Issues of gas film stability with performance characteristics in u-ECDM: A review of existing approaches and preliminary investigation on proposed stable & sustainable approach
Restricted accessReview articleFirst published online May, 2025
Issues of gas film stability with performance characteristics in u-ECDM: A review of existing approaches and preliminary investigation on proposed stable & sustainable approach
Micro-featured devices (made of glass and its composites) are becoming increasingly necessary for Micro Electro-Mechanical Systems (MEMS) and healthcare devices with the emergence of technology. Due to limitations of existing methods, Micro Electro Chemical Discharge Machining (μ-ECDM) is an evolving technique for difficult to micro machine materials like glass. However, improper flushing and unstable electrolytic conditions in the processing zone percolates the efficacy, accuracy, and repeatability of μ-ECDM. Consequently, deteriorating the sustainability and industrial feasibility of this process. To cope up with these problems, various approaches like ultrasonic assistance, rotary mode, magneto hydrodynamic are integrated and investigated with μ-ECDM in the literature. Although these approaches achieved the intended objectives but do not assure the stability and sustainability of the process, which are essential for industrial feasibility in the present scenario. The present review has stressed upon the effects of existing approaches on gas film formation, discharge characteristics and performance outcomes. Systematic review methodology indicated the extensive usage of ultrasonic vibrations in μ-ECDM and, the studies on the stability/sustainability of μ-ECDM process are neglected. According to literature and preliminary investigation, problems pertaining to the rising electrolyte temperature and heterogeneous electrolyte concentration are the attributed reasons, which affects the stability as well as sustainability. Therefore, the present review proposed an innovative approach to achieve the stability and sustainability of μ-ECDM process by controlling the electrolytic conditions (termed as controlled-ECDM). A preliminary experimental investigation witnessed the enhancement of process performance and quality characteristics in controlled-ECDM.
JainVKBalasubramaniamRMoteRG, et al. Micromachining: an overview (part I). J Micromanuf2020; 3: 142–158.
2.
JudyJW. Microelectromechanical systems (MEMS): Fabrication, design and applications. Smart Mater Struct2001; 10: 1115–1134.
3.
DarioPCarrozzaMCBenvenutoA, et al. Micro-systems in biomedical applications. J Micromech Microeng2000; 10: 235–244.
4.
JainVKPatelDSRamkumarJ, et al. Micro-machining: an overview (part II). J Micromanuf2022; 5: 46–73.
5.
LiuQZhangQZhuG, et al. Effect of electrode size on the performances of micro-EDM. Mater Manuf Process2016; 31: 391–396.
6.
CheemaMSDvivediASharmaAK. Tool wear studies in fabrication of microchannels in ultrasonic micromachining. Ultrasonics2015; 57: 57–64.
7.
BehroozfarARazfarMR. Experimental study of the tool wear during the electrochemical discharge machining. Mater Manuf Process2016; 31: 574–580.
8.
JhaNKSinghTDvivediA, et al. Experimental investigations into triplex hybrid process of GA-RDECDM during subtractive processing of MMC’s. Mater Manuf Process2019; 34: 243–255.
JainVKSreenivasa RaoPChoudharySK, et al. Experimental investigations into traveling wire electrochemical spark machining (TW-ECSM) of composites. J Eng Ind1991; 113: 75–84.
11.
MannaANarangV. A study on micro machining of e-glass–fibre–epoxy composite by ECSM process. Int J Adv Manuf Technol2012; 61: 1191–1197.
12.
BhattacharyyaBDoloiBNSorkhelSK. Experimental investigations into electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM) of non-conductive ceramic materials. J Mater Process Technol1999; 95: 145–154.
13.
MalikAMannaA. An experimental investigation on developed WECSM during micro slicing of e-glass fibre epoxy composite. Int J Adv Manuf Technol2016; 85: 2097–2106.
14.
JainVKTandonSKumarP. Experimental investigations into electrochemical spark machining of composites. J Eng Ind1990; 112: 194–197.
