The relative importance of nature and nurture for various forms of expertise has been intensely debated. Music proficiency is viewed as a general model for expertise, and associations between deliberate practice and music proficiency have been interpreted as supporting the prevailing idea that long-term deliberate practice inevitably results in increased music ability. Here, we examined the associations (rs = .18–.36) between music practice and music ability (rhythm, melody, and pitch discrimination) in 10,500 Swedish twins. We found that music practice was substantially heritable (40%−70%). Associations between music practice and music ability were predominantly genetic, and, contrary to the causal hypothesis, nonshared environmental influences did not contribute. There was no difference in ability within monozygotic twin pairs differing in their amount of practice, so that when genetic predisposition was controlled for, more practice was no longer associated with better music skills. These findings suggest that music practice may not causally influence music ability and that genetic variation among individuals affects both ability and inclination to practice.
BengtssonS. L.NagyZ.ForsmanL.ForssbergH.SkareS.UllénF. (2005). Extensive piano practicing has regionally specific effects on white matter development. Nature Neuroscience, 8, 1148–1150.
BokerS. M.NealeM.MaesH.WildeM.SpiegelM.BrickT.. . . FoxJ. (2011). OpenMx: An open source extended structural equation modeling framework. Psychometrika, 76, 306–317.
4.
CharnessN.FeltovichP. J.HoffmanR. R.EricssonK. A. (2006). The Cambridge handbook of expertise and expert performance. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
5.
CoonH.CareyG. (1989). Genetic and environmental determinants of musical ability in twins. Behavior Genetics, 19, 183–193.
de BruinA. B.SmitsN.RikersR. M.SchmidtH. G. (2008). Deliberate practice predicts performance over time in adolescent chess players and drop-outs: A linear mixed models analysis. British Journal of Psychology, 99, 473–497.
8.
de GeusE. J. C.de MoorM. H. M. (2008). A genetic perspective on the association between exercise and mental health. Mental Health and Physical Activity, 1, 53–61.
9.
DettermanD. K.RuthsatzJ. M. (1999). Toward a more comprehensive theory of exceptional abilities. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 22, 148–158.
10.
DraynaD.ManichaikulA.de LangeM.SniederH.SpectorT. (2001). Genetic correlates of musical pitch recognition in humans. Science, 291, 1969–1972.
11.
DuboisL.Ohm KyvikK.GirardM.Tatone-TokudaF.PerusseD.HjelmborgJ.. . . MartinM. G. (2012). Genetic and environmental contributions to weight, height, and BMI from birth to 19 years of age: An international study of over 12,000 twin pairs. PLoS ONE, 7(2), Article e30153. Retrieved from http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0030153
12.
DuffyD. L.MartinN. G. (1994). Inferring the direction of causation in cross-sectional twin data: Theoretical and empirical considerations. Genetic Epidemiology, 11, 483–502.
13.
EricssonK. A. (2002). Attaining excellence through deliberate practice: Insights from the study of expert performance. In FerrariM. (Ed.), The pursuit of excellence through education (pp. 21–55). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
14.
EricssonK. A. (2013). Training history, deliberate practice and elite sports performance: An analysis in response to Tucker and Collins review—What makes champions?British Journal of Sports Medicine, 47, 533–535. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2012–091767
15.
EricssonK. A. (2014). Why expert performance is special and cannot be extrapolated from studies of performance in the general population: A response to criticisms. Intelligence, 45, 81–103.
16.
EricssonK. A.ChaseW. G.FaloonS. (1980). Acquisition of a memory skill. Science, 208, 1181–1182.
17.
EricssonK. A.KrampeR. T.HeizmannS. (1993). Can we create gifted people? [Target article and commentaries]. Ciba Foundation Symposium, 178, 222–249.
18.
EricssonK. A.KrampeR. T.Tesch-RömerC. (1993). The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychological Review, 100, 363–406.
19.
