Abstract
My essay focuses on the figure of the phantom in the work of phenomenologist Maurice Merleau-Ponty and the ethnographer Michel Leiris. I study their evocation of gestures as a site of communication and argue that within the colonial situation all communication—including the gestural—is ghosted by histories and cultural understandings that remain opaque.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alcoff
LM
(1999 ) “Towards a Phenomenology of Racial Embodiment.” Radical Philosophy . 95 (May/June) 1995. https://www.radicalphilosophy.com/article/towards-a-phenomenology-of-racial-embodiment (accessed 3 November 2023).
2.
Bhabha
H
(1984 ) Of Man and Mimicry: The Ambivalence of Colonial Discourse. October 28: 125–133 .
3.
Clifford
J
(1988 ) The Predicament of Culture: Twentieth-Century Ethnography, Literature, and Art . Cambridge : Harvard University Press .
4.
Clifford
J
Marcus
GE
(1986 ) Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography . Berkeley : University of California Press .
5.
Cooperrider
K
(2019 ) Universals and diversity in gesture . Gesture 18 (2/3 ): 209 –238 .
6.
Covington-Ward
Y
(2016 ) Gesture and Power: Religion, Nationalism, and Everyday Performance in the Congo . Durham and London : Duke University Press .
7.
Debaene
V
(2014 ) Far Afield: French Anthopology between Science and Literature. Trans. Justin Izzo . Chicago : University of Chicago Press . (Originally published as Adieu au voyage: l’ethnologie française entre science et littérature . Gallimard, 2010) .
8.
Derrida
J
(1994 ) Specters of Marx: The State of the Debt, The Work of Mourning and the New International. Trans. Peggy Kamuf . London : Routledge .
9.
Edwards
BH
(2019 ) Introduction to the English translation . In:
Leiris
M
(eds) Phantom Africa. Trans. Brent Hayes Edwards . Calcutta, London, New York : Seagull Books , 1–52.
10.
Effron
D
(1941 ) Gesture, Race and Culture: A Tentative Study of Some of the Spatio-Temporal and ‘Linguistic’ Aspects of The Gestural Behavior of Eastern Jews and Southern Italians in New York City, Living Under Similar as well as Different Environmental Conditions . New York : King’s Crown Press .
11.
Fanon
F
(1952 ) Peau noire, masques blancs . Paris : Seuil .
12.
Geertz
C
(1973 ) Thick description: Toward an interpretive Theory of Culture . In: The Interpretation of Cultures . New York : Basic Books , 3 –30 .
13.
Glissant
É
(1992 ) Michel Leiris: The Répli and the Dépli . Yale French Studies 81 (61 ): 21 –27 .
14.
Hollier
D
(2013 ) Chronologie . In:
Hollier
D
(eds) Michel Leiris, La Règle du jeu . Paris : Gallimard, Pléiade , XLXIX–CI.
15.
Hollier
D
(2014 ) Notice . In:
Hollier
D
Marmande
F
Maubon
C
(eds) L’Âge d’homme précédé de L’Afrique fantôme . Paris : Gallimard, Pléiade .
16.
Lee
ES
(2012 ) “Merleau-Ponty and Philosophy of Race” in Berfrois . https://www.berfrois.com/2012/10/emily-lee-maurice-merleau-ponty/ (accessed 3 November 2023).
17.
Leiris
M
(1939 ) Textes en langue secrète des Dogons de Sanga . Paris : Institut d’enthologie . Revised in 1948 .
18.
Leiris
M
(1950 ) L’Ethnographe devant le colonialisme . Les Temps modernes 58 : 357 –374 .
19.
Leiris
M
(1955 ) Contacts de civilisations en Martinique et Guadeloupe . Paris : Gallimard .
20.
Leiris
M
(1958 ) La Possession et ses aspects théâtraux chez les Éthiopiens de Gondar . Paris : Plon . Reprinted by Gallimard in 1996 .
21.
Leiris
M
(1989 ) The ethnographer faced with colonialism . In: Brisées: Broken Branches. Trans. Lydia Davis. San Francisco : North Point Press , 112 –131 .
22.
Leiris
M
(1996 )
L’Afrique fantôme
. In:
Jamin
J
(eds) Michel Leiris, Miroirs de l’Afrique . Paris : Gallimard , 61–868.
23.
Leiris
M
(2014 ) Prière d’insérer de l’édition originale 1934 . In:
Hollier
D
Marmande
F
Maubon
C
(eds) L’Âge d’homme précédé de L’Afrique fantôme . Paris : Gallimard, Pléiade , 747 –748 .
24.
Leiris
M
(2019 ) Phantom Africa. Trans. Brent Hayes Edwards . Calcutta, London, New York : Seagull Books .
25.
Leiris
M
(1935 ) “L’Abyssine intime” in Cahiers Dakar-Djibouti ; 43–47 .
26.
Leiris
M
Griaule
M
(2015 ) Instructions sommaires pour les collecteurs d’objets ethnographiques . In:
Jolly
É
Lemaire
M
(eds) Cahier Dakar-Djibouti . Paris : Les Cahiers .
27.
Low
D
(2019 ) Merleau-Ponty on Race, Gender and Anti-Semitism . International Philosophical Quarterly 59 (3 ): 257 –275 .
28.
Mercier
J
(2003 ) Les Traverses Éthiopiennes de Michel Leiris: Amour, Possession, Ethnographie . Montpellier : L’Archange Minotaure .
29.
Merleau-Ponty
M
(1945 ) Phénoménologie de la perception . Paris : Gallimard .
30.
Merleau-Ponty
M
(1997 ) Les Relations avec l’autrui chez l’enfant . In: Parcours 1935–1951 . Paris : Verdier , 147 –229 .
31.
Merleau-Ponty
M
(2010 ) Interview avec Georges Charbonnier, 31 July 1959 . In:
Lefort
C
(eds) Oeuvres . Paris : Gallimard , 84.
32.
Merleau-Ponty
M
(2012 ) Phenomenology of Perception. Trans. Donald A. Landes . London and New York : Routledge .
33.
Moten
F
(2018a ) Gestural critique of judgment . In: Stolen Life . Durham and London : Duke University Press , 96–114.
34.
Moten
F
(2018b ) There is no racism intended . In: The Universal Machine . Durham and London : Duke University Press , 1–64.
35.
Noland
C
(2009 ) Agency and Embodiment: Performing Gestures, Producing Culture . Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard University Press .
36.
Schneider
R
(2017 ) In our hands: An ethics of gestural response-ability . Performance Philosophy 3 (1 ): 108 –125 .
37.
Véron
K
(2021 ) Aimé Césaire . Paris : Seuil .