This paper focuses on the shift from a concept of insanity understood in terms of religion to another (as entertained by early psychiatry, especially in France) according to which it is believed that forms of madness tinged by religion are difficult to cure. The traditional religious view of madness, as exemplified by Pascal (inter alia), is first illustrated by entries from the Encyclopédie. Then the shift towards a medical view of madness, inspired by Vitalistic physiology, is mapped by entries taken from the same publication. Firmed up by Pinel, this shift caused the abandonment of the religious view. Esquirol considered religious mania to be a vestige from the past, but he also believed that mental conditions carrying a religious component were difficult to cure.
AckerknechtE (1967) Medicine at the Paris Hospital. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press.
2.
BaillargerJ (1845) Sur les pseudo-hallucinations chez deux délirants mystiques. Annales Médico-Psychologiques197: 573–574.
3.
BaillargerG (1853/2008) ‘Essay on a classification of different genera of insanity’, by BaillargerJ. (1853) [Classic Text No. 75; introduction and translation by BerriosG]. History of Psychiatry19(3): 358–373.
4.
BeauchesneP (1781) De l’influence des affections de l’âme dans les maladies nerveuses des femmes, avec le traitement qui convient à ces maladies. Amsterdam et Paris: Muignon.
5.
BerriosGE (1999) ‘Délire’: Introduction [to Classic Text No. 40]. History of Psychiatry10(4): 525–536.
6.
BoissierdeSauvagesF (1772) Nosologie méthodique, ou distribution des maladies en classes, genres et espèces selon l’esprit de Sydenham et la méthode botanique, VIII. Lyon: Mercier.
7.
BordeuT (1751) Recherches anatomiques sur la position des glandes et leur action. Paris: Quillau père.
8.
BordeuT (1755) Recherches sur les maladies chroniques. Paris: Quillau père.
9.
BossuetJB (1861) De la connaissance de Dieu et de soi-même. In: Œuvres, Vol. 1. Paris: Didot, 18–102 (first published in 1741).
10.
CalmeilLF (1845) De la folie considérée sous le point de vue pathologique, philosophique, historique et judiciaire: depuis la renaissance des sciences en Europe jusqu’au xixe siècle. Paris: J.B. Baillière.
11.
ChamfortSN (1795/1923) Maximes et pensées, caractères et anecdotes. Paris: Grès & Cie.
12.
CharlandL (2010) Science and morals in the affective psychopathology of Philippe Pinel. History of Psychiatry21(1): 38–53.
13.
CheyneG (1733) The English Malady. Reprinted in 1991, London: Routledge.
14.
CullenW (1781) Lectures on Materia Medica, 2nd edn.Dublin: Whitestone.
15.
CullenW (1784) First Lines of the Practice of Physic, 4 vols, 4th edn.London: Cadell (first published in1771).
16.
D’AumontA (1765a) Délire. In: Encyclopédie, IV. Paris: Briasson, 785–788; trans. BerriosGE (1999) ‘Délire’ in Encyclopédie … [Classic Text No. 40]. History of Psychiatry10(4): 536–541.
17.
D’AumontA (1765b) Démence (Médecine). In: Encyclopédie, IV. Paris: Briasson, 807–808.
D’AumontA (1765d) Phrénésie. In: Encyclopédie, XII. Paris: Briasson, 530–553.
20.
DiderotDD’AlembertJ (eds) (1751–72) Encyclopédie ou Dictionnaire raisonné des sciences, des arts et des métiers. Paris: Briasson.
21.
DigbyA (1985) Moral treatment at The Retreat, 1796–1846. In: BynumWFPorterRShepherdM (eds) Anatomy of Madness: Essays in the History of Psychiatry, Vol. I. London: Tavistock, 55–72.
22.
ErmakoffA (2012) Le conseil général d’administration des hospices civils de Paris: science d’administration des hôpitaux et médecine clinique (1801–1832). Unpublished thesis, Université Paris7.
23.
EsquirolJED (1805) Des passions considérées comme causes, symptômes et moyens curatifs. Paris: Didot.
24.
EsquirolJED (1838) Des maladies mentales, Vol. I. Paris: Baillière (cited as MM); translation by HuntE Kingsbury: Mental Maladies: A Treatise on Insanity. Philadelphia, PA: Lea and Blanchard (1845).
25.
FoucaultM (1961) Histoire de la folie à l’âge classique. Paris: Gallimard.
26.
FoucaultM (2003) Le pouvoir psychiatrique (Cours au Collège de France, 1976). Paris: Seuil.
