019). The impact of urbanization and industrialization on energy security: A case study of China. Energies, 12(11), 2194.
33.
LiangC. C., TroyC., & RouyerE. (2020). US uncertainty and Asian stock prices: Evidence from the asymmetric NARDL model. The North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 51, 101046.
34.
LiddleB. (2004). Demographic dynamics and per capita environmental impact: Using panel regressions and household decompositions to examine population and transport. Population and Environment, 26, 23–39.
35.
LutzenhiserL. (1992). A cultural model of household energy consumption. Energy, 17(1), 47–60.
36.
LvY., ChenW., & ChengJ. (2020). Effects of urbanization on energy efficiency in China: New evidence from short run and long run efficiency models. Energy Policy, 147, 111858.
37.
LvY., SiC., ZhangS., & SarwarS. (2018). Impact of urbanization on energy intensity by adopting a new technique for regional division: Evidence from China. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 25, 36102–36116.
38.
MaB. (2015). Does urbanization affect energy intensities across provinces in China? Long-run elasticities estimation using dynamic panels with heterogeneous slopes. Energy Economics, 49, 390–401.
39.
MahmoodH., AlkhateebT. T. Y., & FurqanM. (2020). Industrialization, urbanization and CO2 emissions in Saudi Arabia: Asymmetry analysis. Energy Reports, 6, 1553–1560.
40.
MajeedM. T., TauqirA., MazharM., & SamreenI. (2021). Asymmetric effects of energy consumption and economic growth on ecological footprint: New evidence from Pakistan. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 28, 32945–32961.
41.
MananM. A. (2016). The relationship between financial development and increased energy consumption under the shadow of industrialization and urbanization in Malaysia. Journal of Administrative Management, Education and Training, 12(4), 154–167.
42.
MeoM. S., KhanV. J., IbrahimT. O., KhanS., AliS., & NoorK. (2018). Asymmetric impact of inflation and unemployment on poverty in Pakistan: New evidence from asymmetric ARDL cointegration. Asia Pacific Journal of Social Work and Development, 28(4), 295–310.
43.
MetcalfG. E. (2008). An empirical analysis of energy intensity and its determinants at the state level. The Energy Journal, 29(3), 1–26.
MujtabaA., & JenaP. K. (2021). Analyzing asymmetric impact of economic growth, energy use, FDI inflows, and oil prices on CO2 emissions through NARDL approach. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 28(24), 30873–30886.
46.
O’DohertyJ., LyonsS., & TolR. S. (2008). Energy-using appliances and energy-saving features: Determinants of ownership in Ireland. Applied Energy, 85(7), 650–662.
47.
OtsukaA. (2018a). Population agglomeration and residential energy consumption: Evidence from Japan. Sustainability, 10(2):469.
48.
OtsukaA. (2018b). Regional determinants of energy efficiency: Residential energy demand in Japan. Energies, 11(6), 1557.
49.
OtsukaA. (2020). Energy intensity and population density in Japan. In MaddenJ., ShibusawaH., & HiganoY. (Eds), Environmental economics and computable general equilibrium analysis (pp. 233–252). Springer.
50.
PanX., AshrafA., RazaS. M. F., NasriddinovF., & AhmadM. (2023). Exploring the asymmetric effects of urbanization and trade on CO2 emissions: Fresh evidence from Pakistan. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 30(38), 89770–89783.
51.
PanX., UddinM. K., SaimaU., JiaoZ., & HanC. (2019). How do industrialization and trade openness influence energy intensity? Evidence from a path model in case of Bangladesh. Energy Policy, 133, 110916.
52.
ParikhJ., & ShuklaV. (1995). Urbanization, energy use and greenhouse effects in economic development: Results from a cross-national study of developing countries. Global Environmental Change, 5(2), 87–103.
53.
PesaranM. H., ShinY., & SmithR. J. (2001). Bounds testing approaches to the analysis of level relationships. Journal of Applied Econometrics, 16(3), 289–326.
54.
PhillipsP. C., & PerronP. (1988). Testing for a unit root in time series regression. Biometrika, 75(2), 335–346.
55.
RafiqS., SalimR., & NielsenI. (2016). Urbanization, openness, emissions, and energy intensity: A study of increasingly urbanized emerging economies. Energy Economics, 56, 20–28.
56.
RahmanA., KhanM. A., & CharfeddineL. (2021). Regime-specific impact of financial reforms on economic growth in Pakistan. Journal of Policy Modeling, 43(1), 161–182.
57.
RahmanM. M., KhanZ., KhanS., & TariqM. (2023). How is energy intensity affected by industrialisation, trade openness, and financial development? A dynamic analysis for the panel of newly industrialized countries. Energy Strategy Reviews, 49, 101182.
58.
RashidA., & YousafN. (2015). Linkage of financial development with electricity-growth, nexus of India and Pakistan. EuroEconomica, 34(2), 151–160.
59.
RazaM. Y., & LinB. (2023). Development trend of Pakistan’s natural gas consumption: A sectorial decomposition analysis. Energy, 278, 127872.
60.
SadorskyP. (2010). The impact of financial development on energy consumption in emerging economies. Energy Policy, 38(5), 2528–2535.
