An unresolved research question regarding crime and justice policy is the relationship between an individual’s media consumption and their support for punitive and preventive criminal justice policies. The relationship between media, crime, and justice is under-examined in countries other than the United States and Britain and the relationship between media and criminal justice policy support remains less than fully understood in all locales. In response, an examination of a media— policy relationship in a Western democracy not previously studied was conducted. Based on data from an October 2005 national telephone survey of Trinidad and Tobago residents, this study measured support for punitive and preventive criminal justice policies in association with crime and justice media consumption and worldviews. Multivariate analysis showed that, for Trinidadians, support for punitive policies was significantly related to perceiving television crime dramas as realistic and crime news as accurate. For preventive policy support, the same media factors plus the level of exposure to crime dramas on television were significant. Overall, media were found to play similar but not especially strong roles in support levels for both punitive and preventive criminal justice policies.
Altheide D. ( 2002) Creating fear. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
2.
Applegate B. ( 1997) Specifying public support for rehabilitation: A factorial survey approach. PhD dissertation. University of Cincinnati .
3.
Applegate B., Cullen F., Turner M. and Sundt J. ( 1996) Assessing public support for three-strike and you’re-out laws: Global versus specific attitudes. Crime and Delinquency42: 517-534.
4.
Barille L. ( 1984) Television and attitudes about crime: Do heavy viewers distort criminality and support retributive justice? In R Surette (ed.) Justice and the media: issues and research. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas, 141-158.
5.
Beckett K. and Sasson T. ( 2000) The politics of injustice: Crime and punishment in America . Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
6.
Bennett R. ( 1991) Development and crime: A cross-national, time series analysis of competing models. Sociological Quarterly32: 343-363.
7.
Bennett R. and Lynch JP ( 1996) Towards a Caribbean criminology: Prospects and problems . Caribbean Journal of Criminology and Social Psychology1: 8-45.
8.
Brown M. and Elrod P. ( 1995) Electronic house arrest: An examination of citizen attitudes . Crime and Delinquency41:332-334.
9.
Chadee D. ( 2007, January-December). ANSA McAL Psychological Research Centre Polls. Trinidad: Sunday Guardian Newspapers.
10.
Chadee D. and Ditton J. ( 2005) Fear of crime and the media: Assessing the lack of relationship . Crime Media Culture1: 322-332.
11.
Chadee D. and Ditton J. ( 2007) Perceptual fear and risk of victimization. In: R Deosaran (ed.) Crime, delinquency and justice: A Caribbean reader. Kingston, Jamaica: Ian Randle, 653-673.
12.
Chermak S. ( 1998) The presentation of drugs in the news media: The news sources involved in the construction of social problems. In: GW Potter (ed.) Constructing crime: Perspectives on making news and social problems. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press, 161-192.
13.
Chiricos T. and Eschholz S. ( 1997) Crime, news and fear of crime: Toward an identification of audience effects. Social Problems44: 342-357.
14.
Claussen DS ( 2004) Cognitive dissonance, media illiteracy, and public opinion on news media. American Behavioral Scientist48: 212-218.
15.
Cohen S. ( 2002) Folk devils and moral panics: The creation of the mods and rockers. London: Routledge.
16.
Cullen F., Skovron S., Scott J. and Burton V. ( 1990) Public support for correctional treatment: The tenacity of rehabilitative ideology. Criminal Justice and Behavior17: 6-18.
17.
Cumberland J. and Zambie E. ( 1992) General and specific measures of attitudes toward early release of criminal offenders. Canadian Journal of Behavioral Science24: 442-455.
18.
Deosaran R. and Chadee D. ( 1997) Juvenile delinquency in Trinidad and Tobago. Caribbean Journal of Criminology and Social Psychology2: 45-50.
19.
Dowler K. ( 2003) Media consumption and public attitudes toward crime and justice: The relationship between fear of crime, punitive attitudes, and perceived police effectiveness. Journal of Criminal Justice and Popoular Culture10: 109-126.
20.