15.
SinghMSinghSKumarS. Experimental Investigation for generation of micro-holes on silicon Wafer using electrochemical discharge machining process. Silicon2020; 12: 1683–1689.
16.
KumarNDasAK. Machining of micro features through µ-ECSM process and evaluation of surface integrity. CIRP J Manuf Sci Technol2022; 36: 45–56.
17.
JainVKAdhikaryS. On the mechanism of material removal in electrochemical spark machining of quartz under different polarity conditions. J Mater Process Technol2008; 200: 460–470.
SarkarBRDoloiBBhattacharyyaB. Investigation into the influences of the power circuit on the micro-electrochemical discharge machining process. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2009; 223: 133–144.
20.
GuptaPKDvivediAKumarP. Developments on electrochemical discharge machining: a review of experimental investigations on tool electrode process parameters. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2015; 229: 910–920.
21.
LangenHBleulerHMasuzawaT. Micro electrochemical discharge machining of glass. Int J Electr Machining1998; 3: 65–69.
22.
FascioVWüthrichRBleulerH. Spark assisted chemical engraving in the light of electrochemistry. Electrochim Acta2004; 49: 3997–4003.
23.
BasakIGhoshA. Mechanism of spark generation during electrochemical discharge machining: a theoretical model and experimental verification. J Mater Process Technol1996; 62: 46–53.
24.
HofLAWüthrichR. Industry 4.0 – towards fabrication of mass-personalized parts on glass by Spark Assisted Chemical Engraving (SACE). Manuf Lett2018; 15: 76–80.
25.
BaharDDvivediAKumarP. On innovative approach in ECDM process by controlling the temperature and stirring rate of the electrolyte. Mater Manuf Process2024; 39: 408–426.
26.
WüthrichRFascioV. Machining of non-conducting materials using electrochemical discharge phenomenon—an overview. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2005; 45: 1095–1108.
27.
LiuJWYueTMGuoZN. An analysis of the discharge mechanism in electrochemical discharge machining of particulate reinforced metal matrix composites. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2010; 50: 86–96.
28.
WeierTLandgrafS. The two-phase flow at gas-evolving electrodes: bubble-driven and Lorentz-force-driven convection. Eur Phys J Spec Top2013; 220: 313–322.
29.
PramanikA. Developments in the non-traditional machining of particle reinforced metal matrix composites. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2014; 86: 44–61.
30.
FascioVLangenHHBleulerH. Investigations of the spark assisted chemical engraving. Electrochem Commun2003; 5: 203–207.
31.
LiuHXieeryazidanA. Study of gas film characteristics in electrochemical discharge machining and their effects on discharge energy distribution. Micromachines2023; 14: 1079.
32.
DuineveldP. Bouncing and coalescence of bubble pairs rising at high Reynolds number in pure water or aqueous surfactant solutions. Appl Sci Res1997; 58: 409–439.
33.
AllaguiAWüthrichR. Gas film formation time and gas film life time during electrochemical discharge phenomenon. Electrochim Acta2009; 54: 5336–5343.
34.
KolhekarKRSundaramM. Study of gas film characterization and its effect in electrochemical discharge machining. Precis Eng2018; 53: 203–211.
35.
SinghTDvivediA. Developments in electrochemical discharge machining: a review on electrochemical discharge machining, process variants and their hybrid methods. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2016; 105: 1–13.
36.
KulkarniASharanRLalGK. An experimental study of discharge mechanism in electrochemical discharge machining. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2002; 42: 1121–1127.
37.
JainVKDixitPMPandeyPM. On the analysis of the electrochemical spark machining process. Int J Mach Tools Manuf1999; 39: 165–186.
38.
RuszajA. Unconventional processes of ceramic and composite materials shaping. Mechanik2017; 90: 188–194.
39.
GhoshA. Electrochemical discharge machining: Principle and possibilities. Sadhana1997; 22: 435–447.
40.
