The second part of this paper1 explores deepening doubts about pyromania as a special insanity, British debates post-1890, and pyromania’s supplanting with the broader diagnostic category of insane incendiarism. It assesses the conceptual importance of revenge and morbid-motivations for arson, and the relationship of Victorian and Edwardian concepts of arson to more modern psychiatric research. The main objective is to ascertain the extent to which Victorian and Edwardian medico-psychologists and medical legists arrived at meaningful and workable definitions of criminal insanity linked to arson. It concludes by emphasizing the limitations, contentiousness and inconsistencies in the use of technical terms such as ‘pyromania’, contrasted with the qualified success of authorities in arriving at more viable and broadly acceptable explanations of insane firesetting.
Anonymous (1861) British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review26 (Apr.): 223
3.
Baker JL ( 1889) Cases of incendiarism with commentary. Journal of Mental Science35 (149): 45-54.
4.
Baker JL ( 1892a) Pyromania. In Tuke DH, A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, 2 vols. London: J. & A. Churchill , Vol. I: 1056-1059.
5.
Baker JL ( 1892b) Kleptomania. In Tuke DH, A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, 2 vols. London: J. & A. Churchill , Vol. I: 726-728
6.
Baker J. ( 1892c) Some points connected with criminals. Journal of Mental Science38 (162): 364-369.
7.
Baker J. ( 1903) General paralysis and crime. Journal of Mental Science50: 438-439.
8.
Browne JHB ( 1871) The Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity. London: Churchill; also 2nd edn: The Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity: With References to the Scotch and American Decisions. San Francisco: Sumner, Whitney & Co., 1875.
9.
Casper JL ( 1846) On the hobgoblin called the morbid impulse to firesetting . In: Casper JL Denkwűrdigkeiten zur Medicinischen Statistik und Staatsarzneikunde für Criminalisten und Aerzte. Berlin: Duncker and Humblot, 257-392.
10.
Casper JL ( 1864) A Handbook of the Practice of Forensic Medicine Based Upon Personal Experience, translated by GW Balfour from 3rd edn of Practisches Handbuch der gerichtlichen Medicin nach Eigenen Erfahrungen Bearbeite [Berlin: A. Hirschwald, 1857-8], 4 vols, London: The New Sydenham Society [ 1861-5], Vol. 4: 184-185, 311-315.
11.
Chapman HC ( 1892) A Manual of Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology . Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders .
East WN ( 1946) The legal aspects of psychiatry: crime and punishment . Journal of Mental Science92: 682-712.
14.
Everts O. ( 1887) Are dipsomania, kleptomania, pyromania, etc., valid forms of mental disease?American Journal of Insanity44: 52-59.
15.
Fowler R. ( 1875) The Medical Vocabulary Containing a Concise Explanation of the Terms Used in Medicine and its Accessory Sciences, 2nd edn. London: Henry Renshaw [1st edn 1860].
16.
Goldwyn J. ( 1930) Impulses to incendiarism and theft. American Journal of Psychiatry86 (6): 1093-1099.
17.
Griesinger W. ( 1867) Mental Pathology and Therapeutics, translated by CL Robinson and J Rutherford from 2nd German edn. [1861]. London: New Sydenham Society.
18.
Hammond WA ( 1883) Treatise on Insanity and its Medical Relations . New York: D. Appleton & Co.
Jessen PW ( 1860) Die Brandstiftungen in Affecten und Geistesstörungen: ein Beitrag zur Gerichtlichen Medicin für Juristen und Aerzte. Kiel: Ernst Homann.
21.
Jessen PW ( 1861-62) Incendiarism in Mental Affections and Diseases: A Contribution to Legal Medicine, for Jurists and Physicians, reviewed in: American Journal of Insanity1861, 18: 61-70, 163-182; 1862, 18: 286-305, 434-453.
22.
Kraepelin E. ( 1902) Clinical Psychiatry: A Text-book for Students and Physicians, translated by AR Defendorf from 6th German edn [1899]. New York and London: Macmillan .
23.
Kraepelin E. ( 1904) Lectures on Clinical Psychiatry, edited by T Johnstone. London: Baillière, Tindall and Cox.
24.
Leroy R. ( 1904) Pyromania, a psychosis of puberty. Archives de Neurologie, précised in Lancet (1) 583-584 ( 1905).
25.
Marc CCH ( 1833) Considerations medico-legales sur la monomania et particulièrement sur la monomania incendiaire. Annales d’Hygiene Publique10: 357-473.
26.
Maudsley H. ( 1874) Responsibility in Mental Diseases. London: King; also 2nd (US) edn, New York: Appleton & Co., 1899.
27.
Mayne RG ( 1860) An Expository Lexicon of the Terms, Ancient and Modern , in Medical and General Science. London : J. Churchill.
