The benefits of being a multi-capital: The economic impact of the international and European institutions and interest groups

Abstract

Brussels is known worldwide for hosting (most of) the European institutions as well as several other international organisations like North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). Besides the symbolic political value, their presence has an economic impact because of their administrative activities and staff remunerations. Estimating the economic impact poses two main challenges. First, the supranational nature of these organisations makes it challenging to quantify the size of these institutions and related bodies because country-based statistical systems hardly account for transnational organisations. Second, as these institutions and organisations mainly rely on taxpayers’ funding, policymakers need transparent estimates to assess the implications of their decisions as well as for a matter of accountability. For these purposes, a meticulous data collection is carried out, and transparent assumptions are used to estimate the local economic multiplier effect of these activities accounting for operational expenditures, employees’ consumption as well as (Belgian) taxes and saving. The results show that the economic impact for the Brussels-Capital Region lies between 23% and 26% of regional turnover and 19% and 20% of employment, while interregional spillovers are estimated being around 1.5% to 1.7% of regional turnover and 0.6% to 0.7% of employment for both Flemish and Walloon regions.

Keywords

Brussels economic impact European institutions European interest groups input-output multiplier international organisations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bajenova

(2019) Rescaling expertise in EU policy-making: European think tanks and their reliance on symbolic, political and network capital. Globalisation, Societies and Education 17(1): 61–77.

Batey

PWJ

(2018) What can demographic–economic modeling tell us about the consequences of regional decline? International Regional Science Review 41(2): 256–281.

Batey

PWJ

Rose

(1990) Extended input-output models: progress and potential. International Regional Science Review 13(1–2): 27–49.

Batey

PWJ

Bazzazan

Madden

(2001) Dynamic extended input-output models: some preliminary thought. In: Felzenshṭain

McCann

McQuaid

, et al. (eds) Public Investment and Regional Economic Development. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Berkhout

Lowery

(2010) The changing demography of the EU interest system since 1990. European Union Politics 11(3): 447–461.

Bernard

(2008) The impact of the European Union on real estate in Brussels: between stereotype and underestimate. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/617

Biedenkopf

Petri

(2019) EU Delegations in European Union climate diplomacy: the role of links to Brussels, individuals and country contexts. Journal of European Integration 41(1): 47–63.

BISA (2018) Working Population (at Place of Residence): BISA Database. Brussels: BISA/IBSA. Available at: http://statistics.brussels/files/figures/7.3_labour_market_active_working_population.xls (accessed 24 July 2021).

IBSA (2020) Marché du Travail, Emploi Interieur. Brussels: Institut Bruxellois de Statistique et d’Analyse (IBSA) / Brussels Instituut voor Statistiek en Analyse (BISA). Available at: http://ibsa.brussels/fichiers/chiffres/7.4_marche_du_travail_emploi_interieur.xls (accessed 23 January 2020).

10.

Brachert

Brautzsch

H-U

Titze

(2016) Mapping potentials for input–output-based innovation flows in industrial clusters: an application to Germany. Economic Systems Research 28(4): 450–466.

11.

Brussels Interns NGO (2018) Young Professionals’ General Situation: Survey, by the Brussels Interns NGO ASBL – Survey. Brussels: Brussels Interns NGO (BINGO) ASBL, Young Professionals’ General Situation: Survey, by the Brussels Interns NGO ASBL.

12.

Burley

Dinan

Haar

Wesselius

(eds) (2010) Bursting the Brussels bubble: the battle to expose corporate lobbying at the heart of the EU: Alliance for lobbying transparency. Available at: https://books.google.be/books?id=PKq3oQEACAAJ

13.

Casier

(2019) The transformation of demographic structures and the geography of Europeans in Brussels between 2000 and 2018. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. DOI: 10.4000/brussels.2932.

14.

Christiaens

(2003) Rich Europe in poor Brussels: the impact of the European institutions in the Brussels Capital Region. City 7(2): 183–198.

15.

