In-work poverty and labour market trajectories: Poverty risks among the working population in 22 European countries

Abstract

Is in-work poverty a low-wage or an unemployment problem, and is it the same problem all across Europe? Because of the definitional ambiguity, we really do not know. In this article, we use longitudinal European Union-Statistics on Income and Living Conditions (EU-SILC) data from 22 countries and derive a set of distinct clusters of labour market trajectories (LMTs) from information about monthly labour market position from a 36-month observation window and estimate in-work poverty risk for each LMT. The results show that in-work poverty is a problem that affects the self-employed and people in a marginal labour market position, that is, those who for different reasons move in and out of employment. Hence, in-work poverty is mainly an unemployment problem, not a low-wage problem. Besides the fact that the size of LMTs varies between countries, we also expected to find systematic country differences in the effect of LMTs. The analysis did not support that assumption.

Keywords

In-work poverty labour market trajectories low-wage unemployment welfare regimes

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aidukaite

(2011) ‘Welfare Reforms and Socio-Economic Trends in the 10 New EU Member States of Central and Eastern Europe’, Communist and Post-Communist Studies 44(3): 211–9.

Andreß

H.-J.

Lohmann

(eds) (2008) The Working Poor in Europe: Employment, Poverty and Globalization. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Atkinson

A.B.

(1984) ‘Manpower Strategies for Flexible Organisations’, Personnel Management 16(115): 21–31.

Bardone

Guio

A.-C.

(2005) ‘In-Work Poverty’, in Statistics in Focus – Population and Social Conditions. Luxembourg: Eurostat, available at http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/social_inclusion/docs/statistics5-2005_en.pdf.

Barron

D.R.

Norris

G.M.

(1976) ‘Sexual Divisions and the Dual Labour Market’, in Barker

D.L.

Allen

(eds) Dependence and Exploitation in Work and Marriage, pp. 47–69. New York: Longman.

Bengtsson

Berglund

(2012) ‘Labour Market Policies in Transition: From Social Engineering to Standby-Ability’, in Larsson

Letell

Thörn

(eds) Transformations of the Swedish Welfare State: From Social Engineering to Governance? pp. 86–103. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Bradshaw

Mayhew

(2011) The Measurement of Extreme Poverty in the European Union. Brussels: Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion.

Copeland

Daly

(2012) ‘Varieties of Poverty Reduction: Inserting the Poverty and Social Exclusion Target into Europe 2020’, Journal of European Social Policy 22(3): 273–87.

Corluy

Vandenbroucke

(2014) ‘Individual Employment, Household Employment, and Risk of Poverty in the European Union: A Decomposit Analysis’, in Cantillon

Vandenbroucke

(eds) Reconciling Work and Poverty Reduction, pp. 94–130. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

10.

Crettaz

(2011) Fighting Working Poverty in Post-Industrial Economies: Causes Trade-Offs and Policy Solutions. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

11.

Crettaz

Bonoli

(2011) ‘Worlds of Working Poverty: National Variations in Mechanisms’, in Fraser

Gutiérrez

Peña-Casaan

(eds) Working Poverty in Europe: A Comparative Approach, pp. 46–72. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

12.

De Graaf-Zijl

Nolan

. (2011) ‘Household Joblessness and Its Impact on Poverty and Deprivation in Europe’, Journal of European Social Policy 21(5): 413–31.

13.

De La Porte

Jacobsson

(2012) ‘Social Investment or Recommodification? Assessing the Employment Policies of the EU Member States’, in Morel

Palier

Palme

(eds) Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, Policies and Challenges, pp. 117–52. Bristol: Policy Press.

14.

Ellingsaeter

A.L.

(1998) ‘Labour Market Restructuring and Polarization Processes: The Significance of Political-Institutional Factors’, Economic and Industrial Democracy 19: 579–603.

15.

Esping-Andersen

(1991) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Oxford: Polity Press.

16.

Eurostat (2010) In-Work Poverty in the EU. Luxembourg: Eurostat.