28.
Mayne RG ( 1889) Mayne’s Medical Vocabulary, Being an Explanation of All Terms and Phrases Used in the Various Departments of Medical Science and Practice, 6th edn, revised by WW Wagstaffe. London: Churchill.
29.
Nicolson D. ( 1895a) Presidential address. Journal of Mental Science41 (175): 567-587.
30.
Nicolson D. ( 1895b) Discussion on the President’s address. Journal of Mental Science41 (175): 587-591.
31.
North JW ( 1886) Insanity and crime. Journal of Mental Science32 (133): 163-181.
32.
Pilgrim CW ( 1885) Pyromania (so-called), with report of a case. American Journal of Insanity41: 456-465.
33.
Pitt-Lewis G., Smith RP and Hawke JA ( 1895) The Insane and the Law: A Plain Guide for Medical Men, Solicitors and Others. London: Churchill, and Sweet & Maxwell.
34.
Quain R (1890) (ed.) A Dictionary of Medicine, 2 vols. London : Longmans, Green & Co.
35.
Ray I. ( 1853) A Treatise on the Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity, 3rd (US) edn. Boston: Little, Brown & Co.; first published in1838.
36.
Rousseau E-E. ( 1881) Contribution à l’étude de la monomanie incendiaire. Annales Mèdico-psychologiques39: 384-399.
37.
Sutherland JF ( 1907) Recidivism regarded from the environmental and psychopathological standpoints. Journal of Mental Science53: 568-590.
38.
Sydenham Society (1899) Sydenham Society’s Lexicon of Medicine and the Allied Sciences (Based on Mayne’s Lexicon), 5 vols. London: The New Sydenham Society.
39.
Taylor AS ( 1856) Medical Jurisprudence, 4th (US) edn (from 5th British edn). Philadephia: King & Baird Printers.
40.
Young HTP ( 1925) Incendiarism in adult males. Lancet (1): 1334-6.
41.
(b) Secondary sources
42.
Abelson ES ( 1989) The invention of kleptomania. Signs15: 123-143.
43.
APA (2004) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Association.
44.
Barker AF ( 1994) Arson: A Review of the Psychiatric Literature. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
45.
Barnett W. ( 2005) Psychiatrie der Brandstiftung: Eine psychopathologische Studie anhand von Gutachten. Darmstadt: Steinkopff.
46.
Cleman J. ( 1991) Irresistible impulses: Edgar Allan Poe and the insanity defense. American Literature63 (4): 623-640.
47.
Eigen JP ( 1991) Mad-doctors in the dock: forensic psychiatry’s early claims to expert knowledge. Transactions and Studies of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia5 (13): 445-462.
48.
Eigen JP ( 1995) Witnessing Insanity. Madness and Mad-Doctors in the English Court. New Haven, CT, and London : Yale University Press.
49.
Faulk M. ( 1982) Assessing dangerousness in arsonists. In: Hamilton JR and Freeman H (eds) Dangerousness: Psychiatric Assessment and Management . London: Gaskell, 73-76.
50.
Finkel NJ ( 2007) Insanity’s disconnect: the law’s madness, and the irresistible impulses of experts. In: Costanzo M, Krauss D and Pezdek K (eds) Expert Psychological Testimony for the Courts. Mahwah, NJ, and London: Erlbaum, 177-202.
51.
Gaynor J. and Hatcher G. ( 1987) The Psychology of Child Firesetting: Detection and Intervention . New York: Brunner/Mazel .
52.
Geller JL ( 1992) Pathological firesetting in adults. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry15 (3): 283-302.
53.
Geller JL, Erlen J. and Pinkus RL ( 1986) A historical appraisal of America’s experience with ‘pyromania’ - a diagnosis in search of a disorder. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry9 (2): 201-229.
54.
Grant JE ( 2008) Impulse Control Disorders: A Clinician’s Guide to Understanding and Treating Behavioral Addictions. New York : W.W. Grant & Co.
55.
Guillais J. ( 1991) Crimes of Passion: Dramas of Private Life in Nineteenth-Century France. New York: Routledge, translation from 1895 French edn.
56.
Hales RE, Yudofsky SC and Gabbard GO (eds) ( 2008) The American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Psychiatry , 5th edn. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc.
57.
Harris R. ( 1988) Melodrama, hysteria and feminine crimes of passion in the fin-de-siècle. History Workshop25: 31-63.
58.
Harris R. ( 1989) Murder and Madness: Medicine, Law, and Society in the fin de siècle. Oxford: Clarendon Press;New York : Oxford University Press.
59.
Hegerl U. ( 2004) Whether pyromaniac, kleptomaniac, pathological gambler or messy - the impulse is out of control. MMW Fortschritte der Medizin146 (45): 33-34.
