This article analyses the use of coercive measures in two national institutions for high-security psychiatry in Norway – Kriminalasylet (Criminal Asylum) and Reitgjerdet – during the period 1895–1978. Historical study of coercion in psychiatry is a fruitful approach to new insight into the moral and ethical considerations within the institutions. We approach the topic through a qualitative study of patient case files and ward reports from the institutions’ archives, as well as a comprehensive quantification of the coercive measures used. The data show shifting considerations of humane treatment and changes in the respect for human dignity in the institutions’ practices. They also show that technological developments, such as the introduction of new psychopharmaceuticals, did not necessarily lead to higher standards of treatment.
AllisonLMoncrieffJ (2014) ‘Rapid tranquillisation’: an historical perspective on its emergence in the context of the development of antipsychotic medications. History of Psychiatry25(1): 57–69.
BjørhovdeV (1988) Presteseter sykehus 75 år: Et psykiatrisk sykehus i utvikling 1913–1988 [Presteseter Hospital 75 Years: A Psychiatric Hospital in Development 1913–1988]. Reinsvoll: Sykehuset.
BlombergW (2002) Galskapens hus: Utskilling og internering i Norge 1550–1850 [House of Madness: Segregation and Internment]. Oslo: Universitetsforl; doi: 10.1177/0957154X05052223
6.
BlombergW (2005) Some traits of Norwegian pre-medical social reactions to madness. History of Psychiatry16(1): 99–105.
7.
BraslowJT (1997) Mental Ills and Bodily Cures: Psychiatric Treatment in the First Half of the Twentieth Century. Berkeley: University of California Press.
8.
BrooksKLMulaikJSGileadMP, et al. (1994) Patient overcrowding in psychiatric hospital units: effects on seclusion and restraint. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research22: 133–144.
9.
DahlH (2017) ‘Insane criminals’ and the ‘criminally insane’: criminal asylums in Norway, 1895–1940. History of Psychiatry28(2): 209–224.
10.
EvensenH (1921) Haandbok i sindssykepleie [Handbook of Insanity Care]. Kristiania: H. Aschehoug & Co.
11.
EvensenSAGradmannCLarsenØ (2010) Nedleggelsen av Reitgjerdet sykehus [The closure of Reitgjerdet]. Michael Quarterly7: 371–530.
12.
FoucaultM (2006) Psychiatric Power: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1973–74, trans. BurchellG. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan; originally published in French in 2003.
13.
FygleS (2002) Marmor og menneskeskjebner: Rønvik sykehus i det 20. århundre [Marble and Human Fates: Rønvik Hospital in the 20th century]. Bodø: Nordlandssykehuset Bodø psykiatri.
14.
GoffmanE (1961) Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. London: Penguin.
15.
HaaveP (2008) Ambisjon og handling: Sanderud sykehus og norsk psykiatri i et historisk perspektiv [Ambition and Action: Sanderud Hospital and Norwegian Psychiatry in a Historical Perspective]. Oslo: Unipub.
16.
JacobsenJM (1965) Personlighetsvernet for pasienten i det psykiatriske sykehus [The Patient’s Statutory Protection in the Psychiatric Hospital]. Lov og rett: Norsk juridisk tidsskrift: 110–116.
17.
KringlenE (2004) A history of Norwegian psychiatry. History of Psychiatry15(3): 259–283.
18.
KringlenE (2012) History of Norwegian psychiatry. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry66: 31–41.
19.
LudvigsenKSeipÅA (2009) The establishing of Norwegian child psychiatry: ideas, pioneers and institutions. History of Psychiatry20(1): 5–26.
20.
MyhreEThomassenØ (2014) The construction of an accepted masculinity: castration in high security psychiatric institutions in Norway 1923–1945. In: LanderI (ed.) Masculinities in the Criminological Field: Control, Vulnerability and Risk-Taking. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing.
Norges offisielle statistikk [Norway’s Official Statistics] (NOS) (1895 to 1969) Sinnssykehusenes virksomhet/Psykiatriske sykehus [The Mental Hospitals’ Activity/Psychiatric Hospitals]. Published by Medisinaldirektøren [the Medical Director] up to 1930, and by Statistisk sentralbyrå [Central Bureau of Statistics] after 1935.
23.
ØgaardIMS (2015) Opprettelsen av Reitgjerdet asyl i 1923 [The Establishing of Reitgjerdet Asylum in 1923]. Master’s thesis, Department of Historical Studies Trondheim: NTNU; accessed (10 July 2019) at: https://ntnuopen.ntnu.no/ntnu-xmlui/handle/11250/299532
24.
ØienVJ (2016) Tvang i norsk sikkerhetspsykiatri: En studie av Kriminalasylet i Trondheim 1895–1915 [Coercion in Norwegian High Security Psychiatry: A Study of Kriminalasylet in Trondheim 1895–1915]. Master’s thesis, Department of Historical Studies. Trondheim: NTNU; accessed (10 July 2019) at: https://ntnuopen.ntnu.no/ntnu-xmlui/handle/11250/2388031
25.
RabbenMBThomassenØ (2019) Humanitet, kontroll og tvang ved Kriminalasylet 1895–1915 [Control, coercion and humane treatment at Kriminalasylet 1895–1915]. Historisk tidsskrift98(1): 68–86.
26.
RiaunetÅ (2014) Oppdrag, pasienter og praksiser – Kriminalasylet i Trondheim 1895–1905 [Assignment, Patients and Practices – Kriminalasylet in Trondheim 1895–1905]. Master’s thesis, Department of Interdisciplinary Studies of Culture. Trondheim: NTNU; accessed (10 July 2019) at: https://docplayer.me/23583898-Oppdrag-pasienter-og-praksiser.html
27.
ScullA (2015) Madness in Civilization: A Cultural History of Insanity, from the Bible to Freud, from the Madhouse to Modern Medicine. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
28.
SkålevågSA (2002) Constructing curative instruments: psychiatric architecture in Norway, 1820–1920. History of Psychiatry13(1): 51–68.
29.
SolbergS (1979) Rapport fra Reitgjerdet [Report from Reitgjerdet]. Oslo: Pax.
30.
SøndenaaEGuddeCThomassenØ (2015) Patients with intellectual disabilities in the forensic asylums 1915–1982: before admission. Scandinavian Journal of Disability Research17: 14–25.
31.
SzaszT (2007) Coercion as Cure: A Critical History of Psychiatry. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
32.
ThomassenØ (2010) Diagnosing the criminal insane in Norway 1895–1915. In: AndresenAHubbarbWHRyyminT (eds) International and Local Approaches to Health and Health Care. Oslo: Novus Press, 79–98.
33.
TjelmelandS (2010) I det trygge huset – Valen sjukehus gjennom hundre år [In the Safe House – Valen Hospital through 100 years]. Haugesund: Valen sjukehus.
34.
TranøyJBlombergW (2005) Lobotomy in Norwegian psychiatry. History of Psychiatry16(1): 107–110.