27.
GelfandT (1980) Professionalizing Modern Medicine: Paris Surgeons and Medical Science and Institutions in the 18th Century. Westport, CT, and London: Greenwood Press.
28.
GeorgetE (1820) De la folie. Paris: Crevot.
29.
GoldsteinJ (1987) Console and Classify: The French Psychiatric Profession in the Nineteenth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
30.
GregoryJ (1777) A Comparative View of the State and Faculties of Man with Those of the Animal World. Edinburgh: Dodsley.
31.
HuertasR (2008) Between doctrine and clinical practice: nosography and semiology in the work of Jean-Etienne-Dominique Esquirol (1772–1840). History of Psychiatry19(2): 123–140.
32.
HunemanP (2004) Les théories de l’économie animale et la naissance de l’aliénisme. Psychiatrie, Sciences humaines, Neurosciences (PSN)2(2): 47–59.
33.
HunemanP (2007) ‘Animal economy’: anthropology and the rise of psychiatry from the Encyclopédie to the alienists. In: WolffLCipolloniM (eds) The Anthropology of the Enlightenment. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 262–276.
34.
HunemanP (2008) Montpellier vitalism and the emergence of alienism in France (1750–1800): the case of the passions. Science in Context21(4): 1–33.
LélutJ (1836) Du démon de Socrate, spécimen d’une application de la science psychologique à celle de l’histoire. Reprinted in 2000, Paris: l’Harmattan.
37.
LemaistredeSacyL-I (1838) Le Nouveau Testament de Notre Seigneur Jésus-Christ, traduit sur la Vulgate, 2nd edn.Bruxelles: Meline, Cans & Cie (first published in 1667).
MénuretdeChambaudJJ (1765c) Œconomie animale (Médecine). Encyclopédie, XI. Paris: Briasson, 360–366.
41.
PascalB (1962) Pensées, edited by L Lafuma. Paris: Seuil.
42.
PigeaudJ (2002) Aux portes de la psychiatrie : Pinel, l’ancien et le moderne. Paris: Flammarion.
43.
PinelP (1802) Traité médico-philosophique de l’aliénation mentale, Vol. I(Paris, an IX): Richard, Caille, et Ravier [cited as TMP]; also 2nd edn, 1809; translation by DavisD: A Treatise on Insanity: in Which Are Contained the Principles of a New and More Practical Nosology of Maniacal Disorders, Than Has Yet Been Offered to the Public. London: Cavell and Davies (1806) [cited as TI].
44.
PinelP (1804) La médecine clinique, rendue plus precise et plus exacte par l’application de l’analyse. Paris: Brosson.
45.
PiresMarques T (2010) Mystique, politique et maladie mentale. Historicités croisées (France, c. 1830–c. 1900). Revue d’Histoire des Sciences Humaines23(2): 37–74.
46.
PommeP (1757) Traité sur les affections vaporeuses des deux sexes. Paris: Benoit Duplain libraire.
47.
ReyR (1995) Vitalism, disease and society. In: PorterR (ed.) Medicine in the Enlightenment. Amsterdam: Clio Medica, 275–288.
48.
RosenG (1968) Madness and Society: Chapters in the Historical Sociology of Mental Illness. London: Routledge.
49.
ScullA (1990) Social Order/Mental Disorder: Anglo-American Psychiatry in Historical Perspective. Berkeley: University of California Press.
50.
ScullA (1993) The Most Solitary of Afflictions: Madness and Society in Britain 1700–1900. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
51.
SwainG (1978) Le sujet de la folie. Paris: Payot.
52.
SwainG (1994) Dialogue avec l’insensé. Paris: Gallimard.
53.
SwainGGauchetM (1985) La pratique de l’esprit humain. Paris: Gallimard.
54.
TenonJ (1788) Mémoires sur les hôpitaux. Paris: Imprimerie Pierres.
55.
TukeS (1813) Description of the Retreat, an Institution near York, of the Society of Friends, Containing an Account of its Origin and Progress, the Modes of Treatment, and the Statment of Cases. London: Process Press.
56.
Vauvenargues (1857) Oeuvres. Paris: D.-L. Gilbert, Furne et Cie.
57.
WeinerD (2001) Comprendre et soigner. Paris: Fayard.
58.
WeiszGC (2006) Divide and Conquer: A Comparative History of Medical Specialization. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
59.
WolfeCTeradaM (2008) The animal economy as object and program in Montpellier vitalism. Science in Context21(4): 537–579.
