This paper examines Drs Julius and Edwin van Millingen, father and son physicians from a Constantinople-based Levantine family. They thrived in late 19th-century Ottoman Constantinople, a period of modernization aimed at survival amid decline. The profiles of Millingen family members set an exemplary case of the Levantine families who preferred to settle and pursue their careers in the Ottoman capital, particularly for generations in the Pera (Beyoglu) bourgeoisie, associated with the prominent industrial and literate centers in Europe. Dr Julius Michael van Millingen (1800–1878) was physician and companion to Lord Byron (1788–1824), and served as the private physician of the Sultan Abdulmecid (1839–1861), and the Queen Mother, Bezm-i Alem Valide Sultan (1807–1853) at the Imperial Ottoman Palace. He published considerable writings on balneology, then. His son, Dr Edwin van Millingen (1850–1900), an Istanbul-born ophthalmologist, worked at top hospitals, taught at the Imperial School of Medicine, and collaborated with the Société Impériale de Médecine. He reported on common ophthalmological diseases, with detailed statistics and meticulously organized tabular data. The multicultural lives of this Levantine family offer a unique glimpse into 19th-century Turkish medical history, reflecting close ties with Western medical centers.
MantranR.17.yy.in ikinci yarisinda Istanbul. vol.2. Ankara, Türk Tarih Kurumu. 1990, p.117; Millingen, Alexander van. Constantinople, Reproduction of the Original, Frankfurt am Main, Deutschland, 2018. (accessed 16 August 2024)
2.
UlmanYI, Portraits of Italians in health affairs in 19th century Istanbul: “Dr. Castaldi, pharmacist A. Calleja, midwife Messani”, In: GallettiM (ed), Medici, missionari, musicisti militari italiani attivi in Persiaİmpero Ottomano ed Egitto, Quaderni di Oriente Moderno Roma, Istituto per l'Oriente C.A. Nallino,
2008:
88:
135–
149.
3.
EldemEGoffmanDMastersB. Dogu ile Bati Arasinda Osmanli Kenti, Halep, Izmir ve Istanbul.
Istanbul:
Tarih Vakfi Yurt Yayinlari,
2003.
4.
PoyrazB. The history of church diplomacy in Turkey. Istanbul:
Libra Kitap,
2016, Ahmad F. Ottoman perceptions of the capitulations 1800–1914. Journal of Islamic Studies2000;
11:
1–
20.
5.
In Ottoman history, the term Tanzimat, which means ‘the reforms’, refers to the era that started in 1839 and concluded in 1876. Findley, CV. The Tanzimat. In: Kasaba, R (ed) The Cambridge History of Turkey 4. Cambridge University Press,
2008, pp.
11–
37.
6.
ToprakZ.
Modernization and commercialization in the Tanzimat Period: 1838–1875. New Perspectives on Turkey1992;
7:
62.
7.
KeyderC. Belle Époque ve liman kentleri. In: KolluogluBToksozM (eds) Osmanlılardan Günümüze Doğu Akdeniz kentleri. Translated by Neyyir Berktay.
Istanbul:
Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları,
2010, pp.
15–
16. Kasaba R, Keyder C, Tabak F. Eastern Mediterranean port cities and their bourgeoisies: Merchants, political projects, and nation-states. Rev (Fernand Braudel Center).1986;
10(
1):
121–
35.
8.
BurkeEIII. Akdeniz Modernitesinin Derin Yapilari. In: KolluogluBToksozM (eds) Osmanlilardan Gunumuze Dogu Akdeniz Kentleri. Neyyir Berktay, trans.
Istanbul:
Turkiye İş Bankasi Kultur Yayinlari,
2010, p.
246.
9.
QuataertD.The Ottoman Empire (1700–1922).
New York:
Cambridge University Press,
2005, p.
157.
EldemE. Levanten Kelimesi Uzerine. In: YumrulADikkayaF (eds) Avrupali mi Levanten mi.
Istanbul:
Baglam Yayınları,
2006, pp.
15–
16.
12.
