In this discussion paper we consider the influence of ethnicity, religiosity, spirituality and health literacy on Advance Care Planning for older people. Older people from cultural and ethnic minorities have low access to palliative or end-of-life care and there is poor uptake of advance care planning by this group across a number of countries where advance care planning is promoted. For many, religiosity, spirituality and health literacy are significant factors that influence how they make end-of-life decisions. Health literacy issues have been identified as one of the main reasons for a communication gaps between physicians and their patients in discussing end-of-life care, where poor health literacy, particularly specific difficulty with written and oral communication often limits their understanding of clinical terms such as diagnoses and prognoses. This then contributes to health inequalities given it impacts on their ability to use their moral agency to make appropriate decisions about end-of-life care and complete their Advance Care Plans. Currently, strategies to promote advance care planning seem to overlook engagement with religious communities. Consequently, policy makers, nurses, medical professions, social workers and even educators continue to shape advance care planning programmes within the context of a medical model. The ethical principle of justice is a useful approach to responding to inequities and to promote older peoples’ ability to enact moral agency in making such decisions.
FreyRRaphaelDBellamyG, et al.Advance care planning for Māori, Pacific and Asian people: the views of New Zealand healthcare professionals. Health Soc Care Community2014; 22(3): 290–299.
2.
SinclairCWilliamsGKnightA, et al.A public health approach to promoting advance care planning to Aboriginal people in regional communities. Aust J Rural Health2014; 22(1): 23–28.
3.
JohnsonKS. Racial and ethnic disparities in palliative care. J Palliat Med2013; 16(11): 1329–1334.
4.
CalanzaniNKoffmanJHigginsonIJ. Demographic profile and the current state of palliative and end of life care provision for black Asian and minority ethnic groups in the UK. London: Cicely Saunders Institute, King’s College London, 2013.
5.
CarrD. Racial and ethnic differences in advance care planning: identifying subgroup patterns and obstacles. J Aging Health2012; 24(6): 923–947.
6.
CarrD. ‘I don’t want to die like that…’: the impact of significant others’ death quality on advance care planning. Gerontologist2012; 52: 770–781.
7.
McGrathPOgilvieKFRaynerRD, et al.The ‘right story’ to the ‘right person’: communication issues in end-of-life care for Indigenous people. Aust Health Rev2005; 29(3): 306–316.
8.
McGrathP. ‘I don’t want to be in that big city; this is my country here’: research findings on Aboriginal peoples’ preference to die at home. Aust J Rural Health2007; 15(4): 264–268.
9.
McGrathPHolewaHKail-BuckleyS. ‘They should come out here…’: research findings on lack of local palliative care services for Australian aboriginal people. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2007; 24: 105–113.
10.
OwensARandhawaG. It’s different from my culture; they’re very different: providing community-based, ‘culturally competent’ palliative care for South Asian people in the UK. Health Soc Care Community2004; 12(5): 414–421.
11.
HalpernSDEmanuelEJ. Advance directives and cost savings: greater clarity and perpetual confusion. Arch Intern Med2012; 172(3): 266–268.
12.
KlinglerC, in der SchmittenJMarckmannG. Does facilitated advance care planning reduce the costs of care near the end of life?Systematic review and ethical considerations. Palliat Med2016; 30(5): 423–433.
13.
CarrD. Racial differences in end-of-life planning: why don’t Blacks and Latinos prepare for the inevitable. Omega2011; 63(1): 1–20.
14.
BrownGC. Living too long. EMBO Rep2015; 16(2): 137–141.
15.
BakerME. Economic, political and ethnic influences on end-of-life decision making: a decade in review. J Health Soc Policy2002; 14(3): 27–39.
16.
HanchateAKronmanACYoung-XuY, et al.Racial and ethnic differences in end of life costs: why do minorities cost more than Whites. Arch Intern Med2009; 169(5): 493–501.
17.
KelleyASEttnerSLMorrisonS, et al.Determinants of medical expenditures in the last 6 months of life. Ann Intern Med2011; 154(4): 235–242.
18.
NicholasLHLangaKMIwashynaTJ, et al.Regional variation in the association between advance directives and end of life medical expenditures. JAMA2011; 306: 1447–1453.
19.
JohnstoneMKanitsakiO. Ethics and advance care planning in a culturally diverse society. J Transcult Nurs2009; 20(4): 405–416.
20.
Harrison DeningK. End of life, dementia and black and minority ethnic groups. In: BotsfordJDeningKH (eds) Dementia, culture and ethnicity: issues for all. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2015, pp. 219–236.
21.
VenkatasaluMArthurASeymourJ. Talking about end-of-life care: the perspectives of older South Asians living in East London. J Res Nurs2013; 18(5): 394–406.
22.
TeixeiraAAHanveyLTaylerC, et al.What do Canadians think of advanced care planning? Findings from an online opinion poll. BMJ Support Palliat Care2013; 5(1): 40–47.