61.
SadorskyP. (2011). Financial development and energy consumption in Central and Eastern European frontier economies. Energy Policy, 39(2), 999–1006.
62.
SadorskyP. (2013). Do urbanization and industrialization affect energy intensity in developing countries?Energy Economics, 37, 52–59.
63.
SadorskyP. (2014). The effect of urbanisation and industrialization on energy use in emerging economies: Implications for sustainable development. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 73(2), 392–409.
64.
SamargandiN. (2019). Energy intensity and its determinants in OPEC countries. Energy, 186(c), 115803.
ScottS. (1997). Household energy efficiency in Ireland: A replication study of ownership of energy-saving items. Energy Economics, 19(2), 187–208.
67.
SehrawatM., GiriA. K., & MohapatraG. (2015). The impact of financial development, economic growth and energy consumption on environmental degradation: Evidence from India. Management of Environmental Quality: An International Journal, 26(5), 666–682.
68.
ShahbazM. (2015). Electricity consumption, financial development and economic growth nexus in Pakistan: A visit. Bulletin of Energy Economics (BEE), 3(2), 48–65.
69.
ShahbazM., BenkraiemR., MiloudiA., & LahianiA. (2017). Production function with electricity consumption and policy implications in Portugal. Energy Policy, 110, 588–599.
70.
ShahbazM., ChaudharyA. R., & OzturkI. (2017). Does urbanization cause increasing energy demand in Pakistan? Empirical evidence from STIRPAT model. Energy, 122, 83–93.
71.
ShahbazM., & LeanH. H. (2012). Does financial development increase energy consumption? The role of industrialization and urbanization in Tunisia. Energy Policy, 40, 473–479.
72.
ShahbazM., Van HoangT. H., MahalikM. K., & RoubaudD. (2017). Energy consumption, financial development and economic growth in India: New evidence from a nonlinear and asymmetric analysis. Energy Economics, 63, 199–212.
73.
ShakyaS. R., AdhikariR., PoudelS., & RupakhetiM. (2022). Energy equity as a major driver of energy intensity in South Asia. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 170, 112994.
74.
ShengP., & GuoX. (2018). Energy consumption associated with urbanization in China: Efficient- and inefficient-use. Energy, 165, 118–125.
75.
ShinY., YuB., & Greenwood-NimmoM. (2014). Modelling asymmetric cointegration and dynamic multipliers in a nonlinear ARDL framework. In SicklesR. & HorraceW. (Eds), Festschrift in honor of Peter Schmidt (pp. 281–314). Springer.
76.
SongF., & ZhengX. (2012). What drives the change in China’s energy intensity: Combining decomposition analysis and econometric analysis at the provincial level. Energy Policy, 51, 445–453.
77.
TorglerB., & Garcia-ValiñasM. A. (2007). The determinants of individuals’ attitudes towards preventing environmental damage. Ecological Economics, 63(2–3), 536–552.
78.
UllahA., NeelumZ., & JabeenS. (2019). Factors behind electricity intensity and efficiency: An econometric analysis for Pakistan. Energy Strategy Reviews, 26, 100371.
79.
UllahK., AbbasS., TariqM., MahmoodN., & KaecheleH. (2023). The symmetric and asymmetric impacts of green energy, eco-innovation, and urbanization in explaining low-carbon economy for Pakistan. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 30(12), 33375–33395.
80.
WangK. Y., & ZhangH. W. (2016). An empirical research on the effects of urbanization and industrialization on energy intensity. China Journal of Population, Resources and Environment, 6, 122–129.
81.
WangR., LailaU., NazirR., & HaoX. (2023). Unleashing the influence of industrialization and trade openness on renewable energy intensity using path model analysis: A roadmap towards sustainable development. Renewable Energy, 202, 280–288.
82.
WangZ., RasoolY., ZhangB., AhmedZ., & WangB. (2020). Dynamic linkage among industrialisation, urbanisation, and CO2 emissions in APEC realms: Evidence based on DSUR estimation. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 52, 382–389.
83.
WDA. (2020). World Data Atlas. https://knoema.com/atlas/Pakistan/Primary-energy-consumption
84.
WuY. (2012). Energy intensity and its determinants in China’s regional economies. Energy Policy, 41, 703–711.
85.
YanH. (2015). Provincial energy intensity in China: The role of urbanisation. Energy Policy, 86, 635–650.
86.
YueS., LuR., ShenY., & ChenH. (2019). How does financial development affect energy consumption? Evidence from 21 transitional countries. Energy Policy, 130, 253–262.
87.
ZhangB., WangB., & WangZ. (2017). Role of renewable energy and non-renewable energy consumption on EKC: Evidence from Pakistan. Journal of Cleaner Production, 156, 855–864.
88.
ZhangR., & DingR. J. (2015). The impact of industrialization and urbanization on energy intensity: An empirical study based on inter-provincial dynamic panel data in China. Exploratory Economic Problems, 1, 11–15.
89.
ZhouS. F., & WangY. N. (2015). The impact of China’s industrialization and urbanization on energy intensity: Based on a dynamic panel data model. Ecological Economy, 31, 317–343.
