This article surveys evolving and competing medico-legal concepts of pyromania and insane arson. Exploiting evidence from medical jurisprudence, medico-legal publications, medical lexicography and case histories, it seeks to explicate the key positions in contemporary professional debates concerning arson and mental derangement. A major focus is the application of the doctrines of moral and partial insanity, monomania, instinctive insanity and irresistible impulse to understandings of pyromania and insane arson. The limited extent to which mental defect provided a satisfactory diagnosis and exculpatory plea for morbid arson is also explored. Additionally, this article compares and contrasts contemporary debates about other special manias, especially kleptomania. Part 2 will be published in the next issue, History of Psychiatry 21(4).
Annual Register … for 1829. London: Baldwin and Craddock, 1830, 301-306.
2.
Anonymous (n.d.) Trial, Confession, and Execution of C.T. White, for Arson ... at the Old Bailey, the Horrible and Appalling Spectacle Witnessed on the Fatal Gallows [broadside]. In: Hindley C, Curiosities of Street Literature . London: Reeves and Turner, 1871, 21, 186-189.
3.
Anonymous (1861) review of Jessen, Die Brandstiftungen, 1860. British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review47 (April): 446.
4.
Baker JL ( 1889) Cases of incendiarism with commentary. Journal of Mental Science35 (149): 45-54.
5.
Baker JL ( 1892) Pyromania. In: Tuke DH, A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, 2 vols. London: Churchill, Vol. I: 1056-1059.
6.
Beck TR and Beck JB ( 1842) Elements of Medical Jurisprudence, 7th edn. London: Longman, Brown, Green, and Longman.
7.
Brown A. ( 1844-6) Reports of Cases before the High Court and Circuit Courts of Justiciary in Scotland … During the Years 1842-45, 2 vols. T. Clark: Edinburgh.
8.
Browne JHB ( 1871) The Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity. London: Churchill, 148-153.
9.
Browne JHB ( 1875 and 1876) The Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity, with References to the Scotch and American Decisions. 2nd US ed., San Francisco: Sumner Whitney and Co., and Philadelphia: Lindsay and Blakiston, 332-337.
10.
Casper JL ( 1846) On the hobgoblin called the morbid impulse to firesetting . In: Denkwűrdigkeiten zur Medicinischen Statistik und Staatsarzneikunde für Criminalisten und Aerzte. Berlin : Duncker and Humblot, 257-392.
11.
Casper JL ( 1864) A Handbook of the Practice of Forensic Medicine Based Upon Personal Experience, Vol. IV. London: The New Sydenham Society; published in 4 vols ( 1861- 1865), translated by GW Balfour from Practisches Handbuch der gerichtlichen Medicin nach Eigenen Erfahrungen Bearbeite, 3rd edn. Berlin: A. Hirschwald, 1860, originally published 1857 -1858.
12.
Conolly J. ( 1830) An Inquiry Concerning Indications of Insanity with Suggestions for the Better Protection and Care of the Insane. London ; facsimile reprint, London: Dawsons, 1964.
13.
Crichton-Browne J. ( 1860) Psychical diseases of early life. Journal of Mental Science6 (33): 284-320.
14.
Dunglison R. ( 1842) A New Dictionary of Medical Science, Containing a Concise Account of the Various Subjects and Terms, 3rd edn. Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard .
15.
Dunglison R. ( 1848) Medical Lexicon. A Dictionary of Medical Science , 7th edn. Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard.
16.
Esquirol JED ( 1845) Mental Maladies. A Treatise on Insanity. Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard.
17.
Feuchtersleben E von ( 1847) The Principles of Medical Psychology: Being the Outlines of a Course of Lectures by Baron Ernst von Feuchtersleben, M.D. Vienna, translated by H Evans Lloyd, rev. and ed. by BG Babington.London: Printed for the Sydenham Society, C. and J. Adlard; originally published in German, Vienna, 1845.
18.
Georget E-J. ( 1826) Discussion Medico-legale sur la Folie: ou Alienation Mentale . Paris: Migneret.
19.
Griesinger W. ( 1867) Mental Pathology and Therapeutics. London: New Sydenham Society; translated by CL Robinson and J Rutherford from 2nd German edn, 1861.
20.
Gross HGA ( 1911) Criminal Psychology: A Manual for Judges, Practitioners, and Students, translated by HM Kallen from 4th German edn. Montclair, NJ: Patterson Smith Reprint, 1998; retrieved (12 Oct. 2008) from: http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/etext98/crmsy10.txt .
