The role of permanent secretary represents the apogee of a career in the Whitehall bureaucracy. Even so it is under-researched and, with exceptions, notably Dunleavy et al. on bureau shaping, under-theorised. Emanating from a longitudinal survey of eight successive permanent secretaries at the Ministry of Education from 1976 to 2011, this paper identifies them as members of a meta-political class who, whilst influencing the policy decisions of politicians, are nonetheless not members of the political class. A model locating them across a spectrum of six related yet distinct genres of ‘centrism’, and a continuum of five contingent descriptive styles is used to illustrate and interpret their praxis.
KingA (1981) The rise of the career politician in Britain. British Journal of Political Science11: 249–285.
18.
KoganM (1971) The Politics of Education: Edward Boyle and Anthony Crossland, Harmondsworth: Penguin.
19.
KohoutekJNekolaMNovotnyV (2013) Conceptualizing policy work as activity and field of research. Central European Journal of Public Policy7: 28–59.
20.
MarshDRichardsDSmithM (2004) Understanding and explaining civil service reform: A reply to Dowding and James. British Journal of Political Science34: 189–192.
21.
MarshDSmithMRichardsD (2000) Bureaucrats, politicians and reform in Whitehall: Analysing the bureau-shaping model. British Journal of Political Science30: 461–482.
22.
NairneP (1990) The civil service: Mandarins and Ministers. Wroxton Papers in Politics, Paper A6, Barnstable: Phillip Charles Media.
23.
NiskanenW (1971) Bureaucracy and Representative Government, Chicago: Aldine-Atherton.
24.
Nolan (1995) Standards in Public Life. Nolan Report. Cn 2850-1, London: HMSO.
25.
NormingtonD (2013) Speaking note. In: IFG seminar on the appointment of permanent secretaries, London: Civil Service Commission,The Institute of Government, 28 January, pp.1–6.
26.
O’TooleB (1989) Private Gain and Public Service, London: Routledge.
27.
PlowdenW (1985) What prospects for the civil service?Public Administration63: 393–414.
28.
PontingC (1989) Whitehall: Changing the Old Guard, London: Unwin.
29.
RhodesR (2005) Everyday life in a ministry: Public administration as anthropology. American Review of Public Administrationxx: 1–23.
30.
RibbinsP (1986) Qualitative perspectives in research in secondary education. In: SimkinsT (ed) Research in the Management of Secondary Education, Sheffield: Sheffield City Polytechnic, pp. 3–53.
31.
RibbinsPSherrattB (1997) Radical Educational Policies and Conservative Secretaries of State, London: Cassell.
32.
RibbinsPSherrattB (2012) Permanent secretaries, consensus and centrism in policy making in education – David Hancock and the 1988 Reform Act. Educational Management Administration and Leadership40: 544–558.
33.
RibbinsPSherrattB (2013a) The permanent secretary as policy maker, shaper, taker, sharer and resister in education – Sir James Hamilton as a centralising outsider. Journal of Educational Administration and History45: 28–49.
34.
Ribbins P and Sherratt B (2013b) Michael Bichard at the Department of Education and Employment: The life and career of an un-mandarin like mandarin (unpublished).
35.
Ribbins P and Sherratt B (2013c) Portrait of a permanent secretary: Reflections on the career of Sir Geoffrey Holland – a ‘big beast in the Whitehall jungle (unpublished).
36.
RibbinsPSherrattB (2013d) Leading education in Whitehall: Examining the policy, personal and professional relationships of permanent secretaries and their secretaries of state. International Studies in Educational Administration41: 105–122.
37.
RibbinsPSherrattB (2014a) Re-forming the civil service and revising the role of the mandarin in Britain. Public Policy and Administration29: 21–44.
38.
Ribbins P and Sherratt B (2014b) ‘Centrism’ and the UK mandarin: Selected vignettes of the policy praxis of permanent secretaries (unpublished).
39.
RichardsD (1997) The Civil Service under the Conservatives 1979–1997, Brighton: Sussex.
40.
RichardsD (2008) New Labour and the Civil Service, Basingstoke: Palgrave.
41.
RiddellP (1983) The Thatcher Government, Oxford: Martin.
42.
RidleyF (1985) Political neutrality and the British Civil Service. In: Royal Institute of Public Administration (ed.) Politics, Ethics and Public Service, London: RIPA, pp. 31–42. .
43.
RoseR (1987) Steering the ship of state; one tiller but two pairs of hands. British Journal of Political Science17: 409–433.
44.
SherrattB (2004) Permanent Secretaries and Education Policy: The Meta-Politics of Bureaucratic Neutrality, University of Birmingham, Birmingham(Unpublished). PhD Thesis.
45.
SpeakeJ (1979) A Dictionary of Philosophy, London: Pan Books.
46.
ThatcherM (1993) The Downing Street Years, London: Harper Collins.
47.
ThatcherM (1995) The Path to Power, London: Harper Collins.
48.
WattsR.Ministers’ new plan to steamroller civil servants. The Telegraph,2013. 16 February, p.2.
49.
WeberM (1994) The profession and vocation of politics. In: LassmanISpeirsE (eds) Weber: Political Writings, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,pp.309–370.