JainVKChoudhurySKRameshKM. On the machining of alumina and glass. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2002; 42: 1269–1276.
41.
GuptaPKDvivediAKumarP. Effect of pulse duration on quality characteristics of blind hole drilled in glass by ECDM. Mater Manuf Process2016; 31: 1740–1748.
42.
LiuJLinZYueT, et al. An analysis of the tool electrode working mechanism of grinding-aided electrochemical discharge machining of MMCs. Int J Adv Manuf Technol2018; 99: 1369–1378.
43.
SabahiNRazfarMR. Investigating the effect of mixed alkaline electrolyte (NaOH + KOH) on the improvement of machining efficiency in 2D electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM). Int J Adv Manuf Technol2018; 95: 643–657.
44.
LeeESHowardDLiangE, et al. Removable tubing interconnects for glass-based micro-fluidic systems made using ECDM. J Micromech Microeng2004; 14: 535–541.
45.
SinghMSinghS. Electrochemical discharge machining: A review on preceding and perspective research. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2019; 233: 1425–1449.
46.
CaoXDKimBHChuCN. Micro-structuring of glass with features less than 100μm by electrochemical discharge machining. Precis Eng2009; 33: 459–465.
47.
YadavRN. Electro-chemical spark machining–based hybrid machining processes: RESEARCH trends and opportunities. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2019; 233: 1037–1061.
48.
AlarifiIM. A review on factors affecting machinability and properties of fiber-reinforced polymer composites. J Nat Fibers2023; 20: 2154304.
49.
RattanNMulikR. Experimental set up to improve machining performance of silicon dioxide (quartz) in magnetic field assisted TW-ECSM process. Silicon2018; 10: 2783–2791.
50.
ChengCPWuKLMaiCC, et al. Study of gas film quality in electrochemical discharge machining. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2010; 50: 689–697.
51.
GoudMSharmaAK. A three-dimensional finite element simulation approach to analyze material removal in electrochemical discharge machining. Proc IMechE, Part C: J Mechanical Engineering Science2017; 231: 2417–2428.
52.
HerrmannCSchmidtCKurleD, et al. Sustainability in manufacturing and factories of the future. Int J Precis Eng Manuf Technol2014; 1: 283–292.
53.
LeeHTSongJHMinSH, et al. Research trends in sustainable manufacturing: a review and future perspective based on research databases. Int J Precis Eng Manuf Green Technol2019; 6: 809–819.
54.
SharmaSSinghTDvivediA. Developments in tandem micro-machining processes to mitigate the machining issues at micron level: a systematic review, challenges and future opportunities. Mach Sci Technol2022; 26: 515–570.
55.
BhondweKLYadavaVKathiresanG. Finite element prediction of material removal rate due to electro-chemical spark machining. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2006; 46: 1699–1706.
56.
ArabJAdhalePMishraDK, et al. Micro array hole formation in glass using electrochemical discharge machining. Procedia Manuf2019; 34: 349–354.
57.
SinghDGoudM. A 3D spark model to evaluate MRR in ECDM. J Adv Manuf Syst2019; 18: 435–446.
58.
KamarajABJuiSKCaiZ, et al. A mathematical model to predict overcut during electrochemical discharge machining. Int J Adv Manuf Technol2015; 81: 685–691.
59.
PaulLKurianDG. Effects of preheating electrolyte in micro ECDM process. Mater Today Proc2018; 5: 11882–11887.
60.
SinghTDvivediAShanuA, et al. Experimental investigations of energy channelization behavior in ultrasonic assisted electrochemical discharge machining. J Mater Process Technol2021; 293: 1–14.
61.
ChuWSKimCSLeeHT, et al. Hybrid manufacturing in micro/nano scale: a review. Int J Precis Eng Manuf Green Technol2014; 1: 75–92.
62.
SharmaSDvivediA. Simultaneous electrochemical and electrodischarge machining process: an approach to sustainable manufacturing. J Manuf Process2023; 104: 123–137.
63.
