This article summarizes and reviews research on union responses to precarious work in Europe, based on a systematic coding of 56 case study-based articles published between 2008 and 2019. Analyses of these cases suggest two paths to labour market dualism, with the first involving institutional fragmentation and union division, and the second a combination of weak structural power and partnership-oriented union identities. The authors also identify two paths to solidarity, with the result of reduced precarity for peripheral workers: a conflict-based path and a social partnership-based path. Campaigns to organize migrant workers present distinctive institutional and structural challenges to unions, with studies involving migrants most often finding ‘failed solidarity’, in which inclusive organizing fails to reduce precarity. The article integrates these findings with past frameworks on union responses to precarious work and concludes with recommendations for future research.
AhlstrandR (2015) Integrative strategy, competitiveness and employment: A case study of the transition at the Swedish truck manufacturing company Scania during the economic downturn in 2008–2010. Economic and Industrial Democracy36(3): 457–477.
2.
AlbertiG (2016) Moving beyond the dichotomy of workplace and community unionism: The challenges of organising migrant workers in London’s hotels. Economic and Industrial Democracy37(1): 73–94.
3.
AlbertiGHolgateJTapiaM (2013) Organising migrants as workers or as migrant workers? Intersectionality, trade unions and precarious work. International Journal of Human Resource Management24(22): 4132–4148.
4.
AlbertiGPeròD (2018) Migrating industrial relations: Migrant workers’ initiative within and outside trade unions. British Journal of Industrial Relations56(4): 693–715.
5.
AlsosKEldringL (2008) Labour mobility and wage dumping: The case of Norway. European Journal of Industrial Relations14(4): 441–459.
6.
ArnholtzJRefslundB (2019) Active enactment and virtuous circles of employment relations: How Danish unions organised the transnationalised Copenhagen Metro construction project. Work, Employment and Society33(4): 682–699.
7.
BaccaroLHowellC (2011) A common neoliberal trajectory: The transformation of industrial relations in advanced capitalism. Politics & Society39(4): 521–563.
8.
BarronPBoryAChauvinSJouninNTouretteL (2016) State categories and labour protest: Migrant workers and the fight for legal status in France. Work, Employment and Society30(4): 631–648.
9.
BenassiC (2017) Varieties of workplace dualisation: A study of agency work in the German automotive industry. Industrial Relations Journal48(5–6): 424–441.
10.
BenassiCDorigattiL (2014) Straight to the core – Explaining union responses to the casualization of work: The IG Metall campaign for agency workers. British Journal of Industrial Relations53(3): 533–555.
11.
BenassiCDoellgastVSarmiento-MirwaldtK (2016) Institutions and inequality in liberalizing markets: Explaining different trajectories of institutional change in social Europe. Politics & Society44(1): 117–142.
12.
BenassiCDorigattiLPanniniE (2019) Explaining divergent bargaining outcomes for agency workers: The role of labour divides and labour market reforms. European Journal of Industrial Relations25(2): 163–179.
13.
BerntsenLLillieN (2016) Hyper-mobile migrant workers and Dutch trade union representation strategies at the Eemshaven construction sites. Economic and Industrial Democracy37(1): 171–187.
14.
BonacichE (1972) A theory of ethnic antagonism: The split labor market. American Sociological Review37(5): 547–559.
15.
ChhachhiA (2014) Introduction: The ‘labour question’ in contemporary capitalism. Development and Change45(5): 895–919.
16.
ConnollyHMarinoSMartínez LucioM (2014) Trade union renewal and the challenges of representation: Strategies towards migrant and ethnic minority workers in the Netherlands, Spain and the United Kingdom. European Journal of Industrial Relations20(1): 5–20.
17.
ConnollyHMarinoSMartínez LucioM (2017) ‘Justice for janitors’ goes Dutch: The limits and possibilities of unions’ adoption of organizing in a context of regulated social partnership. Work, Employment and Society31(2): 319–335.
18.
DoellgastV (2008) National industrial relations and local bargaining power in the US and German telecommunications industries. European Journal of Industrial Relations14(3): 265–287.
19.
DoellgastVLillieNPulignanoV (eds) (2018) Reconstructing Solidarity: Labour Unions, Precarious Work, and the Politics of Institutional Change in Europe. New York: Oxford University Press.