Doyle A. ( 2006) How not to think about crime in the media. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice48: 867-885.
21.
Dubois J. ( 2002) Media coverage of organized crime: impact on public opinion? Available at: www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca.
22.
Fishman M. ( 1978) Crime waves as ideology. Social Problems25: 531-543.
23.
Flanagan T. and Caulfield S. ( 1984) Public opinion and prison policy: a review. Prison Journal64: 31-46.
24.
Frankfurter F. and Pound R. ( 1922) Criminal justice in Cleveland. Cleveland , OH: The Cleveland Foundation.
25.
Garofalo J. ( 1981) The fear of crime: Causes and consequences. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology72: 839-857.
26.
Ghany H. ( 1998) The Privy Council and judicial indifference to terrorism in the Commonwealth Caribbean. Caribbean Journal of Criminology and Social Psychology3: 116-134.
27.
Gillespie M. and McLaughlin E. ( 2003). Media and the shaping of public knowledge and attitudes towards crime and punishment. Available at: www.rethinking.org.uk .
28.
Gilliam F. and Iyengar S. ( 2000) Prime suspects: The influence of local television news on the viewing public. American Journal of Political Science44: 560-573.
29.
Gottfredson S. and Taylor R. ( 1984) Public policy and prison populations: Measuring opinions about reform. Judicature68: 190-121.
30.
Gottfredson S., Warner B. and Taylor R. ( 1988) Conflict and consensus about criminal justice in Maryland . In: N Walker and M Hough (eds) Public attitudes to sentencing: Surveys from five countries. Brookfield, VT: Gower, 16-55.
31.
Gunter B. ( 1987) Television and fear of crime. London : John Libbey.
32.
Heath L. and Gilbert K. ( 1996) Mass media and fear of crime. American Behavioral Scientist39: 379-386.
33.
Holbert R., Shah D. and Kwak N. ( 2004) Fear, authority, and justice: Crime-related TV viewing and endorsements of capital punishment and gun ownership. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly81: 343-363.
34.
Hurwitz J. and Peffley M. ( 1997) Public perceptions of race and crime: The role of racial sterotypes. American Journal of Political Science41: 375-401.
35.
Jenkins P. ( 1998) The ice age: The social construction of a drug panic. Justice Quarterly11: 7-31.
36.
Johnson B. and Huff CR ( 1987) Public opinion and criminal justice policy formulation . Criminal Justice Policy Review2: 118-132.
37.
Kappeler V., Blumberg M. and Potter G. ( 2000) The mythology of crime and criminal justice. Prospects Heights, ILWaveland Press.
38.
Kemshall H. ( 1997) Sleep safely: Crime risks may be smaller than you think . Social Policy and Administration31: 247-259.
39.
Kiousis S. ( 2001) Public trust or mistrust? Perceptions of media credibility in the information age. Mass Communication and Society, 4: 381-403.
40.
Kramer R. and Michalowski R. ( 1995) The iron fist and the velvet tongue: Crime control in the Clinton administration. Social Justice22: 87-101.
41.
Kraska P. and DeMichele M. ( 2001) Policing Kentucky’s school children: Issues and trends. Kentucky Justice and Safety Research Bulletin3: 1-8.
42.
Lambert-Peterson B. ( 2007) Juvenile delinquency, juvenile justice and legal reform: The case for an evidence-based approach. In R Deosaran (ed.) Crime, delinquency and justice: A Caribbean reader. Jamaica, Kingston: Ian Randle Publishers, 149-157.
43.
Lawrence R. and Mueller D. ( 2003) School shootings and the man-bites-dog criterion of newsworthiness . Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice1: 330-345.
44.
Liska A. and Baccaglini W. ( 1990) Feeling safe by comparison: Crime in the newspapers. Social Problems37: 360-374.
45.
Lynch M., Stretesky P. and Hammond P. ( 2000) Media coverage of chemical crimes, Hillsborough County, Florida. British Journal of Criminology40: 112-126.
46.
