This article examines why some trade unions are able to spread innovations aimed at revitalisation across their organisation, while similar initiatives elsewhere remain isolated. Drawing on innovation diffusion and union sociology literatures, it explores the conditions and mechanisms that enable organisation-wide adaptation of these innovations. The study analyses 12 cases from 10 union organisations in eight European countries, using a framework distinguishing between background, remote and proximate conditions. Configurational analysis identifies distinct pathways underpinning successful diffusion across varying institutional and organisational contexts. These pathways work through four generative mechanisms emerging via structure–agency dynamics: internal resource mobilisation; resource compensation; legitimacy assessment; and organisational learning. Based on case study insights providing contextual understanding, the mechanisms demonstrate how unions activate power resources through their agential capabilities to translate innovation-driven revitalisation into sustained organisational change.
BernaciakMKahancováM (eds) (2017) Innovative union practices in Central-Eastern Europe. ETUI.
2.
BernaciakMTrifA (2023) Multiple strategies but small gains: trade union revitalization and power resources in Central Eastern Europe after 2008. European Journal of Industrial Relations29(1): 83–102.
3.
BéroudSDoumencS (2025) France – a shift in organisational structures within the CGT? New union strategies for precarious and dissociated workers. In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 49–65.
4.
Brøns KringelumLBrixJ (2021) Critical realism and organizational learning. The Learning Organization28(1): 32–45.
5.
BurchielliRBartramT (2009) What helps organizing work? The indicators and the facilitators of organizing. Journal of Industrial Relations51(5): 687–707.
6.
Coderre-LaPalmeG (2024) Old habits die hard? The role of trade union identity and framing processes in shaping strategy. Work, Employment & Society39(2): 380–403.
7.
GreenhalghTRobertGMacfarlaneF, et al. (2004) Diffusion of innovations in service organizations. Systematic review and recommendations. The Milbank Quarterly82(4): 581–629.
8.
Gumbrell-McCormickRHymanR (2013) Trade Unions in Western Europe. Hard Times, Hard Choices. Oxford University Press.
9.
HeeryEKellyJ (1994) Professional, participative and managerial unionism. An interpretation of change in trade unions. Work, Employment & Society8(1): 1–22.
10.
HodderAEdwardsP (2015) The essence of trade unions: understanding identity, ideology and purpose. Work, Employment & Society29(5): 843–854.
11.
HymanR (2007) How can trade unions act strategically?Transfer13(2): 193–210.
12.
IbsenCL (2025) Denmark – innovative organising strategies for engaging employers and young people. In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 131–147.
13.
LarocheMMurrayG (eds) (2024) Experimenting for Union Renewal: Challenges, Illustrations and Lessons. ETUI.
14.
LévesqueCMurrayG (2010) Understanding union power: resources and capabilities for renewing union capacity. Transfer16(3): 333–350.
15.
MannewitzT (2011) Two-level theories in QCA. A discussion of Schneider and Wagemann’s two-step approach. Compasss Working Paper 2011–64.
16.
MartiškováMŠumichrastA (2025) Czechia – the grouping of trade union members revisited: slow policy transfer arising from external barriers and internal controversies. In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 31–47.
17.
MrozowickiAMaciejewskaM (2017) Bricolage unionism. Unions’ innovative responses to the problems of precarious work in Poland. In: BernaciakMKahancováM (eds) Innovative Union Practices in Central-Eastern Europe. ETUI, 139–159.
18.
MurrayG (2017) Union renewal: what can we learn from three decades of research?Transfer23(1): 9–29.
19.
MurrayGLévesqueCDufourC, et al. (2013) Workplace representatives: strategic actors of union renewal?Industrial Relations Journal44(4): 340–354.
20.
MurrayGLévesqueCMorganG, et al. (2020) Disruption and re-regulation in work and employment: from organisational to institutional experimentation. Transfer26(2): 135–156.
21.
O’BradyS (2024) Institutional power resources. A critical analysis. In: ArnholtzJRefslundB (eds) Workers, Power and Society. Power Resource Theory in Contemporary Capitalism. Routledge, 76–96.
22.
O’MahoneyJVincentS (2014) Critical realism as an empirical project: a beginner’s guide. In: EdwardsPKO’MahoneyJVincentS (eds) Studying Organizations Using Critical Realism. A Practical Guide. Oxford University Press, 1–20.
23.
RaginC (1987) The Comparative Method. Moving Beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies. University of California Press.
24.
RakowskaK (2025) Poland – being simultaneously defensive and offensive. The resistance to Amazon by Workers’ initiative. In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 109–128.
25.
RogersEM (2003) Diffusion of Innovations. 5th Edition. Simon & Schuster.
26.
RuttenR (2024) Qualitative Comparative Analysis. Learning from Cases. Edward Elgar.
27.
SamalukB (2025) Slovenia – achieving policy transfer in the organisation of young and precarious workers. In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 167–183.
28.
SamalukBKallK (2023) Trade union project-based revitalization strategies in Central and Eastern Europe: the case of Slovenia and Estonia. European Journal of Industrial Relations29(1): 7–24.
29.
SayerA (2000) Realism and Social Science. Sage.
30.
SchneiderCQ (2019) Two-step QCA revisited: the necessity of context conditions. Quality and Quantity53(3): 1109–1126.
31.
SchneiderCQWagemannC (2006) Reducing complexity in Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA). Remote and proximate factors and the consolidation of democracy. European Journal of Political Research45(5): 751–786.
32.
SchneiderCQWagemannC (2012) Set-Theoretic Methods for the Social Sciences. A Guide to Qualitative Comparative Analysis. Cambridge University Press.
33.
SzabóIGTuraiE (2025) Hungary – what facilitates the policy transfer of participatory organising? In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 149–166.
34.
TassinariAGirolamoA (2025) Italy – turning tourism upside down: campaigning to organise precarious workers. In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 91–108.
35.
TassinariAMangiacottiLGirolamoA (2024) Actions et innovation syndicales dans le context italien: examen de deux initiatives dans le secteur manufacturier et celui des services. In: FabrisBLVandaeleK (eds) Les Syndicats En Action En Europe. Études De Cas En Allemagne, Belgique, Danemark, Espagne, Italie Et Au Niveau Européen. ETUI, 109–131.
36.
UNI Europa (2021) UNI Europa Organising Strategy 2021-25. UNI Europa.
37.
VandaeleK (2025) Belgium – on the road again. Explaining membership growth in the socialist transport union. In: VandaeleKFabrisBL (eds) When Trade Unions Learn to Innovate. Case Study Evidence from Across Europe. ETUI, 69–90.
38.
VisserJ (2024) Will they rise again? Four scenarios for the future of trade unions. Economic and Industrial Democracy45(3): 629–652.
39.
WaddingtonJMüllerTVandaeleK (eds) (2023) Trade Unions in the European Union. Picking up the Pieces of the Neoliberal Challenge. Peter Lang.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
