Lion Conservation and the Lion Bone Trade in South Africa: On CITES,Shifting Paradigms,“Sustainable Use” and Rehabilitation

Abstract

In lion conservation, the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), and Trade Records Analyses of Flora and Fauna in Commerce (TRAFFIC) are considered key United Nations (UN) institutions for “science-based decisions” on global policy formulation for conservation and combating wildlife crime.

CITES, but probably also TRAFFIC and IUCN, still adheres to and operates in the paradigm of the “sustainable use” of animals, based on the long leading philosophical Cartesian paradigm in academia that premises that humans and animals differ in kind, and that animals do not “feel” and have the neurological capacities to think like us. But this Cartesian worldview can no longer withstand the latest scientific evidence, developments, and new insights that show how people and animals only differ in degree and not in kind. The concept of “sustainable use” of wildlife, including lions, therefore needs to be rethought in the light of this new paradigm.

In South Africa, the “sustainable use” of lions includes the trade in lion’s bones from captive lions, which was legalized in 2016. The Wildlife Animal Protection Forum of South Africa (WAPFSA) appealed against this legalized trade, based on rational arguments that fit CITES and its Cartesian approach to animals but also on the paradigm shift where humans and animals are no longer considered different in kind but only in degree. This paradigm shift has led to initiatives to try and suggest possible ways forward for a political order that matches this “new normal.” Probably the most developed in this context is the concept of “zoopolis,” which is explored in this article. The four “vulnerabilities” on which the concept is based were all found to be relevant to lion conservation and fighting wildlife crime in South Africa.

Keywords

Sustainable use lion bone trade CITES Zoopolis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anthony

L. (with Spence G.)

. (2012). The last rhinos. The powerful story of one man’s battle to save a species . Sidgwick & Jackson.

Bauer

Nowell

Sillero-Zubiri

Macdonalds

D. W.

(2018). Lions in the modern arena of CITES. Conservation Letters , 11(5). https://doi:10.1111/conl.12444

Bauer

Packer

Funston

Henschel

Nowell

(2015). Panthera leo in the 2015 IUCN red list of threatened species . https://www.iucnredlist.org/details/15951/0

Bekoff

(2008). The emotional lives of animals. A leading scientist explores animal joy, sorrow, and empathy–and why they matter . New World Library.

Bradshaw

(2017). Carnivore mind: Who these fearsome animals really are . Yale University Press.

Broekhuis

Cushman

S. A.

Elliot

N. B.

(2017). Identification of human-carnivore conflict hotspots to prioritize mitigation efforts. Ecology and Evolution , 7(24), 10630–10639.

Büscher

Ramutsindela

(2016). Green violence: Rhino poaching and the war to save southern Africa’s Peace Parks. African Affairs , 115(458), 1–22.

Calarco

(2015). Thinking through animals. Identity, difference, indistinction . Stanford University Press.

Calarco

(2008). Zoographies. The question of animal from Heidegger to Derrida . Columbia University Press.

10.

Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries. (2019). Animal Improvement Act (62/1998): Regulations relating to amendment of Table 7 of the regulations (Government Gazette no. 42464:664; 17 May [cited 2019 Dec 12]). South Africa. http://www.gpwonline.co.za/Gazettes/Pages/Published-National-Government-Gazettes.aspx?p=2

11.

Donaldson

Kymlicka

(2011). Zoopolis. A political theory of animal rights . Oxford University Press.

12.

Duffy

(2010). Nature crime. How we’re getting conservation wrong . Yale University Press.

13.

Edelijn

(2019). The trade in lion body parts in Africa: A literature overview and recent developments (Unpublished paper). Leiden University and University of Utrecht.

14.

Eisenstein

(2018). Climate. A new story . North Atlantic Books.

15.

Ellis

(1994). Of elephants and men: Politics and nature conservation in South Africa. Journal of Southern African Studies , 20(1), 53–69.

16.

Gewald

J. B.

Spierenburg

Wels

H. (Eds.)

. (2018). Nature conservation in southern Africa–Morality and marginality: Towards sentient conservation? Brill Academic Publishers.

17.

Haenlein

Smith

L. R.

(Eds.). (2016). Poaching, wildlife trafficking and security in Africa (Whitehall Papers 86). Routledge.

18.