ShamimFADvivediAKumarP. On near-dry wire ECDM of Al6063/SiC/10p MMC. Mater Manuf Process2021; 36: 122–134.
64.
KansalADvivediAKumarP. Development and performance study of biomedical porous zinc scaffold manufactured by using additive manufacturing and microwave sintering. Mater Manuf Process2023; 38: 1020–1032.
65.
BaharDDvivediAKumarP. Computational modelling and experimental investigation of micro-electrochemical discharge machining by controlling the electrolyte temperature. J Micromech Microeng2024; 34: 035001.
66.
KangXTangWZhaoW, et al. Experimental and numerical investigations of material removal process in electrochemical discharge machining of glass in discharge regime. Precis Eng2021; 72: 706–716.
67.
ElhamiSRazfarMR. Numerical and experimental study of discharge mechanism in the electrochemical discharge machining process. J Manuf Process2020; 50: 192–203.
68.
GoudMSharmaAKJawalkarC. A review on material removal mechanism in electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM) and possibilities to enhance the material removal rate. Precis Eng2016; 45: 1–17.
69.
WüthrichRHofLA. The gas film in spark assisted chemical engraving (SACE)—a key element for micro-machining applications. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2006; 46: 828–835.
70.
ElhamiSRazfarMR. Analytical and experimental study on the integration of ultrasonically vibrated tool into the micro electro-chemical discharge drilling. Precis Eng2017; 47: 424–433.
71.
XuYChenJJiangB, et al. Experimental investigation of magnetohydrodynamic effect in electrochemical discharge machining. Int J Mech Sci2018; 142–143: 86–96.
72.
Elhami JoosheghanSRezvaniPReza RazfarM. Characteristics and improvement of the double-pass electro-chemical discharge machining. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture. Epub ahead of print 13January2024. DOI: 10.1177/09544054231222049
73.
WüthrichRFujisakiKCouthyP, et al. Spark assisted chemical engraving (SACE) in microfactory. J Micromech Microeng2005; 15: S276–S280.
74.
SinghTArabJDixitP. A review on microholes formation in glass-based substrates by electrochemical discharge drilling for MEMS applications. Mach Sci Technol2022; 26: 276–337.
75.
RathoreRSDvivediA. Sonication of tool electrode for utilizing high discharge energy during ECDM. Mater Manuf Process2020; 35: 415–429.
76.
SinghTDvivediA. Impact of gas film thickness on the performance of RM-ECDM process during machining of glass. Mater Manuf Process2022; 37: 652–663.
77.
PawariyaKDvivediASinghT. On performance enhancement of electrochemical discharge trepanning (ECDT) process by sonication of tool electrode. Precis Eng2019; 56: 8–19.
78.
KhatriBCRathodPValakiJB. Ultrasonic vibration–assisted electric discharge machining: a research review. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2016; 230: 319–330.
79.
WüthrichRDespontBMaillardP, et al. Improving the material removal rate in spark-assisted chemical engraving (SACE) gravity-feed micro-hole drilling by tool vibration. J Micromech Microeng2006; 16: N28–N31.
80.
WangJChenWGaoF, et al. Ultrasonically assisted electrochemical micro drilling with sidewall-insulated electrode. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2016; 230: 466–474.
81.
LeeseRIvanovA. Electrochemical micromachining: review of factors affecting the process applicability in micro-manufacturing. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2018; 232: 195–207.
82.
ElhamiSRazfarMR. Effect of ultrasonic vibration on the single discharge of electrochemical discharge machining. Mater Manuf Process2018; 33: 444–451.
83.
HanM-SMinB-KLeeSJ. Geometric improvement of electrochemical discharge micro-drilling using an ultrasonic-vibrated electrolyte. J Micromech Microeng2009; 19: 1–8.
84.
RusliMFurutaniK. Performance of micro-hole drilling by ultrasonic-assisted electro-chemical discharge machining. Adv Mater Res2012; 445: 865–870.
85.