21.
Harris CA ( 1855) A Dictionary of Medical Terminology, Dental Surgery, and the Collateral Sciences, 2nd edn. Philadelphia: Lindsay and Blakiston.
22.
Henke ACH ( 1817) Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der gerichtlichen Medicin: als Erläuterungen zu dem Lehrbuche der gerichtlichen Medicin . Leipzig: Brockhaus.
23.
Hoblyn RD ( 1892) A Dictionary of Terms Used in Medicine and the Collateral Sciences, rev. and enlarged by JAP Price. London : Whittaker and Co; previous edns: 1835, 1858, 1871.
24.
Hooper R. ( 1798) A Compendius Medical Dictionary. London : printed for Murray and Highley.
25.
Hooper R (ed.) (1811) Quincy’s Lexicon-Medicum. A New Medical Dictionary. London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Co.
26.
Hooper R (1820) Lexicon-Medicum; or Medical Dictionary, 4th edn. London; Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme and Co.; 6th edn, London: Longman, Orme and Co., 1839; 7th edn revised and enlarged by Klein Grant, London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, 1848.
27.
Jessen PW ( 1860) Die Brandstiftungen in Affecten und Geistesstörungen: ein Beitrag zur Gerichtlichen Medicin für Juristen und Aerzte. Kiel: Ernst Homann.
28.
Jessen PW ( 1861-2) Incendiarism in Mental Affections and Diseases: A Contribution to Legal Medicine, for Jurists and Physicians, review in: American Journal of Insanity1861, 18: 61-70, 163-182; 1862, 18: 286-305, 434-453.
29.
King W.(1833) Influence of medical evidence on a question of criminal responsibility. Letter dated 2 April. The London Medical Gazette12: 80.
30.
Leroy R. ( 1904) Pyromania, a psychosis of puberty. Archives de Neurologie; précis in Lancet1905: 583-584.
31.
MacPhail HD ( 1911) A case of moral insanity with pyromania. Journal of Mental Science57: 124-126.
32.
Marc CCH ( 1833) Considerations medico-legales sur la monomania et particulièrement sur la monomania incendiaire. Annales d’Hygiene Publique10: 357-473.
33.
Marshall A. ( 1815) The Morbid Anatomy of the Brain, in Mania and Hydrophobia; with the Pathology of these two Diseases as Collected from the Papers of the late Andrew Marshall MD. London: Longman and Co.
34.
Masius GH ( 1822) Handbuch der Gerichtlichen Arzneiwissenschaft: Zum Gebrauche für Gerichtliche Ärzte und Rechtsgelehrte. Stendal : Franzen and Grosse.
35.
Matthey A. ( 1816) Nouvelles recherches sur les maladies de l’esprit . Paris and Geneva: Paschoud.
36.
Mayo T. ( 1834) An Essay on the Relation of the Theory of Morals to Insanity . London: Fellowes .
37.
Meckel AA ( 1820) Beiträge zur gerichtlichen Psychologie. Halle: Carl Friedrich Schimmelpfennig .
38.
Mercier C. ( 1911) Crime and Insanity. London: Williams and Norgate; New York: Henry Holt and Co.; Toronto: W.M. Briggs; India: R. and T. Washbourne Ltd.
39.
Nasse CF ( 1818-22) (ed.) Zeitschrift für Psychische Aerzte[journal published in Leipzig].
40.
Neumann H. ( 1859) Lehrbuch der Psychiatrie. Erlangen : Enke.
41.
Parigot J. ( 1862) On moral insanity in relation to criminal acts. Précis and remarks on. American Journal of Insanity18 (3): 404-421.
42.
Pilgrim C. ( 1885) ‘Pyromania (so-called) with report of a case . American Journal of Insanity41: 456-465.
43.
Platner E. ( 1797-1807) Ernestus Platnerus,... Panegyrin medicam... concelebrandam indicit. Quaestiones medicinae forensis. Leipzig: Klaubarth.
44.
Platner E. ( 1801) Ernestus Platnerus Universitatis Litterarum Lipsiensis…Procancellarius panegyrin medicam ... concelebrandam indicit. Quæstiones medicinæ forensis. XIII. De judiciis medicorum publicorum observatio alia quaedam. Leipzig: Klaubarth.
45.
Platner E. ( 1824) Quæstiones Medicinae Forensis: Medicinae Studium et October Semestribus Descriptum: Accedit Effigies. Leipzig : L. Voss.
