Why Do Cooperatives Succeed? A Comparative Analysis of the Global South and North

Abstract

This article investigates why only some cooperatives succeed. World Cooperative Monitor 2021 reveals that Europe and USA have maximum high-performing cooperatives (based on turnover), while the representation of developing countries in the list of the world’s top cooperatives is meagre. According to the data source of Cooperative Monitor, out of the top 300 coops worldwide, Europe has 159, the USA has 95, the Asia-Pacific region has only 46, and Africa has none. Therefore, this study becomes very pertinent in understanding the performance differences of cooperatives in the Global South vis-à-vis Global North. This study tries to identify the factors that determine the performance of cooperatives operating in both regions. By using Cooperative Monitor’s (2021) data set, the article tries to link the performance of cooperatives with the macro conditions. The democratic condition of a country (macro-level) may influence the performance of institutions at the meso-level (cooperatives). We found that cooperatives in the Global North in countries with higher democratic values have performed better than the cooperatives in the Global South. The study finds that the performance of cooperatives is positively related to democratic values. However, no significant relationship is found between social inclusiveness and the performance of cooperatives.

Keywords

Cooperatives Global North & South cooperative performance Macro-meso democratic values Social inclusion

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Amit

, MacCrimmon

K. R.

, Zietsma

, and Oesch

J. M.

2001. Does Money Matter? Wealth Attainment as the Motive for Initiating Growth-Oriented Technology Ventures. Journal of Business Venturing 16, no. 2: 119–43.

Aris

N. A.

, Marzuki

M. M.

, Othman

, Rahman

S. A.

, and Ismail

N. H.

2018. Designing Indicators for Cooperative Sustainability: The Malaysian Perspective. Social Responsibility Journal 14, no. 1: 226–48.

Bhowmik

M. R.

2021. SDGs, Social Responsibility, Institutions and Cooperatives: Evidence From the Handloom Weaving Sector in India. International Journal of Rural Management 17, no. 1_suppl: 97S–114S.

Bhuyan

2007. The “people” Factor in Cooperatives: An Analysis of Members’ Attitudes and Behavior. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue Canadienned’agroeconomie 55, no. 3: 275–98.

Birchall

2004. Cooperatives and the Millennium Development Goals. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/

Birchall

, & Simmons

(2004). What motivates members to participate in co-operative and mutual businesses? Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics , 75, no. 3: 465–495.

Biswas

S. N.

2015. Organizational Behaviour Research in Rural Producers’ Cooperatives: A Neglected Domain. International Journal of Rural Management 11, no. 1: 40–59.

Boone

, and Özcan

2014. Why Do Cooperatives Emerge in a World Dominated by Corporations? The Diffusion of Cooperatives in the US Bio-Ethanol Industry, 1978–2013. Academy of Management Journal 57, no. 4: 990–1012.

Borzaga

, Bodini

, Carini

, Depedri

, Galera

, and Salvatori

2014. Europe in Transition: The Role of Social Cooperatives and Social Enterprises (Euricse Working Papers No. 69|14). http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2436456

10.

Bourguignon

2013. The Globalization of Inequality. Max Weber Program Lecture Series/Number: EUI MWP LS; 2013/02. https://hdl.handle.net/1814/26496

11.

Braff

, and Nelson

The Global North: Introducing the Region. Gendered Lives. Available at: https://milnepublishing.geneseo.edu/genderedlives/chapter/chapter-15-the-global-north-introducing-the-region/

12.

Bretos

, and Marcuello

2017. Revisiting Globalization Challenges and Opportunities in the Development of Cooperatives. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 88, no. 1: 47–73.

13.

Carlberg

J. G.

, Ward

C. E.

, and R. B.

2006. Success factors for new generation cooperatives. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review 9, no. 1: 33–52.

14.

Cartan-Quinn

, and Carson

2003. Issues which Impact Upon Marketing in the Small Firm. Small Business Economics , 21, no. 2: 201–13.

15.

Cheney

, Cruz

I. S.

, Peredo

A. M.

, and Nazareno

2014. Worker Cooperatives as an Organizational Alternative: Challenges, Achievements and Promise in Business Governance and Ownership. Organization 21: 591–603.

16.

Cook

M. L.

2018. A Life Cycle Explanation of Cooperative Longevity. Sustainability 10, no. 5: 1586.

17.

Dave

2021. RETRACTED: Resilient to Crises: How Cooperatives are Adapting Sustainably to Overcome COVID-19-Induced Challenges. International Journal of Rural Management 17, no. 1_suppl: 13S–39S.