Clerbaux

Orianne

J-F

(2004) L’emploi Touristique En Région De Bruxelles-capitale : Tourisme D’affaires Et Tourisme De Loisirs. Bruxelles: Observatoire bruxellois du Marché du Travail et des Qualifications. Available at: http://www.actiris.be/Portals/36/Documents/FR/Emploi_touristique.pdf (accessed 19 November 2019).

16.

Corijn

Macharis

Jans

Huysseune

(2008) The impact of international institutions on Brussels: a multi-criteria analysis approach. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel/The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/638

17.

Corijn

Vandermotten

Decroly

J-M

Swyngedouw

(2009) Brussels as an international city: synopsis, CFB No. 13. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/995

18.

Deschouwer

Reuchamps

(2013) The Belgian federation at a crossroad. Regional & Federal Studies 23(3): 261–270.

19.

Dotti

(2015) Update of the Economic Impact of the European and International Institutions on the Brussels-Capital Region: Europe in Brussels. Figures 2016, April. Brussels: Visit Brussels. Available at: http://visitbrussels.be/bitc/static/front/img/db/ContentArticle_36735/pdf_34895.pdf (accessed 18 January 2016).

20.

Dotti

Spithoven

(2017) Spatial perspectives on knowledge brokers: evidence from Brussels. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 49(10): 2203–2222.

21.

Dotti

Spithoven

Wautelet

Yesbaert

(2021) The ‘certain’ returns from expenditures for ‘uncertain’ activities: a local multiplier approach to evaluate regional R&I policy. European Planning Studies 29(2): 389–409.

22.

EU Commission DG-Budget (2016a) Statement of estimates of the European Commission for the financial year 2017, SEC(2016)280, June. Brussels, Belgium EU: EU Commission, Directorate-General for Budget. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/budget/library/biblio/documents/2017/statement-of-estimates-of-the-european-commission.pdf (accessed 20 May 2020).

23.

EU Commission DG-HR (2016b) HR Key Figures 2016: staff members, 1 January. Brussels, Belgium EU: EU Commission, Directorate-General for Human Ressources. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/european-commission-hr-key-figures_2016_en.pdf (accessed 20 May 2020).

24.

EU Commission DG-Budget (2017a) Statement of estimates of the European Commission for the financial year 2018, SEC(2017) 250, May. Brussels, Belgium EU: EU Commission, Directorate-General for Budget. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/budget/library/biblio/documents/2018/statement-of-estimates-of-the-european-commission.pdf (accessed 20 May 2020).

25.

EU Commission DG-HR (2017b) HR Key Figures 2017: staff members, 1 January. Brussels, Belgium EU: EU Commission, Directorate-General for Human Ressources. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/european-commission-hr-key-figures_2017_en.pdf (accessed 20 May 2020).

26.

EU Commission DG-HR (2018) General Report on the activities of Human Ressources and Security. Brussels, Belgium EU: EU Commission, Directorate-General for Human Ressources. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/about_the_european_commission/departments_and_executive_agencies/documents/general-activity-report-2018-human-resources-and-security_en.pdf (accessed 20 May 2020).

27.

EU Commission SG (2019) EU Transparency Registry. Brussels, Belgium EU: EU Commission. Available at: https://data.europa.eu/euodp/en/data/dataset/transparency-register (accessed 19 November 2019).

28.

EU Commission DG-HR (2020) ‘Blue book’ traineeship. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/stages/home_en (accessed 21 May 2020).

29.

Faggio

Overman

(2014) The effect of public sector employment on local labour markets. Spatial Dimensions of Labor Markets 79: 91–107.

30.

Federal Planning Bureau (2016) Interregional input-output table: multipliers 2010 – ESA 1995. Available at: http://www.plan.be/databases/data-55-en-interregional+input+output+table+multipliers+2010+esa+1995 (accessed 27 February 2018).

31.