20.
DoellgastVNoharaHTchobanianR (2009) Institutional change and the restructuring of service work in the French and German telecommunications industries. European Journal of Industrial Relations15(4): 373–394.
21.
DoellgastVSarmiento-MirwaldtKBenassiC (2016) Contesting firm boundaries: Institutions, cost structures, and the politics of externalization. ILR Review69(3): 551–578.
22.
DoerflingerNPulignanoV (2018) Crisis-related collective bargaining and its effects on different contractual groups of workers in German and Belgian workplaces. Economic and Industrial Democracy39(1): 131–150.
23.
DorigattiL (2017) Trade unions in segmented labor markets: Evidence from the German metal and chemical Sectors. ILR Review70(4): 919–941.
24.
DurazziNFleckensteinTLeeSC (2018) Social solidarity for all? Trade union strategies, labor market dualization, and the welfare state in Italy and South Korea. Politics & Society46(2): 205–233.
25.
EmmeneggerPHäusermannSPalierBSeeleib-KaiserM (eds) (2012) The Age of Dualization: The Changing Face of Inequality in Deindustrializing Societies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
26.
GasparriSIkelerPFullinG (2019) Trade union strategy in fashion retail in Italy and the USA: Converging divergence between institutions and mobilization?European Journal of Industrial Relations25(4): 345–361.
27.
GioiaDACorleyKGHamiltonAL (2012) Seeking qualitative rigor in inductive research: Notes on the Gioia methodology. Organizational Research Methods16(1): 15–31.
28.
GreerICiupijusZLillieN (2013) The European Migrant Workers Union and the barriers to transnational industrial citizenship. European Journal of Industrial Relations19(1): 5–20.
29.
HåkanssonKPulignanoVIsidorssonTDoerflingerN (2020) Explaining job insecurity for temporary agency workers: A comparison between Sweden and Belgium. Economic and Industrial Democracy41(2): 254–275.
30.
HardyJEldringLSchultenT (2012) Trade union responses to migrant workers from the ‘new Europe’: A three sector comparison in the UK, Norway and Germany. European Journal of Industrial Relations18(4): 347–363.
31.
HelfenMSydowJWirthC (2020) Service delivery networks and employment relations at German airports: Jeopardizing industrial peace on the ground?British Journal of Industrial Relations58(1): 168–198[onlinefirst:2018].
32.
HolstH (2008) The political economy of trade union strategies in Austria and Germany: The case of call centres. European Journal of Industrial Relations14(1): 25–45.
33.
JaehrlingKJohnsonMLarsenTPRefslundBGrimshawD (2018) Tackling precarious work in public supply chains: A comparison of local government procurement policies in Denmark, Germany and the UK. Work, Employment and Society32(3): 546–563.
34.
JaehrlingKMéhautP (2013) ‘Varieties of institutional avoidance’: Employers’ strategies in low-waged service sector occupations in France and Germany. Socio-Economic Review11(4): 687–710.
35.
JiangZKorczynskiM (2016) When the ‘unorganizable’ organize: The collective mobilization of migrant domestic workers in London. Human Relations69(3): 813–838.
36.
KahancováMSzabóIG (2015) Hospital bargaining in the wake of management reforms: Hungary and Slovakia compared. European Journal of Industrial Relations21(4): 335–352.
37.
KeuneMPedaciM (2020) Trade union strategies against precarious work: Common trends and sectoral divergence in the EU. European Journal of Industrial Relations26(2): 139–155.
38.
KornelakisAVoskeritsianH (2018) Getting together or breaking apart? Trade union strategies, restructuring and contingent workers in Southern Europe. Economic and Industrial Democracy39(2): 357–375.
39.
KretsosL (2011) Union responses to the rise of precarious youth employment in Greece. Industrial Relations Journal42(5): 453–472.
40.
LarsenTPMailandM (2018) Lifting wages and conditions of atypical employees in Denmark: The role of social partners and sectoral social dialogue. Industrial Relations Journal49(2): 88–108.
41.
LillieN (2012) Subcontracting, posted migrants and labour market segmentation in Finland. British Journal of Industrial Relations50(1): 148–167.
42.
LillieNSippolaM (2011) National unions and transnational workers: The case of Olkiluoto 3, Finland. Work, Employment and Society25(2): 292–308.
