Strengthening legislation,weakening collective bargaining? Two faces of trade union strategies in Czechia and Slovakia

Abstract

The paper studies how unions used two types of resources, namely, access to national legislation/policy and to collective bargaining, to improve working conditions in healthcare and in agency work in Czechia and Slovakia. It examines how these two types of institutional resources interact, whether they are potentially in competition and how this affects union revitalization. Unions’ post-2008 strategies in the two sectors converged towards political action due to their preference for legislative regulation of issues previously bargained about or unregulated. The paper argues that extensive use of institutional safeguards contributes to improving working conditions; however, prioritizing political action may weaken other types of union strategies and undermine future access to collective bargaining. In other words, extensive utilization of one institutional resource (legislation) may gradually weaken other types of resources (collective bargaining) and thereby undermine the overall revitalization capacity of trade unions.

Keywords

Trade unions collective bargaining legislation Czechia Slovakia temporary agency work healthcare revitalization

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adamczyk

(2018) Inside the trade union family: The ‘two worlds’ within the European Trade Union Confederation. European Journal of Industrial Relations 24(2): 179–192.

Akgüç

Kahancová

Martišková

(2019) Enhancing the effectiveness of social dialogue articulation in Europe. Comparative Report. Bratislava: CELSI Research Report No. 30. Available at: https://celsi.sk/en/publications/research-reports/detail/95/enhancing-the-effectiveness-of-social-dialogue-articulation-in-europe-eesda-comparative-report/

Avdagic

(2005) State-labour relations in East Central Europe: explaining variations in union effectiveness. Socio-Economic Review 3(1): 25–53.

Behrens

Hamann

Hurd

(2004) Conceptualizing Labour Union Revitalization. Varieties of unionism: Strategies for union revitalization in a globalizing economy. Oxford University Press 11–30.

Benassi

(2017) Varieties of workplace dualisation: A study of agency work in the German automotive industry. Industrial Relations Journal 48(5–6): 424–441.

Benassi

Vlandas

(2016) Union inclusiveness and temporary agency workers: The role of power resources and union ideology. European Journal of Industrial Relations 22(1): 5–22.

Benedeková

Drobný

Bartovicová

, et al. (2019) Extenzia kolektívnych zmlúv vyššieho stupňa: princíp, realizácia, dopady [Extension of higher-level collective agreements: Principles, Implementation, Impact]. Bratislava: Confederation of Trade Unions of the Slovak Republic. available at: https://www.kozsr.sk/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Extenzia-kolekt%C3%ADvnych-zml%C3%BAv-vy%C5%A1%C5%A1ieho-stup%C5%88a.pdf

Bohle

Greskovits

(2006) Capitalism without compromise: Strong business and weak labor in Eastern Europe’s new transnational industries. Studies in Comparative International Development 41(1): 3–25.

Bryson

(2014) Union Wage Effects. IZA World of Labor. Available at: https://wol.iza.org/articles/union-wage-effects/long (accessed 6 January 2022).

10.

Choonara

Murgia

Carno

(2022) Faces of Precarity: Critical Perspectives on Work, Subjectivities and Struggles. Bristol, UK: Bristol University Press.

11.

Colling

(2009) Court in a trap? Legal mobilisation by trade unions in the United Kingdom (No. 91). Warwick Papers in Industrial Relations. Available at: https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/48542/1/60401631X.pdf (accessed 6 January 2022).

12.

Czíria

(2012) Doctors End Strike Alert in Protracted Hospital Crisis. Dublin, Ireland: Eurofound. Available at: https://www.eurofound.europa.eu/publications/article/2012/doctors-end-strike-alert-in-protracted-hospital-crisis (accessed 7 January 2022).

13.

Doellgast

Lillie

Pulignano

(eds), (2018) Reconstructing Solidarity: Labour Unions, Precarious Work, and the Politics of Institutional Change in Europe. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

14.

Dörre

Holst

Nachtwey

(2009) Organising-A strategic option for trade union renewal? International Journal of Action Research 5(1): 33–67.

15.

Eurostat (2020) Temporary Employment in Czechia and Slovakia. [lfsa_etpgan, lfsa_etgaed].

16.

Frege

Kelly

(2003) Union revitalization strategies in comparative perspective. European Journal of Industrial Relations 9(1): 7–24.

17.

George

Bennett

(2005) Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

18.

Gumbrell-McCormick

Hyman

(2013) Trade Unions in Western Europe: Hard Times, Hard Choices. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

19.

Gumbrell-McCormick

(2011) European trade unions and ‘atypical’workers. Industrial Relations Journal 42(3): 293–310.

20.

Hassel

(2007) The Curse of Institutional Security: The Erosion of German Trade Unionism. Industrielle Beziehungen 14(2): 176–191.

21.

Hašková

(2017) Kolektívne zmluvy na Slovensku [Collective Agreements in Slovakia], ePráca 1/2017. Available at: https://kozsr.sk/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/2017_01_ePR%C3%81CA.pdf

22.

Kahancová

Szabó

(2015) Hospital bargaining in the wake of management reforms: hungary and Slovakia compared. European Journal of Industrial Relations 21(4): 335–352.

23.

Kahancová

Martišková

Sedláková

(2019) Slovakia: between coordination and fragmentation (Chapter 25). In: Muller

Vandaele

Waddington

(eds) Collective Bargaining in Europe: Towards an Endgame. Brussels, Belgium: ETUI.

24.

Kahancová

(2016) The Rise of the Dual Labour Market: Fighting Precarious Employment in the New Member States through Industrial Relations, Case study: Slovakia. CELSI Research Report No. 19 (2016). Available at: https://celsi.sk/media/research_reports/RR19.pdf

25.

