A core hypothesis in developmental theory predicts that genetic influences on intelligence and academic achievement are suppressed under conditions of socioeconomic privation and more fully realized under conditions of socioeconomic advantage: a Gene × Childhood Socioeconomic Status (SES) interaction. Tests of this hypothesis have produced apparently inconsistent results. We performed a meta-analysis of tests of Gene × SES interaction on intelligence and academic-achievement test scores, allowing for stratification by nation (United States vs. non–United States), and we conducted rigorous tests for publication bias and between-studies heterogeneity. In U.S. studies, we found clear support for moderately sized Gene × SES effects. In studies from Western Europe and Australia, where social policies ensure more uniform access to high-quality education and health care, Gene × SES effects were zero or reversed.
AdlerN. E.NewmanK. (2002). Socioeconomic disparities in health: Pathways and policies. Health Affairs, 21(2), 60–76.
2.
AsburyK.WachsT. D.PlominR. (2005). Environmental moderators of genetic influence on verbal and nonverbal abilities in early childhood. Intelligence, 33, 643–661.
3.
BartelsM.van BeijsterveldtC. E.BoomsmaD. I. (2009). Breastfeeding, maternal education and cognitive function: A prospective study in twins. Behavior Genetics, 39, 616–622.
4.
BatesT. C.HansellN. K.MartinN. G.WrightM. J. (2015). When does socioeconomic status moderate the heritability of IQ? Evidence from an Australian adolescent sample. Manuscript submitted for publication.
5.
BatesT. C.LewisG. J.WeissA. (2013). Childhood socioeconomic status amplifies genetic effects on adult intelligence. Psychological Science, 24, 2111–2116.
6.
BouchardT. J.Jr.McGueM. (1981). Familial studies of intelligence: A review. Science, 212, 1055–1059.
7.
BrileyD. A.Tucker-DrobE. M. (2013). Explaining the increasing heritability of cognitive ability across development: A meta-analysis of longitudinal twin and adoption studies. Psychological Science, 24, 1704–1713.
8.
BronfenbrennerU.CeciS. J. (1994). Nature-nurture reconceptualized in developmental perspective: A bioecological model. Psychological Review, 101, 568–586.
9.
CheungA. K.HardenK. P.Tucker-DrobE. M. (2014). Gene×Environment interactions in early externalizing behaviors: Parental emotional support and socioeconomic context as moderators of genetic influences?Behavior Genetics, 44, 468–486.
10.
CheungM. W. L. (2008). A model for integrating fixed-, random-, and mixed-effects meta-analyses into structural equation modeling. Psychological Methods, 13, 182–202.
11.
DaviesG.TenesaA.PaytonA.YangJ.HarrisS. E.LiewaldD.. . . DearyI. J. (2011). Genome-wide association studies establish that human intelligence is highly heritable and polygenic. Molecular Psychiatry, 16, 996–1005.
12.
DeNavas-WaltC.ProctorB. D. (2014). Income and poverty in the United States: 2013 (Current Population Reports No. P60-249). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce, Economics and Statistics Administration, U.S. Census Bureau.
13.
DuncanG. J.MorrisP. A.RodriguesC. (2011). Does money really matter? Estimating impacts of family income on young children’s achievement with data from random-assignment experiments. Developmental Psychology, 47, 1263–1279.
14.
EavesL. J.JinksJ. L. (1972). Insignificance of evidence for differences in heritability of IQ between races and social classes. Nature, 240, 84–88.
15.
FischbeinS. (1980). IQ and social class. Intelligence, 4, 51–63.
16.
FriendA.DeFriesJ. C.OlsonR. K. (2008). Parental education moderates genetic influences on reading disability. Psychological Science, 19, 1124–1130.
17.
FriendA.DeFriesJ. C.OlsonR. K.PenningtonB.HarlaarN.ByrneB.. . . KeenanJ. M. (2009). Heritability of high reading ability and its interaction with parental education. Behavior Genetics, 39, 427–436.
18.
GaltonF. (1869). Hereditary genius: An inquiry into its laws and consequences. London, England: Macmillan.
19.
GrantM. D.KremenW. S.JacobsonK. C.FranzC.XianH.EisenS. A.. . . LyonsM. J. (2010). Does parental education have a moderating effect on the genetic and environmental influences of general cognitive ability in early adulthood?Behavior Genetics, 40, 438–446.
20.
HanscombeK. B.TrzaskowskiM.HaworthC. M.DavisO. S.DaleP. S.PlominR. (2012). Socioeconomic status (SES) and children’s intelligence (IQ): In a UK-representative sample SES moderates the environmental, not genetic, effect on IQ. PLoS ONE, 7(2), Article e30320. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0030320
21.
HardenK. P.TurkheimerE.LoehlinJ. C. (2007). Genotype by environment interaction in adolescents’ cognitive aptitude. Behavior Genetics, 37, 273–283.
22.
HauserR. M. (1970). Educational stratification in the United States. Sociological Inquiry, 40(2), 102–129.
23.
HaworthC. M.WrightM. J.MartinN. W.MartinN. G.BoomsmaD. I.BartelsM.. . . PlominR. (2009). A twin study of the genetics of high cognitive ability selected from 11,000 twin pairs in six studies from four countries. Behavior Genetics, 39, 359–370.
24.