60.
Hollander E and Stein DJ (eds) (2005) Clinical Manual of Impulse-Control Disorders. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association; London: Eurospan.
61.
Hollweg M. ( 1994) Arson - a disorder of impulse control? Gesundheitswesen56 (6): 330-334.
62.
House of Lords (2003) Opinions of the Lords of Appeal for judgement in the cause Regina v. G and another (appellants). 16 Oct.; accessed (12 Nov. 2009) at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200203/ldjudgmt/jd031016/g-2.htm .
63.
Jacobson RR ( 1985a) The subclassification of child firesetters. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry26 (5): 769-775.
64.
Jacobson RR ( 1985b) Child firesetters: a clinical investigation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry26 (5): 759-768.
65.
Kolko DJ and Kazdin AE ( 1991) Motives of childhood firesetters: firesetting characteristics and psychological correlates. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry32 (3): 535-550.
66.
Lewis NDC and Yarnell H. ( 1951) Pathological Fire-setting (Pyromania). New York: Coolidge Foundation.
67.
Lieberman L. ( 1999) Crimes of reason, crimes of passion: Suicide and the adulterous woman in nineteenth-century France. Journal of Family Hisory . 24 (2): 131-47.
68.
Lindberg N., Holi MM, Tani P. and Virkkunen M. ( 2005) Looking for pyromania: characteristics of a consecutive sample of Finnish male criminals with histories of recidivist fire-setting between 1973 and 1993. BMC Psychiatry5: 47; accessed (12 June 2008) at: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov .
69.
Mavromatis M. ( 2000) Serial arson: repetitive firesetting and pyromania . In: Schlesinger LB (ed.) Serial Offenders: Current Thought, Recent Findings. London : CRC Press, 67-102.
70.
McElroy SL, Hudson JI, Phillips KA, Keck PE Jr and Pope HG Jr ( 1993) Clinical and theoretical implications of a possible link between obsessive-compulsive and impulse control disorders. Depression1 (3): 121-132.
71.
Moore DP and Jefferson JJ ( 2004) Handbook of Medical Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Philadelphia: Elsevier Mosby .
72.
Prins H. ( 1994) Fire-Raising: Its Motivation and Management. London and New York: Routledge .
73.
Puri BK, Baxter R. and Cordess CC ( 1995) Characteristics of fire-setters. A study and proposed multiaxial psychiatric classification. British Journal of Psychology166: 393-396.
74.
Scottish Law Commission (2003) Discussion Paper No. 122. Insanity and diminished responsibility; accessed (15 Nov. 2008) at: http://www.scotlawcom.gov.uk/downloads/dp122_insanity.pdf .
75.
Smith R. ( 1981a) Trial by Medicine. Insanity and Responsibility in Victorian Trials. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
76.
Smith R. ( 1981b) The boundary between insanity and criminal responsibility in nineteenth-century England. In: Scull AT (ed.) Madhouses, Mad-doctors, and Madmen: The Social History of Psychiatry in the Victorian Era. London: Athlone Press, 363-384.
77.
Smith R. ( 1988a) Criminal Responsibility, Psychiatry and History: Three Essays, 2nd edn. Lancaster : Centre for Science Studies & Science Policy ; Paris : Cité des Sciences et de l’Industrie .
78.
Smith R. ( 1988b) The Victorian controversy about the insanity defence . Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine81: 70-73.
79.
Smith R. ( 1988c) Brain science and insanity in Victorian murder trials . Medical Historian1: 39-48.
80.
Stewart LA ( 1993) Profile of female firesetters. Implications for treatment . British Journal of Psychology163: 248-256.
81.
Wachi T. et al. (2007) Offender and crime characteristics of female serial arsonists in Japan. Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling4 (1): 29-52.
82.
Weiner MJ ( 1999) Judges v. jurors: courtroom tensions in murder trials and the law of criminal responsibility in nineteenth-century England . Law and History Review17 (3): 467-506.
83.
Weiner MJ ( 2004) Men of Blood. Violence, Manliness and Criminal Justice in Victorian England. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
84.
White S. ( 1985) The insanity defence in England and Wales since 1843. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science477 (1): 43-57.
85.
Whitlock T. ( 1999) Gender, medicine, and consumer culture in Victorian England: creating the kleptomaniac. Albion31: 413-437.
86.
Williams J. ( 2002) Pyromania, Kleptomania, and Other Impulse-Control Disorders . Berkeley Heights, NJ, and Aldershot : Enslow.
87.
Wooden W. and Berkey ML ( 1984) Children and Arson: America’s Middle Class Nightmare . New York: Plenum.
88.
Young HTP ( 1925) Incendiarism in adult males. Lancet (1): 1334-1336.