46.
Prichard JC ( 1833) Insanity. In: Forbes J , Tweedie A and Conolly J (eds) The Cyclopædia of Practical Medicine, 4 vols. London: Sherwood et al., II: 824-874.
47.
Prichard JC ( 1835) A Treatise on Insanity and Other Disorders Affecting the Mind. London: Sherwood, Gilbert, and Piper.
48.
Prichard JC ( 1842) On the Different Forms of Insanity, in Relation to Jurisprudence . London: Baillière .
49.
Ray I. ( 1838) A Treatise on the Medical Juriprudence of Insanity . Boston: Thomas & Brown.
50.
Ray I. ( 1839) A Treatise on the Medical Juriprudence of Insanity, 1st British edn. London: G. Henderson .
51.
Ray I. ( 1844) A Treatise on the Medical Juriprudence of Insanity , 2nd US edn. Boston: Ticknor.
52.
Ray I. ( 1853) A Treatise on the Medical Juriprudence of Insanity, 3rd US edn. Boston: Little, Brown & Co.
53.
Ray I. ( 1861) An examination of the objections to the doctrine of moral insanityAmerican Journal of Insanity18 (2): 112-138.
54.
Savage GH ( 1881) Moral insanity. Journal of Mental Science27: 147-155.
55.
Taylor AS ( 1856) Medical Jurisprudence, 4th US edn. Philadephia: King and Baird Printers ; from 5th improved edn, London: Churchill; also 6th edn, 1858 ; 7th edn, 1861.
56.
Taylor AS ( 1865) The Principles and Practice of Medical Jurisprudence, Vol. I. London: Churchill; also 2nd edn, 1873; 3rd edn, ed. by T Stevenson, 1883; 4th ed., 1894.
57.
Vogel SG ( 1825) Ein Beitrag zur Gerichtsärztlichen Lehere von der Zurechnungsfähigkeit. Stendal: Franzen and Grosse.
58.
Abbiateci A. ( 1978) Arsonists in eighteenth-century France: an essay on the typology of crime. In: Forster R and Ranum O (eds) Deviants and the Abandoned in French Society (translated from the French by E Forster and PM Ranum), Vol. 4. Baltimore and London. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 157-179.
59.
Abelson ES ( 1989) The invention of kleptomania. Signs15: 123-143.
60.
Archer JE ( 1982) The Wells-Charlesworth debate: a personal comment on arson in Norfolk and Suffolk. Journal of Peasant Studies9 (4): 277-284.
61.
Archer JE ( 1990) ‘By a Flash and a Scare’: Arson, Animal Maiming and Poaching in East Anglia, 1815- 1870. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
62.
Augstein HF ( 1999) James Cowles Prichard’s Anthropology. Remaking the Science of Man in Early Nineteenth Century Britain. Amsterdam and Atlanta, GA: Rodopi.
63.
Balston T. ( 1945) The Life of Jonathan Martin…with some Account of William and Richard Martin. London: Macmillan.
64.
Barker AF ( 1994) Arson. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
65.
Barnett W. ( 2005) Psychiatrie der Brandstiftung: Eine psychopathologische Studie anhand von Gutachten. Darmstadt: Steinkopff.
66.
Bartlett P. ( 2001) Legal madness in the nineteenth century. Social History of Medicine14: 107-131.
67.
Becker P. ( 2005) Criminological language and prose from the late eighteenth to the early twentieth centuries. In: Srebnick AG and Lévy R (eds) Crime and Culture. An Historical Perspective. Aldershot : Ashgate, 23-36.
68.
Camhi L. ( 1993) Stealing femininity: department store kleptomania as sexual disorder. Differences5: 26-
69.
Colaizzi J. ( 1989) Homicidal Insanity, 1800-1985. Alabama : University of Alabama Press.
70.
Davie N. ( 2003) Criminal man revisited? Continuity and change in British criminology, c.1865-1918Journal of Victorian Culture8 (1): 1-32.
71.
Davie N. ( 2005) Tracing the Criminal: The Rise of Scientific Criminology in Britain, 1860-1918. Oxford: Bardwell Press.
72.
Eigen JP ( 1985) Intentionality and insanity: what the eighteenth century juror heard. In: Bynum WF, Porter R and Shepherd M (eds) The Anatomy of Madness: Essays in the History of Psychiatry, Vol. 2. London: Tavistock, 34-51.
73.