EricssonK. A.LehmannA. C. (1996). Expert and exceptional performance: Evidence of maximal adaptation to task constraints. Annual Review of Psychology, 47, 273–305.
20.
EricssonK. A.NandagopalK.RoringR. W. (2005). Giftedness viewed from the expert performance perspective. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 28, 287–311.
21.
GladwellM. (2008). Outliers: The story of success. New York, NY: Little, Brown.
22.
HambrickD. Z.OswaldF. L.AltmannE. M.MeinzE. J.GobetF.CampitelliG. (2014). Deliberate practice: Is that all it takes to become an expert?Intelligence, 45, 34–45.
23.
HoweM. J. A.DavidsonJ. W.SlobodaJ. A. (1998). Innate talents: Reality or myth?Behavioral & Brain Sciences, 21, 399–442.
24.
HydeK. L.LerchJ.NortonA.ForgeardM.WinnerE.EvansA. C.SchlaugG. (2009). Musical training shapes structural brain development. Journal of Neuroscience, 29, 3019–3025.
25.
JangK. L.LivesleyW. J.VernonP. A. (1996). Heritability of the Big Five personality dimensions and their facets: A twin study. Journal of Personality, 64, 577–591.
26.
KrampeR. T.EricssonK. A. (1996). Maintaining excellence: Deliberate practice and elite performance in young and older pianists. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 125, 331–359.
27.
LichtensteinP.De FaireU.FloderusB.SvartengrenM.SvedbergP.PedersenN. L. (2002). The Swedish Twin Registry: A unique resource for clinical, epidemiological and genetic studies. Journal of Internal Medicine, 252, 184–205.
28.
LichtensteinP.SullivanP. F.CnattingiusS.GatzM.JohanssonS.CarlströmE.. . . PedersenN. L. (2006). The Swedish Twin Registry in the third millennium: An update. Twin Research and Human Genetics, 9, 875–882.
29.
NealeM. C.BokerS. M.XieG.MaesH. H. (2006). Mx: Statistical modeling (7th ed.). Richmond: Virginia Commonwealth University, Department of Psychiatry.
30.
NealeM. C.MaesH. H. M. (2004). Methodology for genetic studies of twins and families. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic.
31.
PlominR.DeFriesJ. C.LoehlinJ. C. (1977). Genotype-environment interaction and correlation in the analysis of human behavior. Psychological Bulletin, 84, 309–322.
32.
PlominR.ShakeshaftN. G.McMillanA.TrzaskowskiM. (2014). Nature, nurture, and expertise. Intelligence, 45, 46–59.
33.
PosthumaD.de GeusE. J. C.DearyI. J. (2009). The genetics of intelligence. In GoldbergT. E.WeinbergerD. R. (Eds.), The genetics of cognitive neuroscience (pp. 97–122). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
34.
RuthsatzJ.DettermanD.GriscomW. S.CirulloB. A. (2008). Becoming an expert in the musical domain: It takes more than just practice. Intelligence, 36, 330–338.
35.
SchellenbergE. G.WeissM. W. (2013). Music and cognitive abilities. In DeutschD. (Ed.), The psychology of music (3rd ed., pp. 499–550). Waltham, MA: Elsevier.
36.
SeashoreC. E. (1960). Manual of instructions and interpretations for Measures of Musical Talent. New York, NY: Psychological Corp. (Original work published 1919)
37.
TuckerR.CollinsM. (2012). What makes champions? A review of the relative contribution of genes and training to sporting success. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 46, 555–561.
38.
UllénF.MosingM. A.HolmL.ErikssonH.MadisonG. (2014). Psychometric properties and heritability of a new online test for musicality, the Swedish Musical Discrimination Test. Personality and Individual Differences, 63, 87–93.
39.
VinkhuyzenA. A.van der SluisS.PosthumaD.BoomsmaD. I. (2009). The heritability of aptitude and exceptional talent across different domains in adolescents and young adults. Behavior Genetics, 39, 380–392.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