18.

Dejene

, & Regasa

D. G.

2015. Factors Affecting Success of Agricultural Marketing Cooperatives. International Journal of Cooperative Studies 4, no. 1: 9–17.

19.

Dollery

, & Wallis

2001. The Theory of Market Failure and Equity-Based Policy Making in Contemporary Local Government. Local Government Studies 27, no. 4: 59–70.

20.

Dopfer

, Foster

, & Potts

2004. Micro-Meso-Macro. Journal of Evolutionary Economics 14, no. 3: 263–79. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00191-004-0193-0

21.

Errasti

, Bretos

, & Nunez

2017. The Viability of Cooperatives: The Fall of the Mondragon Cooperative Fagor. Review of Radical Political Economics 49, no. 2: 181–97.

22.

Esim

2014. The Cooperative Key to Sustainable Development. In Conference on Cooperatives and the Sustainable Development Goals: Focus on Africa, Berlin, Germany (Vol. 2). https://www.ilo.org/global/about-the-ilo/newsroom/comment-analysis/WCMS_303222/lang–en/index.htm

23.

Eum

H. S.

2017. Cooperatives and Employment: Second Global Report (Report for CICOPA). Accessed January 23, 2023. https://www.cicopa.coop/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Cooperatives-and-Employment-Second-Global-Report-2017.pdf. Available at https://ica.coop/sites/

24.

Fatai

2011. Small and Medium Scale Enterprises in Nigeria: The Problems and Prospects. The Collegiate Journal of Economics 5, no. 6: 1–22.

25.

Fforde

2022. Services and Evidence of Irremediable Market Failure in Rich Countries: Australian Experience. The Economic and Labour Relations Review 33, no. 3: 654–71.

26.

Forcadell

F. J.

2005. Democracy, Cooperation and Business Success: The Case of MondragónCorporaciónCooperativa. Journal of Business Ethics 56, no. 3: 255–74.

27.

Grashuis

2018. An Exploratory Study of Cooperative Survival: Strategic Adaptation to External Developments. Sustainability 10, no. 3: 652.

28.

Guinnane

T. W.

2001. Cooperatives as Information Machines: German Rural Credit Cooperatives, 1883–1914. The Journal of Economic History 61, no. 2: 366–89.

29.

Hakelius

1996. Cooperative Values. Farmers’ Cooperatives in the Minds of the Farmers . Dissertation № 23. Uppsala, Sweden: The Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences.

30.

Hans-Joachim

, & Schlenkrich

2019. Core Measurement in the Democracy Matrix. URL: https://www.democracymatrix.com/concept-treeoperationalisation/core-measurement. Consulted on 31/03/2019.

31.

ICA. 2022. Cooperative Identity, Values & Principles. Brussels. Retrieved on 19 December 2022. https://www.ica.coop/en/cooperatives/cooperative-identity

32.

Iliopoulos

, & Valentinov

2018. Cooperative Longevity: Why are so Many Cooperatives So Successful? Sustainability 10, no. 10: 3449.

33.

Jackall

, & Levin

H. M.

(Eds.). 2021. Worker Cooperatives in America California: University of California Press.

34.

Jackson

E. A.

, & Jabbie

2020. Understanding Market Failure in the Developing Country Context. In Decent Work and Economic Growth , 1095–105. Cham: Springer International Publishing.

35.

Lafleur

2012, January 10. Cooperatives have twice the lifespan of traditional businesses. Coop News. Available at: https://www.thenews.coop/37164/sector/retail/cooperatives-have-twice-lifespan-traditional-businesses/

36.

Lauermann

G. J.

, Moreira

V. R.

, Souza

, & Piccoli

P. G. R.

2020. Do Cooperatives with Better Economic–Financial Indicators also have Better Socioeconomic Performance? VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 31, no. 6: 1282–93.

37.

Mahazril‘Aini

, Hafizah

H. A. K.

, & Zuraini

2012. Factors Affecting Cooperatives’ Performance in Relation to Strategic Planning and Members’ Participation. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 65, 100–05.

38.

Mazerolle

2006. Improving Data Analysis in Herpetology: Using Akaike’s Information Criterion (AIC) to Assess the Strength of Biological Hypotheses. Amphibia-Reptilia 27, no. 2: 169–80.

39.

