Knowledge about moral development and elderly persons is very limited. A hermeneutical interpretative study was conducted with healthy elderly persons (n = 20) in order to explore and describe their moral orientation based on the paradigms of justice (Kohlberg) and care (Gilligan). The types of moral reasoning, dominance, alignment and orientation were determined. All but one participant included both types of reasoning when discussing an ethical conflict. None of the men’s moral reasoning was dominated by caring, but justice dominated the reasoning of four women. The implications for ethical decision-making and future research are discussed.
American Hospital Association . Preparing for advanced directives (Video [157301] broadcast and resource book). Chicago, IL: AHA , 1991.
6.
Pinch WJ , Parsons ME.The ethics of treatment decision making: the elderly’s perspective . Geriatr Nurs1993; 14: 289-293 .
7.
Kohlberg L. The development of modes of moral thinking and choice in the years ten to sixteen [Dissertation]. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago, 1958.
8.
Kohlberg L.The psychology of moral development: the nature and validity of moral stages. San Francisco, CA: Harper and Row , 1984.
9.
Gilligan C.In a different voice: women’s conceptions of self and of morality . Harvard Educ Rev1977; 4: 481-517 .
10.
Gilligan C.Woman’s place in men’s life cycle . Harvard Educ Rev1979; 49: 431-446 .
11.
Gilligan C.In a different voice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press , 1982.
12.
Millette BE.Using Gilligan’s framework to analyze nurses’ stories of moral choice . West J Nurse Res1994; 16: 660-674 .
13.
Rest J.Recent research on an objective test of moral judgment: how the important issues of a moral dilemma are defined. In: DePalma DJ , Foley JM eds. Moral development: current theory and research. New York: Wiley , 1975: 75-93.
14.
Brown L , Argyris D , Attanucci J , et al.A guide to reading narratives of conflict and choice for self and moral voice (Monograph 1). Cambridge, MA: Center for the Study of Gender, Education and Human Development, Harvard University, Graduate School of Education , 1988.
15.
Cavanaugh JC.Adult development and aging. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole , 1993.
16.
Haber J , McMahon AL , Price-Hoskins P , Sideleau BF.Comprehensive psychiatric nursing. St Louis, MO: Mosby Year Book , 1992: 99-100, 126-129.
17.
Pratt M , Golding G , Kerig P.Lifespan differences in adult thinking about hypothetical and personal moral issues . Int J Behav Dev1987; 10: 359-375 .
18.
Rybash JM , Hoyer WJ , Roodin PA.Responses to moral dilemmas involving self versus others . Int J Aging Hum Dev1983/84; 18: 73-77 .
19.
Chap JB.Moral judgment in middle and late adulthood: the effects of age-appropriate moral dilemmas and spontaneous role taking . Int J Aging Hum Dev1985/86; 22: 161-172 .
20.
Little GL , Robinson KD.Effects of moral reconation therapy upon moral reasoning, life purpose, and recidivism among drug and alcohol offenders . Psychol Rep1989; 64: 83-90 .
21.
Little GL , Robinson KD.Relationship of DUI recidivism to moral reasoning, sensation seeking, and MacAndrew alcoholism scores . Psychol Rep1989; 64: 171-174 .
22.
Shulik RN.Faith development in older adults . Educ Gerontol1988; 14: 291-301 .
23.
Snarey J , Lydens L.Worker equality and adult development: the kibbutz as a development model . Psychol Aging1990; 5: 86-93 .
24.
White CB.Age, education, and sex effects on adult moral reasoning . Int J Aging Hum Dev1988; 27: 271-281 .
25.
Norman DK , Murphy JM , Gilligan C , Vasudev J.Sex differences and interpersonal relationships: a cross-sectional sample in the US and India . Int J Aging Hum Dev1981/82; 14: 291-306 .
26.
Pratt MW , Diessner R , Hunsberger B , Prancer SM , Savoy K.Four pathways in the analysis of adult development and aging: comparing analyses of reasoning about personal-life dilemmas . Psychol Aging1991; 6: 666-675 .
27.
Lipson JG.The use of self in ethnographic research. In: Morse JM ed. Qualitative nursing research. Newbury Park, CA: Sage , 1991: 73-89.
28.
Sandelowski M.The problem of rigor in qualitative research . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1986; 8: 27-37 .
29.
Stetler CB.Refinement of the Stetler/Marram model for application of research findings to clinical practice . Nurs Outlook1994; 42: 15-25 .
30.
Chally PS.Moral decision making in neonatal intensive care . J Obstet Gynecol Neonat Nurs1992; 21: 475-482 .
31.
Pratt M , Golding G , Hunter W , Sampson R.Sex differences in adult moral orientations . J Pers1988; 56: 373-391 .
32.
Walker L.A longitudinal study of moral reasoning . Child Dev1989; 60: 522-526 .
