Awards and competitions are often used to motivate public servants, and this paper examines how the central government of China uses these to try and motivate cities to improve public hygiene. The authors argue that apart from improving performance,(1) awards and competitions are good at motivating user participation and spreading good practice. However, the design of the schemes used in China tends to prioritize disproportionately the winning mentality, and sometimes causes high costs and social tension.
Besley, T. and M. Ghatak ( 2005), "Competition and incentives with motivated agents" , American Economic Review Vol 95, No 3, pages 616-636.
2.
Bevan, G. and C. Hood ( 2006), "What’s measured is what matters: targets and gaming in the English public health care system", Public Administration Vol 84, No 3, pages 517-538.
3.
Boyne, G.A. ( 1996), "Competition and local government: a public choice perspective" , Urban Studies Vol 33, No 4, pages 703-721.
4.
Brettell, A.M. ( 2003), "The politics of public participation and the emergence of environmental proto-movements in China", University of Maryland, PhD Dissertation, accessible at http://hdl.handle.net/1903/70, page 520.
5.
Bruns, B. ( 2004), "From voice to empowerment: re-routing irrigation reform in Indonesia", in Alex Bolding (editor), The Politics of Irrigation Reform: Contested Policy Formulation and Implementation in Asia, Africa and Latin America, Ashgate Publishing, Chapter 5, pages 145-165.
6.
Cctv (2009), "Fraudulent behaviour in the HCC by Jiaozuo of Henan province disturbed the public (Henan Jiaozuo Chuangwei Beibao Zuojia Raomin)", News 1+1 edited by Weijie Tang, China News Net, 17 August 2010, accessible at http://www.chinanews.com.cn/gn/news/2009/03-18/1606084.shtml .
7.
Chen, X. ( 2007), "Guangzhou office for hygienic city campaign starts to use text message as a platform for the campaign (Guangzhoushi Chuangweiban Chuanxin Yunyong Hongduanzi Pingtai)", China News, China Central Television, 14 August, accessible at http://news.cctv.com/china/20071210/107901.shtml.
8.
Chen, L. and Y. Guo ( 2007), "Four steps to regulate non-taxation collections by grassroots authorities", China State Finance (Zhongguo Caizheng) No 9, pages 34-36.
9.
Chen, X., Y. Li, M. Wu, S. Zhou, S. Li and Z. Tian ( 2001), "Hygienic city construction and economic development: an analysis of the theoretical turning point on LEPC curve", Chinese Journal of Public Health Management Vol 17, No 4, pages 257-260.
10.
Dai, L. and W. Wang ( 2007), "Some suggestions on the campaigns for national hygienic cities (Guanyu Woshi Chuangjian Guojia Weisheng Cheng Huodong De Jidian Jianyi)" , Daqing Social Science (Daqing Shehui Kexue) No 4, pages 54-59.
11.
Fotaki, M. ( 1999), "The impact of market-oriented reforms on choice and information: a case study of cataract surgery in outer London and Stockholm" , Social Science & Medicine Vol 48, No 10, pages 1415-1432.
12.
Glennerster, H. ( 1991), "Quasi-markets for education?", The Economic Journal Vol 101, No 408, pages 1268-1276.
13.
Grimshaw, D., S. Vincent and H. Wilmott ( 2002), "Going privately: partnership and outsourcing in UK public services", Public Administration Vol 80, No 3, pages 475-502.
14.
Guangzhou Government (2007), "Gangzhou will set up long-term urban governance system and promote bundled HCC", Guangzhou Daily, Guangzhou , 6 December, accessible at http://www.gz.gov.cn/vfs/content/newcontent.jsp?contentId=530607&catId=5540.
15.
Hanson, M. ( 2008), "Maoist public health campaigns, Chinese medicine and SARS", The Lancet Vol 372, pages 1457-1458.
16.
Hesketh, T. and W.X. Zhu ( 2004), "Effect of restricted freedom on health in China" , British Medical Journal Vol 329, pages 14-27.
17.
Huang, Y. ( 2004), "One trillion to promote transportation and environment improvement. Guangzhou to be evaluated by the hygienic city campaign (1,000 Yi Tuijin Jiaotong Huanjing Jianshe. Guangzhou Chuangwei Jieshou Kaohe)", Southern Daily, Guangzhou, 14 August, accessible at http://www.southcn.com/news/dishi/guangzhou/shizheng/200409140078.htm .
18.
John, P., H. Ward and K. Dowding ( 2004), "The bidding game: competitive funding regimes and the political targeting of urban programme schemes", British Journal of Political Science Vol 34, No 3, pages 405-428.
19.
Le Grand, J. ( 1991), "Quasi-markets and social policy’, The Economic Journal Vol 101, No 408, pages 1256-1267.
20.
Le Grand, J. ( 2006), "A better class of choice", Public Finance , accessible at http://www.publicfinance.co.uk/features/2006/a-better-class-of-choice-byjulian-le-grand/ .
21.
Le Grand, J. ( 2007), "The politics of choice and competition in public services" , Political Quarterly Vol 78, pages 207-213.
22.
Li, Z. ( 2010), "A literature review on the research of patriotic hygiene campaigns in recent years (Jinnianlai Guanyu Aiguoweisheng Yundong de Yanjiu Zongshu)", Beijing Party History (Beijing Dangshi) Vol 3, pages 25-30.