MarmaraR. Osmanli baskentinde bir levanten semti: Galata-Pera.
Is Bankasi Yayinlari,
2020.
13.
YumulA. Melez kimlikler. In: YumrulADikkayaF (eds) Avrupali mi Levanten mi.
Istanbul:
Baglam Yayınları,
2006, pp.
40.
14.
DoyleG.Marginality and boundary-making among Latins of 19th century Ottoman Istanbul. In: Blackthorne-O’BarrEÇağlarB (eds) Levantines of the Ottoman world: communities, identities, and cultures. Ibn Haldun Universitesi Yayinlari,
2023, p.
39.
15.
RussellGA.
Physicians at the Ottoman Court. Medical History1990;
34:
243–
267. Yildirim N. Turk Hekimlerinin Seckinlesme Surecinde Tip Bilgisinin Transferi. In: Erdemir AD, Oncel O, Kucukdag Y, Okka B, Erer S (eds) I. Uluslararasi Turk Tip Tarihi Kongresi, 10. Ulusal Turk Tip Tarihi Kongresi Bildiri Kitabi, vol. 1. Istanbul, 2008: p. 103.
16.
UlmanYI. op. cit; Ulman YI. Osmanli Devrinin Kadin Dogum Hekimlerinden Dr. A. Vuccino (1829–1893). Hastane2006;
42:
32–
33.
17.
MasonJ.Three years in Turkey: the journal of a medical mission to the Jews.
London:
J.Snow publisher,
1860, pp.
313–
315.
MillingenJM. Memoirs of the affairs of Greece: containing an account of the military and political events which occurred in 1823 and following years; with various anecdotes relating to Lord Byron, and an account of his last illness and death.
John Rodwell,
1831.
21.
MavrogenisS. Les Bains orientaux: avec une notice biographique sur Jules van Millingen. G. Fischbach, 1891, p. 9.
22.
TasyakanB.The volunteer firefighters of Istanbul 1826–1923. MA. Thesis, Bogaziçi University, Ataturk İnstitute for Modern Turkish History, Istanbul,
2008, p.
41.
23.
MillingenJR. Dr. Julius Van Millingen (1800–1878). Unpublished biography. No date available. We extend our gratitude to Mr. Gideon Cumming, Millingen's great-grandchild, for generously sharing this biography with us.
24.
Journal de Constantinople, Echo de l’Orient (JCEO), 4e année, No: 197, 9 Novembre 1849.
25.
MasonJ.Three years in Turkey: the journal of a medical mission to the Jews.
London:
J.Snow publisher,
1860, p.
315.
26.
The use of baths, particularly in natural mineral waters, to treat diseases, injuries, and other physical conditions. The suggestion of Dr. Millingen led to increased demand, prompting upgrades such as expanded roads, enlarged bathhouses, and the construction of a mansion, hamam, pool, and other facilities. The related properties were transferred to the sultan's private treasury, becoming a significant source of income. However, as interest waned, the springs experienced a decline in attendance, reduced upkeep, and eventual deterioration over the following decades. Evered, K and Evered E. Therapeutic landscapes and nationalism: Turkey and the curative waters of Kemalism. Landscape History.2017,
38 (
2), p.
85.
27.
Mordtmann. Annexe Balnéologique concernant la vie et les actes de Julius van Millingen. Gazette Médicale d’Orient, XXXVe année, No: 9, Constantinople, 30 Juillet 1892: 172. Mavrogenis S. Les Bains orientaux: avec une notice biographique sur Jules van Millingen. G. Fischbach, 1891: 25.
28.
Journal de Constantinople, Echo de l’Orient (JCEO), 3e année, No: 80, 21 Mars 1848.
29.
Wellcome Collection. Medallic history of Napoleon. A collection of all the medals, coins, and jettons, relating to his actions and reign. From the year 1796 to 1815 / [A.L. Millin]. Millin AL. 1819–1821. https://wellcomecollection.org/works/btndxgym (accessed16 August 2024).
30.
