This paper examines the institutional and political constraints that inhibit
multilateral and bilateral donor agencies supporting poverty reduction initiatives
on the ground. These include the constraints related to their own structures and the
political systems in which they are embedded, and those related to their
relationships with recipient governments. The paper also considers how current
trends in development assistance towards greater donor harmonization and the
associated processes within Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs), the shift
from project support to budget support, and the drive for greater
“efficiency” may further limit donors’ capacity to
support pro-poor local initiatives. It also discusses how these trends in
development assistance are marginalizing support for those aspects of development
that require relatively little external funding but also require that this funding
be used carefully and strategically, engaging directly with poor groups and their
organizations, and enlarging their scope for influence and action.
Bigg, Tom
and
David Satterthwaite
(editors) (2005), How to Make Poverty History: The Central
Role of Local Organizations in Meeting the MDGs,
IIED, London
.
2.
Booth, David
(2004), “Budgets not projects: a new way of
doing business for aid donors”, in ODI Opinions,
February,
Overseas Development Institute (ODI), London
, website:
%5Bhttp://www.odi.org.uk/publications/opinions/index.html%5D 3Budgets not projects.
3.
Carlsson, Jerker
and
Lennart Wohlgemuth
(2000), “Learning in development cooperation - an
introduction”, in
Lennart Wohlgemuth
and
Jerker Carlsson
(editors) (2001), Learning in Development Cooperation,
International Expert Group on Development Issues,
Almqvist & Wiksell International,
Stockholm, pages 6-23
.
4.
Chambers, Robert
(1997), Whose Reality Counts: Putting The First Last,
Intermediate Technology Publications
.
D’Cruz, Celine
and
David Satterthwaite
(2005), “Building homes, changing official
approaches: the work of urban poor federations and their contributions to
meeting the Millennium Development Goals in urban areas”,
Working Paper 16 in the Poverty Reduction in Urban Areas Series,
IIED, London
.
8.
Degnbol-Martinussen, John and Poul Enberg-Pedersen (2003), Aid, Understanding
International Development Cooperation, Mellemfolkeligt Samvirke (Danish Association
for International Cooperation), Zed Books, London.
9.
DFID
(2000), “Eliminating world poverty: making
globalization work for the poor”,
White Paper on International Development
, website: http://www.dfid.gov.uk/pubs/files/whitepaper2000.pdf.
DGIS
(1996), “Aid in progress - development cooperation
and the re-verification of foreign policy”,
Netherlands Ministry of Foreign Affairs (DGIS),
The Hague
.
12.
Driscoll, Ruth
,
Karin Christiansen
and
David Booth
(2005), “Progress reviews and performance
assessment in poverty reduction strategies and budget support; a survey of
current thinking and practice”, Overseas Development Institute
Report, May,
London
.
13.
Edgren, Gus
(2000), “Fashions, myths and delusion: obstacles to
organizational learning in agencies”, in
Lennart Wohlgemuth
and
Jerker Carlsson
(editors) (2001), Learning in Development Cooperation,
International Expert Group on Development Issues,
Almqvist & Wiksell International, Stockholm
, pages 41-68.
14.
Eyben, Rosalind
(2003), “Donors as political actors: fighting the
Thirty Years War in Bolivia”, IDS Working Paper 183, April,
Institute of Development Studies, Brighton
.
15.
Eyben, Rosalind
and
Clare Ferguson
(2004), “How can donors become more accountable
to poor people?”, in
Leslie Groves
and
Rachel Hinton
(editors) (2004), Inclusive Aid: Changing Power and Relationships in
International Development,
Earth-scan, London
, pages 163-180.
16.
Green, Reginald Herbold
and
John Toye
(1996), Multilateral Development Bank Concessional Lending. Forward
into the Second Half Century, in Degnbol-Martinussen, John and Poul
Enberg-Pedersen (2003), Aid, Understanding International Development
Cooperation, Mellemfolkeligt Samvirke (Danish Association for International
Cooperation),
Zed Books, London
.
17.
Groves, Leslie
and
Rachel Hinton
(editors) (2004), Inclusive Aid: Changing Power and
Relationships in International Development,
Earthscan, London
.
18.
Hasan, Arif
,
Sheela Patel
and
David Satterthwaite
(2005),
“How to meet the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in urban areas?”
, in Environment & Urbanization Vol 17, No
1, April, pages
3-19
.
19.
