The history of the construction of the concept of hallucination remains biased in
favour of the French contribution. Important to this history are the first 30 years
of the nineteenth century for it was then that it was decided that hallucinations
were: (1) primary disorders of perception; (2) the same class of phenomena,
regardless of the sense modality in which they occurred; (3) generated by
stimulation of brain regions related to perception and hence were mechanical
responses with no semantic or informational import; and (4) medical problems.
In 1826 Johannes Müller published a book on the fantastic phenomena of
vision. Therein he proposed new rules for the description and explanation of
hallucinations. Although published after Purkinje’s books on an analogous
theme, and after Esquirol’s entry for the Panckoucke dictionary,
Müller’s book served as one of the foundations for the new
nineteenth-century speculative physiology and physiopathology of hallucinations.
This way of conceptualizing these phenomena was to culminate in the irritation model
proposed by Tamburini in the 1880s. This paper justifies the choice of
Müller’s book as a classic text, provides biographical data about
its author, and places the book in its historical context.
Bayle, P. (1820) Jerome Cardan. In Dictionnaire Historique et critique de
Pierre Bayle, Vol. 4 (Paris: Desoer), 436–51.
2.
Bayle, P. (1855) Reil, Jean Chrétien. Biographie
Médicale, Vol. 2 (Paris: A. Delahays), 797–800.
3.
Beiser, F.
(2002) German Idealism. The Struggle against
Subjectivism: 1781–1801 (
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
).
4.
Berrios, G. E.
(1982)
Tactile hallucinations
. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry,
45,
285–293
.
5.
Berrios, G. E.
(1988)
Melancholia and depression during the 19th century. A conceptual history
. British Journal of Psychiatry, 153,
298–304
.
6.
Berrios, G. E.
(1990a)
A theory of hallucinations
. History of Psychiatry, 1,
145–156
.
7.
Berrios, G. E.
(1990b)
Musical hallucinations: a historical and clinical study
. British Journal of Psychiatry, 156,
188–194
.
8.
Berrios, G. E.
(1996) The History of Mental Symptoms (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
9.
Berrios, G. E.
(2004)
Of mania (Classic Text No. 57)
. History of Psychiatry15,
105–124
.
10.
Berrios, G. E.
and
Brook, P.
(1982)
The Charles Bonnet syndrome and the problem of visual perceptual disorders
in the elderly
. Age and Ageing, 11,
17–23
.
11.
Boissier de Sauvages (1771) Nosologie Méthodique, Vol. 2
(Paris: Hérissant le Fils), 604–607.
12.
Bonnet, Ch. (1760) Essai Analytique sur les Facultés de
l’Ame (Copenhagen: C. & A. Philibert).
13.
Brierre de Boismont, A. (1862) Des Hallucinations ou histoire
raisonnée des apparitions, des visions, des songes, de
l’extase, des rêves, du magnétisme et du
sonambulisme (Paris: Baillière).
14.
Calmet, A. (1751) Traité sur les apparitions des esprits
(Paris: Debure).
Dahlstrom, D. O.
(1997) Introduction. In
M. Mendelssohn
, Philosophical Writings (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
.
17.
Dareste (no first name) (c. 1860) Jean Muller. In
Michaud’s Biographie Universelle, Vol. 10 (Paris: Madame C.
Desplaces), 549–59.
18.
Dening, T.
and
Berrios, G. E.
(1994)
Autoscopic phenomena. A clinical analysis of 56 cases
. British Journal of Psychiatry, 165,
808–817
.
19.
Depping (no first name) (c. 1860) Justus Moeser. In
Michaud’s Biographie Universelle, Vol. 28 (Paris: Madame C.
Desplaces), 447–8.
20.
Dupre, J.
(1993) The Disorder of Things (
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
).
21.
Esquirol, E. (1817) Hallucination. In Adelon et al. (eds),
Dictionaire des sciences médicales par une
société de médecines et de chirurgiens,
Vol. 20 (Paris: Panckoucke), 64–71.
22.
Ey, H. (1973) Traité des Hallucinations, 2 vols (Paris: Masson).
23.
Ferriar, J.
(1813) An Essay towards a Theory of Apparitions (
London: Cadell & Davies
).
24.
Finger, S.
and
Wade, N.
(2002a)
The neuroscience of Helmholtz and the theories of Johannes Müller.
Part 1: Nerve cell structure, vitalism and the nerve impulse
. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences, 11,
136–155
.
25.
Finger, S.
and
Wade, N.
(2002b)
The neuroscience of Helmholtz and the theories of Johannes Müller.
Part 2: Sensation and perception
. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences, 11,
234–254
.
26.
Fischer-Homberger, E
, (1979)
On the medical history of the doctrine of imagination
. Psychological Medicine, 9,
619–628
.
27.
Friedlander (no first name) (c. 1860) Moses Mendelssohn. In
Michaud’s Biographie Universelle, Vol. 27 (Paris: Madame C.
Desplaces), 617–21.
28.
Goethe, J. W. von (1988) Scientific Studies, translated by Douglas
Miller, Vol. 12 (New York: Suhrkamp Publishers).
29.
Grimm, J. and Grimm, W. (1862) Deutsches Wörterbuch, Vol. 3
(Leipzig: Hirzel), ‘Eigenleben’.
30.
Grimm, J. and Grimm, W. (1889) Deutsches Wörterbuch, Vol.
13 (Leipzig: Hirzel), ‘plastisch’.