23.
CarrDLuthEA. Advance care planning: contemporary issues and future directions. Innov Aging2017; 1(1): igx012.
24.
SudoreRLLumHDYouJJ, et al.Defining advance care planning for adults: a consensus definition from a multidisciplinary Delphi panel. J Pain Symptom Manage2017; 53(5): 821–832. e1.
25.
vanEechoudIJPiersRDVanCampS, et al.Perspectives of family members on planning end-of-life care for terminally ill and frail older people. J Pain Symptom Manage2014; 47(5): 876–886.
26.
PiersRDvan EechoudIJVan CampS, et al.Advance care planning in terminally ill and frail older persons. Patient Educ Couns2013; 90: 323–329.
27.
BoernerKCarrDMoormanS. Family relationships and advance care planning: do supportive and critical relations encourage of hinder planning?J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci2013; 68(2): 246–256.
28.
SandersJJRobinsonMTBlockSD. Factors impacting advance care planning among African Americans: results of a systematic integrated review. J Palliat Med2016; 19(2): 202–227.
29.
HuangIANeuhausJMChiongW. Racial and ethnic difference in advanced directive possession: role of demographic factors, religious affiliation, and personal health values in a national survey of older adults. J Palliat Med2016; 19(2): 149–156.
30.
WestSKHollisM. Barriers to completion of advance care directives among African Americans ages 25–84: a cross-generational study. Omega2012; 65(2): 125–137.
31.
BullockKMcGrawSABlankK, et al.What matters to older African Americans facing end-of-life decisions? A focus group study. J Soc Work End Life Palliat Care2005; 1(3): 3–19.
32.
BullockK. Promoting advance directives among African Americans: a faith based model. J Palliat Med2006; 9(1): 183–195.
33.
DavisNS. A heavenly collaboration: social workers and churches working to increase advance directive completion among African American elderly. J Hum Behav Soc Environ2013; 23: 462–474.
34.
RichSEGruber-BaldiniALQuinnCC, et al.Discussion as a factor in racial disparity in advance directive completion at nursing home admission. J Am Geriatr Soc2009; 57(1): 146–152.
35.
PerkinsHGeppertCMGonzalesA, et al.Cross-cultural similarities and differences in attitudes about advance care planning. J Gen Intern Med2002; 17(1): 48–57.
36.
WatersCM. End of life care directives among African Americans: lessons learned – a need for community-centered discussion and education. J Community Health Nurs2000; 17(1): 25–37.
37.
WatersCM. Understanding and supporting African Americans’ perspectives of end-of-life care planning and decision-making. Qual Health Res2001; 11(3): 385–398.
38.
KossCSBakerTA. Race differences in advance directive completion: the narrowing gap between white and African American older adults. J Aging Health2017; 29(2): 324–342.
39.
KossCSBakerTA. A question of trust: does mistrust or perceived discrimination account for race disparities in advance directive completion. Innov Aging2017; 1(1): igx017.
40.
ColcloughYYBrownGM. End-of-life treatment decision making: American Indians’ perspective. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2013; 31(5): 503–512.
41.
Care Quality Commission (CQC). People from Black and minority ethnic communities a different ending: addressing inequalities in end of life care. Newcastle upon Tyne: CQC, 2016.
42.
GarridoMMIdlerELLeventhalH, et al.Pathways from religion to advance care planning: beliefs about control over length of life and end-of-life values. Gerontologist2012; 53(5): 801–816.
43.
PhelpsACMaciejewskiPKNilssonM, et al.Religious coping and use of intensive life-prolonging care near death in patients with advanced cancer. JAMA2009; 301(11): 1140–1147.
44.
BalboniTVanderwerkerLCBlockSD, et al.Religiousness and spiritual support among advanced cancer patients and associations with end-of-life treatment preferences and quality of life. J Clin Oncol2007; 25(5): 555–560.
45.
BraunUKBeythRJFordME, et al.Decision-making styles of seriously ill male veterans for end-of-life care: autonomists altruists authorizers absolute trusters, and avoiders. Patient Educ Couns2014; 94(3): 334–341.
46.
BarrettRK. Dialogues in diversity: an invited series of papers Advance Directives DNRS, and end-of-life care for African Americans. OMEGA2006; 52(3): 249–261.
47.
JohnsonKSElbert-AvilaKITulskyJA. The influence of spiritual beliefs and practices on the treatment preferences of African Americans: a review of the literature. J Am Geriatr Soc2005; 53(4): 711–719.
48.
JohnsonKSKuchibhatlaMTulskyJA. What explains racial differences in the use of advance directives and attitudes toward hospice care. J Am Geriatr Soc2008; 56(10): 1953–1958.
49.
NathSHirschmanKBLewisB, et al.A place called life: exploring the advance care planning of African-American PACE enrollees. Soc Work Health Care2008; 47(3): 277–292.
