There has been an increasing effort to promote renewable energies as climate change mitigation measures in Japan. Yet, the installation of wind turbines and solar photovoltaic (PV) power plants is being contested in several parts of the country. There is a need to understand these oppositions to reduce the number of delayed projects or overcome future barriers. Thus, in this study, we investigated cases of opposition movements and legal proceedings against wind and solar PV power development. Results indicated that landscape elements and socio-ecological factors motivate local oppositions. For instance, there were cases filed due to landscape view obstruction caused by wind turbines and solar panels. In terms of socio-ecological barriers, examples of cases scrutinized showed opposition caused by the potential impact on recreational activities such as climbing and hiking trails. Additionally, we observed that there were differences in the scope and scale of opposition movements and legal proceedings between wind and solar PV power projects. These differences were related to the scale (project size) and duration (construction to operation) of the project coupled with the renewable energy-related legal system changes in Japan. We observed that the overall legislative framework is frequently designed at the national level while challenges in project site selection are dealt with at the municipal- and prefectural-level. The findings of this study can help policymakers to revise and/or develop legal systems that minimize impacts on landscape and social elements while satisfying the demand for renewable energy transitions.
GharaibehAAl-ShboulDAAl-RawabdehAM,et al.Establishing regional power sustainability and feasibility using wind farm land-use optimization. Land (Basel)2021; 10: 442.
2.
AkitaNOheYArakiS,et al.Managing conflicts with local communities over the introduction of renewable energy: the solar-rush experience in Japan. Land (Basel)2020; 9: 290.
3.
ShahzadU. The need for renewable energy sources. ITEEJ2015; 4: 16–18.
4.
GielenDBoshellFSayginD, et al.The role of renewable energy in the global energy transformation. Energy Strategy Rev2019; 24: 38–50.
5.
SenAGangulyS. Opportunities, barriers and issues with renewable energy development – A discussion. Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev2017; 69: 1170–1181.
6.
NasirovSSilvaCAgostiniCA. Investors’ perspectives on barriers to the deployment of renewable energy sources in Chile. Energies2015; 8: 3794–3814.
7.
SusskindLChunJGantA,et al.Sources of opposition to renewable energy projects in the United States. Energy Policy2022; 165: 112922.
8.
JonesCREiserR. Understanding ‘local’ opposition to wind development in the UK: how big is a backyard?Energy Policy2010; 38: 3106–3117.
9.
AnsariMFKharbRKLuthraS,et al.Analysis of barriers to implement solar power installations in India using interpretive structural modeling technique. Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev2013; 27: 163–174.
10.
SeetharamanMPatwaKSaravananN,et al.Breaking barriers in deployment of renewable energy. Heliyon2019; 5: e01166.
11.
ObaneHNagaiYAsanoK. Assessing land use and potential conflict in solar and onshore wind energy in Japan. Renew Energy2020; 160: 842–851.
12.
KitanoMShirakiS. Estimation of bird fatalities at wind farms with complex topography and vegetation in hokkaido, Japan. Wildl Soc Bull2013; 37: 41–48.
McCarthyNHendersonH. The role of renewable energy laws in expanding energy from non-traditional renewables. Inter-American Development Bank Working Paper Series 2014. No. IDB-WP-540.
15.
AidunHElkinJGoyalR,et al.Opposition to renewable energy facilities in the United States. Sabin Center for Climate Change Law March 2022 ed.
16.
ZimmermanMGReamesTG. Where the wind blows: exploring barriers and opportunities to renewable energy development on the United States tribal lands. Energy Research & Social Science2021; 72: 101874.
17.
HafnerMRaimondiPP. Priorities and challenges of the EU energy transition: from the European green package to the new green deal. Russian Journal of Economics2020; 6: 374–389.
18.
HuhtaK. Anchoring the energy transition with legal certainty in EU law. Maastrich J Eur Comp Law2020; 27: 425–444.
BennunLvan BochoveJNgC, et al.Mitigating Biodiversity Impacts Associated with Solar and Wind Energy Development. Guidelines for Project Developers. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN and Cambridge, UK: The Biodiversity Consultancy, 2021 Available here: https://portals.iucn.org/library/sites/library/files/documents/2021-004-En-Summ.pdf (accessed 4 March 2022).
TigueC. Wind energy development and protection of wildlife: creating a balance between two competing interests. TELJ2015; 45: 223–243.
24.
TurneyDFthenakisV. Environmental impacts from the installation and operation of large-scale solar power plants. Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev2011; 15: 3261–3270.
25.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ,et al.Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Br Med J2009; 339: b2535.
