The pathophysiology of Meniere’s disease (MD) is complex and intertwined with endolymphatic hydrops. Available experimental models have limitations.
Objective
This study aimed to analyze the impact of endolymphatic hydrops on cochleovestibular hydrodynamics through numerical simulations.
Methods
A comprehensive literature review was conducted following PRISMA guidelines for Scoping Reviews. Articles were sourced in June 2024 from PubMed and Google Scholar using a combination of MESH terms related to hydrodynamics, numerical simulation, and MD. Studies involving numerical simulations of hydrops in the vestibule, cochlea, or both were included.
Results
Eight studies on hydrodynamics in hydrops using numerical simulations were included. In cochlear models, hydrops affect basilar membrane mechanics, causing low-frequency hearing loss, auditory distortions, and frequency shifts. Vestibular models revealed increased static pressure in the horizontal semicircular canal, explaining abnormal vHIT findings in hydrops patients. Models also suggested chaotic fluid dynamics in dilated labyrinthine structures during caloric tests. The reviewed studies underscore the utility of numerical models in understanding the mechanics of MD; however, significant limitations were identified.
Conclusions
Numerical modeling offers valuable insights into the hydrodynamic changes caused by endolymphatic hydrops in MD, but future work should address the current limitations by incorporating more accurate anatomical features and chronic progression in simulations.
MerchantSNAdamsJCNadolJB. Pathophysiology of Meniere’s syndrome: are symptoms caused by endolymphatic hydrops?Otol Neurotol2005; 26(1): 74–81.
4.
RiveraTSanzLCamareroG, et al.Drug delivery to the inner ear: strategies and their therapeutic implications for sensorineural hearing loss. Curr Drug Deliv2012; 9(3): 231–242.
5.
SaltANPlontkeSK. Principles of local drug delivery to the inner ear. Audiol Neurootol2009; 14(6): 350–360.
6.
KakigiATakedaT. Effect of artificial endolymph injection into the cochlear duct on the endocochlear potential. Hear Res1998; 116(1–2): 113–118.
7.
KurzbuchARMomjianANicoucarK, et al.Extreme sensitivity of hearing to decreases of ICP in Menière’s disease. Acta Neurochir2009; 151(8): 1005–1008.
8.
TakeuchiSTakedaTSaitoH. Pressure relationship between perilymph and endolymph associated with endolymphatic infusion. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol1991; 100(3): 244–248.
9.
WalstedA. Effects of cerebrospinal fluid loss on hearing. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl2000; 543: 95–98.
10.
WalstedASalomonGThomsenJ, et al.Hearing decrease after loss of cerebrospinal fluid. A new hydrops model?Acta Otolaryngol1991; 111(3): 468–476.
11.
DunnebierESegenhoutJWitH, et al.Two-phase endolymphatic hydrops: a new dynamic Guinea pig model. Acta Otolaryngol1997; 117: 13–19.
12.
KimuraRSSchuknechtHF. Membranous hydrops in the inner ear of the Guinea pig after obliteration of the endolymphatic sac. Pract Oto-Rhino-Laryngol2010; 27(6): 343–354.
13.
TakedaTTakedaSKitanoH, et al.Endolymphatic hydrops induced by chronic administration of vasopressin. Hear Res2000; 140(1–2): 1–6.
14.
TakumidaMAkagiNAnnikoM. A new animal model for Ménière’s disease. Acta Otolaryngol2008; 128(3): 263–271.
15.
WickCCSemaanMTZhengQY, et al.A genetic murine model of endolymphatic hydrops: the Phex mouse. Curr Otorhinolaryngol Rep2014; 2(3): 144–151.
16.
BöhmerA. Hydrostatic pressure in the inner ear fluid compartments and its effects on inner ear function. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl1993; 507: 3–24.
17.
LongCHMorizonoT. Hydrostatic pressure measurements of endolymph and perilymph in a Guinea pig model of endolymphatic hydrops. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1987; 96(1): 83–95.
18.
WarmerdamTJSchröderFHHJWitHP, et al.Perilymphatic and endolymphatic pressures during endolymphatic hydrops. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol2003; 260(1): 9–11.
19.
SaltANRask-AndersenH. Responses of the endolymphatic sac to perilymphatic injections and withdrawals: evidence for the presence of a one-way valve. Hear Res2004; 191(1–2): 90–100.
