In the aftermath of World War II, a struggle ensued over the direction of American
psychoanalysis. Led by William Menninger, who reluctantly assumed the presidency of
the American Psychoanalytic Association in 1946, a cohort of American-born
psychoanalysts sought to make their profession more responsive to other medical
practitioners and the general public. Insisting that divisive theoretical debates
should be relegated to the past, these psychoanalysts promoted a medicalized,
Americanized and popularized version of psychoanalysis that deliberately blurred the
distinction between psychiatry and psychoanalysis. They were opposed by a group of
more orthodox psychoanalysts, including many émigrés, who
viewed their efforts as undermining psychoanalysis from within.
Anonymous
(1948)
Are you always worrying?
, Time, 52 (25 Oct.),
69–69
.
2.
Brand, J. L.
(1965)
The National Mental Health Act of 1946. A retrospect
. Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 39,
231–245
.
3.
Bresnahan, J. C. (1999) Danger in paradise. The battle against combat fatigue
in the Pacific war. PhD thesis, Harvard University.
4.
Brown, T. M.
(1987)
Alan Gregg and the Rockefeller Foundation’s support of Franz
Alexander’s psychosomatic research
. Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 61,
155–182
.
5.
Buhle, M. J.
(1998) Feminism and Its Discontent. A
Century of Struggle with Psychoanalysis (
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
).
6.
Burnham, J. C.
(1978) The influence of psychoanalysis upon American
culture. In
J. M. Quen
and
E. T. Carlson
(eds), American Psychoanalysis. Origins and Development (
New York: Brunner/Mazel
), 52–69.
7.
Carney, J. E.
(1993)
The Freudians come to Kansas. Menninger, Freud, and the
émigré psychoanalysts
. Kansas History, 16,
78–93
.
8.
Coser, L.
(1984) Refugee Scholars in America. Their
Impact and Their Experiences (
New Haven: Yale University Press
), 42–82.
9.
Fermi, L.
(1968) Illustrious Immigrants. The
Intellectual Migration from Europe, 1930–1941 (
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
), 139–173.
10.
Freud, S.
(1930) Introduction to the Special Psychopathology Number
of The Medical Review of Reviews. In Standard Edition of the
Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. 21 (
London: Hogarth Press
, 1961), 254–254.
11.
Friedman, L. J.
(1990) Menninger. The Family and the
Clinic (
New York: Knopf
).
12.
Furnas, J. C.
(1945)
Meet Ed Savickas. A victim of combat fatigue
. Ladies’ Home Journal, 62
(Feb.):
141–147
.
13.
Glass, A. J.
(ed.) (1966, 1973) Neuropsychiatry in World War II, 2
vols (
Washington, DC: Office of the Surgeon General,
Department of the Army
).
14.
Greene, R. S. (1977) The role of the psychiatrist in World War II. PhD
thesis, Columbia University.
15.
Grob, G.
(1991) From Asylum to Community. Mental
Health Policy in Modern America (
Princeton: Princeton University Press
).
16.
Hale, N., Jr.
(1995) The Rise and Crisis of Psychoanalysis in the United
States. Freud and the Americans, 1917–1985 (
Oxford: Oxford University Press
).
17.
Harris, B.
and
Brock, A.
(1991)
Otto Fenichel and the left opposition in psychoanalysis
. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences,
27,
157–165
.
18.
Herman, E.
(1995) The Romance of American Psychology.
Political Culture in the Age of Experts (
Berkeley: University of California Press
).
19.
Hersey, J.
(1945)
A short talk with Erlanger
. Life, 19 (29 Oct.),
108–112
.
20.
Hughes, H. S.
(1975) The Sea Change. The Migration of
Social Thought, 1930–1965 (
New York: Harper & Row
).
21.
Jacoby, R.
(1991) The Repression of Psychoanalysis.
Otto Fenichel and the Political Freudians (
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
).
22.
Jahoda, M.
(1969) The migration of psychoanalysis: its impact on
American psychology. In
D. Fleming
and
B. Bailyn
(eds), The Intellectual Migration. Europe and America,
1930–1960 (
Cambridge: Harvard University Press
), 420–462.
23.
Jay, M.
(1973) The Dialectical Imagination. A
History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute for Social Research,
1923–1950 (
Boston: Little, Brown
).
24.
Kirsner, D.
(2000) Unfree Associations: Inside Psychoanalytic
Institutes (
London: Process Press
).
25.
Knight, R.
(1953)
The present status of organized psychoanalysis in the United States
. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association,
1,
197–221
.
26.
Lasswell, H.
(1946)
Psychiatric testing urged for leaders to see if they are fit to wield power
. New York Times, (13 May),
2–2
.
27.
Leys, R.
(2000) Trauma. A Genealogy (
Chicago: Chicago University Press
).
28.
Lynch, W.
(1945)
Strictly personal. Home fears burning
. Saturday Review of Literature, 28 (28
Apr.),
8-8
.
29.
Menninger, W. C.
(1946)
Remarks on accepting nomination for presidency of the American
Psychoanalytic Association
. Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 15,
413–415
.
30.
Michel, S.
(1983)
American conscience and the unconscious. Psychoanalysis and the rise of
personal religion, 1906–63
. Psychoanalysis and Contemporary Thought, 7,
387–421
.
31.
Moskowitz, E. S.
(2001) In Therapy We Trust.
America’s Obsession with Self-Fulfillment (
Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press)
.
32.
Palmer, G.
(1945)
What do you know about psychiatry?Woman’s Home Companion, 72 (Oct.),
30-30
.
33.
Pols, J. C. (1997) Managing the mind. The culture of American mental hygiene,
1910–1950. PhD thesis, University of Pennsylvania.
34.
Pressman, J. D.
(1993) Last Resort: Psychosurgery and the Limits of
Medicine (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
.
35.
Turkle, S.
(1992) Psychoanalytic Politics. Jacques
Lacan and Freud’s French Revolution, 2nd edn (
New York: Guilford Press)
.
36.
Wells, M. K.
(1995) Courage and Air Warfare. The Allied
Aircrew Experiences in the Second World War (
London: Frank Cass)
.
37.
Whitman, H.
(1948)
Where do you take your troubles?Woman’s Home Companion, 75 (Oct.),
36–37
.
38.
Younger, J.
(1949)
Mental illness. Public enemy number one
. Ladies’ Home Journal, 66
(Mar.),
44–45, 214–218
.
39.
Zaretsky, Eli
(2004) Secrets of the Soul. A Social and
Cultural and History of Psychoanalysis (
New York: Knopf)
.