Majee

, & Hoyt

2011. Cooperatives and Community Development: A Perspective on the use of Cooperatives in Development. Journal of Community Practice , 19, no. 1: 48–61. https://doi.org/10.1080/10705422.2011.550260

40.

Mara

, & Alabaster

2008. A New Paradigm for Low-Cost Urban Water Supplies and Sanitation in Developing Countries. Water Policy 10, no. 2: 119–29.

41.

Marello

, & Helwege

2018. Solid Waste Management and Social Inclusion of Wastepickers: Opportunities and Challenges. Latin American Perspectives 45, no. 1: 108–29.

42.

Masuku

T. A.

, Masuku

M. B.

, & Mutangira

J. P. B.

2016. Performance of Multi-Purpose Cooperatives in the Shiselweni Region of Swaziland. International Journal of Sustainable Agricultural Research 3, no. 4: 58–71.

43.

Mourya

, & Mehta

2021. Farmer Producer Company: India’s Magic Bullet to Realise Select SDGs? International Journal of Rural Management 17, no. 1_suppl: 115S–147S.

44.

Munck

G. L.

, & Verkuilen

2002. Conceptualizing and Measuring Democracy: Evaluating Alternative Indices. Comparative Political Studies 35, no. 1: 5–34. https://doi.org/10.1177/001041400203500101

45.

Nilsson

1996. The Nature of Cooperative Values and Principles: Transaction Cost Theoretical Explanations. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics 67, no. 4: 633–53. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8292.1996.tb01411.x

46.

Novkovic

2006. Co-Operative Business: The Role of Co-Operative Principles and Values. Journal of Co-operative Studies 39, no. 1: 5–16.

47.

Novkovic

2008. Defining the Cooperative Difference. The Journal of Socio-Economics 37, no. 6: 2168–77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socec.2008.02.009

48.

Ortmann

G. F.

, & King

R. P.

2007. Agricultural Cooperatives I: History, Theory and Problems. Agrekon 46, no. 1: 40–68.

49.

Sapovadia

V. K.

, & Patel

2013. What Works for Workers’ Cooperatives? An Empirical Research on Success & Failure of Indian Workers’ Cooperatives. An Empirical Research on Success & Failure of Indian Workers’ Cooperatives (January 15, 2013).

50.

Schoening

2005. Cooperative Entrepreneurialism: Reconciling Democratic Values with Business Demands at a Worker-Owned Firm. In Worker Participation: Current Research and Future Trends (Research in the Sociology of Work, Vol. 16) , edited by V. Smith, 293–315. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0277-2833(06)16011-2

51.

Shylendra

H. S.

2013. Microfinance and the Cooperatives in India: Can the Poor Gain from Their Coming Together? International Journal of Rural Management 9, no. 2: 151–81.

52.

Skokan

, Pawliczek

, & Piszczur

2013. Strategic Planning and Business Performance of Micro, Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises. Journal of Competitiveness 5, no. 4.

53.

Social Progress Org. 2022. Social Progress Imperative. Explore the 2022 Social Progress Index Map. Washington, DC. Available at: https://www.socialprogress.org/?tab=2&code=NOR

54.

Sommet

, & Morselli

2017. Keep Calm and Learn Multilevel Logistic Modeling: A Simplified Three-Step Procedure Using Stata, R, mplus, and SPSS. International Review of Social Psychology 30: 203–18.

55.

Sozzo

2022. Inequality, Welfare and Punishment. Comparative Notes Between the Global North and South. European Journal of Criminology 19, no. 3: 368–93.

56.

Storey

, Basterretxea

, & Salaman

2014. Managing and Resisting “degeneration” in Employee-Owned Businesses: A Comparative Study of Two Large Retailers in Spain and the United Kingdom. Organization 21: 626–44.

57.

UNO. 2022. World Urbanization Prospects 2022. New York. USA. Available at: https://population.un.org/wup/

58.

Wanyama

F. O.

2016. Cooperatives and the Sustainable Development Goals A contribution to the post-2015 development debate. Source: repository.mut.ac.ke

59.

Wassie

F. A.

2020. Determinants of Business Cooperatives’ Success in North Gondar Zone, Ethiopia. Horn of African Journal of Business and Economics (HAJBE) 3, no. 2: 13–28.

60.

Zamani

, Mojaverian

, & Nader

2019. Comparing Efficiency Between Cooperative and Non-cooperative Farms: A Case of Sugar Beet Farmers of West Azerbaijan, Iran. International Journal of Rural Management 15, no. 1: 78–96.