Despite the rise in employment, consistently high EU-average poverty rates continue to generate debates about the factors that explain the level and changes in the relative poverty rate, both within and across countries. Assuming a strong negative correlation between poverty and employment, the article investigates the role of four mechanisms responsible for this blurred relationship. Using decomposition analysis and macro-level regression analysis, we investigate the extent to which (i) the distribution of employment across households with different levels of work intensity, (ii) the expansion of non-standard work, (iii) the change in the effectiveness of social welfare systems, and (iv) the change in median income and the corresponding shift in the poverty threshold have contributed to changes in relative income poverty in the last decades. We found that employment growth benefits poverty reduction, but this positive effect was partially offset by the precarious characteristics of some newly created jobs. If the distribution of jobs had favoured the jobless more in the pre-crisis period, the relative income poverty rate would have been lower. Although the share of persons in jobless households decreased during the recovery years, their risk of poverty increased due to the retrenchment of social transfers during and after the Great Recession. Furthermore, the use of a floating threshold, which is linked to changes in median income, underestimates the strength of the relationships between poverty, employment and social transfers: when the poverty threshold is kept fixed, not only do the dynamics of poverty look different, but the estimated coefficients are considerably larger.
AlperKHuberEStephensJD (2021) Poverty and social rights: among the working age population in post-industrial democracies. Social Forces99: 1710–1744.
2.
AtkinsonAB (2010) Poverty and the EU: The New Decade (Macerata Lecture on European Economic Policy). Working Paper 24. Macerata, Italy: Università Degli Studi di Macerata.
3.
AtkinsonABGuioA-CMarlierE (2017) Monitoring social inclusion in Europe. In: AtkinsonABGuioA-CMarlierE (eds) Monitoring Social Inclusion in Europe. Luxembourg: Eurostat.
4.
BrülleJGanglMLevanonA, et al. (2019) Changing labour market risks in the service economy: low wages, part-time employment and the trend in working poverty risks in Germany. Journal of European Social Policy29(1): 115–129.
5.
CaminadaKGoudswaardKKosterF (2012) Social income transfers and poverty: a cross-country analysis for OECD countries. International Journal of Social Welfare21(2): 115–126.
6.
CantillonB (2011) The paradox of the social investment state: growth, employment and poverty in the Lisbon era. Journal of European Social Policy21(5): 432–449.
7.
CantillonB (2018) Social Security and Poverty Reduction in Rich Welfare States: Cracks in the Post War Policy Paradigm, Avenues for the Future. Working Paper 1817. Antwerp: Herman Deleeck Centre for Social Policy, University of Antwerp.
8.
CantillonBVandenbrouckeF (2014) Reconciling Work and Poverty Reduction. How Successful Are European Welfare States?Oxford: Oxford University Press.
9.
CantillonBGoedeméTHillsJR (eds) (2019) Decent Incomes for All: Improving Policies in Europe. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
10.
CantillonBParolinZColladoD (2020) A glass ceiling on poverty reduction? An empirical investigation into the structural constraints on minimum income protections. Journal of European Social Policy30(2): 129–143.
11.
ChenTHallaertJ-JPittA, et al. (2018) Inequality and Poverty Across Generations in the European Union. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.
12.
ChzhenYNolanBCantillonB (2017) Impact of the economic crisis on children in rich countries. In: CantillonBChzhenYHandaS, et al. (eds) Children of Austerity: Impact of the Great Recession on Child Poverty in Rich Countries. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 8–29.
13.
ColladoDCantillonBVan den BoschK, et al. (2019) The end of the cheap talk about poverty reduction: the cost of closing the poverty gap while maintaining work incentives. In: CantillonBGoedeméTHillsJR (eds) Decent Incomes for All: Improving Policies in Europe. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 223–244.
14.
CorluyVVandenbrouckeF (2014) Individual employment, household employment, and risk of poverty in the European Union: a decomposition analysis. In: CantillonBVandenbrouckeF (eds) Reconciling Work and Poverty Reduction: How Successful Are European Welfare States?Oxford: Oxford University Press, 94–130.
15.
CrettazE (2013) A state-of-the-art review of working poverty in advanced economies: theoretical, models, measurement issues and risk groups. Journal of European Social Policy23(4): 347–362.
16.
DarvasZ (2019) Why is it so hard to reach the EU’s poverty target?Social Indicators Research141(3): 1081–1105.
Eurofound (2017) Work Poverty in Europe. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
19.
European Commission (2019) Employment and Social Developments in Europe. Sustainable Growth for All: Choices for the Future of Social Europe. Luxembourg: European Commission, Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion.
20.
European Commission (2020) Employment and Social Developments in Europe. Leaving No One Behind and Striving for More: Fairness and Solidarity in the European Social Market Economy. Luxembourg: Directorate-General of Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion.
21.
European Council (2023) Recommendation on adequate minimum income ensuring active inclusion, 3 February. Official Journal of the European Union66(C41): 1–12.
GábosATomkaZ (2022) Developments in minimum income levels in Europe. EUROSHIP Working Paper No. 11. Oslo: Oslo Metropolitan University.
24.
GábosABinderBBranyiczkiR, et al. (2019) Employment and poverty dynamics before, during, and after the crisis. In: CantillonBGoedeméTHillsJR (eds) Decent Incomes for All: Improving Policies in Europe. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 34–55.
25.
