This article investigates the development of collective wage bargaining systems in manufacturing in five countries: Denmark, Finland, Germany, Norway and Sweden. We illustrate the responses of collective actors to two key challenges: first, increased cross-country competition between Northern European companies operating within the same high-value/high-cost segment of the market; second, the competitive pressures resulting from increased east-north integration. Our analytical framework sets out different forms and outcomes of institutional change, with a focus on how the responses of collective actors to these two challenges shaped the development of wage bargaining systems.
AbdonABacateMFelipeJKumarU (2010) Product complexity and economic development. Levy Economics Institute Working Paper no. 616, 17 September. New York: SSRN.
AE-rådet (2015) Stærkeste lønkonkurrenceevne siden 1995. Copenhagen: Occupational Movement Erversråd.
4.
ArnholtzJAndersenSK (2017) Extra-institutional changes under pressure from posting. British Journal of Industrial Relations. 56: 395–417.
5.
BaccarroLPontussonJ (2016) Rethinking comparative political economy: The growth model perspective. Politics & Society44(2): 175–207.
6.
BahnmüllerR (2010) Dezentralisierung der Tarifpolitik: Re-Stabilisierung des Tarifsystems? In: BispinckRSchultenT (eds) Zukunft der Tarifautonomie – 60 Jahre Tarifvertragsgesetz: Bilanz und Ausblick. Hamburg: VSA-Verlag, pp. 81–113.
7.
BahnmüllerR (2017) Von der Erosion des Flächentarifvertrags zur Chance gewerkschaftlicher Erneuerung. In: SchultenTDribbuschHBäckerGKlennerC (eds) Tarifpolitik als Gesellschaftspolitik: Strategische Herausforderungen im 21. Jahrhundert. Hamburg: VSA-Verlag, pp. 34–47.
8.
BispinckR (1995) Tarifpolitik in der ersten Hälfte der 90er Jahre: Eine zwiespältige Bilanz. In: BispinckR (ed.) Tarifpolitik der Zukunft: Was wird aus dem Flächentarifvertrag?Hamburg: VSA-Verlag, pp. 9–27.
9.
BispinckR (2016) Tarifpolitik vor alten und neuen Herausforderungen. In: BäckerGLehndorffSWeinkopfC (eds) Den Arbeitsmarkt verstehen, um ihn zu gestalten: Festschrift für Gerhard Bosch. Wiesbaden: Springer VS, pp. 181–198.
10.
BispinckRDribbuschH (2011) Collective bargaining, decentralisation and crisis management in the German metalworking industries since 1990. WSI Discussion Paper no. 177. Available at: https://www.boeckler.de/pdf/p_wsi_disp_177.pdf
DølvikJE (2004) Industrial relations under EMU: Renationalization and Europeanization two sides of the same coin? In: MartinARossG (eds) Euros and Europeans: Monetary Integration and the European Model of Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 278–309.
14.
DølvikJEVartiainenJ (2002) Globalisering og europeisk integrasjon: utfordringer for lønnsdannelsen og kollektivavtalene i de nordiske land. Stockholm: Saltsa/Arbetslivsinstitutet.
15.
DølvikJEMarginsonPAlsosKArnholtzJMeardiGMüllerTTrygstadS (2018) Collective wage regulation in northern Europe under strain: Multiple drivers of change and differing responses. European Journal of Industrial Relations24(4).
16.
DølvikJEMarginsonP (2018) Cross-sectoral Coordination and Regulation of Wage Determination in Northern Europe: Divergent responses to multiple external pressures. European Journal of Industrial Relations24(4).
17.
DjelicM-LQuackS (2003) Introduction: Governing globalization: Bringing institutions back in. In: DjelicM-LQuackS (eds) Globalization and Institutions. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 1–14.
18.
DueJMadsenJSJensenCSPetersenLK (1994) The Survival of the Danish Model. Copenhagen: DJOF.
19.
DustmannCFitzenbergerBSchonbergUSpitz-OenerA (2014) From sick man of Europe to economic superstar: Germany’s resurgent economy. Journal of Economic Perspectives28(1): 167–188.
HaipeterT (2009) Tarifabweichung und Flächentarifvertrag. Eine Analyse der Regulierungspraxis in der Metall- und Elektroindustrie. Wiesbaden: VS-Verlag.
24.
IbsenCL (2016a) The role of mediation institutions in Sweden and Denmark after centralized bargaining. British Journal of Industrial Relations54(2): 285–310.
25.
IbsenCL (2016b) Making sense of employer collectivism: The case of Danish wage bargaining under recession. Journal of Industrial Relations58(5): 669–687.
26.
IbsenCLAndersenSKDueJMadsenJS (2011) Bargaining in the crisis: A comparison of the 2010 collective bargaining round in the Danish and Swedish manufacturing sectors. Transfer17(3): 323–339.
27.
IG Metall (2015) Geschäftsbericht 2011–2014. Frankfurt: IG Metall.
JürgensUKrzywdzinskiM (2010) Die neue Ost-West-Arbeitsteilung: Arbeitsmodelle und industrielle Beziehungen in der europäischen Automobilindustrie. Frankfurt: Campus.
MailandM (2016) Danske trepartsforhandlinger og europæiske samfundsmæssige pagter: En asynkron historie. In: IlsøeALarsenTP (eds) Den danske model set udefra: Komparative perspektiver på dansk arbejdsmarkedsregulering. Copenhagen: DJOF, pp. 251–278.
33.
MüllerTSchultenTZuckerstätterS (2015) Wages and economic performance in Europe. In: Van GyesGSchultenT (eds) Wage Bargaining Under the New European Economic Governance. Brussels: ETUI, pp. 259–282.
34.
SchultenTBispinckR (2018) Varieties of decentralization in German collective bargaining. In: LeonardiSPedersiniR (eds) Multi-Employer Bargaining Under Pressure: Decentralization Trends in Five European Countries. Brussels: ETUI, pp. 105–149.
35.
StormSNaastepadCWM (2015) Europe’s hunger games: Income distribution, cost competitiveness and crisis. Cambridge Journal of Economics39(3): 959–986.
36.
SvalundJBergström CasinowskyGDølvikJEHåkanssonKJarvensivuAKervinenHMøbergRJPiirainenT (2013) Stress testing the Nordic models: Manufacturing labour adjustments during crisis. European Journal of Industrial Relations19(3): 183–200.
37.
TraxlerF (1996) European trade union policy and collective bargaining: Mechanisms and levels of labour market regulation in comparison. Transfer2(2): 287–297.
38.
TraxlerFBrandlB (2009) Towards Europeanization of wage policy. European Union Politics10(2): 177–201.
39.
TraxlerFBlaschkeSKittelB (2001) National Labour Relations in Internationalized Markets: A Comparative Study of Institutions, Change and Performance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
