This study examines over 300 letters of recommendation for medical faculty at a large American medical school in the mid-1990s, using methods from corpus and discourse analysis, with the theoretical perspective of gender schema from cognitive psychology. Letters written for female applicants were found to differ systematically from those written for male applicants in the extremes of length, in the percentages lacking in basic features, in the percentages with doubt raisers (an extended category of negative language, often associated with apparent commendation), and in frequency of mention of status terms. Further, the most common semantically grouped possessive phrases referring to female and male applicants (`her teaching,' `his research') reinforce gender schema that tend to portray women as teachers and students, and men as researchers and professionals.
Association of American Medical Colleges (1996) Association of American Medical Colleges Data Book: Statistical Information Related to Medical Education (eds P. Jolly and D. Hudley). Washington, DC: AAMC; AAMC Faculty Roster System Historical File (1995).
2.
Bell, S. , Cole, C.S. and Floge, L. (1992) `Letters of Recommendation in Academe: Do Women and Men Write Different Languages?', The American SociologistFall: 7-22.
3.
Bouton, L.F. (1995) `A Cross-Cultural Analysis of the Structure and Content of Letters of Reference', Studies in Second Language Acquisition17: 122-144.
4.
Bowman, M.A. and Allen, D.I. (1990) Stress and Women Physicians. New York: Springer.
5.
Brownlee, S. and Pezzullo, E. (1992) `A Cure for Sexism: Women Doctors Herald a Kinder, Gentler Way to Practice Medicine', U.S. News & World ReportMarch 23: 86-87, 90.
6.
Conley, F.K. (1998) Walking Out On the Boys. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
7.
Cowan, G. and Kasen, J.H. (1984) `Form of Reference: Sex Differences in Letters of Recommendation', Journal of Personality & Social Psychology46(3): 636-645.
8.
DeLisa, J.A. , Jain, S.S. and Campagnolo, D.I. (1994) `Factors Used by Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Residency Training Directors to Select Their Residents', American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation73(3): 152-156.
9.
Drew, P. and Sorjonen, M-L. (1997) `Institutional Dialogue', in T.A. van Dijk, (ed.), Discourse as Social Interaction. London: Sage.
10.
Eckert, P. and McConnell-Ginet, S. (1992) `Think Practically and Look Locally: Language and Gender as Community-Based Practice', Annual Review of Anthropology21: 461-490.
11.
Eger, H. (1991) `Writer Perception, Writer Projection: The Influence of Personality, Ideology, and Gender on Letters of Recommendation', unpublished dissertation, University of Illinois at Chicago.
12.
Ferrara, K.W. (1994) Therapeutic Ways with Words. New York: Oxford University Press.
13.
Fiske, S.T. Trial Testimony 3/28/85, Tr. 534-633, in the Joint Appendix of the Briefs to the Supreme Court for Appellee in Price Waterhouse V. Ann B. Hopkins, Docket No. 87-1167, October Term, 1987, 21-82.
14.
Fried, L.P. , Francomano, C.A., MacDonald, S.M., Wagner, E.M., Stokes, E.J., Carbone, K.M., Bias, W.B., Newman, M.M. and Stobo, J.D. (1996) `Career Development for Women in Academic Medicine: Multiple Interventions in a Department of Medicine', Journal of the American Medial Association276: 898-905.
15.
Gayed, N.M. (1991) `Residency Directors Assessments of Which Selection Criteria Best Predict the Performances of Foreign-Born Medical Graduates During Internal Medicine Residencies', Academic Medicine66(11): 699-701.
16.
Goffman, E. (1981) `Radio Talk', in Forms of Talk. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
17.
Greenburg, A.G. , Doyle, J. and McClure, D.K. (1994) `Letters of Recommendation for Surgical Residencies: What They Say and What They Mean', Journal of Surgical Research56(2): 192-198.
18.
Gross, J. (1991) `A Woman's Resignation Touches a Nerve at Medical Schools', The New York Times14 July, 10.
19.
Hatcher, L.L. (1983) `Letters of Recommendation: Validity and Contribution to Variance in Judgements About Applicants', unpublished dissertation, Bowling Green State University, Ohio.
20.
Johnson, M. , Elam, C., Edwards, J., Taylor, D., Heldberg, C., Hinkley, R. and Comeau, R. (1998) `Predicting Performance and Satisfaction: Beyond the Crystal Ball', Academic Medicine73(10, Suppl.): S41-S43.
21.
LaCroix, P.P. (1985) `Sex in Recs', The Journal of College AdmissionFall: 24-26.
22.
Morrisett, L.N. (1935) Letters of Recommendation: A Study of Letters of Recommendation as an Instrument in the Selection of Secondary School Teachers. New York: Columbia University.
23.
O'Halloran, B.A. , Altmaier E., Smith, W. and Franken, E. (1993) `Evaluation of Resident Applicants by Letters of Recommendation: A Comparison of Traditional and Behavior-Based Formats', Investigative Radiology28: 274-277.
24.
Precht, K. (1998) `A Cross-cultural Comparison of Letters of Recommendation', English for Special Purposes17(3): 241-265.
25.
Rayber, G.A.B. (1985) `Source of Letters of Recommendation and Subsequent Teaching Performance of First-Year Teachers', unpublished dissertation, University of Georgia, Athens.
26.
Selvin, P. (1993) `Jenny Harrison Finally Gets Tenure in Math at Berkeley', Science21: 287.
27.
Stokoe, E.H. and Smithson, J. (2001) `Making Gender Relevant: Conversation Analysis and Gender Categories in Interaction', Discourse & Society12(2): 217-244.
28.
Tannen, D. (1989) Talking Voices: Repetition, Dialogue, and Imagery in Conversational Discourse. New York: Cambridge University Press.
29.
Tannen, D. (1994) Talking from 9 to 5. New York: Avon Books.
30.
Tommasi, G. , Williams, K. and Nordstrom, C. (1998) `Letters of Recommendation: What Information Captures HR Professionals' Attention?', Journal of Business and Psychology13(1): 5-18.
31.
Trix, F. and Sankar, A. (1998) `Women's Voices and Experiences of the Hill/Thomas Hearings', American Anthropologist100(1): 32-40.
32.
Valian, V. (1998) Why so Slow? The Advancement of Women. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
33.
Van Dijk, T.A. (1993) Elite Discourse and Racism. London: Sage.
34.
Van Dijk, T.A. , Ting-Toomey, S., Smitherman, G. and Troutman, D. (1997) `Discourse, Ethnicity, Culture, and Racism', in T.A. van Dijk (ed.) Discourse as Social Interaction. London: Sage.
35.
Van Leeuwen, T. (1996) `The Representation of Social Actors', in C.R. Caldas-Couthard and M. Coulthard (eds) Texts and Practices: Readings in Critical Discourse Analysis. London: Routledge.
36.
Watson, C. (1987) `Sex-Linked Differences in Letters of Recommendation', Women and LanguageX(2): 26-28.
37.
Wenneras, C. and Wold, A. (1997) `Nepotism and Sexism in Peer-Review', Nature387: 341-343.
38.
Yourcenar, M. (1981) Discours Prononcé dans la Séance Publique. Paris. http://www.academierancise.fr/imortels/discours_reception/yourcenar.html