GoedeméTPenneTSwedrupO, et al. (2019) Is there common ground for defining a decent social minimum in Europe? In: KotkasTLeijtenIPenningsF (eds) Specifying and Securing a Social Minimum in the Battle against Poverty. Oxford: Hart, 93–109.
26.
GoedeméTDecerfBVan den BoschK (2022) A new poverty indicator for Europe: the extended headcount ratio. Journal of European Social Policy32(3): 287–301.
27.
HallerödBEbkrandHBengtssonM (2015) In-work poverty and labour market trajectories: poverty risks among the working population in 22 European countries. Journal of European Social Policy25(5): 1–17.
28.
HemerijckA (2018) Social investment as a policy paradigm. Journal of European Public Policy25(6): 810–827.
29.
HermannC (2017) Crisis, structural reform and the dismantling of the European social model(s). Economic and Industrial Democracy38(1): 51–68.
30.
HickRLanauA (2017) In-work Poverty in the UK: Problem, Policy Analysis and Platform for Action. Cardiff: Cardiff University.
31.
HickRMarxI (2022) Poor Workers in Rich Democracies: On the Nature of In-Work Poverty and Its Relationship to Labour Market Policies. IZA Discussion Papers 15163. Bonn: Institute of Labor Economics (IZA).
32.
HoremansJ (2019) Atypical work and in-work poverty. In: LohmannHMarxI (eds) Handbook on In-Work Poverty. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 146–170.
33.
JaumotteFLallSPapageorgiouC (2013) Rising income inequality: technology, or trade and financial globalization?IMF Economic Review61(2): 271–309.
34.
JenkinsSP (2020) Perspectives of poverty in Europe: following in Tony Atkinson’s footsteps. Italian Economic Journal6(1): 129–155.
35.
KnotzCM (2018) A rising workfare state? Unemployment benefit conditionality in 21 OECD countries. Journal of International and Comparative Social Policy34(2): 91–108.
36.
LohmannHMarxI (eds) (2019) Handbook on In-Work Poverty. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
37.
MarchalSMarxI (2018) Stemming the tide: what have European Union countries done to support low-wage workers in an era of downward wage pressures?Journal of European Social Policy28(1): 18–33.
38.
MarxINolanB (2012) In-work poverty. GINI Discussion Paper No 51. Amsterdam: Amsterdam Institute for Advanced Labor Studies (AIAS).
39.
MarxIVandenbrouckePVerbistG (2012) Can higher employment levels bring down relative income poverty in the EU? regression-based simulations of the Europe 2020 target. Journal of European Social Policy22: 472–486.
40.
MarxIHoremansJMarchalS, et al. (2013) Towards a better marriage between job growth and poverty reduction. GINI Policy Paper No. 5. Amsterdam: Amsterdam Institute for Advanced Labor Studies (AIAS).
41.
MarxINolanBOliveraJ (2015) The welfare state and anti-poverty policy in rich countries. In: AtkinsonABBourguignonF (eds) Handbook of Income Distribution. Amsterdam: Elsevier, Vol. 2B.
42.
McKnightAStewartKMohun HimmelweitS, et al. (2016) Low Pay and In-Work Poverty: Preventative Measures and Preventative Approaches. Luxembourg: European Commission, Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion.
43.
MollerSHuberEStephensJD, et al. (2003) Determinants of relative poverty in advanced capitalist democracies. American Sociological Review68(1): 22–51.
44.
NolanBMarxI (2009) Economic inequality, poverty and social exclusion. In: SalverdaWNolanBSmeedingTM (eds) Oxford Handbook of Economic Inequality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
45.
NottenGGuioAC (2019) The impact of social transfers on income poverty and material deprivation. In: CantillonBGoedeméTHillsJR (eds) Decent Incomes for All: Improving Policies in Europe. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 85–107.
46.
ParolinZVan LanckerW (2021) What a social investment ‘litmus test’ must address: a response to Plavgo and Hemerijck. Journal of European Social Policy31(3): 297–308.
47.
PlavgoIHemerijckA (2021) The social investment litmus test: family formation, employment and poverty. Journal of European Social Policy31(3): 282–296.
48.
PolinVRaitanoM (2014) Poverty transitions and trigger events across EU groups of countries: evidence from EU-SILC. Journal of Social Policy43(4): 745–772.
49.
RonchiS (2018) Which roads (if any) to social investment? The recalibration of EU welfare states at the crisis crossroads (2000–2014). Journal of Social Policy47(3): 459–478.
50.
SalverdaW (2019) Low earnings and their drivers in relation to in-work poverty. In: LohmannHMarxI (eds) Handbook on In-Work Poverty. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 26–49.
51.
Jara TamayoHXPopovaD (2021) Second earners and in-work poverty in Europe. Journal of Social Policy50(3): 470–492.
52.
TudoracheM-D (2019) Poverty rate determinants in the Central and Eastern Europe member states. Theoretical and Applied Economics26(4): 163–180.
53.
ValaavuoMSirniöO (2022) Jobs against poverty: a fixed-effects analysis on the link between gaining employment and exiting poverty in Europe. European Societies24(3): 1–32.
54.
VandenbrouckeFVleminckxK (2011) Disappointing poverty trends: is the social investment state to blame?Journal of European Social Policy21(5): 450–471.
55.
WeishauptT (2013) Origin and genesis of activation policies in ‘old’ Europe: towards a balanced approach? In: MarxINelsonK (eds) Minimum Income Protection in Flux. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 190–216.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