23.
Li, B. and Y. Zhang ( 2011 forthcoming), "Competition between local authorities as a way of motivating local public provision - lessons from China", in J P Faguet (editor), Decentralization and the Construction of Governance for Development, Oxford University Press.
24.
Liu, B. and J. Liu ( 1994), "New understandings of the Chinese style of patriotic hygiene campaigns (Dui Zhongguo Tese de Aiguo Weisheng Yundong de Xin Renshi)" , Journal of Shandong Medical School (Shandong Yike Daxue Xuebao) Vol 2, pages 21-22.
25.
Longxi, Z. ( 1999), "Debating Chinese post-modernism", Postcolonial Studies Vol 2, pages 185-198.
26.
Martin, S. ( 2000), "Implementing ‘best value’: local public services in transition", Public Administration Vol 78, No 1, pages 209-227.
27.
Matosevic, T., M. Knapp and J. Le Grand ( 2008), "Motivation and commissioning: perceived and expressed motivations of care home providers", Social Policy & Administration Vol 42, No 3, pages 228-247.
28.
McGuire, R.A., R.L. Ohsfeldt and T.N. Van Cott ( 1987), "The determinants of the choice between public and private production of a publicly funded service", Public Choice Vol 54, No 3, pages 211-230.
29.
Ministry of Health of PRC (2009), "List of national hygienic cities and districts" (stored by time of approval), accessible at http:/www.moh.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/mohjbyfkzj/s5899/200903/39661.htm.
30.
Ministry of Health of PRC and National PHC ( 2009), "Announcement on the reassessment of national hygienic cities (or districts and towns)", (Quanguo Aiweithui Guanyu 2009 nian, Guojia Weishen Chengshi, Qu, Zhen Fushen Gongzuo de Tongbao ( 2009)), accessible at http:/www.moh.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/mohjbyfkzj/s7934/200912/44918.htm.
31.
Neckermann, S. and B.S. Frey ( 2008), "Awards as incentives", Institute for Empirical Research in Economics Working Paper No 334, accessible at http://ssrn.com/paper=1021208.
32.
Paul, S. ( 1992), "Accountability in public services: exit, voice and control" , World Development Vol 20, pages 1047-1060.
33.
People’s Daily (2008), "Difficult path for the 18 years’ hygienic city campaign. Guangzhou puts on a new look from 2000 (Shibazai Chuangwei Jianxinlu Liangqiannian Yangcheng Zhanxinyan)", Beijing, 7 April 2008, accessible at
Shen, R. ( 2004), "Alternatives to improve the ability of public provision by the government (Tigao Zhengfu Gonggong Fuwu Nengli De Xuanze)" , China Public Administration (Zhongguo Xingzheng Guanli) No 223, pages 29-32.
36.
Smith, A.J. ( 1974), "Public health in China", British Medical Journal Vol 2, pages 492-494.
37.
State Council PRC (1989), "Decisions on improving the work for patriotic hygiene (Guanyu Jiaqiang Aiguo Weisheng Gongzuo de Jueding)", State Council Issue No 22, Beijing, accessible at http://wsj.lishui.gov.cn/ztbd/cwzt/zcxx/t20081206_494765.htm.
38.
The National Patriotic Committee PRC (1989 ), "Notice on creating the national hygienic city campaign (Guanyu Kaizhan Chuangjian Guojia Weisheng Chengshi Huodong de Tongzhi)", The National Patriotic Committee PRC, accessible at http://www.gxws.gov.cn/2005/5-16/18280230195.htm.
39.
The National Patriotic Hygiene Committee PRC ( 2009), "The standards for national hygienic city (Guojia Weisheng Chengshi Biaozhun)", accessible at http://www.chinanews.com.cn/jk/jk-zcdt/news/2010/06-10/2336132.shtml.
40.
Wang, H., Y. Ge and S. Gong ( 2007), "Regulating medical services in China", Milbank Memorial Fund and the Department of Social Development, Development Research Centre (DRC), the State Council of PR China, Beijing .
41.
Webler, T., S. Tuler and R. Krueger ( 2001), "What is a good public participation process? Five perspectives from the public", Environmental Management Vol 27, No 3, pages 435-450.
42.
Wong, C P W ( 2000), "Central-local relations revisited. The 1994 tax-sharing reform and public expenditure management in China", China Perspectives No 31, pages 52-63, accessible at http://www.cuhk.edu.hk/gpa/wang_files/C%20Wong%202000.pdf.
43.
Xi, X., L. Fan and X. Deng ( 1998), "Public environment awareness in China: an analysis of the results of public surveys", Project Report, National Research Centre for Science and Technology for Development , Ministry of Science and Technology, Beijing, December, accessible at http://www.andrew.cmu.edu/user/kf0f/Envir_Awareness_Report.pdf .
44.
Zhu, H. ( 2009), "Twelve departmental leaders signed ‘Military order for the hygienic city campaign’ (12 Bumen Fuzeren Qianxia ‘Chuangwei Junlingzhuang’)", Kunming Municipal Government, accessible at http://xxgk.yn.gov.cn/newsview.aspx?id=1119918 .
