The ISO 6336 Standard provides widely accepted analytical methods for calculating load distribution factors in helical gears, particularly the face load factor. However, these methods rely on simplifications that may not accurately capture real-world operating conditions, potentially leading to non-conservative results. This study critically assesses the ISO 6336 Standard approach by comparing its predictions to those obtained from an advanced finite element model (FEM) of a helical gear transmission, which incorporates a complete gear-shaft-support system. The numerical results reveal that the methods in ISO 6336 Standard systematically overestimate the face load factor in most cases, though its predictions remain close to FEM calculations for certain configurations. Additionally, the study highlights the influence of helix angle direction and power input/output configuration on load distribution, factors not explicitly considered in the standard. The findings suggest potential refinements to the ISO 6336 Standard to improve its accuracy in engineering applications.
VulloV. Load carrying capacity of spur and helical gears: influence factors and load analysis. Springer International Publishing, Cham, Switzerland2020.
2.
LitvinFLFuentesAGonzalez-PerezI, et al. Modified involute helical gears: computerized design, simulation of meshing and stress analysis. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng2003; 192(33–34): 3619–3655.
3.
HotaitMKahramanA.Experiments on root stresses of helical gears with lead crown and misalignments. J Mech Des2008; 130(7): 0745021–0745025.
4.
LiS.Finite element analyses for contact strength and bending strength of a pair of spur gears with machining errors, assembly errors and tooth modifications. Mech Mach Theory2007; 42(1): 88–114.
5.
PatilSSKaruppananSAtanasovskaI.Experimental measurement of strain and stress state at the contacting helical gear pairs. Measurement2016; 82: 313–322.
6.
International Organization for Standardization. ISO 6336-1:2019: calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears — part 1: basic principles, introduction and general influence factors. Geneva, 2019.
7.
International Organization for Standardization. ISO 6336-2:2019: calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears — part 2: calculation of surface durability (pitting). Geneva, 2019.
8.
International Organization for Standardization. ISO 6336-3:2019: calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears — part 3: calculation of tooth bending strength. Geneva, 2019.
9.
American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and American Gear Manufacturers Association (AGMA). ANSI/AGMA 2001-D04: gear rating standard — manual of gear design and application. Fairfax, VA, USA, 2001.
10.
KimSCMoonSGSohnJH, et al. Macro geometry optimization of a helical gear pair for mass, efficiency, and transmission error. Mech Mach Theory2020; 144: 103634.
11.
MilerDLončarAŽeželjD, et al. Influence of profile shift on the spur gear pair optimization. Mech Mach Theory2017; 117: 189–197.
12.
JohnsonKL.Contact mechanics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989.
13.
CuràF.Iso standard based method for calculating the in-operation application factor ka in gears subjected to variable working conditions. Int J Fatigue2016; 91: 459–465.
14.
BelingardiGCuffaroVCuràF.Dynamic additional loads influencing the fatigue life of gears in an electric vehicle transmission. Frattura ed Integrita Strutturale2014; 8: 469–477.
15.
ZhaoLFrazerRCShawB.Comparative study of stress analysis of gears with different helix angle using the iso 6336 standard and tooth contact analysis methods. Proc IMechE, Part C: J Mechanical Engineering Science2016; 230(7-8): 1350–1358.
16.
KawalecAWiktorJCeglarekD.Comparative analysis of tooth-root strength using iso and agma standards in spur and helical gears with fem-based verification. J Mech Des2006; 128: 1141–1158.
17.
LisleTJShawBAFrazerRC.External spur gear root bending stress: a comparison of ISO 6336:2006, AGMA 2101-d04, ANSYS finite element analysis and strain gauge techniques. Mech Mach Theory2017; 111: 1–9.
18.
ZhouCChenCGuiL, et al. A nonlinear multi-point meshing model of spur gears for determining the face load factor. Mech Mach Theory2018; 126: 210–224.
19.
KamyckiWNogaS.Application of the thin slice model for determination of face load distribution along the line of contact and the relative load distribution measured along gear root. Stroj Vestn/J Mech Eng2020; 66(5): 300–310.
20.
AtanasovskaIDNikolić-StanojevićV.3d spur gear fem model for the numerical calculation of face load factor. Mech Autom Control Rob J2006; 6: 131–143.
21.
Roda-CasanovaVSanchez-MarinFTGonzalez-PerezI, et al. Determination of the iso face load factor in spur gear drives by the finite element modeling of gears and shafts. Mech Mach Theory2013; 65: 1–13.
22.
JelaskaD.Gears and gear drives. John Wiley Sons, Chichester, United Kingdom2012.
23.
BettaïebMNVelexPAjmiM.A static and dynamic model of geared transmissions by combining substructures and elastic foundations—applications to thin-rimmed gears. J Mech Des2007; 129: 184–194.
24.
International Organization for Standardization. ISO 53:1998: cylindrical gears for general and heavy engineering — standard basic rack tooth profile. Geneva, 1998.
25.
SchäferWF.Beitrag zur Ermittlung des wirksamen Flankenrichtungsfehlers bei Stirnradgetrieben und der Lastverteilung bei Geradverzahnung. PhD Thesis, Technische Hochschule Darmstadt, 1971.
26.
WeberCBanaschekKNiemannG.Formänderung und profilrücknahme: bei gerad-und schrägverzahnten rädern. (No Title), 1955.
27.
Deutsches Institut für Normung eV. DIN 3990-1: calculation of load capacity of cylindrical gears: introduction and general influence factors. Berlin, 1987.
28.
MarquesPMartinsRSeabraJ.Analytical load sharing and mesh stiffness model for spur/helical and internal/external gears – towards constant mesh stiffness gear design. Mech Mach Theory2017; 113: 126–140: 023301.
29.
Gonzalez-PerezIFuentes-AznarA.Implementation of a finite element model for gear stress analysis based on tie-surface constraints and its validation through the Hertz’s theory. J Mech Des2018; 140. DOI: 10.1115/1.4038301.
ArgyrisJFuentesALitvinFL.Computerized integrated approach for design and stress analysis of spiral bevel gears. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng2002; 191: 1057–1095.
32.
Gonzalez-PerezISanchez-MarinFRoda-CasanovaV, et al. A finite element model for consideration of the torsional effect on the bearing contact of gear drives. J Mech Des2012; 134(7): 071007. DOI: 10.1115/1.4006831
33.
NiemannGWinterH.Maschinenelemente band 2: getriebe allgemein, zahnradgetriebe - Grundlagen, stirnradgetriebe. Berlin Heidelberg: Springer, 2003.