Sir John Soane’s Museum London. Millin AL. Medallic history of Napoleon. A collection of all the medals, coins, and jettons, relating to his actions and reign. From the year 1796 to 1815. London: Rodwell and Martin, 1819. vi, [2], 112, [8] p., LX pl.; 28.8 cm. (4°). https://collections.soane.org/b8355 (accessed16 August 2024).
31.
Some of the topics covered in this book are obesity, gigantic races, unlawful cures, medicinal effects of water, barber-surgeons, flagellation, decapitation, hydrophobia, and mummies. See: The Project Gutenberg eBook. Curiosities of Medical Experience, by Millingen JG. Release Date: March 7, 2012 [eBook #39074]. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/39074/39074-h/39074-h.htm (accessed16 August 2024).
32.
Larousse Grand Dictionnaire Universel, Tome Onzieme. Paris: 1865, p. 268.
33.
Buyuk Larousse Sozluk ve Ansiklopedisi, cilt 16. Istanbul, 1986, p. 8184.
Gazette Médicale d’Orient (GMO), IIe année, No: 1, Constantinople, Avril 1858, p: 12; ibid, II, 6, Septembre 1858, p: 120.
37.
MillingenJ. Analyse des Réponses aux quatre questions sur la vaccination, adressées en 1856 par le Comité Général de Santé de Londres aux Medecins des tous les pays. Gazette Médicale d’Orient (GMO), Ie année, No: 9, Décembre 1857: 161–165; No: 10, Janvier 1858: 472–475.
MillingenJ. Les Bains Orientaux. Gazette Médicale d’Orient (GMO), Ie année, No: 10, Janvier 1858: 169–181; No: 11, Février 1858: 185–196; No: 12, Mars 1858: 201–210.
40.
ScottJ.
Medical memorial: sir James Young Simpson (1811–1870). Journal of Medical Biography2013;
23:
178. Millingen J. De L’Amenorrhée et son traitement local par le Prof. Simpson d’Edinbourgh. Gazette Médicale d’Orient (GMO), Ve année, No: 6, Septembre 1861: 85–88.
41.
MasonJ.Three years in Turkey: the journal of a medical mission to the Jews.
London:
J.Snow publisher,
1860, p.
321.
42.
MarmaraR. Osmanlı başkentinde bir levanten semti: Galata-Pera. İş Bankası Yayınları, 2020., Kentel, K. M. Assembling ‘Cosmopolitan’Pera: an infrastructural history of late Ottoman İstanbul. PhD Thesis. University of Washington, 2018.
43.
Muller-WienerW. Istanbul’un Tarihsel Topografyasi. Istanbul: Yapi Kredi, 2002, pp. 14, 37. See also Byzantine Constantinople: the walls of the city and adjoining historical sites (John Murray, London, 1899); Van Millingen A. Constantinople. London: Adam & Charles Black, 1906.; with Traquair R, George WS, Henderson AE. Byzantine Churches in Constantinople: their history and architecture. London: Macmillan & Co, 1912.; George WS. The Church of Saint Eirene at Constantinople, with a historical notice by Alexander Van Millingen. London: Oxford University Press, [1913]. Also contributed to Murray's Handbook of Constantinople and the Encyclopædia Britannica.
44.
J. Millingen relates that his children were baptized by Protestant ministers. See Mason, ibid, p. 321.
45.
ToprakZ. ibid, p. 336.
46.
Foreign missions in the Ottoman capital had established their hospitals in Constantinople, most of them are still activating their main purpose under the Ministry of Health Affairs in Turkey now. One of those historical institutions, the British Seamen’s Hospital, was established by the British Government during the Crimean War (1853–1855), in the Galata Pera region as a spacious, airy, and high place to care for the British seamen and made them breath fresh air. For more information please see Yildirim, N. “Ingiliz Hastanesi”, Istanbul Ansiklopedisi, Kultur Bakanligi and Tarih Vakfi, Istanbul, 1994; 4, p. 173.
47.
Van MillingenE.Aide de la clinique otologique. Gazette Médicale d’Orient1876;
XX: 5–6-7:
69–
71.
