There has been little historical research into the post-war treatment of homosexuality, especially in Scotland. Using surviving records from the Jordanburn Nerve Hospital (JNH) in Edinburgh for the 1950s, this paper sets out to rectify this omission. The views of homosexuality held by the psychiatrists, and the main treatment strategies adopted (categorized as hospitalization, suppression, reorientation/‘cure’, and adjustment) are surveyed and illustrated from particular cases. The Edinburgh experience is also compared with perceptions and practices relating to the treatment of homosexual problems in Glasgow. It is concluded that psychiatrists at the JNH adopted a cautious, ad hoc approach to therapy, reflecting both ideological and resource constraints and an attachment to taxonomies of deviance rooted in established notions of sexual pathology.
(a) Archive sources Edinburgh University Library Special Collections [EULSC], George Square, Edinburgh, EH8 9LJ: GD16/Box 24, Papers of Professor T. A. Munro:
2.
(c.1950) Paper on ‘An Unknown Psychoanalyst Returns to the Mental Hospital’
3.
(1954) T. A. Munro to Dr D. Hill, 21 Oct.
4.
(1955) T. A. Munro, Statement in support of increases in medical and medical auxiliary staff at the Royal Edinburgh Hospital for Mental and Nervous Disorders.
5.
(1955a) T. A. Munro to Chairman, South-East Regional Hospital Board, 29 June.
6.
(1956a) Note by T. A. Munro on ‘Future of the Hospital’, May.
7.
(1956b) Note by T. A. Munro on the Royal Edinburgh Hospital for Mental and Nervous Disorders, Nov.
8.
(1956c) Diary note by T. A. Munro, 12 March.
9.
(1956d) Diary note by T. A. Munro, 3 Nov.
10.
Lothian Health Services Archive [LHSA], Edinburgh University Library, George Square, Edinburgh, EH8 9LJ:
11.
Lothian Health Board [LHB] Papers:
12.
(1928-9) LHB7/7/14, Annual Report by the Ordinary Managers of the Royal Edinburgh Hospital for Mental and Nervous Disorders.
13.
(1929) LHB7/12/8, extract from Scotsman, 26 Feb.
14.
(1944) LHB7/7/16, Royal Edinburgh Hospital, Annual Report of the Physician-Superintendent.
15.
(1946) LHB7/10/3/1, Annual Report of Physician Superintendent.
16.
(1947) LHB7/10/3/2, Annual Report of the Physician Superintendent.
17.
(1947a) LHB7/7/16. Annual Report of the Royal Edinburgh Hospital, Morningside.
18.
LHB7/CC1, Royal Edinburgh Hospital and medical clinic and out-patient letters:
19.
(1950) correspondence relating to X. T., 13 May.
20.
(1951) correspondence relating to X.T., 11 July.
21.
(1951a) correspondence relating to U. N., 12 March.
22.
(1951b) correspondence relating to H. N., 12 Oct.
23.
(1951c) correspondence relating to G.T., 27 Dec.
24.
(1951d) correspondence relating to F. N., 26 May.
25.
(1951e) correspondence relating to K. I., n.d.
26.
(1952) correspondence relating to H. T., 16 July.
27.
(1952a) correspondence relating to B. S. H., 28 Feb.
28.
(1953) correspondence relating to Q. L., 10 June.
29.
(1953a) correspondence relating to Q. C., 3 Dec.
30.
(1953b) correspondence relating to K. N., 19 March.
31.
(1954) correspondence relating to S. S., 10 Feb.
32.
(1954a) correspondence relating to M. H., 22 June.
33.
(1954b) correspondence relating to X. S., 29 Oct.
34.
(1954c) correspondence relating to S. N., 8 April.
35.
(1954d) correspondence relating to S. B., 3 Dec.
36.
(1954e) correspondence relating to K. L., 5 Oct.
37.
(1954f) correspondence relating to S. H., 19 Nov.
38.
(1955) correspondence relating to B. T., 17 Nov.
39.
(1955a) correspondence relating to E.T., 28 Feb.
40.
(1955b) correspondence relating to N. E., 17 Jan.
41.
(1955c) correspondence relating to S. T., 27 June.
42.
(1955d) correspondence relating to N. E. 14 July.
43.
(1955e) correspondence relating to S. H. 24 March.
44.
(1955f) correspondence relating to B. T., 22 Nov.
45.
(1956) correspondence relating to D. McH., 3 Oct.
46.
(1956a) correspondence relating to B. C., 22 May.
47.
(1956b) correspondence relating to K. P., 28 Aug.
48.
(1956c) correspondence relating to S. H., 9 May.
49.