20.
GuildSR. The circulation of the endolymph. Am J Anat1927; 39(1): 57–81.
21.
SaltANThalmannRMarcusDC, et al.Direct measurement of longitudinal endolymph flow rate in the Guinea pig cochlea. Hear Res1986; 23(2): 141–151.
22.
ReidL. An introduction to biomedical computational fluid dynamics. Adv Exp Med Biol2021; 1334: 205–222.
GargulaSEbodeDMeisterL, et al.Sound-induced drug distribution in the cochlea, how close are we? A PRISMA scoping review. Int J Audiol2024: 1–8.
25.
TriccoACLillieEZarinW, et al.PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanation. Ann Intern Med2018; 169(7): 467–473.
26.
MoherDShamseerLClarkeM, et al.Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 statement. Syst Rev2015; 4(1): 1.
27.
FleischerMSchmidtRGummerA. Compliance profiles derived from a three-dimensional finite-element model of the basilar membrane. J Acoust Soc Am2010; 127: 2973–2991.
28.
ManoussakiDDimitriadisEChadwickR. Radial profile of the basilar membrane in a coiled cochlea: results and biological implications. J Biomech2006; 39: S433.
29.
RoblesLRuggeroMA. Mechanics of the mammalian cochlea. Physiol Rev2001; 81(3): 1305–1352.
30.
Von BékésyG. Experiments in hearing. Oxford, England: Mcgraw Hill, 1960, vol x, p. 745. (Experiments in hearing).
31.
KaleSSOlsonES. Intracochlear scala media pressure measurement: implications for models of cochlear mechanics. Biophys J2015; 109(12): 2678–2688.
32.
PetersonLCBogertBP. A dynamical theory of the cochlea. J Acoust Soc Am1950; 22(1_Supplement): 84.
33.
VossSERosowskiJJPeakeWT. Is the pressure difference between the oval and round windows the effective acoustic stimulus for the cochlea?J Acoust Soc Am1996; 100(3): 1602–1616.
34.
BöhnkeFvon Mikusch-BuchbergJArnoldW. Active nonlinear mechanics of the organ of Corti including the stereocilia-tectorial membrane complex. ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec1999; 61(5): 311–317.
35.
BohnkeFArnoldW. Nonlinear mechanics of the organ of Corti caused by Deiters cells. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng1998; 45(10): 1227–1233.
36.
KempDT. Stimulated acoustic emissions from within the human auditory system. J Acoust Soc Am1978; 64(5): 1386–1391.
37.
AreiasBParenteMPLGentilF, et al.A finite element model to predict the consequences of endolymphatic hydrops in the basilar membrane. Int J Numer Method Biomed Eng2022; 38(1): e3541.
38.
LeeSKoikeT. Simulation of the basilar membrane vibration of endolymphatic hydrops. Procedia IUTAM2017; 24: 64–71.
39.
OhYLimJChoYS, et al.Relationship between endolymphatic hydrops and symptoms of Meniere disease in acoustic hearing. ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec2021; 83(3): 172–180.
40.
ObristD. Flow phenomena in the inner ear. Annu Rev Fluid Mech2019; 51: 487–510.
41.
ObristDHegemannSKronenbergD, et al.In vitro model of a semicircular canal: design and validation of the model and its use for the study of canalithiasis. J Biomech2010; 43(6): 1208–1214.
42.
ShenSLiuYSunX, et al.A biomechanical model of the inner ear: numerical simulation of the caloric test. Sci World J2013; 2013: e160205.
43.
BoselliFObristDKleiserL. Vortical flow in the utricle and the ampulla: a computational study on the fluid dynamics of the vestibular system. Biomech Model Mechanobiol2013; 12(2): 335–348.
PaisalMSAWahabMTaibI, et al.Flow behaviour in normal and Meniere’s disease of endolymphatic fluid inside the inner ear. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng2017; 243: 012033.
46.
RabbittRDYamauchiAMBoyleR, et al.How endolymph pressure modulates semicircular canal primary afferent discharge. Ann N Y Acad Sci2001; 942: 313–321.
47.
Rey-MartinezJMcGarvieLPérez-FernándezN. Computing simulated endolymphatic flow thermodynamics during the caloric test using normal and hydropic duct models. Acta Otolaryngol2017; 137(3): 270–274.
