The possibility of convergence of national industrial relations systems has been
debated for a long time. However, the predominant approach is to stress the
persistence of national variation. This article draws on a number of comparative
studies in order to consider whether globalization and European policy developments
are important drivers towards increasing convergence. Consequently, the article
concludes that a critical review of the prevalent research methods is necessary.
Bamber, G.J.
,
Lansbury, R.D.
and
Wailes, N.
(eds) (2004) International and Comparative Employment
Relations, 4th edn.London: Sage
.
2.
Biagi, M.
(ed.) (2001) Towards a European Model of Industrial Relations?The Hague: Kluwer Law International
.
3.
Biagi, M.
,
Tiraboschi, M.
and
Rymkevitch, O.
(2002) ‘Literature Review On: The
“Europeanization” of Industrial Relations: Evaluating the
Quality of Industrial Relations in a Global Context’, in
R. Blanpain
(ed.) White Paper on the Labor Market in Italy, The Quality of European
Industrial Relations, and Changing Industrial Relations.
Dordrecht: Kluwer, Bulletin of Comparative
Labour Relations
, no. 44.
4.
Blanpain, R.
(1990)
‘1992 en daarna. De impact van de Europese Gemeenschappen op de
Arbeidsverhoudingen in de lidstaten’ (‘The Impact of the
European Communities on the Industrial Relations in the Member States’)
. Tijdschrift voor Arbeidsvraagstukken1:
54–58
.
5.
Blanpain, R.
(2002) ‘The Impact of the Information Society on
the World of Work in Developed Countries’, in
T. Hanami
(ed.) Global Integration and Challenges for Industrial Relations and
Human Resource Management in the Twenty-first Century. Selected Papers from the
12th IIRA World Congress, pp. 35–48.
Tokyo: Japan Institute of Labour
, JIL Report Series No.9.
6.
Castells, M.
(1998) End of Millennium.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
7.
Cattero, B.
(1999) ‘Jenseits van Konvergenz und
Pfadabhängigkeit — über die Europäisierung
der industriellen Beziehungen im Zeitalter der
Globalisierung’, in
G. Schmidt
and
R. Trinczek
(eds) Globalisierung — ökonomische und soziale
Herausforderungen am Ende des zwanzigsten Jahrhunderts, Soziale Welt Sonderheft
13, pp. 95–114.
Baden-Baden: Nomos
.
8.
CBS/Central Bureau of Statistics
(2004) Nederland langs de Europese meetlat (The
Netherlands According to the European Yardstick).
Voorburg/Heerlen: CBS
.
9.
Chouraqui, A.
and
O'Kelly, K.
(2001)
‘Which European Social Model? A Challenged Balance between
Regulation and Deregulation’
, paper presented at the Aix-en-Provence seminar,
11–12 September.
10.
Coldrick, P.
(1998)
‘The ETUC's Role in the EU's New Economic and
Monetary Architecture’
, Transfer4(1):
21–35
.
11.
Cortebeeck, V.
,
Huys, R.
,
Van Gyes, G.
and
Vandenbrande, T.
(2004) Quality of Industrial Relations: Country Profiles.
Second Draft.
Leuven: KU Leuven/European Foundation
.
12.
Cortebeeck, V.
,
Huys, R.
,
van Gyes, G.
and
Vandenbrande, T.
(2005) The Quality of Industrial Relations Indicators: An
Assessment of the Data and Country Profiles of 15 EU Member States.
Leuven: KU Leuven/European Foundation
.
13.
Dunlop, J.T.
(1958) Industrial Relations Systems.
New York: Holt
.
14.
Ederveen, S.
,
Gorter, J.
,
de Mooij, R.
and
Nahuis, R.
(2002) Funds and Games. The Economics of European Cohesion
Policy.
The Hague: CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic
Policy Analysis
.
15.
EIRO
(2000) Wage Policy and EMU.
Dublin: European Foundation
.
EC
(2002a) Communication from the Commission: The European
Social Dialogue, a Force for Innovation and Change. COM(2002)341 final, 26
June.
18.
EC
(2002b) Industrial Relations & Industrial Change.
Report of the High Level Group on Industrial Relations and Change in the
European Union.
Luxembourg: OOPEC
.
19.
EC
(2004a) Industrial Relations in Europe 2004.
Luxembourg: OOPECities
.
20.
EC
(2004b) Communication from the Commission: Partnership for
Change in an Enlarged Europe. COM(2004)557 final.
21.
European Foundation
(2002) The Europeanization of Industrial Relations in a
Global Perspective: A Literature Review, eds
J. Hoffmann
,
R. Hoffmann
,
J. Kirton-Darling
and
L. Rampeltshammer
.
Luxembourg: OOPEC
.
22.
European Foundation
(2004) Quality in Industrial Relations: Comparative
Indicators, writer A. Weiler.
Luxembourg: OOPEC
.
23.
Faber, R.P.
and
Stockman, A.C.J.
(2005)
‘Europese prijsconvergentie in volgelvlucht’
(‘European Price Convergence from a Bird's-eye View’)
. ESB25:
128–130
24.
Hanami, T.