17.

Fraser

Gutiérrez

Peña-Casa

(eds) (2011) Working Poverty in Europe: A Comparative Approach. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

18.

Gal

(2010) ‘Is There an Extended Family of Mediterranean Welfare States?’ Journal of European Social Policy 20(4): 283–300.

19.

Gallie

(2007) Employment Regimes and the Quality of Work. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

20.

Gallie

White

Cheng

Tomlinson

(1998) Restructuring the Employment Relationship. New York: Oxford University Press.

21.

Goerne

(2011) ‘A Comparative Analysis of in-Work Poverty in the European Union’, in Fraser

Gutiérrez

Peña-Casaan

(eds) Working Poverty in Europe: A Comparative Approach, pp. 15–45. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

22.

Guio

A.-C.

Gordon

Marlier

(2012) ‘Measuring Material Deprivation in the EU: Indicators for the Whole Population and Child-Specific Indicators’, Eurostat Methodologies and Working Papers, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities (OPOCE), Luxembourg.

23.

Halleröd

(1995) ‘The Truly Poor: Indirect and Direct Measurement of Consensual Poverty in Sweden’, Journal of European Social Policy 5(2): 111–29.

24.

Halleröd

(2004) ‘What I Need and What the Poor Deserve: Analyzing the Gap between the Minimum Income Needed for Oneself and the View of an Adequate Norm for Social Assistance’, Social Forces 83(1): 35–59.

25.

Halleröd

Ekbrand

(2014) ‘Labour Market Trajectories and Young Europeans’ Capabilities to Avoid Poverty, Social Exclusion and Dependency: A Comparative Analysis of 23 European Countries’, in Otto

H.-U.

Atzmüller

Berthet

Bifulco

Bonvin

J.-M.

Chiappero-Martinetti

Egdell

Zielenska

. . . M.

(eds) Facing Trajectories from School to Work. Cham: Springer International Publishing Switzerland.

26.

Halleröd

Larsson

(2008a) ‘In-Work Poverty in a Transitional Labour Market: Sweden, 1988–2003’, in Andreß

H.-J.

Lohmann

(eds) The Working Poor in Europe: Employment, Poverty and Globalization, pp. 155–78. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

27.

Halleröd

Larsson

(2008b) ‘Poverty, Welfare Problems and Social Exclusion’, International Journal of Social Welfare 17(1): 15–25.

28.

Halleröd

Westberg

(2006) ‘Youth Problem: What’s the Problem? A Longitudinal Study of Incomes and Economic Hardship among Swedish Youth’, Acta Sociologica 49(1): 83–102.

29.

Halleröd

Örestig

Stattin

(2013) ‘Leaving the Labour Market: The Impact of Exit Routes from Employment to Retirement on Health and Wellbeing in Old Age’, European Journal of Ageing 10: 25–35.

30.

Hox

J.J.

(2010) Multilevel Analysis: Techniques and Applications. New York: Routledge.

31.

Jørgensen

(2009) ‘From a Beautiful Swan to an Ugly Duckling: The Renewal of Danish Activation Policy since 2003’, European Journal of Social Security 11(4): 337–67.

32.

Junestav

(2011) ‘Promoting Employment or Employability? The Move from Active Labour Market Policy to Workfare’, in Thörnquist

Engstrand

Å.-K.

(eds) Precarious Employment in Perspective: Old and New Challenges to Working Conditions in Sweden, pp. 221–48. Bruxelles/New York: P.I.E. Peter Lang.

33.

Kalleberg

A.L.

(2003) ‘Flexible Firms and Labor Market Segmentation: Effects of Workplace Restructuring on Jobs and Workers’, Work and Occupations 30: 154–75.

34.

Klein

B.W.

Rones

P.-L.

(1989) ‘A Profile of the Working Poor’, Monthly Labor Review 112: 3–13.

35.

Kohl

Platzer

H.-W.