Mackey D., Courtright K. and Packard S. ( 2006) Testing the rehabilitative ideal among college students . Criminal Justice Studies19: 153-170.
47.
Mahabir C. ( 1985) Crime and nation building in the Caribbean: The legacy of legal barriers. Cambridge, MA: Schenkman Publishing Company.
48.
McCormack RJ ( 1999) The Caribbean sovereignty and the war on drugs: Historical factors and current perspectives. Caribbean Journal of Criminology and Social Psychology4: 71-84.
49.
O’Connell M. ( 1999) Is Irish public opinion towards crime distorted by media bias? European Journal of Communication14: 191-212.
50.
Oliver M. and Armstrong B. ( 1995) Predictors of viewing and enjoyment of reality-based and fictional crime shows. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly72: 559-570.
51.
Patchett KW ( 1972) Reception of law in the West Indies. Jamaican Law Review6: 16-32.
52.
Prange R. and O’Hearn J. ( 2004) The crime study. Fort Lauderdale, FL : Insights, Inc.
53.
Proctor J., Badzinski D. and Johnson M. ( 2002) The impact of media on knowledge and perceptions of Megan’s Law. Criminal Justice Policy Review13: 356-379.
54.
Reichel P. and Gauthier AK ( 1990) Boot camp corrections: A public reaction. In: R. Muraskin (ed.) Issues in justice: exploring policy issues in the criminal justice system. Bristol, IN: Wyndham Hall, 73-96.
55.
Reith M. ( 1999) Viewing of crime drama and authoritarian aggression: An investigation of the relationship between crime viewing, fear and aggression . Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media4: 211-221.
56.
Riley P. and Rose V. ( 1980) Public vs. elite opinion on correctional reform: implications for social policy. Journal of Criminal Justice8: 345-356.
57.
Roomer D., Jamieson K. and Aday S. ( 2003) Television news and the cultivation of fear of crime. Journal of Communication53: 88-104.
58.
Senese J. ( 1992) Intensive supervision probation and public opinion: Perceptions of community correctional policy and practice. American Journal of Criminal Justice16: 33-56.
59.
Simmons D. ( 1998) Judicial legislation for the Commonwealth Caribbean. Caribbean Journal of Criminology and Social Psychology3: 96-103.
60.
Sims B. and Johnston E. ( 2004) Examining public opinion about crime and justice: A statewide study. Criminal Justice Policy Review15(3): 270-293.
61.
Skogan W. and Maxfield M. ( 1981) Coping with crime. Beverly Hills, CA : Sage.
62.
Sotirovic M. ( 2001) Affective and cognitive processes as mediators of media influences on crime-policy preferences. Mass Communication & Society4: 311-329.
63.
Sotirovic M. ( 2003) How individuals explain social problems: The influences of media use. Journal of Communication53: 122-137.
64.
Surette R. ( 1992) Methodological problems in determining media effects on criminal justice: A review and suggestions for the future. Criminal Justice Policy Review6: 291-310.
65.
Surette R. ( 2007) Media, crime, and criminal justice: Images, realities, and policies. Belmont, CA: Thomson Wadsworth.
66.
Thompson-Ahye H. ( 1999) Youth and crime in the Caribbean. Caribbean Journal of Criminology and Social Psychology4: 187-189.
67.
Trinidad Central Statistical Office (1999) Annual crime report. Trinidad: Central Statistical Office.
68.
Trinidad Central Statistical Office (2003) Housing and population census of Trinidad and Tobago, 2000. Trinidad: Central Statistical Office.
69.
US Department of Justice (2007) Sourcebook of Criminal Justice Statistics. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics .
70.
Williams B. ( 1961) Democracy and ideology. Political Quarterly32: 374-384.
71.
Williams E. ( 1964) History of the peoples of Trinidad and Tobago. London: Andre Deutsch.
72.
Williams J. ( 2003) Criminal justice policy innovation in the states. Criminal Justice Policy Review14: 401-422.
73.
Young J. ( 2003) The role of fear in agenda setting by television news . American Behavioral Scientist46: 1673-1695.