48.
Rey-MartinezJAltunaXChengK, et al.Computing endolymph hydrodynamics during head impulse test on normal and hydropic vestibular labyrinth models. Front Neurol2020; 11: 289.
49.
ShamsuddinNMat IsaNTaibI, et al.Computational fluid dynamics simulation of pressure and velocity distribution inside Meniere’s diseased vestibular system. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng2017; 243: 012041.
50.
Soriano-ReixachMMRey-MartinezJAltunaX, et al.Enhanced eye velocity with backup saccades in vHIT tests of a Menière disease patient: a case report. Front Surg2021; 8: 727672.
51.
TsujiKVelázquez-VillaseñorVRauchS, et al.Temporal bone studies of the human peripheral vestibular system. Meniere’s disease. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol2000; 109(181): 26–31.
52.
ParkHJMigliaccioAADella SantinaCC, et al.Search-coil head-thrust and caloric tests in Ménière’s disease. Acta Otolaryngol2005; 125(8): 852–857.
53.
CurthoysISOmanCM. Dimensions of the horizontal semicircular duct, ampulla and utricle in the human. Acta Otolaryngol1987; 103(3–4): 254–261.
54.
McGarvieLACurthoysISMacDougallHG, et al.What does the dissociation between the results of video head impulse versus caloric testing reveal about the vestibular dysfunction in Ménière’s disease?Acta Otolaryngol2015; 135(9): 859–865.
55.
LeeCValenzuelaCGoodmanS, et al.Early detection of endolymphatic hydrops using the Auditory Nerve Overlapped Waveform (ANOW). Neuroscience2020; 425: 251–266.
56.
ValenzuelaCVLeeCMispagelA, et al.Is cochlear synapse loss an origin of low-frequency hearing loss associated with endolymphatic hydrops?Hear Res2020; 398: 108099.
57.
AlbersFWJDe GrootJCMJVeldmanJE, et al.Ultrastructure of the organ of Corti in experimental hydrops. Acta Otolaryngol1988; 105(3–4): 281–291.
58.
HornerKCGuilhaumeACazalsY. Atrophy of middle and short stereocilia on outer hair cells of Guinea pig cochleas with experimentally induced hydrops. Hear Res1988; 32(1): 41–48.
59.
ShinozakiNKimuraRS. Scanning electron microscopic observations on the distended Reissner’s and saccular membranes in the Guinea pig. Acta Otolaryngol1980; 90(5–6): 370–384.
60.
NadolJBAdamsJCKimJR. Degenerative changes in the organ of Corti and lateral cochlear wall in experimental endolymphatic hydrops and human Menière’s disease. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl1995; 519: 47–59.
61.
SaltANDeMottJ. Endolymph calcium increases with time after surgical induction of hydrops in Guinea-pigs. Hear Res1994; 74(1–2): 115–121.
62.
SziklaiIFerraryEHornerKC, et al.Time-related alteration of endolymph composition in an experimental model of endolymphatic hydrops. Laryngoscope1992; 102(4): 431–438.
63.
CianfroneGRalliGFabbricatoreM, et al.Distortion product otoacoustic emmissions in Ménière’s disease. Scand Audiol2000; 29(2): 111–119.
64.
AvanPGiraudetFChauveauB, et al.Unstable distortion-product otoacoustic emission phase in Menière’s disease. Hear Res2011; 277(1–2): 88–95.
65.
GaraycocheaOManrique-HuarteRCalaviaD, et al.Speech recognition during follow-up of patients with Ménière’s disease: what are we missing?J Int Adv Otol2022; 18(1): 14–19.
66.
ValenteMMispagelKValenteLM, et al.Problems and solutions for fitting amplification to patients with Ménière’s disease. J Am Acad Audiol2006; 17(1): 6–15.
67.
Di StadioARicciGRalliM, et al.Head-shaking nystagmus in the early stage of unilateral Meniere’s disease. J Int Adv Otol2019; 15(3): 425–430.
68.
ValliPBuizzaABottaL, et al.Convection, buoyancy or endolymph expansion: what is the actual mechanism responsible for the caloric response of semicircular canals?J Vestib Res2002 2003; 12(4): 155–165.
69.