(2007) ‘The Role of the State in Central and Eastern European Industrial Relations: The Case of Minimum Wages’, Industrial Relations Journal 38(6): 614–35.

36.

Korpi

Palme

(1998) ‘The Paradox of Redistribution and Strategies of Equality: Welfare State Institutions, Inequality, and Poverty in the Western Countries’, American Sociological Review 63(5): 661–87.

37.

Korpi

Palme

(2004) ‘New Politics and Class Politics in the Context of Austerity and Globalization: Welfare State Regress in 18 Countries 1975–1995’, American Political Science Review 97(3): 425–46.

38.

Larsson

Halleröd

(2011) ‘Sweden: The Impact of Policy and Labour Market Transformation’, in Fraser

Gutiérrez

Peña-Casas

(eds) Working Poverty in Europe: A Comparative Approach, pp. 112–32. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.

39.

Lohmann

(2009) ‘Welfare States, Labour Market Institutions and the Working Poor: A Comparative Analysis of 20 European Countries’, European Sociological Review 25(4): 489–504.

40.

Lohmann

Marx

(2008) ‘The Different Faces of in-Work Poverty across Welfare State Regimes’, in Andreß

H.-J.

Lohmann

(eds) The Working Poor in Europe: Employment, Poverty and Globalisation, pp. 17–46. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

41.

Maechler

Rousseeuw

Struyf

Hubert

Hornik

(2014) Cluster: Cluster Analysis Basics and Extensions, R package version 1.15.3. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.

42.

Maitre

Nolan

Whelan

C.T.

(2012) ‘Low Pay, in-Work Poverty and Economic Vulnerability: A Comparative Analysis Using EU-SILC’, Manchester School 80(1): 99–116.

43.

Marx

Nolan

(2014) ‘In-Work Poverty’, in Cantillon

Vandenbroucke

(eds) Reconciling Work and Poverty Reduction: How Successful Are European Welfare States? pp. 131–156. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

44.

Marx

Vanhille

Verbist

(2012) ‘Combating in-Work Poverty in Continental Europe: An Investigation Using the Belgian Case’, Journal of Social Policy 41: 19–41.

45.

Mosisa

A.T.

(2003) ‘The Working Poor in 2001’, Monthly Labor Review 126: 13–9.

46.

Nightingale

D.S.

Fix

(2004) ‘Economic and Labor Market Trends’, Future of Children 14: 49–59.

47.

Nikolai

(2012) ‘Towards Social Investment? Patterns of Public Policy in the OECD World’, in Morel

Palier

Palme

(eds) Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, Policies and Challenges, pp. 91–116. Bristol: Policy Press.

48.

Palier

Martin

(2007) ‘Editorial Introduction – From ‘A Frozen Landscape’ to Structural Reforms: The Sequential Transformation of Bismarckian Welfare Systems’, Social Policy and Administration 41(6): 535–54.

49.

Peña-Casas

Latta

(2004) Working Poor in the European Union. Luxembourg: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions.

50.

Polanyi

(1968) The Great Transformation. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.

51.

Scruggs

Allan

(2006) ‘Welfare-State Decommodification in 18 OECD Countries: A Replication and Revision’, Journal of European Social Policy 16(1): 55–72.

52.

Standing

(2011) The Precariat: The New Dangerous Class. London: Bloomsbury Academic.

53.

Van Lancker

. (2012) ‘The European World of Temporary Employment Gendered and Poor?’ European Societies 14(1): 83–111.

54.

Visser

(1996) ‘Traditions and Transitions in Industrial Relations: A European View’, in Van Ruysseveldt

Visser

(eds) Industrial Relations in Europe: Traditions and Transitions, pp. 1–41. London: Sage.

55.

Visser

Beentjes

Van Gerven

Di Stasio

(2009) ‘The Quality of Industrial Relations and the Lisbon Strategy’, in European Commission (ed.) Industrial Relations in Europe, 2008, pp. 45–72. Brussels: European Commission.