Kaminska

Kahancová

(2011) Emigration and labour shortages: An opportunity for trade unions in the New Member States? European Journal of Industrial Relations 17(2): 189–203.

26.

Kaminska

Kahancová

(2017) State, Market, and Collective Regulation in the Hospital Sector in East-Central Europe: Union Strategies against all Odds. Comparative Labour Law & Policy Journal 38(2): 257–289.

27.

Keune

(2015) Trade unions, precarious work and dualisation in Europe. In: Eichhorst

Marx

(eds) Non-Standard Employment in Post-Industrial Labour Markets. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, pp. 378–440.

28.

Keune

Pedaci

(2020) Trade union strategies against precarious work: Common trends and sectoral divergence in the EU. European Journal of Industrial Relations 26(2): 139–155.

29.

Kochan

(1984) Challenges and Choices Facing American Labor (Vol. 1). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

30.

Kohl

Platzer

(2007) The role of the state in Central and Eastern European industrial relations: the case of minimum wages. Industrial Relations Journal 38(6): 614–635.

31.

Košč

(2020) Naozaj odbory nie sú reprezentatívne? [Are trade unions really not representative?], Pole, Kultúrno-spoločenský magazín. Available at: https://new.poleblog.sk/naozaj-odbory-nie-su-reprezentativne/ (accessed 6 January 2022).

32.

Kumar

Schenk

(2013) Paths to Union Renewal. Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press.

33.

Lévesque

Murray

(2010) Understanding union power: resources and capabilities for renewing union capacity. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 16(3): 333–350.

34.

Martišková

(2020) Czech public sector industrial relations in the aftermath of the crisis. In: Keune

Martin

NE Ramos

Mailand

(eds) Working Under Pressure: Employment, Job Quality and Labour Relations in Europe’s Public Sector Since the Crisis. Brussels, Belgium: ETUI.

35.

Martišková

Sedláková

(2017) Reinventing the role of the Czech trade unions: halfway through the journey. In: Bernaciak

Kahancová

(eds) Beyond the Crisis: Strategic Innovation within CEE Trade Union Movements. Brussels, Belgium: ETUI.

36.

Martišková

Sedláková

(2016) The rise of the dual labour market: Fighting Precarious Employment in the New Member States through Industrial Relations (PRECARIR Report): Case study Czechia. CELSI Research Report No. 20. Available at: https://celsi.sk/media/research_reports/RR20.pdf

37.

Meardi

(2018) Economic integration and state responses: Change in European Industrial Relations since Maastricht. British Journal of Industrial Relations 56(3): 631–655.

38.

Ministerstvo zdravotníctva

(2015) Zákon O Spoločnom Odmeňovaní Všetkých Zdravotníckych Pracovníkov. https://www.mzdovecentrum.sk/aktuality/zakon-o-spolo%C4%8Dnom-odmenovani-vsetkych-zdravotnickych-pracovnikov.htm (accessed 6 January 2022).

39.

MPSV (2020) Informace O Pracovních Podmínkách. Ministerstvo práce a Sociálních Věcí ČR. http://kolektivnismlouvy.cz/download/2020/IPP_2020.pdf (accessed 8 January 2022).

40.

Mrozowicki

(2011) Trade union organizing in Eastern Europe: A viable pathway to trade union revitalization? A case study of the automotive sector. Emecon Employment and Economy in Central and Eastern Europe 2(1): 1–20.

41.

Myant

(2019) Czechia: Bargaining supplements legal protection. In: Muller

Vandaele

Waddington

(eds) Collective Bargaining in Europe: Towards an Endgame. Brussels, Belgium: ETUI, pp. 131–149.

42.

OECD (2022) OECD/AIAS ICTWSS Database. www.oecd.org/employment/ictwss-database.htm

43.

Pravda (2022) Matovič predstavil návrh na zvýšenie platov aj pre lekárov a záchranárov [Matovič introduced the proposal for wage increases for doctors and rescue staff]. Available at: https://spravy.pravda.sk/domace/clanok/637671-matovic-predstavil-navrh-na-zvysenie-platov-aj-pre-lekarov-a-zachranarov/ (accessed 18 August 2022).

44.

Sachs

(2013) The Unbundled Union: Politics Without Collective Bargaining. Yale Law Journal 123(1). Available at: https://www.yalelawjournal.org/essay/the-unbundled-union (accessed 8 January 2022).

45.

SOZZaSS (2022) V susedných štátoch zarábajú zdravotníci viac. Healthcare Workers Earn More in Neighbouring Countries. Available at: http://sozzass.com/v-susednych-statoch-zarabaju-zdravotnici-viac/ (accessed 18 August 2022).

46.

Traxler

Brandl

(2009) The Economic Effects of Collective Bargaining Coverage: A Cross-National Analysis. Geneva, Switzerland: ILO.

47.

Trexima (2020) Analytická studie agentur práce a využívání agenturního zaměstnávání v ČR [Analytical study on work agencies and use of agency employment]. Svaz průmyslu a dopravy ČR. Available at: https://www.spcr.cz/images/Studie_Agentury_prace_fin.pdf (Accessed 16 November 2022).

48.

Trif

Paolucci

Kahancová

, et al. (2021) The impact of trade union actions on precarious work in Central and Eastern Europe: beyond institutional and structural resources Human Relations. First published online May 15, 2021 DOI: 10.1177/00187267211020189 (accessed 6 January 2022).

49.

Veverková

(2011) Czech Republic: Industrial Relations in the Health Care Sector. Dublin, Ireland: Eurofound. available at: http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/observatories/eurwork/comparative-information/nationalcontributions/czech-republic/czech-republic-industrial-relations-in-the-health-care-sector (accessed 6 January 2022).