Working Through the Politics of Indigeneity: Decolonising Psychology by Way of a Dialectical Approach

Abstract

Our particular concern here is with how decolonising psychology is interpreted (or misinterpreted) as well as its implications for making our discipline a truly liberating enterprise. We make three related arguments here: first, colonialism was a joint project between the colonisers and the colonised instead of being a one-way imposition of the worldviews of just the colonisers. Second, the constellation of the values of the colonised societies (before their colonisation) that facilitated the fruition of colonialism continues to be a part of the culture of these societies even after their freedom from colonial rule. Third, a version of indigenous psychology that is based on simplistic binaries such as Indigenous vs Western, Local vs Global, or Self vs Other is bound to fail in achieving the goal of substantive decolonisation. Moreover, there is a politics of indigeneity too as Edward Said in his classic Orientalism (1978) has argued that the concept of the orient itself was a construction of the West for an ideological purpose. Therefore, it is ultimately argued that the project of true or substantive decolonisation can be accomplished only by attaining a proper understanding of self and culture and this goal can be achieved by collaborating with others. Further, the culture of a society may be viewed as a set of disparate, often contradictory values which help to keep a check on the excesses of certain cultural tendencies by offering an internal critique of it. This way of looking at culture calls for viewing it as a dynamic process and necessitates a dialectical approach to examine the nature of the relationship between contradictory values of a culture. In this effort, the methodology of critical cultural psychoanalysis helps us to recognise the dialectical relation between the conscious and the unconscious/repressed aspect of the culture of the societies of the coloniser and the colonised and work through them to expand their consciousness by recovering/owning the repressed/disavowed aspect of their self. Finally, it is argued that like colonisation, substantive decolonisation will also involve a collaborative process between the colonisers and the colonised whereby they can recognise and own their selves in entirety.

Keywords

Binary thinking colonialism coloniality critical cultural psychoanalysis decoloniality dialectical approach politics of indigeneity substantive decolonisation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agathangelou

A. M.

(2016). Fanon on decolonization and revolution: Bodies and dialectics. Globalisations , 13(1), 110–128.

Alcoff

L. M.

(2007). Mignolo’s epistemology of coloniality. The New Centennial Review , 2(3), 79–101.

Assoun

P. L.

(1993). Freud and the social sciences: Theory of psychoanalysis and culture . A. Colin.

Barbara

, Apter

, Lezra

, & Wood

(2014). Dictionary of untranslatables: A philosophical lexicon . Princeton University Press.

Bhabha

H. K.

(1991). The question of survival: Nations and psychic states. In Donald

(Ed.), Psychoanalysis and cultural theory: Thresholds (pp. 89–103). Macmillan Education.

Bhabha

H. K.

(2004). Foreword. In Fanon

, Black skin, white masks (R. Philcox, trans.; p. xvi). Grove Press.

Bharte

U. L.

, & Sarang

(2019). Measurement in psychology: Assumptions, ideology and alternatives. International Journal of Indian Psychology , 7(1), 853–864.

Bhatia

(2002). Orientalism in Euro-American and Indian psychology: Historical representations of ‘natives’ in colonial and postcolonial contexts. History of Psychology , 5(4), 376–398.

Chakkarath

(2021). How India almost lost its soul: The detrimental effects of ethnocentrism and colonialism on the psychology of spirituality. In Dueck

(Ed.), Indigenous psychology of spirituality . Palgrave studies in indigenous psychology (pp. 227–254). Palgrave Macmillan.

10.

Ciccariello-Maher

(2014). Decolonial realism: Ethics, politics, and dialectics in Fanon and Dussel. Contemporary Political Theory , 13(1), 2–22.

11.

Dafermos

(2015). Rethinking the crisis in social psychology: A dialectical perspective. Social and Personality Psychology Compass , 9(8), 394–405.

12.

Danziger

(2006). Universalism and indigenization in the history of modern psychology. In Brock

A. C.

(Ed.), Internationalizing the history of psychology (pp. 208–225). New York University Press.

13.

Derrida

(1982). Positions . University of Chicago Press.

14.

DiCenso

J. J.

(1999). The other Freud: Religion, culture, and psychoanalysis . Routledge.

15.

Doxtater

M. G.

(2004). Indigenous knowledge in the decolonial era. American Indian Quarterly , 28(3–4), 618–633.

16.

Drabinski

(2019). Frantz Fanon. In Zalta

Edward N.

(Ed.), Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Spring 2019 ed.). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/frantz-fanon/

17.

Drob

S. L.

(2003). Fragmentation in contemporary psychology: A dialectical solution. Journal of Humanistic Psychology , 43(4), 102–123.

18.