Hermele, Kenneth
(2005),
“The Poverty Reduction Strategies: a survey of the literature”
, Paper prepared for the Forum Syd, June
2006, Stockholm, Sweden.
20.
Hinton, Rachel
(2004), “Enabling inclusive aid: changing power
and relationships in international development”, in
Leslie Groves
and
Rachel Hinton
(editors) (2004), Inclusive Aid: Changing Power and Relationships in
International Development,
Earth-scan, London
, pages 210-220.
21.
Homeless International website: http://www.homelessinternational.org/standard_1.asp?category=3&id=27741.
22.
Jassey, Katja
(2004), “The bureaucrat”, in
Leslie Groves
and
Rachel Hinton
(editors) (2004), Inclusive Aid: Changing Power and Relationships in
International Development,
Earthscan, London Groves
and
Hinton
(editors), pages 128-136.
23.
King, Kenneth
and
Simon McGrath
(2004), Knowledge for Development? Comparing British,
Japanese, Swedish and World Bank Aid,
Zed Books, London and New York, and
HSRC Press, Cape Town
.
24.
Lahiri, Sojal
and
Pascalis Raimondos-Moller
(2002), “Coordinated and uncoordinated foreign
aid”, in
B Mak Arvin
(editor), New Perspectives on Foreign Aid and Economic
Development,
Praeger, London
, pages 125-138.
25.
Martens, Bertin
,
Uwe Mummert
,
Peter Murrel
and
Paul Seabright
(2002), The Institutional Economics of Foreign Aid,
Cambridge University Press
.
26.
Maxwell, Simon
(2005), “Spyglass. Spigot. Spoon. Or spanner. What
future for bilateral aid?”, ODI Working Paper 250, July,
Overseas Development Institute, London
.
27.
Mitlin, Diana
and
David Satterthwaite
(editors) (2004), Empowering Squatter Citizen: Local
Government, Civil Society and Urban Poverty Reduction,
Earthscan, London
.
28.
Mosse, David
(2005), Cultivating Development: An Ethnography of Aid Policy
and Practice,
Pluto Press, London
.
29.
Naschold, Felix
(2002), “Aid and the Millennium Development
Goals”, in ODI Opinions, February,
Overseas Development Institute, London
, website: http://www.odi.org.uk/publications/opinions/index.html.
30.
Netherlands Ministry of Foreign Affairs website: http://www.minbuza.nl.
31.
OECD website: http://www.oecd.org.
32.
Olsen, Gorm Rye
(2000), “Public opinion and development aid: is
there a link?”, CDR Working Paper 009, December,
Centre for Development Research, Copenhagen, Denmark
.
33.
Olsen, Gorm Rye
(2001),
“European public opinion and aid to Africa: is there a link?”
, in Journal of Modern African Studies Vol 39, No
4, pages
645-674
.
34.
Ostrom, Elinor
(team leader),
Clark Gibson
,
Sujai Shivakumar
and
Krister Andersson
(2002), Aid, Incentives and Sustainability; An Institutional
Analysis of Development Cooperation, Sida Studies in Evaluation # 02/01,
December,
Sida, Stockholm
.
35.
Patel, Sheela
and
Diana Mitlin
(2004), “The work of SPARC, the National Slum
Dwellers Federation and Mahila Milan”, in
Diana Mitlin
and
David Satterthwaite
(editors) (2004), Empowering Squatter Citizen: Local Government, Civil
Society and Urban Poverty Reduction,
Earthscan, London
, pages 216-244.
36.
Piron, Laure-Hélène
with
Alison Evans
(2004), “Politics and the PRSP Approach: Synthesis
Paper”, ODI Working Paper 237, March,
Overseas Development Institute, London
.
37.
Pollard, A
and
J Court
(2005), “How Civil Society Organizations Use
Evidence to Influence Policy Processes: A Literature Review”,
ODI Working Paper 249, July,
Overseas Development Institute, London
.
38.
Quarles van Ufford, Philip
and
Ananta Kumar Giri
(2003), A Moral Critique of Development: In Search of Global
Responsibilities,
Routledge, London
.
39.
Randel, Judith
,
Tony German
and
Deborah Ewing
(editors) (2000), The Reality of Aid 2000. An Independent
Review of Poverty Reduction and Development Assistance,
Earthscan, London
.
40.
Rihani, Samir
(2002), Complex Systems Theory and Development Practice:
Understanding Non-linear Realities,
Zed Books, London
41.