Hanks

(2015). Operation lock and the war on rhino poaching . Penguin.

19.

Haraway

(2008). When species meet . University of Minnesota Press.

20.

Iongh

de H. H.

Tumenta

Croes

Funston

Bauer

Haes

H. A.

(2009). Threat of a lion population extinction in Waza National Park, North Cameroon. Cat News , 50(3), 26–27.

21.

Kamuti

(2018). “If it pays, it stays”: The lobby for private wildlife ranching in South Africa. In Gewald

J. B.

Spierenburg

Wels

(Eds.), Nature conservation in southern Africa—Morality and marginality: Towards sentient conservation? (pp. 189–213). Brill Academic Publishers.

22.

Luke

(2007). Brutal. Manhood and the exploitation of animals . University of Illinois Press.

23.

Meier

(2019). When animals speak. Toward and interspecies democracy . New York University Press.

24.

Nyhus

P. J.

(2016). Human-wildlife conflict and co-existence. Annual Review of Environment and Resources , 41(1), 143–171.

25.

Orenstein

(2013). Ivory, horn and blood. Behind the elephant and rhinoceros poaching crisis . Firefly Books.

26.

Packer

(2015). Lions in the balance. Man-eaters, manes, and men with guns . The University of Chicago Press.

27.

Pickover

(2005). Animal rights in South Africa . Double Storey Books.

28.

Rademeyer

(2012). Killing for profit. Exposing the illegal rhino horn trade . Zebra Press.

29.

Ramutsindela

Spierenburg

Wels

(2011). Sponsoring nature. Environmental philanthropy for conservation . Earthscan.

30.

Riggio

Jacobson

Dollar

Bauer

Becker

Dickman

Funston

Groom

Henschel

de.

Iongh H.

Lichtenfeld

Pimm

(2013). The size of savannah Africa: A lion’s (Panthera leo) view. Biodiversity and Conservation , 22(1), 17–35. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-012-0381-4

31.

Safina

(2018). Beyond words. What animals think and feel . Henry Holt & Company.

32.

Scholes

R. J.

Mennell

K. G.

(2008). Elephant management. A scientific assessment for South Africa . Wits University Press.

33.

Somers

M. J.

Walters

Measey

Strauss W.

Turner A.

Venter J.

Nel

Kerley

G. I. H.

Taylor

W. A.

Moodley

(2020). The implications of the reclassification of South African wildlife species as farm animals. South African Journal of Science , 116(1/2). http://doi.org/10.17159/sajs.2020/7724

34.

Somerville

(2016). Ivory. Power and poaching in Africa . Hurst & Company.

35.

Spapens

White

Uhm

van D.

Huisman

W. (Eds.)

. (2018). Green crimes and dirty money . Routledge.

36.

Trinkel

Angelici

F. M.

(2016). The decline in the lion population in Africa and possible mitigation measures. In Angelici

F. M.

(Ed.), Problematic wildlife: A cross-disciplinary approach (pp. 45–68). Springer.

37.

United Nations Economic Commission for Africa (UNECA). (2019). Animals, environment and sustainable development in 21st century Africa: An interlinked approach . Conference Report on 3rd Africa Animal Welfare Conference. https://www.aawconference.org/2019/reports/3rd_Africa_Animal_Welfare_Conference_Report.pdf

38.

de Waal

(2016). Are we smart enough to know how smart animals are? W.W. Norton & Company.

39.

Wels

(2000). Fighting over fences. Organisational co-operation and reciprocal exchange between the Savé Valley Conservancy and its neighbouring communities (PhD thesis). Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.

40.

Wels

(2003). Private wildlife conservation in Zimbabwe: Joint ventures and reciprocity (Unpublished paper). Brill Academic Publishers.

41.

Wels

(2015a). Securing wilderness landscapes in South Africa: Nick Steele, private wildlife conservancies and saving rhinos . Brill Academic Publishers.

42.

Wels

(2015b). “Animals like us”: Revisiting organizational ethnography and research. Journal of Organizational Ethnography , 4(3), 242–259.

43.

Williams

Loveridge

A. J.

Newton

D. J.

Macdonald

D. W.

(2017). A roaring trade? The legal trade i. Panthera leo bones from Africa to East-Southeast Asia. Plos One, 12, e0185996.