JacobsonK. C.VasilopoulosT. (2012). Developmental changes in moderating effects of parental education on individual differences in vocabulary IQ from adolescence to young adulthood. Behavior Genetics, 42, 941.
25.
JensenA. R. (1969). How much can we boost IQ and scholastic achievement?Harvard Educational Review, 39, 1–123.
26.
KirkpatrickR. M.McGueM.IaconoW. G. (2015). Replication of a gene-environment interaction via multimodel inference: Additive-genetic variance in adolescents’ general cognitive ability increases with family-of-origin socioeconomic status. Behavior Genetics, 45, 200–214.
27.
KremenW. S.JacobsonK. C.XianH.EisenS. A.WatermanB.ToomeyR.. . . LyonsM. J. (2005). Heritability of word recognition in middle-aged men varies as a function of parental education. Behavior Genetics, 35, 417–433.
28.
MuthénL. K.MuthénB. O. (2012). Mplus user’s guide (7th ed.). Los Angeles, CA: Author.
29.
NagoshiC. T.JohnsonR. C. (2005). Socioeconomic status does not moderate the familiality of cognitive abilities in the Hawaii Family Study of Cognition. Journal of Biosocial Science, 37, 773–781.
30.
NelsonC. A.IIIZeanahC. H.FoxN. A.MarshallP. J.SmykeA. T.GuthrieD. (2007). Cognitive recovery in socially deprived young children: The Bucharest Early Intervention Project. Science, 318, 1937–1940.
31.
NisbettR. E.AronsonJ.BlairC.DickensW.FlynnJ.HalpernD. F.TurkheimerE. (2012). Intelligence: New findings and theoretical developments. American Psychologist, 67, 130–159.
32.
PlominR.HaworthC. M.MeaburnE. L.PriceT. S., Wellcome Trust Case Control Consortium, & DavisO. S. P. (2013). Common DNA markers can account for more than half of the genetic influence on cognitive abilities. Psychological Science, 24, 562–568.
33.
PrescottC. A.McArdleJ. J.AchornD. L.KaiserA.LaphamS. J. (2014, June). Estimating genetic and family environment effects when zygosity is unknown by using data from twin and sibling pairs. Poster presented at the annual meeting of the Behavior Genetics Association, Charlottesville, VA.
34.
PurcellS. (2002). Variance components models for gene-environment interaction in twin analysis. Twin Research, 5, 554–571.
35.
RamaniG. B.SieglerR. S. (2008). Promoting broad and stable improvements in low-income children’s numerical knowledge through playing number board games. Child Development, 79, 375–394.
36.
RhemtullaM.Tucker-DrobE. M. (2012). Gene-by-socioeconomic status interaction on school readiness. Behavior Genetics, 42, 549–558.
37.
RitchieS. J.BatesT. C.PlominR. (2014). Does learning to read improve intelligence? A longitudinal multivariate analysis in identical twins from age 7 to 16. Child Development, 86, 23–26.
38.
RoweD. C.JacobsonK. C.Van den OordE. J. (1999). Genetic and environmental influences on vocabulary IQ: Parental education level as moderator. Child Development, 70, 1151–1162.
39.
Scarr-SalapatekS. (1971). Race, social class, and IQ. Science, 174, 1285–1295.
SpenglerM.GottschlingJ.SpinathF. M. (2011). Genotype by environment interaction in young children: Parental education moderates the heritability of intelligence. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Psychology, Saarland University, Saarbrücken, Germany.
44.
TaylorJ.RoehrigA. D.Soden HenslerB.ConnorC. M.SchatschneiderC. (2010). Teacher quality moderates the genetic effects on early reading. Science, 328, 512–514.
45.
Tucker-DrobE. M.BrileyD. A.HardenK. P. (2013). Genetic and environmental influences on cognition across development and context. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 22, 349–355.
46.
Tucker-DrobE. M.RhemtullaM.HardenK. P.TurkheimerE.FaskD. (2011). Emergence of a Gene × Socioeconomic Status interaction on infant mental ability between 10 months and 2 years. Psychological Science, 22, 125–133.
47.
TurkheimerE.HaleyA.WaldronM.D’OnofrioB.GottesmanI. I. (2003). Socioeconomic status modifies heritability of IQ in young children. Psychological Science, 14, 623–628.
48.
TurkheimerE.HardenK. P.D’OnofrioB.GottesmanI. I. (2009). The Scarr–Rowe interaction between measured socioeconomic status and the heritability of cognitive ability. In McCartneyK.WeinbergR. A. (Eds.), Experience and development: A festschrift in honor of Sandra Wood Scarr (pp. 81–97). New York, NY: Psychology Press.
49.
TurkheimerE.HornE. E. (2014). Interactions between socioeconomic status and components of variation in cognitive ability. In FinkelD.ReynoldsC. A. (Eds.), Behavior genetics of cognition across the lifespan (Vol. 1, pp. 41–68). New York, NY: Springer.
50.
Van Den OordE. J. C. G.RoweD. C. (1997). An examination of genotype-environment interactions for academic achievement in an U.S. national longitudinal survey. Intelligence, 25, 205–228.
51.
van der SluisS.WillemsenG.de GeusE. J.BoomsmaD. I.PosthumaD. (2008). Gene-environment interaction in adults’ IQ scores: Measures of past and present environment. Behavior Genetics, 38, 348–360.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