Rogerson, Andrew
with
Adrian Hewitt
and
David Waldenberg
(2004), “The International Aid System 2005-2010,
Forces For and Against Change”, ODI Working Paper 235, March,
Overseas Development Institute, London
.
42.
Satterthwaite, David
(2001),
“Reducing urban poverty: constraints on the effectiveness of aid
agencies and development banks and some suggestions for change”
, Environment & Urbanization Vol 13, No
1, April, pages
137-157
.
43.
Satterthwaite, David
(2005),
“Meeting the MDGs in urban areas; the forgotten role of local organizations”
, Journal of International Affairs Vol 58, No
2, pages
87-112
.
44.
Satterthwaite, David
(2005), “Meeting the MDGs in urban areas: the
forgotten role of local organizations”, in
Tom Bigg
and
David Satterthwaite
(editors) (2005), How to Make Poverty History: The Central Role of Local
Organizations in Meeting the MDGs,
IIED, London
, pages 99-126
45.
Satterthwaite, David
(2005), “Why local organizations are central to
meeting the MDGs (Introduction)” in
Tom Bigg
and
David Satterthwaite
(editors) (2005), How to Make Poverty History: The Central Role of Local
Organizations in Meeting the MDGs,
IIED, London
, pages 1-25.
46.
Sida
(2005), Sida’s 2004 Annual Report,
Stockholm, Sweden
, website: http://www.sida.se.
47.
Sida’s website on housing programmes in central America: http://www.sida.se/Sida/jsp/polopoly.jsp?d=693&a=8275.
48.
Smilie, Ian
(1996), “Mixed messages: public opinion and
development assistance in the 1990s”, in
Colm Foy
and
Henry Helmich
(editors), Public Support for International Development,
OECD, Paris
, pages 27-54.
49.
SPARC website: http://www.sparcindia.org.
50.
Stein, Alfredo
and
Luis Castillo
(2005),
“Innovative financing for low-income housing improvements:
lessons from programmes in Central America”
, Environment & Urbanization Vol 17, No
1, April,
London
, pages
47-66
.
51.
Stern, Marc
(1998), Development Aid: What the Public Thinks,
Office of Development Studies, Bureau for Development Policy,
UNDP, New York
.
52.
Stokke, Olav
(2005), “The changing international and
conceptual environments of development cooperation”, in
Paul Hoebink
and
Olav Stokke
(editors), Perspectives on European Development Cooperation: Policy and
Performance of Individual Donor Countries and the EU,
Routledge, London and New York
, pages 32-112.
53.
Toulmin, Camilla
(2005), “Foreword”, in
Tom Bigg
and
David Satterthwaite
(editors) (2005), How to Make Poverty History: The Central Role of Local
Organizations in Meeting the MDGs,
IIED, London
, pages vii-x.
54.
UN Millennium Project Taskforce on Water Supply and Sanitation
(2005), Health, Dignity and Development: What Will It Take?,
Taskforce Final Report,
Stockholm International Water Institute (SIWI) and the UN Millennium
Project, New York
, website: http://www.unmillenniumproject.org/documents/What_Will_It_Take.pdf.
55.
Van Rooy, Alison
(editor) (1998), Civil Society and the Aid Industry,
Earthscan, London
.
56.
Wieslander, Anna
(2000), “When do we ever learn?”, in
Lennart Wohlgemuth
and
Jerker Carlsson
(editors) (2001), Learning in Development Cooperation,
International Expert Group on Development Issues, Almqvist &
Wiksell International, Stockholm
, pages 250-266.
57.
Win, Everjoice
(2004), “If it doesn’t fit on the blue
square it’s out! An open letter to my donor
friend”, in
Leslie Groves
and
Rachel Hinton
(editors) (2004), Inclusive Aid: Changing Power and Relationships in
International Development,
Earthscan, London Groves
and
Hinton
(editors), pages 123-127.
58.
Wohlfensohn, James D
(1999), “A proposal for a comprehensive development
framework - a discussion draft”, website: http://www.worldbank.org/cdf/cdf-text.htm.
59.
World Bank (2004), The World Bank Annual Report 2004, website: http://www.worldbank.org/annual-report/2004/.
60.
World Bank website: http://www1.worldbank.org/harmonization/romehlf/Documents/RomeDeclaration.pdf.
61.
World Bank website: http://www1.worldbank.org/harmonization/Paris/FINALPARISDECLARATION.pdf.
62.
World Bank website: http://ddp-ext.worldbank.org/ext/MDG/gdmis.doc