31.
Grimm, J. and Grimm, W. (1919) Deutsches Wörterbuch, Vol.
17 (Leipzig: Hirzel), ‘Station’.
32.
Haberling, W. (1924) Johannes Müller. Das Leben des rheinischen
Naturforschers (Leipzig: Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft m.b.H.).
33.
Hagner, M. and Wahrig-Schmidt, B. (1992) Johannes Müller und die
Philosophie (Berlin: Akademie Verlag).
34.
Hibbert, S. (1824) Sketches of the Philosophy of Apparitions
(Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd).
35.
Kageyama, J. (1984) Sur l’histoire de la monomanie.
L’Evolution Psychiatrique, 49, 155–62.
36.
Koller, G. (1958) Das Leben des Biologen Johannes Müller
1801–1858 (Stuttgart: Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft m.b.H.).
37.
Kruta, V. and Teich, M. (1962) Jan Evangelista Purkyně
(Prague: State Medical Publishing House).
38.
Lacroix (no first name) (c. 1860) Jerome Cardan. In
Michaud’s Biographie Universelle, Vol. 6 (Paris: Madame C.
Desplaces), 660–3.
39.
Lanteri-Laura, G. (1991) Les Hallucinations (Paris: Masson).
40.
Laporte, J.
(2004) Natural Kinds and Conceptual Change (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
41.
López Piñero, J. M.
(1983) Historical Origins of the Concept of Neurosis,
translated by D. Berrios (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
).
42.
Mazundar, P. M. H.
(1975)
Johannes Müller on the blood, the lymph, and the chyle
. Isis, 66,
242–253
.
43.
Mérat (no first name) (1821) Sympathie. In Adelon et al.
(eds), Dictionaire des sciences médicales par une
société de médecines et de chirurgiens,
Vol. 53 (Paris: Panckoucke), 621–4.
44.
Möser, J. (1768) Osnabrückische Geschichte, 2 vols
(Osnabrück: Schmid).
45.
Mourgue, R. (1932) Neurobiologie de l’hallucination
(Bruxelles: Lamertin).
46.
Müller, J. (1826a) Ueber die phantastischen
Gesichtserscheinungen. Eine physiologische Untersuchung mit einer
physiologischen Urkunde des Aristotles über den Traum, den Philosophen
und Aertzen gewidmet (Coblenz: Hölscher).
47.
Müller, J. (1826b) Zur vergleichenden Physiologie des
Gesichtssinnes des Menschen und der Thiere, nebst einen Versuch über
die Bewegung der Augen und über den menschlichen Blick (Leipzig: Cnobloch).
48.
Müller, J. (1834) Handbuch der Physiologie des Menschen,
Vol. 1 (Coblenz: Hölscher).
49.
Müller, J. (1838) Handbuch der Physiologie des Menschen,
Vol. 2 (Coblenz: Hölscher).
50.
Nicolaï, F. (1799) Beispiel einer Erscheinung mehrerer Phantasmen;
nebst einigen erläuternden Ammerkungen. Neue Berlinische
Monatschrift, 1 (May), 321–59; 470–1.
51.
Paulus, J. (1941) Le Problème de l’hallucination et
l’évolution de la psychologie d’Esquirol
à Janet (Paris: Les Belles Lettres).
52.
Pinel, Ph. (1801) Traité médico-philosophique sur
l’aliénation mentale ou la manie (Paris: Richard,
Caille et Ravier).
53.
Purš, J. (ed.) (1988) Jan Evangelista Purkyne in Science and
Culture, 2 vols (Prague: Ùstav
československých a světových
dýjin ČSAV).
54.
Riese, W.
and
Arrington, G. E.
(1964)
The history of Johannes Müller’s doctrine of the
specific energies of the senses: original and later versions
. Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 37,
179–183
.
55.
Selwyn, P.
(2000) Everyday Life in the German Book Trade: Friedrich
Nicolaï as Bookseller and Publisher in the Age of Enlightenment
1740–1810 (
University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press
).
56.
Smith, P.
(1869) Theon of Samos. In
William Smith
(ed.), Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology, Vol.
3 (
London: James Walton
).
57.
Steen, R. H.
(1917)
Hallucinations in the sane
. Journal of Mental Science, 63,
328–346
.
58.
Steudel, J. (1952) Wissenschaftslehre und Forschungsmethodik Johannes
Müllers. Deutsche medizinische Wochenschrift, 77, 115–18.
59.
Vaidy (no first name) (1815) Éréthisme. In Adelon
et al. (eds), Dictionaire des sciences médicales par une
société de médecines et de chirurgiens,
Vol. 13 (Paris: Panckoucke), 161–2.
60.
Villeneuve (no first name) (1820) Protopathique. In Adelon et al.
(eds), Dictionaire des sciences médicales par une
société de médecines et de chirurgiens,
Vol. 45 (Paris: Panckoucke), 513.
61.
Virchow, R.
(1859)
Johann Müller, the physiologist: an Eloge pronounced in the hall
of the University of Berlin
. Edinburgh Medical Journal, 4,
452–463; 527–544
.
62.
Wade, N. J.
(1998) A Natural History of Vision (
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
).
63.
Wade, N. J.
(2003) Introduction. In
Müller’s Elements of Physiology (
Bristol: Thoemmes Press
), v–xxvii.
64.
Ziolkowski, T.
(1990) German Romanticism and its Institutions (
Princeton: Princeton University Press
).