(1956d) correspondence relating to S. L,, 29 Nov.
50.
(1956e) correspondence relating to X. T., 24 May.
51.
(1956f) correspondence relating to J. I., 27 June.
52.
(1956g) correspondence relating to B.D., 3 June.
53.
(1956h) correspondence relating to U. X., 3 July.
54.
(1957) correspondence relating to J. Q. O., 26 July.
55.
(1957a) correspondence relating to E. S., 16 Sept.
56.
(1957b) correspondence relating to H. Q. Mc., 31 July.
57.
(1957c) correspondence relating to K. E., 7 Dec.
58.
(1957d) correspondence relating to B. I., 10 Dec.
59.
(1957e) correspondence relating to N. D, 22 Aug.
60.
(1958) correspondence relating to E. N., 1 Feb.
61.
(1958a) correspondence relating to E. L. M., 10 and 15 July.
62.
LHB7/CC12, Royal Edinburgh Hospital case notes:
63.
(1956) note on case of Q. L. , 5 Oct. Box 4.
64.
(1957) note by Professor D. M. Dunlop on case of U.N., 22 May. Box 44.
65.
(1961) note on case of K. N., 15 Feb. Box 29.
66.
National Archives of Scotland [NAS], HM General Register House, 2 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH1 3YY:
67.
(1945) ED15/108, evidence of Professor D. K. Henderson to Scottish Advisory Council on the Treatment and Rehabilitation of Offenders [SACTRO], 20 July.
68.
(1945a) ED15/108, evidence of Dr Winifred Rushforth to SACTRO, 20 July.
69.
(1945b) ED15/108, evidence of Professor David Henderson to SACTRO, 20 July.
70.
(1946) ED15/109, summary of evidence of Dr Ferguson Rodger to SACTRO, 12 April.
71.
(1946a) ED15/109, notes of evidence of Dr Agnes Salmon to SACTRO, 17 May.
72.
(1950) HH60/597, Scottish Home Department to Crown Office, 7 Dec.
73.
(1955) HH57/1288, memorandum by Dr T. D. Inch, ‘Sexual Offenders: Treatment in Prisons’.
74.
The National Archives, Public Record Office, Kew, Richmond, Surrey, TW9 4DU [TNA]:
75.
(1955) HO345/15, evidence of Dr T. D. Inch to Wolfenden Committee, 1 Nov.
76.
(1955a) HO345/15, note by Dr. T. D. Inch to Wolfenden Committee, 13 Oct.
77.
University of Glasgow Archives [UGA]: Thomas Ferguson Rodger Papers [FRP]: (a) DC81/136, lecture notes on sexual problems, n.d. 1950s
78.
(b) DC81/125, lecture notes on the diagnosis of depressive cases, n.d.
79.
(c) DC81/376, lecture notes on psychotherapy, n.d. 1950s.
80.
(d) DC81/222, notes on evidence before the Scottish Advisory Council on the Treatment and Rehabilitation of Offenders, 1946.
81.
(e) DC81/225, lecture notes on psychotherapy in General Practice, n.d.
82.
(f) DC81/382, lecture notes on psychiatry in everyday affairs, n.d.
83.
(g) DC81/63, lecture notes on the social role of the psychiatrist, n.d..
84.
(h) DC81/284, Rodger to Dr H. B. Craigie, Senior Commissioner, General Board of Control for Scotland, 2 March 1953.
85.
(i) DC 81/145, Rodger to Winifred Rushforth, 18 Dec. 1953.
86.
(j) DC 81/284, D. L. Halliday to Rodger, 14 March 1951.
87.
(k) DC 81/459, lecture notes on the practice of psychoanalysis, n.d.
88.
(l) DC 81/145, Rodger to GP, 2 July 1951.
89.
(m) DC 81/72, lecture notes on social psychiatry and mental defect, n.d.
90.
Dr Peter Aungle, interview with author, 23 Aug. 2006.
91.
Dr J. D. Haldane, interview with author, 17 and 24 Jan. 2007.
92.
Anne Robertson, ‘Edinburgh Remember When Project’, transcript of interview, 17 March 2005, 26 Sept. 2006.
93.
Professor Henry Walton, interview with author, 15 May 2007.
94.
Anonymous (1960) Alexander Kennedy [Obituary]. Scotsman, 14 June, p. 8.
95.
Burston, D. ( 1996) The Wing of Madness: The Life and Work of R. D. Laing (Cambridge, MA, and London: Harvard UP).
96.
Cant, B. (ed.) (1993) Footsteps and Witnesses: Lesbian and Gay Lifestories from Scotland ( Edinburgh: Polygon).
97.