Etherington

(2016). An answer to the question: What is decolonisation? Modern Intellectual History , 13(1), 151–178.

19.

Fanon

(1952). Black skins white masks: The experiences of a black man in a white world . Grove Press.

20.

Fanon

(1961) The wretched of the earth . Grove Press.

21.

Freud

(1921/1922). Group psychology and the analysis of the ego (Tr. J. Strachey). International Psychoanalytical Press.

22.

Freud

(1927/2004). Future of an illusion . Penguin Books India Ltd.

23.

Freud

(1929/2016,). Civilization and its discontents (Tr. J. Riviere). Martino Publishing.

24.

Freud

(1939/2010). Moses and monotheism . Martino Fine Books.

25.

Gergen

(2014). Culturally inclusive psychology from a constructionist standpoint. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour , 45(1), 96–107.

26.

Golan

(2006). Loving psychoanalysis: Looking at culture with Freud and Lacan . H. Karnac Books Ltd.

27.

Hartnack

(2001). Psychoanalysis in colonial India . Oxford University Press.

28.

Held

B. S.

(2020). Epistemic violence in psychological science: Can knowledge of, from, and for the (othered) people solve the problem? Theory & Psychology , 30(3), 349–370.

29.

Inden

(1990). Imagining India . Basil Blackwell.

30.

Kakar

(1997). Culture and psyche . Oxford University Press.

31.

Krys

, Vignoles

V. L.

, de Almeida

, & Uchida

(2022). Outside the cultural binary: Understanding why Latin American collectivist societies foster independent selves. Perspectives on Psychological Science , 17(4), 1166–1187.

32.

Lawler

(1975). Dialectical philosophy and developmental psychology: Hegel and Piaget on contradiction. Human Development , 18, 1–17.

33.

Maldonado-Torres

(2007). On the coloniality of being. Cultural Studies , 21(2–3), 240–270.

34.

Mannoni

(1956/1991). Prospero and Caliban: The psychology of colonization . Methuen & Co. Ltd.

35.

Maybee

J. E.

(2020). Hegel’s dialectics. In Zalta

Edward N.

(Ed.), Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Winter 2020 ed.). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel-dialectics/

36.

Memmi

(1967). The colonizer and the colonized (Tr. Howard Greenfield). Beacon Press.

37.

Mignolo

W. D.

(2000a). The geopolitics of knowledge and the colonial difference. South Atlantic Quarterly , 101(1), 57–97.

38.

Mignolo

W. D.

(2000b). Local histories/global designs: Coloniality, subaltern knowledges, and border thinking . Princeton University Press.

39.

Mignolo

W. D.

(2003). The darker side of the renaissance: Literacy, territoriality, and colonization (2nd ed.). The University of Michigan Press.

40.

Nandy

(1983). The intimate enemy: Loss and recovery of self under colonialism. Oxford University Press.

41.

Nandy

(1987). Traditions, tyranny, and utopias: Essays in the politics of awareness . Oxford University Press.

42.

Okazaki

, David

E. J. R.

, & Abelmann

(2008). Colonialism and psychology of culture. Social and Personality Psychology Compass , 2(1), 90–106.

43.

Panikkar

K. N.

(2007). Colonialism, culture, and resistance . Oxford University Press.

44.

Pavón-Cuéllar

(2017). Marxism and psychoanalysis: In or against psychology . Routledge.

45.

Pavón-Cuéllar

(2022). Colonialism, subjectivity, and psychology in Latin America. Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology , Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1037/teo0000217

46.

Peng

, & Nisbett

R. E.

(1999). Culture, dialectics, and reasoning about contradiction. American Psychologist , 54(9), 741–754.

47.

Piaget

(1936). Origins of intelligence in the child . Routledge & Kegan Paul.

48.

Piaget

(1952). The origins of intelligence in children . International University Press.

49.

Quijano

(2000). Coloniality of power, Eurocentrism, and Latin America. Nepantla: Views from South , 1(3),533–580.

50.

Riegel

K. F.

(1979). Foundations of dialectical psychology . Academic Press.

51.

Said

(1978). Orientalism: Western representations of the orient . Pantheon.

52.

Sandburg

(1970). The complete poems of Carl Sandburg . Harcourt, Inc.

53.

Sinha

(1965). Integrating modern psychology with Indian thought. Journal of Humanistic Psychology , 5(1), 6–17.

54.

Sinha

(1997). Indigenizing psychology. In Berry

J. W.

, Poortinga

Y. H.

, & Pandey

(Eds.), Handbook of cross-cultural psychology: Theory and method (pp. 129–169). Allyn & Bacon.

55.

Sundararajan

(2019). Introduction to the special issue on Indigenous psychology: What’s the next step? Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology , 39(2), 65–66.