`Cry Wolf',Cried the Wolf: Constructing the Issue of False Rape Allegations in New Zealand Media Texts

Abstract

In this article we analyse New Zealand media texts about so-called false rape allegations from 1995 to 1999, in relation to legislative and social change towards rape. In particular, we focus on a critical reading of a magazine article that stands out as being (the only) relatively balanced investigation into false rape'. We argue that despite the surface neutrality of this text, it privileges an interpretation of the issue in which it is taken for granted that reports of rape claimed to be false by police really are false (that is, women's lies). We show how this happens through the framing of the article, the tacit construction of `the issue' and the denial of the broader social and historical context of rape. In these ways, we argue that it perpetuates contemporary rape myths. Widespread circulation and adherence to such myths, we suggest, hinder the criminal justice system and broader cultural responses to rape that are sympathetic to women who are raped. We further suggest that this construction of the `new issue' of false rape allegations can be read as an expression of `backlash anxiety' about the emergent gains made by feminists in challenging rape-supportive discourses and practices in society.

Keywords

feminism media texts rape social construction

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allan, S. (1999) News Culture. Buckingham: Open University Press.

Bird, S. and Dardenne, R. (1988) `Myth, Chronicle, and Story: Exploring the Narrative Qualities of News', pp. 67-85 in J. Carey (ed.) Media, Myth, and Narratives. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Boniface, D. (1994) `Ruining a Good Boy for the Sake of a Bad Girl', Current Issues in Criminal Justice 6(1): 54-75.

Brownmiller, S. (1976) Against Our Will: Men, Women and Rape. New York: Bantam Books.

Burt, M. (1980) `Cultural Myths and Supports for Rape', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 38: 217-230.

Burt, M. (1991) `Rape Myths and Acquaintance Rape', pp. 26-40 in A. Parrot and L. Bechofer (eds) Acquaintance Rape: The Hidden Crime. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

Campbell, C.P. (1995) Race, Myth and the News. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Campbell, R. and Johnson, C.R. (1997) `Police Officers' Perceptions of Rape: Is there Consistency between State Law and Individual Beliefs?', Journal of Interpersonal Violence 12: 255-274.

Caringella-MacDonald, S. (1998) `The Relative Visibility of Rape Cases in National Popular Magazines', Violence Against Women 4(1): 62-80.

10.

Crawshaw, M. (1998) `The Second Rape', Metro (September): 60-65.

11.

Crawshaw, M. (1999) `Cry Wolf', Metro (January): 80-85.

12.

Doone, P. (1998) `Adult Sexual Assault Investigation Policy', Ten-One 159: 11-15.

13.

Entman, R. (1993) `Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm', Journal of Communication 43(4): 51-58.

14.

Estrich, S. (1987) Real Rape. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

15.

Goldberg-Ambrose, C. (1992) `Unfinished Business in Rape Law Reform', Journal of Social Issues 48: 173-185.

16.

Graham, D. (1996) [Opening address to the `Rape: Ten Years' Progress? An Inter- Disciplinary Conference], pp. 6-10 in J. Broadmore , C. Shand and T. Warburton (eds) The Proceedings of Rape: Ten Years' Progress? An Inter-Disciplinary Conference. Wellington: Doctors for Sexual Abuse Care.

17.

(Reprinted in abridged form from Culture, Society and the Media, pp. 56-90, in M. Gurevitch , T. Bennett , J. Curran and J. Woollacott [eds], 1982, London: Methuen.)

18.

Haws, D. (1997) `The Elusive Numbers on False Rape', Columbia Journalism Review 36(4): 16-19.

19.

hooks, b. (1996) `All Quiet on the Feminist Front', Artforum 35(4): 39-40.

20.

Jordan, J. (1996) `Women, Rape and the Reporting Process', pp. 24-44 in J. Broadmore , C. Shand and T. Warburton (eds) The Proceedings of Rape: Ten Years' Progress? An Inter-Disciplinary Conference. Wellington: Doctors for Sexual Abuse Care.

21.

Koss, M.P. (1985) `The Hidden Rape Victim: Personality, Attitudinal, and Situational Characteristics', Psychology of Women Quarterly 9: 193-212.

22.

Lichtenberg, J. (2000) `In Defence of Objectivity Revisited', pp. 238-254 in J. Curran and M. Gurevitch (eds) Mass Media and Society, 3rd edn. London: Arnold.

23.

Lonsway, K.A. and Fitzgerald, L.F. (1994) `Rape Myths in Review', Psychology of Women Quarterly 18: 133-164.

24.

`No wonder the rape rate is decreasing' (1999), http://www.mediawatch.com [Original article from The Inquirer, 7 December 1999, accessed 6 December 2000].

25.

Ralston, B. (1999) Editorial. `Essentially Auckland 1999', Metro (January): 9.

26.

Russell, D.E.H. (1984) Sexual Exploitation: Rape, Child Sexual Abuse, and Workplace Harassment. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

27.

Schlesinger, P. (1978) Putting `Reality' Together: BBC News. London: Constable.

28.

(Reprinted from 1991, British Journal of Criminology.)

29.

Taylor, J. (1987) `Rape and Women's Credibility: Problems of Recantations and False Accusations Echoed in the Case of Cathleen Crowell and Gary Dotson', Harvard Women's Law Journal 10: 59-116.

30.

Tuchman, G. (1972) `Objectivity as Strategic Ritual: An Examination of Newsmen's Notions of Objectivity', American Journal of Sociology 77: 660-679.

31.

Waldby, S. , Hay, A. and Soothill, K. (1981) `The Social Construction of Rape', Theory, Culture & Society 2(1): 86-98.

32.

Williams, K. (1981) `Few Convictions in Rape Cases: Empirical Evidence Concerning some Alternative Explanations', Journal of Criminal Justice 9: 29-39.

33.

Young, W. (1996) `Rape in New Zealand 1985-1995', pp. 10-14 in J. Broadmore , C. Shand and T. Warburton (eds) The Proceedings of `Rape: Ten Years' Progress? An Inter-Disciplinary Conference. Wellington: Doctors for Sexual Abuse Care.