Crozier, I.D. ( 2000) Taking prisoners: Havelock Ellis, Sigmund Freud, and the construction of homosexuality, 1897-1951. Social History of Medicine, 13, 447-66.
98.
Curtis, A.H. and Presly, A.S. ( 1972) Extinction of homosexual behaviour by covert sensitization . Behavioural Research and Therapy, 10, 81-3.
99.
Darroch, J. ( 1973) The Davidson Clinic 1939-73 (Gilmerton : Bishop and Sons Ltd).
100.
Davenport-Hines, R. ( 1990) Sex, Death and Punishment: Attitudes to Sex and Sexuality in Britain since the Renaissance (London: Fontana Press).
101.
Davidson, R. ( 2009) Law, medicine and the treatment of homosexual offenders in Scotland, 1950-80. In I. Goold and C. Kelly (eds), Lawyers’ Medicine: The Legislature, the Courts and Medical Practice, 1960-2000 ( Oxford: Hart Publishing), 125-42.
102.
Davidson, R. and Davis, G. ( 2004) ‘A field for Private Members’: The Wolfenden Committee and Scottish homosexual law reform, 1950-67. Twentieth Century British History, 15, 174-201
103.
Davidson, T. (ed.) (1989) And Thus Will I Freely Sing: An Anthology of Gay and Lesbian Writing from Scotland (Edinburgh: Polygon).
104.
Henderson, D.K. ( 1939) Psychopathic States (New York: W. W. Norton).
105.
Henderson, D.K. ( 1955) Society and Criminal Conduct (Edinburgh : The Royal College of Physicians).
106.
Henderson, D.K. ( 1964) The Evolution of Psychiatry in Scotland ( Edinburgh and London: E. and S. Livingstone).
107.
Henderson, D.K. and Batchelor, I.R. C. (1962) A Textbook of Psychiatry for Students and Practitioners , 9th edn (London: Oxford University Press).
108.
Henderson, D.K. and Gillespie R.D. ( 1950) A Textbook of Psychiatry for Students and Practitioners , 7th edn (London: Oxford University Press).
109.
Higgins, P. ( 1996) Heterosexual Dictatorship: Male Homosexuality in Post-War Britain (London: Fourth Estate).
110.
Houlbrook, M. ( 2005) Queer London: Perils and Pleasures in the Sexual Metropolis, 1918-1957 (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press).
111.
Jivani, A. ( 1997) It’s Not Unusual: A History of Lesbian and Gay Britain in the Twentieth Century (London: Michael O’Mara Books).
112.
King, M., Smith, G. and Bartlett, A. ( 2004a) Treatments of homosexuality in Britain since the 1950s - an oral history: the experience of patients. British Medical Journal, 328, 427.
113.
King, M., Smith, G. and Bartlett, A. ( 2004b), Treatments of homosexuality in Britain since the 1950s - an oral history: the experience of professionals. British Medical Journal, 328, 429.
114.
Laing, R.D. ( 1985) Wisdom, Madness and Folly: The Making of a Psychiatrist 1927-57 (London: Macmillan).
115.
Mullan, B. ( 1995) Mad to be Normal: Conversations with R. D. Laing ( London: Free Association Books).
116.
Public General Statutes (1949), Vol. 2, Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 1949. 12, 13 & 14 Geo. 6, CH. 94, s. 3 (London: HMSO).
117.
Rodger, T.F., Ingram, I.M., Timbury, G.C. and Mowbray, R.M. ( 1962) Lecture Notes on Psychological Medicine ( Edinburgh and London: E. and S. Livingstone).
118.
Rushforth, W. ( 1984) Ten Decades of Happenings: The Autobiography of Winifred Rushforth (London: Gateway Books ).
119.
Sutherland, J.D. ( 1989) Fairbairn’s Journey into the Interior ( London: Free Association Books).
120.
Turner, G. ( 1959) Scotland and the Wolfenden Report. Scotsman, 6 June, p. 10.
121.
Walker, K.M. and Strauss, E.B. ( 1954) Sexual Disorders in the Male, 4th rev. edn ( London: Hamish Hamilton).
122.
Waters, C. ( 1998) Havelock Ellis, Sigmund Freud and the State: discourses of homosexual identity in interwar Britain. In L. Bland and L. Doan (eds), Sexology in Culture: Labelling Bodies and Desires (Oxford : Polity Press), 165-79.
123.
Weeks, J. ( 1989) Sex Politics and Society: The Regulation of Sexuality since 1800 (London: Longman).
124.
Westwood, G. ( 1960) A Minority: A Report of the Life of the Male Homosexual (London: British Social Biology Council).