Eigen JP ( 1991) Mad-doctors in the dock: forensic psychiatry’s early claims to expert knowledge. Transactions and Studies of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia5 (13): 445-462.
74.
Eigen JP ( 1994) ‘I answer as a physician’: opinion as fact in pre-McNaughtan insanity trials. In: Clark MJ and Crawford C (eds) Legal Medicine in History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 167-199.
75.
Eigen JP ( 1995) Witnessing Insanity. Madness and Mad-Doctors in the English Court. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
76.
Eigen JP ( 1997) Bewitched, bothered and deluded: a maddening pursuit of the insanity defence. History of Psychiatry8 (2): 297-304.
77.
Eigen JP ( 1999) Lesion of the will: medical resolve and criminal responsibility in Victorian insanity trials. Law and Society Review33 (2): 425-459.
78.
Eigen JP ( 2003) Unconscious Crime: Mental Absence and Criminal Responsibility in Victorian London. Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press .
79.
Eigen JP and G. Andoll ( 1986) From mad-doctor to forensic witness: the evolution of early English court psychiatry. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry9: 159-169
80.
Emsley C and Knafla LA (eds) (1996) Crime History and Histories of Crime: Studies in the Historiography of Crime. Westport, CT, and London: Greenwood Press .
81.
Foucault M. ( 1978, 1985, 1986) The History of Sexuality, 3 vols, Volume 1: An Introduction; Volume 2: The Uses of Pleasure; Vol. 3: The Care of the Self, translated by R Hurley from French editions of 1976-84. London: Penguin.
82.
Frierson CA ( 2002) All Russia is Burning!: A Cultural History of Fire and Arson in late Imperial Russia. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
83.
Fullerton RA ( 2004) Shoplifting as moral insanity: historical perspectives on kleptomania. Journal of Macromarketing24 (1): 8-16.
84.
Geller JL ( 1992) Pathological firesetting in adults. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry15 (3): 283-302.
85.
Geller JL ( 2008) Firesetting: a burning issue. In: Kocsis RN (ed.) Serial Murder and the Psychology of Violent Crimes: An International Perspective. Totowa, NJ: Humana Press.
86.
Geller JL, Erlen J. and Pinkus RL ( 1986) A historical appraisal of America’s experience with ‘pyromania’ - a diagnosis in search of a disorder. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry9 (2): 201-229.
87.
Geller JL, McDermeir M. and Brown J. ( 1997) Pyromania? What does it mean. Journal of Forensic Sciences42 (6): 1052-1057.
88.
Gibson M. ( 2005) Science and language in Italian criminology, 1880-1920 . In: Srebnick AG and Lévy R (eds) Crime and Culture. An Historical Perspective. Aldershot: Ashgate, 37-48.
89.
Goldstein J. ( 1987) Console and Classify: The French Psychiatric Profession in the Nineteenth Century. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
90.
Groneman C. ( 1994) Nymphomania: the historical construction of female sexuality . Signs19 (2): 337-367.
91.
Groneman C. ( 2000) Nymphomania: A History. New York: Norton.
92.
Haack K., Herpertz SC and Kumbier E. ( 2007) The case of Sefeloge: a contribution to the history of forensic psychiatry. Der Nervenarzt78 (5): 586-593.
93.
Haack K., Steinberg H., Herpertz SC and Kumbier E. ( 2008) ‘Vom versteckten Wahnsinn’ - Ernst Platners schrift ‘De amentia occulta’ im Spannungsfeld von Medizin und Jurisprudenz im frühen 19 Jahrhundert. Psychiatrische Praxis35 (2): 84-90.
94.
Harris R. ( 1989) Murder and Madness: Medicine, Law, and Society in the Fin de Siècle. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
95.
Hobsbawn E. and Rudé G. ( 1973) Captain Swing. London: Penguin.
96.
Jackson M. ( 2002) Infanticide: Historical Perspectives on Child Murder and Concealment, 1550-2000. Aldershot, Hants, and Burlington, VT: Ashgate.
97.
Kaufman D. ( 1993) Boundary disputes: criminal justice and psychiatry in Germany, 1760-1850. Journal of Historical Sociology6 (3): 276-287.
98.
Košenina A (ed.) (2007) Ernst Platner: The Professor. Hannover: Wehrhahn.
99.
Kuhlken R. ( 1999) ‘Settin’ the woods on fire’: rural incendiarism as protest. Geographical Review89 (3): 343-363.