MorrisAOwleyJ. Mitigating the impacts of the renewable energy gold rush. Minn. J.L. Sci. & Tech2014; 15: 293–594.
28.
PizzoS. Note & comment: when saving the environment hurts the environment: balancing solar energy development with land and wildlife conservation in a warming climate. COLO. J. Int'l Envtl. L. & Pol'y2011; 22: 123–204.
29.
WisemanH. Article: localizing the green energy revolution. Emory L. J. Online2021; 70: 59–103.
30.
KataokaN. The land of koma swaying in the mega solar construction plan (1), responding to disaster risk and conservation of natural landscapes, "wait" for solar power generation equipment. Hidaka City Enacts Ordinance. Friday2019; 27: 40–41.
31.
KanekoM. Natural disaster risk management in photovoltaic business. Journal of Japan Solar Energy Society2019; 45: 41–46.
32.
WallsgroveR. Corporations and climate change: how businesses are changing the environmental landscape is community solar really a security?Vt. L. Rev2019; 43: 777–840.
OtsukaT. Essentials of environmental law (ver. 3). Yuhikaku2021: 112.
35.
TanakaM. Issues in the Environmental Assessment System Associated with the Introduction of Renewable Energy - Toward a Balance between the Introduction of Renewable Energy and Consideration for Tolerance -Available here: https://kanto.env.go.jp/files/5c29c16291 a90a45b72e9a29dbbe36 b7.pdf (accessed 9 March 2022). 2021.
YuasaY. Nuclear power plant siting and social system, bulletin of faculty of letters. Kanto-Gakuin University2011; 124: 1–36.
39.
ShiraiN. The structural regeneration of regional communities through renewable energy in areas affected by the great east Japan earthquake: consideration of administrative measures and resident's awareness. Sustainability Research2017; 7: 45–58.
40.
SekikawaC. Actual condition and agenda of the renewable energy policy of local government: consideration of the survey results on the renewable energy policy of local government. Journal on Public Affairs2015; 11: 229–271.
41.
OhiraY. Perspective of renewable energy policies in fukushima: industrial cluster policies and promotion incentive policies. Sustainability Research2014; 4: 7–16.
42.
Saku City. Environmental (Eco) local government white paper: dissemination of renewable energy and regulation of solar power generation facilities by ordinances. Local Government Officers Seminar2015; 48: 29–31.
43.
KohyamaS. Examining the way of public participation for landscape conservation: a legal view from the environmental administrative law. Journal for Interdisciplinary Research on Community Life2016; 7: 95–116.
44.
NaitoS. Current Status and issues of administrative practice in the region regarding solar power generation facilities (special feature: administrative law of the sea and the earth: renewable energy). Quarterly Jurist2019; 28: 70–76.
45.
KohyamaS. A study on the implementation of solar power generation projects-regional selection by operating entities in the installation of power generation facilities and municipalities. Corporate Law Research2019; 8: 1–21.
46.
SaekiAKondoT. Residents' cass action: residents' lawsuits related to the contract for installation of solar power generation equipment: suita city (osaka district court, 29.5.19 judgment). Judicial Precedent Local Autonomy2018; 429: 100–102.
47.
KohyamaS. Case study: mega solar installation injunction to prevent degradation of natural landscape. The Journal of Economic Studies, University of Toyama2018a; 64: 171–193.
48.
OchiT. Judgment of injunction request case such as installation of mega solar. New: Case Law Commentary Watch2018; 21: 279–282.
49.
TKC (Tochigi Kaikei Center). Appeal Case for Cancellation of Disapproval of River Occupancy (Ito City): Tokyo Appellate Court Judgement, April 21, 2021 (Reiwa 3). LEX/DB 25591140. (accessed 10 March 2022).
50.
Kochi-Newspaper. Contractor sues Shimanto City for Disapproval of Mega Solar Construction: The Basis of the Landscape Ordinance is "Injustice" 11 November, 2021. Available here: https://mainichi.jp/articles/20211203/ddl/k39/040/ 460000c(accessed 9 March 2022).
51.
OtsukaT. Environmental law (ver. 4). Yuhikaku2020a: 92.
52.
TsuijimuraM. The constitutional law (ver.7). Nihon-Hyoron-Sya2021: 248–254.
53.
TakadaH. Current Status and legal issues of solar power business: focusing on FIT system and SLAPP litigation. Annual Report of Institute for Business and Law2019; 1: 27–50.
54.
Kohyama S. Learning the natural environmental laws. Bunshindo2018b; 2018: 304–318.
55.
Industry and Environment. Austria's heat utilization and renewable energy: the road to renewable energy expansion selected by the people “do not rely on nuclear power” (special feature: renewable energy business expanding). Industry and Environment2012; 41: 23–28.
