The study of the health impacts of incarceration has generated new ethical imperatives focused on mitigating the suffering of incarcerated people. The problem with this framing, however, is that it presumes a binary relationship between care and suffering, which does not align with the legal status of the prisoner who suffers through the right to be cared for. Drawing from a prison health care class-action lawsuit in the state of Arizona, this essay explores the ethical insights, critiques, and impasses posed by the prisoner's health care claim. Through an analysis of the prisoner's plea for care, this essay ultimately advances an ethics of unhingement, which unsettles the assumed opposition between suffering and care and self and other. An ethics of unhingement not only refuses the present arrangement of structural violence and suffering under the carceral state, but poses the question, how do we care about the ways in which we suffer together?
AckerJBravemanPArkinE, et al. (2019) Mass Incarceration Threatens Health Equity in America. Princeton, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
2.
AlsanMYangCSJolinJR, et al. (2023) Health care in US correctional facilities—a limited and threatened constitutional right. New England Journal of Medicine388(9): 847–852.
3.
AntonioRJ (1981) Immanent critique as the core of critical theory: its origins and developments in Hegel, Marx and contemporary thought. British Journal of Sociology32(3): 330–345.
4.
BlissJ (2023) Object lessons in a time of tolerable suboptimisation. Feminist Theory24(2): 277–284.
5.
BowlegL (2020) Reframing mass incarceration as a social-structural driver of health inequity. American Journal of Public Health110(S1): S11–S12.
6.
ChasmanDCohenJ (2020) The Politics of Care: From COVID-19 to Black Lives Matter. Boston, MA: Boston Review and Verso Books.
7.
ChatzidakisAHakimJLitterJ, et al. (2020) The Care Manifesto: The Politics of Interdependence. London: Verso Books.
8.
ChavezEK (2021) Intrusions of violence: Afro-pessimism and Reading social death beyond solitary confinement. Theoretical Criminology25(1): 3–22.
9.
ClearTRAustinJ (2017) Mass incarceration. Reforming Criminal Justice: Punishment, Incarceration, and Release4: 55–76.
10.
CloudDHGarcia-GrossmanIRArmstrongA, et al. (2023) Public health and prisons: priorities in the age of mass incarceration. Annual Review of Public Health44(1): 407–428.
11.
CopjecJ (2015) Read My Desire: Lacan Against the Historicists. London: Verso Books.
12.
DavisAY (2011) Are prisons obsolete?Seven stories press.
13.
DavisAY (2003) Are Prisons Obsolete?New York, NY: Seven Stories Press.
14.
DayanC (2014) With law at the edge of life. South Atlantic Quarterly113(3): 629–639.
15.
DiMarioA (2022) To punish, parent, or palliate: governing urban poverty through institutional failure. American Sociological Review87(5): 860–888.
16.
DruckerE (2013) A Plague of Prisons: The Epidemiology of Mass Incarceration in America. New York, NY: The New Press.
17.
DumontDMBrockmannBDickmanS, et al. (2012) Public health and the epidemic of incarceration. Annual Review of Public Health33: 325–339.
18.
FraserN (2016) Capitalism's crisis of care. Dissent63(4): 30–37.
19.
FreudenbergN (2001) Jails, prisons, and the health of urban populations: a review of the impact of the correctional system on community health. Journal of Urban Health78(2): 214–235.
20.
FriedmanB (2021) Toward a critical race theory of prison order in the wake of COVID-19 and its afterlives: when disaster collides with institutional death by design. Sociological Perspectives64(5): 689–705.
21.
GérainPZechE (2022) A harmful care: the association of informal caregiver burnout with depression, subjective health, and violence. Journal of Interpersonal Violence37: 11–12.
22.
GrassianS (1983) Psychopathological effects of solitary confinement. American Journal of Psychiatry140(11): 1450–1454.
23.
GuentherL (2013) Solitary Confinement: Social Death and Its Afterlives. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
24.
HanBC (2021) The Palliative Society: Pain Today. Cambridge: John Wiley & Sons.
25.
HanSY (2012) The purloined prisoner. Theoretical Criminology16(2): 157–174.
26.
HaneyC (2018) The psychological effects of solitary confinement: a systematic critique. Crime and Justice47(1): 365–416.
27.
JamesJE (2023) The problem is not (merely) mass incarceration: incarceration as a bioethical crisis and abolition as a moral obligation. Hastings Center Report53(6): 35–37.
28.
JenkinsJ (2021) Study: Arizona Prisons Get an F for COVID-19 Response. Phoenix, AZ: AZCentral.
29.
Jensen v. Shinn (2022) Order.
30.
Jensen v. Thornell (2025) Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Receiver.
31.
KendrickCT (2020) Declaration of Corene T. Kendrick.
32.
KinnerSAYoungJTSnowK, et al. (2020) Prisons and custodial settings are part of a comprehensive response to COVID-19. The Lancet Public Health5(4): e188–e189.
33.
KupersTA (2017) Solitary: The Inside Story of Supermax Isolation and How We Can Abolish It. Oakland, CA, United States: Univ of California Press.
34.
Lara-MillánA (2021) Redistributing the Poor: Jails, Hospitals, and the Crisis of Law and Fiscal Austerity. New York, NY, United States: Oxford University Press.
35.
LeMastersKBrinkley-RubinsteinLManerM, et al. (2022) Carceral epidemiology: mass incarceration and structural racism during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Lancet Public Health7(3): e287–e290.
36.
LevensonJSamraS (2023) Organized care as antidote to organized violence: an engaged clinical ethnography of the Los Angeles county jail system. Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry49(1): 1–26.
37.