ChoiJEKimYKChoYS, et al.Morphological correlation between caloric tests and vestibular hydrops in Ménière’s disease using intravenous Gd enhanced inner ear MRI. PLoS One2017; 12(11): e0188301.
70.
NiGElliottSJAyatM, et al.Modelling cochlear mechanics. BioMed Res Int2014; 2014: 150637.
71.
YamauchiARabbittRDBoyleR, et al.Relationship between inner-ear fluid pressure and semicircular canal afferent nerve discharge. J Assoc Res Otolaryngol2002; 3(1): 26–44.
72.
GoyensJPourquieMPoelmaC, et al.Asymmetric cupula displacement due to endolymph vortex in the human semicircular canal. Biomech Model Mechanobiol2019; 18: 1577–1590.
LiangJKeZWelchPV, et al.A comprehensive finite element model for studying Cochlear-Vestibular interaction. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Eng2022; 25(2): 204–214.
75.
BradshawJJBrownMAJiangS, et al.3D finite element model of human ear with 3-chamber spiral cochlea for blast wave transmission from the ear canal to cochlea. Ann Biomed Eng2023; 51(5): 1106–1118.
76.
De PaolisABiksonMNelsonJT, et al.Analytical and numerical modeling of the hearing system: advances towards the assessment of hearing damage. Hear Res2017; 349: 111–128.
77.
RenLJYuYFangYQ, et al.Finite element simulation of cochlear traveling wave under air and bone conduction hearing. Biomech Model Mechanobiol2021; 20(4): 1251–1265.
78.
EdomEObristDKleiserL. Simulation of fluid flow and basilar-membrane motion in a two-dimensional box model of the Cochlea. AIP Conf Proc2011; 1403: 608–610.
79.
EdomEObristDKleiserL. Steady streaming in a two-dimensional box model of a passive cochlea. J Fluid Mech2014; 753: 254–278.
80.
GerstenbergerCWolterFE. Numerical simulation of acoustic streaming within the cochlea. J Comput Acoust2013; 5: 21.
81.
NiGElliottSJBaumgartJ. Finite-element model of the active organ of Corti. J R Soc Interface2016; 13(115): 20150913.
82.
GlueckertRJohnson ChackoLSchmidbauerD, et al.Visualization of the membranous labyrinth and nerve fiber pathways in human and animal inner ears using MicroCT imaging. Front Neurosci2018; 31: 12.
83.
HvCLamyMBaumgartnerD, et al.3D finite element model of posterior membranous labyrinth from in vivo MRI of human temporal bone, including sensory zones. J Translat Sci2019; 5. DOI: 10.15761/JTS.1000307.
84.
WuCWangKYangL, et al.Three-dimensional models of the membranous vestibular labyrinth in the Guinea pig inner ear. In: 2011 4th international conference on biomedical engineering and informatics (BMEI), Shanghai, China, 15–17 October 2011, pp. 541–544.
85.
DjukicTFilipovicN. Numerical modeling of the cupular displacement and motion of otoconia particles in a semicircular canal. Biomech Model Mechanobiol2017; 16(5): 1669–1680.
86.
SantosCFBelinhaJGentilF, et al.A computational framework to simulate the endolymph flow due to vestibular rehabilitation maneuvers assessed from accelerometer data. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Eng2018; 21(6): 461–469.
87.
ShenSSunXYuS, et al.Numerical simulation of the role of the utriculo-endolymphatic valve in the rotation-sensing capabilities of semicircular canals. J Biomech2016; 49(9): 1532–1539.
88.
ShenSZhaoFChenZ, et al.Biomechanical analysis of angular motion in association with bilateral semicircular canal function. Biophys J2020; 118(3): 729–741.
89.
BarrettEBoeddinghausRThompsonA, et al.Delayed contrast MRI for the evaluation of Ménière’s disease: an Australian perspective. J Laryngol Otol2024; 25: 1–5.
90.
LiuYPyykköINaganawaS, et al.Consensus on MR imaging of endolymphatic hydrops in patients with suspected hydropic ear disease (Meniere). Front Surg2022; 9: 874971.
91.
OkadaTFujimotoKFushimiY, et al.Neuroimaging at 7 Tesla: a pictorial narrative review. Quant Imag Med Surg2022; 12(6): 3406–3435.