Ferreira

J-P

Ramos

Cruz

Barata

(2017) Modelling commuting patterns in a multi-regional input–output framework: impacts of an ‘urban re-centralization’ scenario. Journal of Geographical Systems 19(4): 301–317.

32.

Gatti

(2009) Defining the expat: the case of high-skilled migrants in Brussels. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/681

33.

Gerolimetto

Magrini

(2016) A spatial analysis of employment multipliers in the US. Letters in Spatial and Resource Sciences 9(3): 277–285.

34.

Giffoni

Schubert

Kroll

Zenker

Griniece

Gulyas

, et al. (2018) Research infrastructure impact assessment pathways: task 3.2 state of play – literature review. Available at: https://ri-paths.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/T3.2_Literature-review-1.pdf (accessed 17 December 2019).

35.

Greenwood

(2011) Actors of the common interest? The Brussels offices of the regions. Journal of European Integration 33(4): 437–451.

36.

Hein

(2000) Choosing a site for the capital of Europe. Geojournal 51(1): 83–97.

37.

Hermannsson

Lisenkova

McGregor

Swales

(2013) The expenditure impacts of individual higher education institutions and their students on the Scottish economy under a regional government budget constraint: homogeneity or heterogeneity? Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 45(3): 710–727.

38.

Hermannsson

Lisenkova

McGregor

Swales

(2014) ‘Policy scepticism’ and the impact of Scottish higher education institutions (HEIs) on their host region: accounting for regional budget constraints under devolution. Regional Studies 48(2): 400–417.

39.

Hermannsson

Lisenkova

McGregor

Swales

(2015) The expenditure impacts of London’s higher education institutions: the role of diverse income sources. Studies in Higher Education 40(9): 1641–1659.

40.

Hewings

GJD

Parr

(2007) Spatial Interdependence in a Metropolitan setting. Spatial Economic Analysis 2(1): 7–22.

41.

Hewings

GJD

Okuyama

Sonis

(2001) Economic interdependence within the Chicago Metropolitan area: a Miyazawa analysis. Journal of Regional Science 41(2): 195–217.

42.

Huysseune

Jans

(2008) Brussels as the capital of a Europe of the regions?. Regional offices as European policy actors. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/547?lang=en

43.

Klüver

(2010) Europeanization of lobbying activities: when national interest groups spill over to the European level. Journal of European Integration 32(2): 175–191.

44.

Klüver

Saurugger

(2013) Opening the black box: the professionalization of interest groups in the European Union. Interest Groups & Advocacy 2(2): 185–205.

45.

Lagrou

(2000) Brussels: five capitals in search of a place – the citizens, the planners and the functions. Geojournal 51(1): 99–112.

46.

Lord

Cassiers

Gerber

(2014) L’impact des migrations internationales et des mobilités résidentielles sur l’évolution socio-spatiale des agglomérations de Luxembourg et Bruxelles. Environnement Urbain / Urban Environment 8: c1–c22.

47.

Madden

(1993) Welfare payments and migration in a nonlinear, extended input-output model with an application to Scotland. Papers in Regional Science 72(2): 177–199.

48.

Merlevede

Schoors

Spatareanu

(2014) FDI spillovers and time since foreign entry. World Development 56: 108–126.

49.

Miller

Blair

(2009) Input-output Analysis: Foundations and Extensions. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

50.

Moretti

(2010) Local multipliers. American Economic Review 100(2): 373–377.

51.

Moretti

Thulin

(2013) Local multipliers and human capital in the United States and Sweden. Industrial and Corporate Change 22(1): 339–362.

52.

National Bank of Belgium (2021) Online Statistics of the National Bank of Belgium. Statistics. Brussels, Belgium EU: National Bank of Belgium. Available at: https://stat.nbb.be/ (accessed 25 August 2021).

53.

North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) (2018) New NATO Headquarters: Factsheet, May. Brussels: NATO. Available at: https://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/pdf_2018_05/20180507_1805-factsheet-nnhq-en.pdf.pdf (accessed 21 May 2020).

54.

