The history of the relationship between tuberculosis and insanity has been neglected.
This is surprising, for during the nineteenth century it was subject to an important
medical and cultural debate and gave rise to a style of analysis which has been used
ever since to study the clinical phenomenon of
‘disease-coexistence’ (rebaptized
‘comorbidity’ during the 1970s). Triggered by a perceived
increase in the prevalence of tuberculosis and insanity, the debate centred around
the meaning and mechanisms of disease-coexistence, techniques which may be used to
rule out fortuitous associations, the comparative relevance of epidemiological,
congenital, genetic and environmental factors, and the clinical effects that the
members of the disease pair may have on each other. The Classic Text reprinted below
provides an adequate introduction to the main issues listed above.
Alexander, F.
(1945)
Psychogenesis, conversion, specificity
. The Year Book of Psychoanalysis, 1,
257–266
.
2.
Barnes D. S.
(1995) The Making of a Social Disease. Tuberculosis in
Nineteenth Century France (
Berkeley: University of California Press
).
3.
Berrios, G. E.
(1995) Epilepsy. In
G. E. Berrios
and
R. Porter
(eds), The History of Clinical Psychiatry (
London: Athlone Press
), 147–163.
4.
Beveridge, A.
(1991) Thomas Clouston and the Edinburgh School of
Psychiatry. In
G. E. Berrios
and
H. Freeman
(eds), 150 Years of British Psychiatry 1841–1991 (
London: Gaskell
), 359–388.
5.
Beveridge, A.
(2004), ‘Clouston, Sir Thomas Smith
(1840–1915)’. In: Oxford Dictionary of National
Biography (
Oxford: Oxford University Press
).
6.
Bleuler, M.
,
Willi, J.
and
Bühler, H. R.
(1966) Akute psychische Begleiterscheinungen
körperlicher Krankheiten (‘Akuter exogener
Reations-Typus’); Ubersicht und neue Forschungen (
Stuttgart: Thieme
).
7.
Bloch, M.
(1973) The Royal Touch. Sacred Monarchy and Scrofula in
England and France (
London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
).
8.
Bonhoeffer, K.
(1910) Die symptomatischen Psychosen im Gefolge von akuten
Infektionen und inneren Erkrankungen (
Leipzig: Franz Deuticke
).
9.
Bucknill, J. C.
and
Tuke, D. H.
(1858) A Manual of Psychological Medicine (
London: Churchill
).
10.
Chalke, H. D.
(1962)
The impact of tuberculosis on history, literature and art
. Medical History, 6,
301–318
.
11.
Clouston, T. S.
(1863)
The connection between tuberculosis and insanity
. Journal of Mental Science, 9,
36–65
.
12.
Clouston, T. S.
(1887) Clinical Lectures on Mental Diseases, 2nd
edn (
London: Churchill
).
13.
Clouston, T. S.
(1892) Phthisical insanity. In
D. H. Tuke
(ed.), A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, Vol. 2 (
London: Churchill
), 937–947.
14.
Clouston, T. S.
(1906) The Hygiene of Mind (
London: Methuen
).
15.
Clouston, T. S.
(1911) Unsoundness of Mind (
London: Methuen
).
16.
Clouston, T. S.
(1913) Before I Wed (
London: Cassell
).
17.
Clouston, T. S.
(1914) Morals and Brain (
London: Cassell
).
18.
Dening, R. G.
,
Dening, T. R.
and
Berrios, G. E.
(1991)
Hoche’s ‘The significance of symptom complexes in psychiatry’
. History of Psychiatry, 2,
329–343
.
19.
Dixon, T.
(2003) From Passions to Emotions. The Creation of a Secular
Psychological Category (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
20.
Dubos, R.
and
Dubos, J.
(1953) The White Plague. Tuberculosis, and Society (
London: Gollanz
).
21.
Faergeman, P. M.
(1963) Psychogenic Psychoses (
London: Butterworths
).
22.
Faure, O.
(2004) Tuberculose. In
D. Lecourt
(ed.), Dictionnaire de la pensée médicale (
Paris: Presses Universitaires de France
), 1167–1170.
23.
Gerö, G.
(1943)
The idea of psychogenesis in modern psychiatry and in psychoanalysis
. Psychoanalytical Review, 30,
187–211
.
24.
Grigg, E. R. N.
(1955)
Historical and bibliographical review of tuberculosis in the mentally ill
. Journal of History of Medicine and Allied Sciences,
10,
58–108
25.
Guillaume, P.
(1986) Du Désespoir au salut: les tuberculeux aux
19e et 20e siècles (
Paris: Aubier
).
26.
Guislain, J.
(1826) Traité sur
l’aliénation mentale et sur les hospices de
aliénés, Vol. 2 (
Amsterdam: Van der Heys et Fils
).
27.
Hähner-Rombach, S.
(2000) Sozialgeschichte der Tuberkulose vom Kaiserreich bis
zum Ende des Zweiten Weltkriegs unter besonderer Berücksichtigung
Württembergs (
Stuttgart: Franz Steiner
).
28.
Herzog, H.
(1998)
History of tuberculosis
. Respiration, 65,
5–15
.
29.
Humphreys, P.
(1989)
The magic mountain – a time capsule of tuberculosis treatment in
the early 20th century
. Canadian Bulletin of Medical History, 6,
147–163
.
30.
Hunter, R.
(1957)
Tuberculosis and insanity. Historical and experimental observations on the
strait-waist-coat as collapse therapy
. St. Bartholomew’s Hospital Journal, 61,
113–119
.
31.
Johnston, W. D.
(1993) Tuberculosis. In
K. F. Kiple
(ed.), The Cambridge World History of Human Disease (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
), 1059–1068.
32.
Laennec, R. T. H.
(1828) Traité de l’auscultation mediate
et des maladies des poumons et du coeur (
Brussels: Librairie Médicale et Scientifique
).
33.
Levi, A.
(1964) French Moralists. The Theory of the
Passions 1585–1649 (
Oxford: Clarendon Press
).
34.
Morton, R.
(1694) Phthsiologia: or, a Treatise of Consumptions wherein
the Difference, Nature, Causes, signs, and Cure of all Sorts of Consumptions are
Explained (
London: Samuel Smith & Benjamin Walford
).
35.
Neumärker, K.-J.
(2001)
Karl Bonhoeffer and the concept of symptomatic psychoses
. History of Psychiatry, 12,
213–226
.
36.
Portal, A.
(1809) Observations sur la nature et le traitement de la
phthisie pulmonaire, Vol. 2 (
Paris: Collin
), 34–67.
37.
Sendrail, M.
(1980) Histoire culturelle de la maladie (
Toulouse: Privat
).
38.
Vegetti, S.
(ed.) (1995) Storia delle Passioni (
Rome: Gius, Laterza & Figli
).
39.
Wimmer, A.
(2003) Psychogenic Psychoses, edited and translated by
Johan Schioldann
(
Adelaide: Adelaide Academic Press
).
