As pressures mount to develop intensive business operations along a coastline prized for its natural beauty, varied plant and wildlife and archeological sites, it is important to present decision makers with a full analysis of all values associated with the area. In this study, we examine whether the benefits of business development along the Rosh Haniqra Marine Reserve in northern Israel indeed outweigh the costs of potential damages to the region’s delicate natural balance. The analysis of business value was carried out on the basis of a detailed survey of facilities operating within the proposed reserve area and assessment of their expansion plans. The non-market benefits associated with conservation of the reserve were estimated according to two independent methods—Contingent Valuation (CVM) and Travel Cost (TCM). Our analysis reveals that under certain assumptions, non-market values of the coastline are higher than its commercial value. Thus, while further analysis is required to investigate the interaction between the number of visitors and the ecological performance of the site, it may already now be concluded that the preservation value is quite significant and should be taken into account in development plans for the region.
Arrow, K. , R. Solow , E. Leamer , P. Portney , R. Radner and H. Schuman (1993), ‘ Natural Resource Damage Assessments under the Oil Pollution Act of 1990 ’, Federal Register, 58(10): 31 , 15 CFR Chapter IX, 58 FR 4601 4614.
2.
Bateman, I. , R. Carson , B. Day , W.M. Hanemann , N. Hanley and T. Hett (2003), Guidelines for the Use of Stated Preference Techniques for the Valuation of Preferences for Non-market Goods. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar .
3.
Bhat, M. (2003), ‘ Application of non-market valuation to Florida Keys Marine Reserve Management ’, Journal of Environmental Management, 67: 315–25 .
4.
Cameron, T.A. and D.D. Huppert (1989), ‘ OLS versus ML Estimation of Non-market Resource Values with Payment Card Interval Data ’, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 17: 230–46 .
5.
Carson, R.C. (2000), ‘ Contingent Valuation: A User Guide ’, Environmental Science and Technology, 34(4): 1413–18 .
6.
Cesar, H. (1996), Economic Analysis of Indonesian Coral Reefs. Environment Department, the World Bank .
7.
Champ, P.A. , N.E. Flores , T.C. Brown and J. Chivers (2002), ‘ Contingent Valuation and Incentives ’, Land Economics, 78(4): 591–604 .
8.
Dixon, J.A. , L.F. Scura and T. Vant Hof (1993), ‘ Meeting Ecological and Economic Goals: Marine Parks in the Caribbean ’, Ambio, 22(2–3): 117–25 .
Freeman, A.M. (2003), The Measurement of Environmental and Resource Values. Washington DC: RFF press .
11.
Hall, D.C. , J.V. Hall and S.N. Murray (2002), ‘ Contingent Valuation of Marine Protected Areas: Southern California Rocky Intertidal Ecosystems ’, Natural Resource Modeling, 15(3): 335–68 .
12.
Hanemann, M. (1994), ‘ Valuing the Environment through Contingent Valuation ’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8(4): 19–43 .
13.
Hodgson, G. and J.A. Dixon (1988), ‘Logging versus Fisheries and Tourism in Palawan: An Environmental and Economic Analysis’, East-West Environment and Policy Institute , Occasional Paper No. 7.
14.
Israels, L.D.E. (1992), ‘ Thirty years of Mediterranean Monk Seal Protection, A Review. Netherlands Commission for International Nature Protection ’, Mededelingen, 28(4): 1–65 .
15.
Johnston, R.J. , T.A. Grigalunas , J.J. Opaluch , M. Mazzotta and J. Diamantedes (2002), ‘ Valuing Estuarine Resource Services using Economic and Ecological Models: The Peconic Estuary System Study ’, Coastal Management, 30(1): 47–65 .
16.
Kahneman, D. and J.L. Knetch (1992), ‘ Valuing Public Goods: The Purchase of Moral Satisfaction ’, Journal of Environmental Economic and Management, 14(1): 226–47 .
17.
Katsin, M. (2007). Heshev Magazine: Costs and General Information. Heshev Information Systems Ltd, Tel-Aviv, Israel . [in Hebrew]
18.
King, O.H. (1995), ‘ Estimating the Value of Marine Resources: A Marine Recreation Case ’, Ocean and Coastal Management, 47(1): 129–41 .
19.
Langford, I.H. , A. Kontogianni , M.S. Skourtos , S. Georgiou and I.J. Bateman (1998), ‘ Multivariate Mixed Models for Open-ended Contingent Valuation Data: A Case Study on Willingness to Pay for Conservation of Monk Seals ’, Environmental and Resource Economics, 12(2): 443–56 .
Mathieu, L.F. , I.H. Langford and W. Kenyon (2003), ‘ Valuing Marine Parks in a Developing Country: A Case Study of the Seychelles ’, Environment and Development Economics, 8(2): 373–90 .
22.
Mitchell, R.C. and R.T. Carson (1989), Using Surveys to Value Public Goods: The Contingent Valuation Method. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press .
23.
Park, T. , J.M. Bowker and V.R. Leeworthy (2002), ‘ Valuing Snorkeling Visits to the Florida Keys with Stated and Revealed Preference Models ’, Journal of Environmental Management, 65(3): 301–12 .
24.
Parras, D.A. (2001), ‘ Coastal Resource Management in the Philippines: A Case Study in the Central Visayas Region ’, Journal of Environment and Development, 10(1): 80–103 .
25.
Pendleton, L.H. (1994), ‘ Environmental Quality and Recreational Demand in a Caribbean Coral Reef ’, Coastal Management, 22(1): 399–404 .
Portney, P.R. (1994), ‘ The Contingent Valuation Debate: Why Economists should Care ’, The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8(4): 3–17 .
28.
Sorensen, J. and N. West (1992), A Guide to Impact Assessment in Coastal Environments. Coastal Resources Center. The University of Road Island .
29.
Tijen, T. and R.A. Kramer (2002), ‘ Divers’ Willingness to Pay to Visit Marine Sanctuaries: An Exploratory Study ’, Ocean and Coastal Management, 45(1): 171–83 .
30.
Turner, R.K. , I.J. Bateman and W.N. Adger (2001), Economics of Coastal and Water Resources: Valuing Environmental Functions. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwe Academic Publishers .
31.
USA EPA. (2002), A Framework for the Economic Assessment of Ecological Benefits, 2. (EPA-821-R-03-009). U.S. EPA, Office of Water, Washington, DC.
32.
World Bank Institute (2002), Environmental Economics and Development Policy Course, Internal report, July 15–26, Session 28.