48.
He also discusses the clinical observations of granular ophthalmia in young people aged 8–21 at a scientific session of the Society: Gazette Médicale d’Orient 1885; XXVIII: 10: 144. Granular refers to a texture or appearance characterized by small, grain-like particles or granules. For the treatment of granular ophtalmia, trachoma, in the period, see Granular Ophthalmia. Hospital (Lond 1886). 1891 Feb 28;9(231):329–330. PMID: 29821133; PMCID: PMC5213898.
49.
Van MillingenE. Augenheilanstalt in Constantinopel: Bericht uber die Jahre 1880 und 1881.
Salzburg:
Zaunrith'sche Buchdruckerei,
1883.
50.
Gazette Médicale d’Orient (GMO), vol. XXVIII, No: 9, 15 Août 1885: 143–144. Gazette Médicale d’Orrient, Esquisse Biographique du Dr. Edwin Van Millingen, par le Dr. Bratzanos, (lu dans la séance du 14 Décembre 1900), 45ème Année, No.24 15 Fevrier 1901, pp: 493–496. Electrotherapy was a method discovered and used in various fields in medicine, including ophthalmology. In galvanocauteries, an electric current is passed through a fine platinum wire, which then glows red and can be used for cauterization. However, to try to volatilize it, which would require its replacement, only a low-energy source is used. Trouvé, Gustave. Manuel theorique, instrumental et pratique d'életrologie médicale. Paris, Octave Duin, 1893., p. 271. Pansier, Pierre,"Traité d'électrothérapie oculaire.” Paris, A. Maloine (1896).
51.
Van MillingenE. Xme Congrès International de Médecine à Berlin. Gazette Médicale d’Orient (GMO), vol. XXXIII, No:12, 1 Septembre 1890: 189–194; No: 15, 15 Octobre 1890: 238–240; No: 16, 30 Octobre 1890; No: 17, 15 Novembre 1890: 273–274; No: 20, 30 Decembre 1890: 322–324; No: 21, 15 Janvier 1891: 339–340; vol. XXXIV, No: 1, 28 Février 1890: 11.
52.
Ottoman State Archives (BOA), Y.MTV. No: 74/103 23 B 1310 (February 11th, 1893).
53.
Ottoman State Archives (BOA), A.MKT.MHM.No: 26/76, 29 Z. 1267 (January 3rd, 1851).
54.
The term ‘galvanoplasty’ is used to refer to an electroplating process, which is an electrochemical operation that allows an alloy or material made conductive to be coated with a layer of metal. Trécourt-Codine, Florence. “Galvanoplastie et fac-similé de monnaies autour de 1900.” Revue Numismatique 6, no. 167 (2011): 517–537.
55.
Bratzanos. Esquisse Biographique du Dr. Edwin van Millingen. Gazette Médicale d’Orient, 45ème année, No: 24, Constantinople, 15 Février 1901: 493–494.
56.
BalsoyGGundogduC.
Ottoman death registers (Vefeyât Defterleri) and recording deaths in Istanbul, 1838–1839. Middle Eastern Studies2020;
57:
197–
208.
57.
The military clinic known as Istanbul Naval Hospital in Kasimpasa today. Established in 1827 to give medical service to the soldiers and officers working at the Arsenal in the neighbourhood. See Yildirim N. A History of Healthcare in Istanbul. Istanbul, 2010: 189–191.
58.
Van MillingenE.
A tri-annual report of 5703 cases of eye diseases seen and treated in private practice at Constantinople in 1877, 1878 and 1879. Constantinople1880:
1–
3.
59.
Van MillingenE.A tri-annual report of 5703 cases of eye diseases seen and treated in private practice at Constantinople in 1877, 1878 and 1879. Constantinople,
1880: Plate 1,
35.
60.
Van MillingenE.
A tri-annual report of 5703 cases of eye diseases seen and treated in private practice at Constantinople in 1877, 1878 and 1879. Constantinople1880:
3–
4.
