Adjudicating Pluralism: The Hijab,Law and Social Change in Post-Colonial Trinidad

Abstract

In 1994, fundamentalist Muslim Islamists in the Caribbean island nation of Trinidad and Tobago organized a campaign to institutionalize the wearing of the traditional Muslim headscarf – the hijab – in nonIslamic schools. A lawsuit was brought on behalf of an 11 year old Muslim schoolgirl who had been told that she would not be allowed to wear the hijab while attending the Catholic run but state supported Holy Name Convent school. The ‘ hijab case’, as it came to be known, was framed as a religious matter, but it was essentially a political contest that was played out in court in an unprecedented case in which law was mobilized as a mechanism for cultural change. Drawing on extensive research and participant interviews, this article examines the strengths and limitations revealed in this attempt to use the law as a means of promoting religious pluralism in a complex, multicultural, secular society.

Keywords

Caribbean fundamentalism hijab Islam liberalism pluralism toleration Trinidad

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barran, Terence (1995) ‘Letter to the Editor’, Trinidad Guardian, 22 February.

Bower, L. (1994) ‘Queer Acts and the Politics of “Direct Address” : Rethinking Law, Culture and Community’, Law and Society Review 28(5): 1009–1033 .

Cain, M. (2002) ‘The Wisdom of Hindsight : Theorizing Progressive Legal Practice in the 21st Century’, Social & Legal Studies 11: 375–386 .

Chock, P. P. (1998) ‘Porous Borders: Discourses of Difference in Congressional Hearings on Immigration’, pp. 143–162 in Carol Greenhouse with Roshanak Kheshti (eds) Democracy and Ethnography: Constructing Identities in Multicultural Liberal States. New York: State University of New York Press .

Chouthi, Sandra (1995) ‘Lady Speaker on Fridays Not Forbidden’ , Trinidad Express, 2 August.

Fernández de Rota Monter, J. (1998) ‘Difference from the People’s Point of View’, pp. 124–142 in Carol Greenhouse and Roshanak Kheshti (eds) Democracy and Ethnography: Constructing Identities in Multicultural Liberal States. New York: State University of New York Press .

Galeotti, A. E. (1997) ‘Contemporary Pluralism and Toleration’ , Ratio Juris 10(2): 223–236 .

Gray, J. (1986) Liberalism. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press .

Greenhouse, Carol (1994) ‘Constructive Approaches to Law, Culture, and Identity’ , Law and Society Review 28(5): 1231–1241 .

10.

Greenhouse, Carol and Roshanak Kheshti (eds) (1998) Democracy and Ethnography: Constructing Identities in Multicultural Liberal States. New York: State University of New York Press .

11.

Hadid, D. (2000) ‘ Hijab’, available at: http://www.amida.au/ident/hijab.html.

12.

Hinkson, Nicole (1994) ‘Sr Paul to Muslims: What Really Is Hijab?’ , Trinidad Guardian, 17 September.

13.

Ibrahim, Youssef (1989) ‘Arab Girls’ Veils at Issue in France’ , New York Times, 12 November.

14.

Kramer, E. W. (2001) ‘Law and the Image of a Nation: Religious Conflict and Religious Freedom in a Brazilian Criminal Case’ , Law & Social Inquiry 26(1): 35–62 .

15.

Massell, G. (1974) The Surrogate Proletariat: Moslem Women and Revolutionary Strategies in Soviet Central Asia, 1910–1929. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .

16.

Merry, Sally Engle (1995) ‘Resistance and the Cultural Power of Law’ , Law and Society Review 29(1): 11–26 .

17.

Mydans, Seth (2002) ‘Singapore School Girls Defy Religious Ban’ , San Francisco Chronicle, 10 March.

18.

Parekh, Bhikhu (1999) ‘Balancing Unity and Diversity’, pp. 106–124 in Dan Avnon and Avner de Shalit (eds) Liberalism and its Practice. London: Routledge .

19.

Parekh, Bhikhu (2000) Rethinking Multiculturalism: Cultural Diversity and Political Theory. London: Macmillan .

20.

Salamat, Haroon (1995) ‘Letter to the Editor’ , Trinidad Guardian, 6 February.

21.

Sarat, Austin and Roger Berkowitz (1998) ‘Disorderly Difference: Recognition, Accommodation, and American Law’, pp. 81–102 in Carol Greenhouse and Roshanak Kheshti (eds) Democracy and Ethnography: Constructing Identities in Multicultural Liberal States. New York: State University of New York Press .

22.

Taylor, Pamela (1994) ‘ Hijab Battles Around the World’ , Islamic Horizons Magazine (November/December).

23.

Trinidad Guardian (1995) 4 February.

24.

Trinidad Guardian (2001) 17 January.

25.

Urcioli, Bonnie (1998) ‘Acceptable Difference: The Cultural Evolution of the Model Ethnic American Citizen’, pp. 178–195 in Carol Greenhouse and Roshanak Kheshti (eds) Democracy and Ethnography: Constructing Identities in Multicultural Liberal States. New York: State University of New York Press .

26.

Washington, Diana (1995) ‘Letter to the Editor’, Trinidad Guardian, 29 January.