50.
DeningKHKingMJonesL, et al.Healthcare decision-making: past present and future, in light of a diagnosis of dementia. Int J Palliat Nurs2017; 23(1): 4–11.
51.
KarchesKEChungGSAroraV, et al.Religiosity spirituality, and end-of-life planning: a single-site survey of medical inpatients. J Pain Symptom Manage2012; 44(6): 843–851.
52.
MelhadoLBushyA. Exploring uncertainty in advance care planning in African Americans: does low health literacy influence decision making preference at end of life. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2011; 28(7): 495–500.
53.
DaalemanTPEmmettCPDobbsD, et al.An exploratory study of advance care planning in seriously ill African American elders. J Natl Med Assoc2008; 100(12): 1457–1462.
54.
DoorenbosAZNiesMA. The use of advance directives in a population of Asian Indian Hindus. J Transcult Nurs2003; 14(1): 17–24.
55.
HtutYShahrulKPoiPJH. The views of older Malaysians on advanced directive and advanced care planning: a qualitative study. Asia Pac J Public Health2009; 19: 58–66.
56.
OchiengBMN. Spirituality as a mediating factor in Black families beliefs and experiences of health and wellbeing. Int J Interdiscipli Soc Sci2010; 5(6): 99–109.
57.
BatterhamRWHawkinsMCollinsPA, et al.Health literacy: applying current concepts to improve health services and reduce health inequalities. Public Health2016; 132: 3–12.
58.
SudoreRLLandefeldCSBarnesDE, et al.An advance directive redesigned to meet the literacy level of most adults: a randomized trial. Patient Educ Couns2007; 69(1–3): 165–195.
59.
VolandesAEPaasche-OrlowMGillickMR, et al.Health literacy not race predicts end-of-life care preferences. J Palliat Med2008; 11: 754–762.
60.
WaiteKRFedermanADMcCarthyM, et al.Literacy and race as risk factors for low rates of advance directives in older adults. J Am Geriatr Soc2013; 61(3): 403–406.
61.
SentellTLHalpinHA. Importance of adult literacy in understanding health disparities. J Gen Intern Med2006; 21(8): 862–866.
62.
VolandesAEPaasche-OrlowMK. Health literacy, health inequality and a just healthcare system. Am J Bioeth2007; 7(11): 5–10.
63.
RuddREMcCrayATNutbeamD. Health literacy and definition of terms. In: BegorayDGillisDRowlandsG (eds) Health literacy in context: international perspectives. New York: Nova Science, 2012: 13–32.
64.
RootmanIGordon-El-BihbetyD. A vision for a health literate Canada: report on the expert panel on health literacy. Ottawa, ON, Canada: Canadian Public Health Association, 2008.
65.
SykesSWillsJRowlandsG, et al.Understanding critical health literacy: a concept analysis. BMC Public Health2013; 13: 150.
66.
LadinKButtafarroKHahnE, et al.End-of-life care? I’m not going to worry about that yet: health literacy gaps and end-of-life planning among elderly dialysis patients. The Gerontologist2018; 58: 290–299.
67.
AhluwaliaSGBekelmanDBHuynhAK, et al.Barriers and strategies to an iterative model of advance care planning communication. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2015; 32(8): 817–823.
68.
TierneyWMDexterPRGramelspacherGP, et al.The effect of discussions about advance directives on patients’ satisfaction with primary care. J Gen Intern Med2001; 16(1): 32–40.
69.
PeriyakoilVSNeriEKraemerH. Patient-reported barriers to high-quality, end-of-life care: a multiethnic, multilingual, mixed-methods study. J Palliat Med2016; 19(4): 373–379.
70.
KindingDPanzerANielsen-BohlmanL. Health literacy: a prescription to end confusion. Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2004.
71.
BakerDWWolfMSFeinglassJ, et al.Health literacy and mortality among elderly persons. Arch Intern Med2007; 167(14): 1503–1509.
72.
CarnevaleFAVissandjeeBNylandA, et al.Ethical considerations in cross-linguistic nursing. Nurs Ethics2009; 16(6): 813–826.
73.
ThomasRWilsonDMJusticeC, et al.A literature review of preferences for end-of-life care in developed countries by individuals with different cultural affiliations and ethnicity. J Hos Palliat Nurs2008; 10(3): 142–161.
HoutsPSDoakCCDoakLG, et al.The role of pictures in improving health communication: a review of research on attention, comprehension, recall, and adherence. Patient Educ Couns2006; 61(2): 173–190.
76.
KohHKBrachCHarrisLM, et al.A proposed ‘health literate care model’ would constitute a systems approach to improving patients’ engagement in care. Health Aff2013; 32(2): 357–367.
77.
EdwardsIDelanyCMTownsendAF, et al.Moral agency as enacted justice. Phys Ther2011; 91(11): 1653–1663.