(ed.) (2002) Global Integration and Challenges for Industrial
Relations and Human Resource Management in the Twenty-first Century. Selected
papers from the 12th IIRA World Congress.
Tokyo: Japan Institute of Labour
, JIL Report Series No.9.
25.
Hay, C.
(2000)
‘Contemporary Capitalism, Globalization, Regionalization and the
Persistence of National Variation’
, Review of International Studies26(4):
509–531
.
26.
Hemerijck, A.
and
Huiskamp, R.
(2002)Public Sector Reform under EMU. A Literature
Review.
Dublin: European Foundation
.
27.
Hyman, R.
(1975) Industrial Relations: A Marxist Introduction.
Basingstoke: Macmillan
.
28.
Hyman, R.
(2001)
‘The Europeanization — or the Erosion — of
Industrial Relations?’
, Industrial Relations Journal32(4):
280–294
.
29.
ILO
(1994)Defending Values, Promoting Change, Social Justice in a
Global Economy: An ILO Agenda.
Geneva: International Labour Office
.
30.
Kauppinen, T.
and
Pochet, P.
(2002) ‘Globalization, EMU and Industrial
Relations in the European Union’, in
T. Hanami
(ed.) Global Integration and Challenges for Industrial Relations and
Human Resource Management in the Twenty-first Century. Selected papers from the
12th IIRA World Congress, pp. 84–95.
Tokyo: Japan Institute of Labour
, JIL Report Series No.9.
31.
Kerr, C.
,
Dunlop, J.T.
,
Harbison, F.H.
and
Myers, C.A.
(1960) Industrialism and Industrial Man: The Problems of
Labor Management in Economic Growth.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
32.
Leibfried, S.
and
Pierson, P.
(2000) ‘Social Policy. Left to Courts and
Markets?’, in
H. Wallace
and
W. Wallace
(eds) Policy Making in the European Union, 4th edn, pp.
267–292.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
33.
Marginson, P.
and
Sisson, K.
(1996)European Collective Bargaining: A Virtual Prospect?Brussels: ETUI Discussion and Working Papers
.
34.
Marginson, P.
and
Sisson, K.
(2004) European Integration and Industrial Relations.
Basingstoke: Palgrave
.
35.
Mooij, R. de
and
Tang, P.
(2003) Four Futures of Europe.
The Hague: CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic
Policy Analysis
.
36.
Müller-Jentsch, W.
(1997) Soziologie der industriellen Beziehungen, Eine
Einführung.
Frankfurt/Mannheim: Campus
.
Rojot, J.
(2001) ‘A European Industrial Relations
System?’, in
M. Biagi
(ed.) Towards a European Model of Industrial Relations?, pp.
71–73.
The Hague: Kluwer Law International
.
39.
Scharpf, F.W.
(1987) ‘The Political Calculus of Inflation and
Unemployment in Western Europe: A Game-theoretical
Interpretation’, working paper,
Harvard University, Center for European Studies
.
40.
Sisson, K.
and
Marginson, P.
(2000) The Impact of Economic and Monetary Union on
Industrial Relations: A Sector and Company View. Report for the European
Foundation.
Dublin: European Foundation
.
41.
Sisson, K.
and
Marginson, P.
(2001) ‘Soft Regulation: Travesty of the Real Thing
or New Dimension? One Europe or Several?’, working paper 32/01.
42.
Sisson, K.
,
Arrowsmith, J.
and
Marginson, P.
(2003)
‘All Benchmarkers Now? Benchmarking and the
“Europeanisation” of Industrial Relations’
, Industrial Relations Journal34(1):
15–31
.
43.
Tan, E.-S.
(2002) ‘Globalization and National Industrial
Relations Systems: Theoretical Implications from the Singapore
Case’, in
T. Hanami
(ed.) Global Integration and Challenges for Industrial Relations and
Human Resource Management in the Twenty-first Century. Selected papers from the
12th IIRA World Congress, pp. 330–336.
Tokyo: Japan Institute of Labour
, JIL Report Series No. 9.
44.
Vandenbroucke, F.
(2002)
‘The EU and Social Protection: What should the European
Convention Propose?’
, paper presented at the Max Planck Institute for the Study of
Societies, Köln, 17 June.
45.
Visser, J.
(2002)Unions, Wage Bargaining and Coordination in the
European Labour Markets.
Amsterdam: Amsterdam Institute for Advanced
Labour Studies
.
46.
Visser, J.
and
Hemerijck, A.
(1997/8) Een Nederlands mirakel(A Dutch Miracle).
Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press
.
47.
Vos, K.J.
(2005)
‘Americanisation of the EU Social Model?’
, The International Journal of Comparative Law and Industrial Relations21(3):
355–367
.
48.
Weiler, A.
(2004) See European Foundation for the Improvement of Living
and Working Conditions (2004).
49.
Welz, C.
and
Kauppinen, T.
(2004)
‘The Role of Social Dialogue in the Acceding Countries during the
Preparatory Phase for Economic and Monetary Union (EMU)’
, International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations20(4):
583–603
.
50.
Whitaker, M.
and
Hölscher, J.
(2003) Europeanisation of Labour Relations: The Quality of
Labour Relations in the Public Sector.
Brighton: University of Brighton Business
School/European Foundation
.