Papadopoulos

(2006) Brussels: pseudo-capital of Europe – perspectives of Belgium’s global city in-themaking. In: Schneider-Sliwa

(ed.) Cities in Transition: Globalization, Political Change and Urban Development: The GeoJournal Library. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands, pp. 251–271.

55.

Perchoc

(2017) Brussels: what European urban narrative? Journal of Contemporary European Studies 25(3): 367–379.

56.

Plehwe

(2012) Measuring European Relations of Lobby Power (Since the German Word Play Does Not Translate): Short Expertise on behalf of AK Wien. Wien: AK Wien. Available at: http://media.arbeiterkammer.at/wien/MWUG_Ausgabe_113_englisch.pdf

57.

Rasmussen

Alexandrova

(2012) Foreign interests lobbying Brussels: participation of non-EU members in commission consultations. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 50(4): 614–631.

58.

Sonis

Hewings

(2006) Miyazawa meet Christaller: spatial multipliers within a triple decomposition of input-output central place systems. The Regional Economics Applications Laboratory. Available at: https://www.iioa.org/conferences/intermediate-2004/pdf/368.pdf

59.

Sorurbakhsh

(2014) Population ecology and European interest Groups over time: a data set. European Political Science 13(1): 61–77.

60.

Struyven

Desiere

Cuyvers

Gangji

(2018) Internationale tewerkstelling: de grote afwezige in de statistieken over de arbeidsmarkt. Over.werk: Tijdschrift van het Steunpunt WSE 28(2): 51–56.

61.

Tatham

Thau

(2013) The More the Merrier: Accounting for Regional Paradiplomats in Brussels: European Union Politics. London: SAGE.

62.

The Economist (2002) The Brussels consensus. The Economist, 2 December. Available at: https://www.economist.com/europe/2002/12/05/the-brussels-consensus (accessed 23 May 2020).

63.

Thulin

(2015) Local multiplier and economic base analysis. In: Karlsson

Andersson

Norman

(eds) Handbook of Research Methods and Applications in Economic Geography. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 213–233.

64.

van Dijk

(2017) Local employment multipliers in U.S. cities. Journal of Economic Geography 17(2): 465–487.

65.

van Dijk

(2018) Robustness of econometrically estimated local multipliers across different methods and data. Journal of Regional Science 58(2): 281–294.

66.

Van Hamme

Grippa

Van Criekingen

(2016) Migratory movements and dynamics of neighbourhoods in Brussels. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/1338

67.

Van Hamme

Waiengnier

Bassens

Hendrikse

(2020) Advanced services: the attractiveness of Brussels and local issues. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/5141

68.

Van Parijs

(2007) Brussels Capital of Europe: the new linguistic challenges. Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/410

69.

Van Parijs

Van Parys

(2010) Brussels, capital of Europe: a sustainable choice? Brussels Studies. La revue scientifique pour les recherches sur Bruxelles / Het wetenschappelijk tijdschrift voor onderzoek over Brussel / The Journal of Research on Brussels. Université Saint-Louis Bruxelles. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/769

70.

Van Wynsberghe

(2013) Brussels and Washington: two federal capital cities with two similar metropolitan experiences? Brussels Studies. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/3044

71.

Vandermotten

Biot

Van Hamme

, et al. (2007) Impact socio-économique de la présence des institutions de l’Union européenne et des autres institutions internationales en Région de Bruxelles-Capitale. March. Brussels, ULB-IGEAT.

72.

Wixted

Yamano

Webb

(2006) Input-output analysis in an increasingly globalised world. Available at: https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/science-and-technology/input-output-analysis-in-an-increasingly-globalised-world_303252313764

73.

Wonka

(2008) Decision-making dynamics in the European Commission: partisan, national or sectoral? Journal of European Public Policy 15(8): 1145–1163.

74.

Wonka

Baumgartner

Mahoney

Berkhout

(2010) Measuring the size and scope of the EU interest group population. European Union Politics 11(3): 463–476.