100.
Lewis NDC and Yarnell H. ( 1951) Pathological Fire-setting (Pyromania). New York: Coolidge Foundation.
101.
Lipsedge M. ( 2003) Jonathan Martin: prophet and incendiary. Mental Health, Religion and Culture6 (1): 59-77.
102.
Marland H. ( 2004) Dangerous Motherhood: Insanity and Childbirth in Victorian Britain. Basingstoke: Palgrave-Macmillan .
103.
McLynn F. ( 1989) Crime and Punishment in Eighteenth-century England . London and New York: Routledge .
104.
Naschert G and Stiening G (eds) (2007) Ernst Platner (1744-1818). Konstellationen der Aufklärung zwischen Philosophie, Medizin und Anthropologie . Hamburg: Meiner.
105.
O’Brien P. ( 1983) The kleptomania diagnosis: bourgeois women and theft in late nineteenth-century France. Journal of Social History17 (1): 65-77.
106.
Peacock AJ ( 1974) Village radicalism in East Anglia, 1800-1850. In: Dunhabin JPD (ed.) Rural Discontent in Nineteenth-Century Britain. London: Faber and Faber, 27-61.
107.
Poole S. ( 2008) A lasting and salutary warning: incendiarism, rural order and England’s last scene of crime execution. Rural History19: 163-177.
108.
Reed M and Wells R (1990) (eds) Class, Conflict and Protest in the English Countryside 1700-1880. London: Frank Cass.
109.
Roberts P. ( 1997) Arson, conspiracy and rumour in Early Modern Europe . Continuity and Change12: 9-29.
110.
Rule JG and Wells R. ( 1997) Crime, Protest, and Popular Politics in Southern England, 1740-1850. London: Hambledon Press .
111.
Schulte R. ( 1994) The Village in Court: Arson, Infanticide, and Poaching in the Court Records of Upper Bavaria, 1848-1910. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press; translated by B Selman from Das Dorf im Verhör. Reinbek: Rowohlt, 1989.
112.
Smith R. ( 1979) Mental disorder, criminal responsibility and the social history of theories of volition. Psychological Medicine9 (1): 13-19.
113.
Smith R. ( 1981) Trial by Medicine. Insanity and Responsibility in Victorian Trials. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
114.
Smith R. ( 1983) Defining murder and madness: an introduction to medicolegal belief in the case of Mary Ann Brough, 1854. In: Jones RA and Kuklick H (eds) Knowledge and Society: Studies in the Sociology of Culture Past and Present. A Research Annual, Vol. 4. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
115.
Smith R. ( 1988a) Criminal Responsibility, Psychiatry and History: Three Essays, 2nd edn. Lancaster : Centre for Science Studies and Science Policy; Paris : Cité des Sciences et de l’Industrie .
116.
Smith R. ( 1988b) The Victorian controversy about the insanity defence . Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine81, 70-73.
117.
Smith R. ( 1991) Legal frameworks for psychiatry. In: Berrios G and Freeman H (eds) 150 years of Psychiatry. London: Gaskell, 137-151.
118.
Smith R and Wynne B (eds) (1989) Expert Evidence: Interpreting Science in the Law. London: Routledge .
119.
Steinberg H., Schmidt-Recla A. and Schmideler S. ( 2007) Forensic psychiatry in nineteenth-century Saxony: the case of Woyzeck. Harvard Review of Psychiatry15 (4): 169-180.
120.
Tennent TG , McQuaid A., Loughnane T. and Hands A. ( 1971) Female arsonists. British Journal of Psychiatry119: 497-502.
121.
Traverso GB, Ciappi S. and Ferracuti S. ( 2000) The treatment of the criminally insane in Italy: an overview . International Journal of Law and Psychiatry23 (5-6): 493-508.
122.
Walker N. ( 1968) Crime and Insanity in England. Vol. One: The Historical Perspective. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
123.
Walker N. and McCabe S. ( 1973) Crime and Insanity in England. Vol. Two: New Solutions and New Problems. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
124.
West DJ and Walk A. ( 1977) Daniel McNaughton: His Trial and the Aftermath . Ashford: Headley Brothers/ RCPsych Publication s.
125.
Whitlock T. ( 1999) Gender, medicine, and consumer culture in Victorian England: creating the kleptomaniac. Albion31: 413-437.
126.
Worthington H. ( 2005) The Rise of the Detective in Early Nineteenth-Century Popular Fiction. Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.