43.
MacKenzieR (2010) Why do contingent workers join a trade union? Evidence from the Irish telecommunications sector. European Journal of Industrial Relations16(2): 153–168.
44.
MarinoS (2015) Trade unions, special structures and the inclusion of migrant workers: On the role of union democracy. Work, Employment and Society29(5): 826–842.
45.
MarinoSBernaciakMMrozowickiAPulignanoV (2019) Unions for whom? Union democracy and precarious workers in Poland and Italy. Economic and Industrial Democracy40(1): 111–131.
46.
MeardiGMartínARieraML (2012) Constructing uncertainty: Unions and migrant labour in construction in Spain and the UK. Journal of Industrial Relations54(1): 5–21.
47.
MeardiGSimmsMAdamD (2019) Trade unions and precariat in Europe: Representative claims. European Journal of Industrial Relations. Epub ahead of print 27 July. DOI: 10.1177/0959680119863585.
48.
MurphyCTurnerT (2016) Organising precarious workers: Can a public campaign overcome weak grassroots mobilisation at workplace level?Journal of Industrial Relations58(5): 589–607.
49.
O’BradyS (2019) Rethinking precariousness and its evolution: A four-country study of work in food retail. European Journal of Industrial Relations25(4): 327–344.
50.
PulignanoVDoerflingerNDe FranceschiF (2016) Flexibility and security within European labor markets: The role of local bargaining and the ‘trade-offs’ within multinationals’ subsidiaries in Belgium, Britain, and Germany. ILR Review69(3): 605–630.
51.
PulignanoVDoerflingerNKeuneM (2017) Re-introducing the company in the analysis of labour market dualisation: Variety of patterns and diversity of outcomes between standard and non-standard workers in multinational subsidiaries in Belgium, Germany and Britain. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Epub ahead of print 6 October. DOI: 10.1177/0143831X17731610.
52.
PulignanoVKeuneM (2015) Understanding varieties of flexibility and security in multinationals: Product markets, institutional variation and local bargaining. European Journal of Industrial Relations21(1): 5–21.
53.
PulignanoVMeardiGDoerflingerN (2015) Trade unions and labour market dualisation: A comparison of policies and attitudes towards agency and migrant workers in Germany and Belgium. Work, Employment and Society29(5): 808–825.
54.
PulignanoVSignorettiA (2016) Union strategies, national institutions and the use of temporary labour in Italian and US plants. British Journal of Industrial Relations54(3): 574–596.
55.
RathgebP (2018) When weak governments confront inclusive trade unions: The politics of protecting labour market outsiders in the age of dualization. European Journal of Industrial Relations24(1): 5–22.
56.
RefslundB (2018) When strong unions meet precarious migrants: Building trustful relations to unionise labour migrants in a high union-density setting. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Epub ahead of print 13 March. DOI: 10.1177/0143831X18760989.
57.
SørensenOHWeinkopfC (2009) Pay and working conditions in finance and utility call centres in Denmark and Germany. European Journal of Industrial Relations15(4): 395–416.
58.
ShireKASchönauerAValverdeMMottweilerH (2009) Collective bargaining and temporary contracts in call centre employment in Austria, Germany and Spain. European Journal of Industrial Relations15(4): 437–456.
59.
SimmsMDeanD (2015) Mobilising contingent workers: An analysis of two successful cases. Economic and Industrial Democracy36(1): 173–190.
60.
TapiaMTurnerL (2013) Union campaigns as countermovements: Mobilizing immigrant workers in France and the United Kingdom. British Journal of Industrial Relations51(3): 601–622.
61.
ThelenK (2014) Varieties of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity. New York: Cambridge University Press.
62.
Van JaarsveldDDe GripASiebenI (2009) Industrial relations and labour market segmentation in Dutch call centres. European Journal of Industrial Relations15(4): 417–435.
63.
WagnerI (2015) Rule enactment in a pan-European labour market: Transnational posted work in the German construction sector. British Journal of Industrial Relations53(4): 692–710.
64.
WagnerIRefslundB (2016) Understanding the diverging trajectories of slaughterhouse work in Denmark and Germany: A power resource approach. European Journal of Industrial Relations22(4): 335–351.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