RathoreRSDvivediA. Experimental investigations and its dimensional analysis–based modeling of the UAECDM process. Int J Adv Manuf Technol2020; 111: 3241–3257.
HungJCZhangYW. Ultrasonic-assisted electrochemical discharge grinding and broaching for machining quartz square microholes. J Mater Res Technol2023; 25: 1782–1799.
88.
JuiSKKamarajABSundaramMM. High aspect ratio micromachining of glass by electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM). J Manuf Process2013; 15: 460–466.
89.
GautamNJainVK. Experimental investigations into ECSD process using various tool kinematics. Int J Mach Tools Manuf1998; 38: 15–27.
90.
SinghTAryaRKDvivediA. Experimental investigations into rotary mode electrochemical discharge drilling (RM-ECDD) of metal matrix composites. Mach Sci Technol2020; 24: 195–226.
91.
ZhengZ-PSuHCHuangF-Y, et al. The tool geometrical shape and pulse-off time of pulse voltage effects in a Pyrex glass electrochemical discharge microdrilling process. J Micromech Microeng2007; 17: 265–272.
92.
GuptaPSinghASharmaAK, et al. Influence of liquid dielectric medium on microwave-metal discharge-based drilling of AISI 304 stainless steel. Appl Phys A Mater Sci Process2023; 129: 1–16.
93.
HarugadeMWaigaonkarSManeN, et al. Experimental investigation of high speed tool rotation on heat affected zone and over cut in ECDM. Mater Today Proc2019; 18: 1472–1478.
94.
GroverSSinghSMangalSK. Hybridization of μ-electrochemical discharge machining (μ-ECDM) process: A review. Mater Today Proc2023; 80: 499–508.
95.
JawalkarCSSharmaAKKumarP. Innovations in electro chemical discharge machining process through electrolyte stirring and tool rotations. Int J Mach Mach Mater2020; 22: 487–503.
96.
SinghRPSinghalS. An experimental study on rotary ultrasonic machining of Macor ceramic. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2018; 232: 1221–1234.
97.
ChengCPWuKLMaiCC, et al. Magnetic field-assisted electrochemical discharge machining. J Micromech Microeng2010; 20: 1–7.
98.
ZhangCZhengPLiangR, et al. Effects of a magnetic field on the machining accuracy for the electrochemical drilling of micro holes. Int J Electrochem Sci2020; 15: 1148–1159.
99.
SinghTAppalanaiduBDvivediA. Improvement in energy channelization behaviour during micro hole formation in Y-SZ ceramic with magnetic field assisted ECSM process. Measurement2022; 194: 1–16.
100.
BaharDDvivediAKumarP. Optimization of Rotary-magnet assisted ECSM on borosilicate-glass using machine learning. Mater Manuf Process2024; 39: 1101–1121.
101.
HajianMRazfarMREtefaghAH. Experimental study of tool bending force and feed rate in ECDM milling. Int J Adv Manuf Technol2017; 91: 1677–1687.
102.
RattanNMulikRS. Experimental investigations and multi-response optimization of silicon dioxide (quartz) machining in magnetic field assisted TW-ECSM process. Silicon2017; 9: 663–673.
103.
YangC-KWuKLHungJ-C, et al. Enhancement of ECDM efficiency and accuracy by spherical tool electrode. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2011; 51: 528–535.
104.
HanZFangXMiaoG, et al. Controllable electrochemical discharge machining with energy–electricity regulation in glycol-based electrolytes. Int J Mech Sci2023; 247: 1–15.
105.
YangCTHoSSYanBH. Micro hole machining of borosilicate glass through electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM). Key Eng Mater2001; 196: 149–166.
106.
JawalkarCSSharmaAKKumarP. Investigations on performance of ECDM process using NaOH and NaNO3 electrolytes while micro machining soda lime glass. Int J Manuf Technol Manag2014; 28: 80–93.
107.
SabahiNRazfarMRHajianM. Experimental investigation of surfactant-mixed electrolyte into electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM) process. J Mater Process Technol2017; 250: 190–202.
