As illustrated by the case of ethanol, claim H is that, for some biological endpoints, low-dose toxins and carcinogens exhibit hormesis, a beneficial or adaprive response characterized by biphasic dose reponses and resulting from compensatory biological processes following an initial disruption in homeostasis. From this uncontroversial claim H, however, the paper argues that some toxicologists invalidly infer HG (that H is generalizable across biological model, endpoint measured, and chemical class) and HD (that a strong case can be made for the use of hormesis H as a default assumption in the risk-assessment/regulation process), Evaluating HG and HD, this paper argues for 5 claims. While (1) H is true, (2) HG falls victim to several logical fallacies and therefore is logically, scientifically, and ethically invalid. (3) Because it relies on logical fallacies, confuses necessary and sufficient conditions, and violates at least 5 sets of ethical norms, HD is logically, scientifically, and ethically invalid. (4) Five remedies could help address HG-HD flaws and failure to adequately assess low-dose exposures. (5) Three objections to these criticisms of HG and HD are easily answered.
1 National Research Council . Intentional human dosing studies for EPA regulatory purposes. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2004. pp. 110, 112–113, 3.
2.
2 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Hormesis: U-shaped dose responses and their centrality in toxicology . Trends Pharmacol Sci2001; 22: 285 – 291 .
3.
3 Thayer KA Melnick R Burns K Davis D Huff J . Fundamental flaws of hormesis for public health decisions . Environ Health Perspect2005; 113: 1272 – 1275 .
4.
5.
5 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Hormesis: the dose-response revolution . Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol2003; 43: 175 – 197 .
6.
6 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Defining hormesis . Hum Exp Toxicol2002; 21: 91 – 97 .
7.
7 Calabrese EJ . Historical blunders: how toxicology got the dose-response relationship half right . Cell Mol Biol2005; 51: 643 – 654 .
8.
8 Axelrod D Burns K Davis D Von Larebeke N . Hormesis – an inappropriate extrapolation from the specific to the universal . Int J Occup Environ Health2004; 10: 335 – 339 .
9.
9 Scientific Advisory Board and FIFRA Scientific Advisory Panel . Comments on the use of data from testing of human subjects, EPA-SAB-EC-00-017.Washington, DC : EPA ; 2000.
10.
10 Kociba RJ Keyes DG Beyer JE . Results of a two-year chronic toxicity and oncogenicity study of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin in rats . Toxicol Appl Pharmacol1978; 46: 279 – 303 .
11.
11 Mead MN . Sour finding on popular sweetener . Environ Health Perspect2006; 114: 739 – 785 [accessed 11.22.06] http://www.ehponline.org/docs/2006/114-3/ss.html.
12.
12 Reir SE Martin DC Bowman RE Domowski WP Becker JL . Endometriosis in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) following chronic exposure to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin . Fundam Appl Toxicol1993; 21: 433 – 441 .
13.
13 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Toxicology rethinks its central belief . Nature2003; 421: 691 – 692 .
14.
14 US National Research Council . Pesticides in the diets of infants and children.Washington, DC : National Academy Press ; 1993.
15.
15 Shrader-Frechette KS . Risk and rationality.Berkeley : SAGE Publications ; 1991. p. 100–145.
16.
16 Shrader-Frechette KS . Ethics of scientific research. New York: Rowman and Littlefield; 1994. p. 9–12, 23–118.
17.
17 Association of Schools of Public Health . Ethics and public health. In: B Jennings J Kahn A Mastroianni L Parker , (eds), Washington, DC : ASPH ; 2003.
18.
18 Hume D . A treatise of human nature.Oxford : Clarendon Press ; 1975.
20 Calabrese EJ Cook R . Hormesis: how it could affect the risk assessment process . BELLE2005; 12: 22 – 27 .
21.
21 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Reevaluation of the fundamental dose: response relationship . BioScience1999; 49: 725 – 732 .
22.
22 Lang L . Strange brew: assessing risk of chemical mixtures . Environ Health Perspect1995; 103: 142 – 145 [accessed 11.22.06] http://www.ehponline.org/docs/1995/103-2/focus.html.
23.
23 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Radiation hormesis . Hum Exp Toxicol2000; 19: 2 .
24.
24 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Scientific foundations of hormesis . Crit Rev Toxicol2001; 31: 351 – 624 .
25.
25 National Research Council . Health risks from exposure to low levels of ionizing radiation, BEIR VII.Washington, DC : National Academy Press ; 2005.
26.
26 Shrader-Frechette KS . Using a thought experiment to clarify a radiobiological controversy . Synthese2001; 128: 319 – 342 .
27.
27 Faden R Beauchamp T . A history and theory of informed consent.New York : Oxford University Press ; 1986.
28.
28 Beauchamp T Childress J . Principles of biomedical ethics.New York : Oxford University Press ; 1989.
29.
29 Shrader-Frechette KS . Taking action, saving lives: our duties to protect environmental and public health.New York : Oxford University Press ; 2007.
30.
30 Krimsky S . Science in the private interest.New York : Rowman and Littlefield ; 2003.
31.
31 Oleskey C Fleishman A Goldman LR . Pesticide testing in humans . Environ Health Perspect2004; 112: 114 – 119 .
32.
32 Lockwood AH . Human testing of pesticides . Am J Public Health2004; 94: 1908 – 1915 .
33.
33 US National Research Council . Health implications of perchlorate ingestion.Washington, DC : National Academy Press ; 2005.
34.
35.
35 US General Accounting Office . Military munitions: DOD needs to develop a comprehensive approach for cleaning up contaminated sites, GAO-04-147.Washington, DC : GAO ; 2003.
36.
37.
38.
38 Clark R . Control of low-level radiation exposure: time for a change . J Radiol Prot1999; 19: 107 – 115 .
39.
40.
40 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA Holland C . Hormesis: a highly generalizable and reproducible phenomenon with important implications for risk assessment . Risk Anal1999; 19: 261 – 281 .
42 World Health Organization. Effects of air pollution on children’s health. Bonn: WHO; 2005. p. 144, 155.
43.
43 Health and Human Services and National Cancer Institute . Health status objectives . Cancer1991; 16: 416 – 440 .
44.
44 McGinnis JM . Attributable risk in practice. In: Institute of Medicine, (ed), Estimating the contributions of lifestyle-related factors to preventable death. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2005. p. 17–19.
45.
45 Lichtenstein P Holm N Verkasalo P Iliadou A Kaprio J Koskenvuo M . Environmental and heritable factors in the causation of cancer . N Engl J Med2002; 343: 78 – 85 .
46.
46 Thayer KA Melnick R Huff J Burns K Davis D . Hormesis: a new religion . Environ Health Perspect2006; 114: 632 – 633 .
47.
47 US National Research Council . Valuing ecosystem services.Washington, DC : National Academy Press ; 2004.
48.
48 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Hormesis and high-risk groups . Regul Toxicol Pharmacol2002; 35: 414 – 428 .
49.
49 Calabrese EJ Baldwin LA . Hormesis: a revolution in toxicology, risk assessment and medicine . EMBO Reports2004; (Suppl. 1): S37 – S40 .
