What do laypersons want to know from scientists? An analysis of a dialogue between scientists and laypersons on the web site Scienzaonline

Abstract

Scienzaonline is an interactive web site developed by the Museum of Zoology of Rome that offers various services. After the site had been online for three years, we examined approximately 800 questions received by the service Expert on line to understand what laypeople's interests in science are and in which life contexts they emerge. The contents of the questions were categorized to reveal the function and the nature of the knowledge that people expect from “experts”. Some kind of actual accomplishment motivates most of the questions, though a considerable number of them have knowledge and understanding as their objective. Information is the main form of expected knowledge and disciplinary knowledge is viewed as the privileged source of it. A relevant percentage of messages reveal the desire to obtain explanations and validations of reported facts, an aid to go beyond factual knowledge. Striving to find answers to “great unanswered questions” emerges as a passionate intellectual endeavor for some people.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aikenhead, G. (2004) “ The Humanistic and Cultural Aspects of Science and Technology Education ,” Paper presented at the 11th International Organization for Science and Technology Education (IOSTE) Symposium, Lublin, Poland. URL: http://www.usask.ca/education/people/aikenhead/

Borgna, P. (2001) Immagini pubbliche della scienza [Public Images of Science]. Turin: Edizioni di Comunità .

Brady, I. and Kumar, A. (2000) “ Some Thoughts on Sharing Science ,” Science Education 84(4): 507—23 .

Bucchi, M. and Mazzolini, R.G. (2003) “ Big Science, Little News: Science Coverage in the Italian Daily Press, 1946—1997 ,” Public Understanding of Science 12: 7—24 .

Cajas, F. (1999) “ Public Understanding of Science: Using Technology to Enhance School Science in Everyday Life ,” International Journal of Science Education 21: 765—73 .

Cross, R.T. and Fensham, P.J. , eds (2000) Science and Citizen for Educators and the Public. Victoria, Australia: Arena Publications .

Dimopoulos, K. and Koulaidis, V. (2003) “ Science and Technology Education for Citizenship: the Potential Role of the Press ,” Science Education 87: 241—56 .

Duschl, R.A. and Osborne, J. (2002) “ Supporting and Promoting Argumentation Discourse in Science Education ,” Studies in Science Education 38: 39—72 .

Eveland Jr., W.P. and Dunwoody, S. (1998) “ Users and Navigation Patterns of a Science World Wide Web Site for the Public ,” Public Understanding of Science 7: 285—311 .

10.

Fensham, P.J. (2000) “ Issues for Schooling in Science ,” in R.T. Cross and P.J. Fensham (eds) Science and Citizen for Educators and the Public, pp. 73—7 . Victoria , Australia: Arena Publications .

11.

Jenkins, E. (1999) “ School Science Citizenship and the Public Understanding of Science ,” International Journal of Science Education 21: 703—10 .

12.

Jidesjö, A. and Oscarsson, M. (2004) “ Students' Attitudes to Science and Technology: First Results from the ROSE-Project in Sweden ,” Paper presented at the 11th International Organization for Science and Technology Education (IOSTE) Symposium, Lublin, Poland.

13.

Kolstoe, S.D. (2001) “ Scientific Literacy for Citizenship: Tools Dealing with the Science Dimension of Controversial Socio-scientific Issues ,” Science Education 85: 291—310 .

14.

Miller, S. (2001) “ Public Understanding of Science at the Crossroads ,” Public Understanding of Science 10: 115—20 .

15.

Newton, P. (1999) “ The Place of Argumentation in the Pedagogy of School Science ,” International Journal of Science Education 21: 553—76 .

16.

OECD (1997) Promoting Public Understanding of Science and Technology. Report OECD/GD(97)52. Paris : Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development .

17.

Ryder, J. (2001) “ Identifying Science Understanding for Functional Scientific Literacy ,” Studies in Science Education 36: 1—44 .

18.

Weigold, M.F. and Treise, D. (2004) “ Attracting Teen Surfers to Science Web Sites ,” Public Understanding of Science 13: 229—48 .

19.

Zimmerman, C. , Bisanz, G.L. , Bisanz, J. , Klein, J.S. and Klein, P. (2001) “ Science and the Supermarket: a Comparison of What Appears in the Popular Press, Experts' Advice to Readers, and What Students Want to Know ” Public Understanding of Science 10: 37—58 .