56.
Nikkei Ecology. Renewable energy fukushima aiming for "100% renewable energy" disseminating cutting-edge technology from land and sea (special feature: from Tohoku, to the world, to the future). Nikkei Ecology2012; 157: 42–44.
57.
MizukamiTSatoY. Legal issues concerning promotion of renewable energy: toward the realization of community-led renewable energy business (special feature: promotion of renewable energy). Urban Problems2012; 103: 9–14.
58.
BerstchVHallMWeinhardtC,et al.Public acceptance and preferences related to renewable energy and grid expansion policy: empirical insights for Germany. Energy2016; 114: 465–477.
59.
SegretoMPrincipeLDesormeauxA, et al.Trends in social acceptance of renewable energy across Europe – A literature review. Int J Environ Res Public Health2020; 17: 9161.
60.
YasudaY. What is the problem with the scientific communication renewable energy connection suspension problem?Science (Iwanami-Shoten2014; 84: 1191–1195.
61.
FurukaneY. Environmental issues regional regeneration by renewable energy: it is necessary to draw out the strengths of the region by using renewable energy instead of selling electricity. Mutual Aid Research Institute Report2015; 137: 39–41.
62.
KomiyamaR. Turning point in energy market: Challenge for the promotion of renewable energy. JAESJ ATOMOΣ2015; 57(1): 714–719.
63.
MaruyamaY. Risks and local resource management related to renewable energy. (ed. Maruyama, Y. Et al.) risks and governance of renewable energy. Minerva Shobo2015: 3–23.
64.
Enforcement Order of the Environmental Impact Assessment Act (Cabinet Order No. 346 of 1997).
65.
Study Group on the Ideal Way of Environmental Impact Assessmetn for the Proper Introduction of Renewable Energy 2020. Study Group on the Ideal Way of Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proper Introduction of Renewable Energy. 2020. (Reiwa 2) Available here: https://www.meti.go.jp/shingikai/safety_security/renewable_energy/pdf/20210331_1.pdf.(accessed 9 March 2022).
KasagiH. Increasing pressure on wind power development and trends in nagano prefecture. Residents and Autonomy2021; 167: 1–4.
68.
Issunboshi Assessment Committee and Renewable Energy Citizens' Association. Issunboshi-yama. Environmental impact survey report on the installation of civilian wind turbines (July, 2009).
69.
AnkeiT. Wind Power Generation and Environmental Assessment: Walking Mitsugamine from Tokusanaka, Yamaguchi City to Yoshika Town, Shimane Prefecture, Available here: http://ankei.jp/takako/?n = 1893 (2013, accessed 10 March, 2021).
Chosyu Newspaper. Maeda Corporation withdraws Wind Plan for Mt. Haguro: A land of Mountain Worship that is Proud of All over the Country, https://www.chosyu-journal.jp/shakai/18455 (2020a, accessed 10 March 2022).
73.
InagakiT. “Wind Power Generation Plan” What is the Future Wind Direction?. Hokuriku Cyunichi Newspaper, https://www.chunichi.co.jp/article/ (2021, accessed 10 March 2022).
Ise Newspaper. Ise-Newspaper. 2021. Tsu, Mie: Hakusan Windmill Construction Suspended Sumitomo Forestry in Protest of Residents 11 November 2021, https://www.isenp.co.jp/2021/11/11/66968/(accessed 10 March 2022). 2021.
76.
Chunichi Newspaper. "Departure from the Deadline" Residents' Repulsion: Large-Scale Wind Power Generation in Matsusaka, Planning Progress 28 November 2021. Available here: https://www.chunichi.co.jp/article/373440 (accessed 10 March 2022). 2021.
77.
KitamuraY. Distant nature view and landscape benefits: range of supreme court decision in kunitachi condominiums case. Industry and Environment2011; 40: 22.
78.
Operating Entity at Kiso Ontake Solar Power Plant Plan (Tentative). Ontake Golf Course Site Development Local Information Session Material (Power Transmission Line) Provided by Kasagi, H on 10 February 2021.
79.
ItoS. Policy innovation from municipalities: from landscape ordinances to landscape act. Mokutan-sha2006: 289.
80.
OhgishiMOkuHFukamachiK,et al.A study of landscape evaluation schema and differences of large wind power generator between residents and visitors. Journal of The Japanese Institute of Landscape Architecture2006; 69: 711–716. DOI: 10.5632/jila.69.711
81.
KohsakaRKohyamaS. State of the art review on land-use policy: changes in forests, agricultural lands and renewable energy of Japan. Land (Basel)2022; 11: 624. DOI: 10.3390/land11050624
