From efficiency to ambivalence: How digitalisation reshapes labour market activation and the moral economy of welfare state

Allhutter FC Fischer F Grill G , et al. (2020) Algorithmic profiling of job seekers in Austria: how austerity politics are made effective? Frontiers in Big Data 3(5): 1–17.

Andersen NA Breidahl KN (2021) The power of ideas in policymaking processes: the role of institutionalised knowledge production in state bureaucracies. Social Policy and Administration 55(5): 848–862.

Bonoli G (2013) The Origins of Active Social Policy: Labour Market and Childcare Policies in a Comparative Perspective. Oxford University Press.

Brodkin EZ Marston G (eds) (2013) Work and the Welfare State: Street-Level Organizations and Workfare Politics. Georgetown University Press.

Clasen J Mascaro C (2022) Activation: a thematic and conceptual review. Journal of European Social Policy 32(4): 484–494.

Collington R (2022) Disrupting the welfare state? Digitalisation and the retrenchment of public sector capacity. New Political Economy 27(2): 312–328.

Considine M McGann M Ball S , et al. (2022) Can robots understand welfare? Exploring machine bureaucracies in welfare-to-work. Journal of Social Policy 51(3): 519–534.

Demazière D Griffin R Leschke J , et al. (2025) Digital Public Employment Services in Action. Policy Press.

Dencik L Kaun A (2020) Datafication and the welfare state. Global Perspectives 1(1): 12912.

Desiere S Struyven L (2021) Using artificial intelligence to classify jobseekers: the accuracy-equity trade-off. Journal of Social Policy 50(2): 367–385.

Dwyer P Fitzpatrick S Fletcher DR , et al. (2019) Welfare Conditionality. Policy Press.

Forgó N Hänold S Schütze B (2017) The principle of purpose limitation and big data. In: Corrales M Fenwick M Forgó N (eds) New Technology, Big Data and the Law. Springer, 17–42.

Griffin R Hansen MP Pultz S , et al. (2025). Co-designing digital services with service users, caseworkers and senior policy makers: the affordance and limitations of expert panels, In Demazière et al. (2025), 150–162.

Grundy J (2015) Statistical profiling of the unemployed. Studies in Political Economy 96(1): 47–68.

Hansen MP (2019) The Moral Economy of Activation: Ideas, Politics and Policies. Policy Press.

Hardill I O’Sullivan R (2020) E-government and digital by default: normalising austerity as the new norm. In: Hall SM Pimlott-Wilson H Horton J (eds) Austerity Across Europe.LIved Experiences of Economic Crises. Routledge, 143–153.

Haug KB Hansen MP (2025) The politics of algorithmic profiling of unemployed: a framework for analysing legitimation, contestation, and compromises. Journal of European Social Policy 09589287251345909.

Iversen T Rehm P (2022) Big Data and the Welfare State. Cambridge University Press.

Kelstrup JD Jørgensen JV Hansen MP (2025) The disenchanted fairy godmother: comparing how and why evidence-based management and public service professionals influenced policy performance in public school and active labour market policy in Denmark. Evidence & Policy 21(2): 186–205.

Knotz CM (2018) A rising workfare state? Unemployment benefit conditionality in 21 OECD countries, 1980–2012. Journal of International and Comparative Social Policy 34(2): 91–108.

Lødemel I Trickey H (eds) (2001) An Offer You Can’T Refuse: Workfare in International Perspective. Policy Press.

Meilvang ML Dahler AM (2024) Decision support and algorithmic support: the construction of algorithms and professional discretion in social work. European Journal of Social Work 27(1): 30–42.

Nordesjö K Scaramuzzino G (2025) The distant, the capable and trustworthy, and the digitally skilled—the production of client roles in municipal activation and social assistance services using automated decision-making. Journal of European Social Policy 09589287251351094.

Pors A Schou J (2021) Street-level morality at the digital frontlines: an ethnographic study of moral mediation in welfare work. Administrative Theory and Praxis 43(2): 154–171.

Sacchi S Scarano G (2025) Unpacking the varieties of welfare digitalisation in the wake of the AI breakthrough. A comparative analysis in five European public employment services. In: Paper presented at the 7th international conference on public policy (ICPP7), Chiang Mai, Thailand, 2-4 July 2025.

Sztandar-Sztanderska K (2025) How context matters: human oversight of automated decision-making systems in welfare administration. Journal of European Social Policy 09589287251358069.

Sztandar-Sztanderska K Zielenska M (2020) What makes an ideal unemployed person? Values and norms encapsulated in a computerized profiling tool. Social Work and Society 18(1).

Trittin-Ulbrich H Scherer AG Munro I , et al. (2021) Exploring the dark and unexpected sides of digitalization: toward a critical agenda. Organization 28(1): 8–25.

van Gerven M (2022) Studying social policy in the digital age. In: Nelsen K Yerkes M Nieuwenhuis R (eds) Social Policy in Changing European Societies. Edward Elgar Publishing, 251–264.

van Gerven M Ruckenstein M (2025) The unhappy marriage of standardization and activation policy: welfare bureaucracy and service professionalism in delivering digital social assistance in Finland. Journal of European Social Policy 09589287251390177.

Watts B Fitzpatrick S (2018) Welfare Conditionality. Routledge.