LevensonJTextorLBluthenthalR, et al. (2023) Abolition and harm reduction in the struggle for “Care, Not Cages”. International Journal of Drug Policy121: 1–7.
38.
LoaderI (2010) For penal moderation: notes towards a public philosophy of punishment. Theoretical Criminology14(3): 349–367.
39.
LumKSwarupSEubankS, et al. (2014) The contagious nature of imprisonment: an agent-based model to explain racial disparities in incarceration rates. Journal of the Royal Society Interface11(98): 20140409.
40.
MacmaduABerkJKaplowitzEMercedesMRichJDBrinkley-RubinsteinL (2020) COVID-19 and mass incarceration: a call for urgent action. The Lancet Public Health5(11): e571–e572.
41.
MassogliaM (2008) Incarceration as exposure: the prison, infectious disease, and other stress-related illnesses. Journal of Health and Social Behavior49(1): 56–71.
42.
MassogliaMPridemoreWA (2015) Incarceration and health. Annual Review of Sociology41: 291–310.
43.
McGeeM (2020) Capitalism’s care problem: some traces, fixes, and patches. Social Text38(1): 39–66.
44.
McGowanT (2016) Capitalism and Desire: The Psychic Cost of Free Markets. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
45.
MoyaertP (2013) The death drive and the nucleus of the ego: an Introduction to freudian metaphysics. The Southern Journal of Philosophy51: 94–119.
46.
Ngo-SmithBR (2015) Letter to a new social worker: On losing and locating ourselves. Keynote speech.
47.
Ngo-SmithBR (2018) This couch has bed bugs: on the psychoanalysis of homelessness and the homelessness of psychoanalysis. Clinical Social Work Journal46(1): 26–33.
48.
OshiroGE (2024) Reimagining Rehabilitation: A Public Health Approach to Transforming Mass Incarceration. In: Handbook on Contemporary Issues in Health, Crime, and Punishment, pp. 689-706. Routledge.
49.
Parsons v. Ryan (2017a) Notice of impending death.
50.
Parsons v. Ryan (2018) Notice I am being killed.
51.
Parsons v. Shinn (2020) Plaintiffs’ emergency motion regarding defendants’ prevention, management, treatment of covid-19.
52.
PetersenAM (2025) Community-oriented copaganda: anti-black violence in a visual archive of policing. Crime, Media, Culture21(1): 1–23.
53.
PiferNA (2023) “The right kind of crazy”: how patrol officers police the boundaries of mental illness through hybridized strategies. Law & Social Inquiry48(2): 1–26.
54.
PittsAJ (2018) Examining carceral medicine through critical phenomenology. IJFAB: International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics11(2): 14–35.
55.
ReiterK (2018) 23/7: Pelican Bay and the Rise of Long-Term Solitary Confinement. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
56.
ReiterKAugustineDStrongJD, et al. (2025) An autopsy of conceptualizing health in solitary confinement: Diagnosing knowledge production in solitary confinement. In: The Legal Determinants of Health. U.C. Humanities Press.
57.
ReiterKVenturaJLovellD, et al. (2020) Psychological distress in solitary confinement: symptoms, severity, and prevalence in the United States, 2017–2018. American Journal of Public Health110(S1): S56–S62.
58.
ResheJ (2023) Negative Psychoanalysis for the Living Dead: Philosophical Pessimism and the Death Drive. Cham: Springer Nature.
59.
SeedsC (2022) Death by Prison: The Emergence of life Without Parole and Perpetual Confinement. Oakland, CA: Univ of California Press.
60.
SeimJDiMarioA (2025) City of gauze: medicine and the governance of urban poverty. Social Problems72(3): 1–15.
61.
SextonJ (2021) Antidoting. The Black Scholar51(3): 5–24.
62.
SextonJ (2024) On treatment. Canadian Journal of Cultural Studies49: 9–12.
63.
SilverR (2020a) Order. Parsons v. Shinn
64.
SilverR (2020b) Order. Parsons v. Shinn
65.
SilverR (2022) Order. Jensen v. Shinn
66.
SimonJ (2007) Governing Through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
67.
SimonJ (2010) Do these prisons make me look fat? Moderating the USA’s consumption of punishment. Theoretical Criminology14(3): 257–272.
68.
SimonJ (2013) The return of the medical model: disease and the meaning of imprisonment from John Howard to brown v. Plata. Harv. CR-CLL Rev.48: 217.
69.
SontagS (2003) Regarding the Pain of Others. New York, NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
70.
StrongJD (2023) Extraction without reserve: The case of Arizona's penal care regime. Punishment & Society25(4): 1042–1061.
71.
StrongJDReiterKGonzalezG, et al. (2020). The body in isolation: The physical health impacts of incarceration in solitary confinement. PLoS One15(10): e0238510.
72.
SueKL (2025) Violence at Rikers Island: Does the Doctor Make It Worse? A Clinician Ethnographer’s Work Amidst Carceral Structural Violence. Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry49(1): 107–126.
73.
SufrinC (2017) Jailcare: Finding the Safety Net for Women Behind Bars. Oakland, CA: Univ of California Press.
74.
TriolaAM (2023) Reasonably unreasonable: American use of force jurisprudence and police impunity. Social & Legal Studies32(2): 257–272.
75.
Van HauteP (2013) Humankind: a sick animal? On the meaning and importance of the primacy of sexuality in Freud, Fonagy, and Laplanche. The Southern Journal of Philosophy51: 4–16.
76.
VanheuleS (2002) Caring and its impossibilities—A Lacanian perspective. Organisational and Social Dynamics2(2): 264–284.
77.
WacquantL (2009) Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
78.
WardG (2015) The slow violence of state organized race crime. Theoretical Criminology19(3): 299–314.