108.
SinghTSharmaSSidhuSS, et al. Determination of nanoindentation behavior of HAZ on glass material machined via ECSM process through simulation approach. Materials2022; 15: 5870.
109.
RanganayakuluJSrihariPVRaoKV. An optimization strategy to improve performance in electrochemical discharge machining of borosilicate glass using graph theory algorithm and desirability index. Silicon2022; 14: 5241–5254.
110.
CaoFLiuYXuJ, et al. Probing nanoscale thermal transport in surfactant solutions. Sci Rep2015; 5(1): 16040.
111.
HanMSMinBKLeeSJ. Improvement of surface integrity of electro-chemical discharge machining process using powder-mixed electrolyte. J Mater Process Technol2007; 191: 224–227.
112.
LaioYSWuLCPengWY. A study to improve drilling quality of electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM) process. Procedia CIRP2013; 6: 609–614.
113.
YangCTSongSLYanBH, et al. Improving machining performance of wire electrochemical discharge machining by adding SiC abrasive to electrolyte. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2006; 46: 2044–2050.
114.
KimD-JAhnYLeeS-H, et al. Voltage pulse frequency and duty ratio effects in an electrochemical discharge microdrilling process of Pyrex glass. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2006; 46: 1064–1067.
115.
ElhamiSRazfarMR. Application of nano electrolyte in the electrochemical discharge machining process. Precis Eng2020; 64: 34–44.
116.
SinghSSinghIDvivediA. Design and development of abrasive-assisted drilling process for improvement in surface finish during drilling of metal matrix composites. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2014; 228: 858–867.
117.
BaharDDvivediAKumarP. Experimental investigation on the stability of electro chemical discharge machining (ECDM). Manuf Technol Today2023; 22(5): 63–70.
118.
ChakSKVenkateswara RaoP. Trepanning of Al2O3 by electro-chemical discharge machining (ECDM) process using abrasive electrode with pulsed DC supply. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2007; 47: 2061–2070.
119.
JainVChoukseyAK. A comprehensive analysis of three-phase electrolyte conductivity during electrochemical macromachining/micromachining. Proc IMechE, Part B: J Engineering Manufacture2018; 232: 2449–2461.
120.
WüthrichRSpaelterUBleulerH. The current signal in spark-assisted chemical engraving (SACE): What does it tell us?J Micromech Microeng2006; 16: 779–785.
121.
SinghMSinghSKumarS. Investigating the impact of LASER assistance on the accuracy of micro-holes generated in carbon fiber reinforced polymer composite by electrochemical discharge machining. J Manuf Process2020; 60: 586–595.
122.
SinghMSinghS. Sustainable electrochemical discharge machining process: Characterization of emission products and occupational risks to operator. Mach Sci Technol2020; 24: 739–757.
123.
BaharDDvivediAKumarP. An investigation of energy utilization behavior on borosilicate glass through heating and stirring of the electrolyte in electro-chemical discharge machining. J Appl Electrochem2024; 54: 341–360.
124.
Abou ZikiJDFatanat DidarTWüthrichR. Micro-texturing channel surfaces on glass with spark assisted chemical engraving. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2012; 57: 66–72.
125.
MaillardPDespontBBleulerH, et al. Geometrical characterization of micro-holes drilled in glass by gravity-feed with spark assisted chemical engraving (SACE). J Micromech Microeng2007; 17: 1343–1349.
126.
JalaliMMaillardPWüthrichR. Toward a better understanding of glass gravity-feed micro-hole drilling with electrochemical discharges. J Micromech Microeng2009; 19: 045001.
127.
DornfeldDA. Moving towards green and sustainable manufacturing. Int J Precis Eng Manuf Green Technol2014; 1: 63–66.
128.
GoyalAAgrawalRSahaCR. Quality management for sustainable manufacturing: moving from number to impact of defects. J Clean Prod2019; 241: 1–15.
