The notorious `tragedy of the commons' is incorrectly held to be the eventual fate of all resources that are used collectively rather than by individual private owners. This essay reviews several examples around the world of successful collective management of environmental resources - institutional regimes that have operated for decades or even centuries without resulting in degradation of resources. It then explores the features shared by these historically unconnected institutional regimes in order to begin specifying the characteristics of regimes that circumvent tragedy. Successful systems usually have well defined communities of eligible user-managers and clear, easily enforced and environmentally cautious rules to constrain resource use. But they vary greatly in terms of the allocation of the harvested supply of the resource, from hierarchical systems of rights with unequal allocation of the resource to very egalitarian systems that assign equal shares by lottery.
Acheson, James M.
(1987) `The Lobster Fiefs Revisited: Economic and Ecological Effects of Territoriality in Maine Lobster Fishing', in Bonnie J. McCay and James M. Acheson (eds) The Question of the Commons: The Culture and Ecology of Communal Resources, pp. 37-65. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.
2.
Agrawal, Arun (1991) `Risks, Resources, and Politics: Studies on Institutions and Resource Use From India'. PhD Dissertation in Political Science, Duke University, December 1991.
3.
Arnold, J. E. M.
and J. Gabriel Campbell (1986) `Collective Management of Hill Forests in Nepal: The Community Forestry Development Project', pp. 425-454 in Proceedings.
4.
Arnold, J. E. Michael and William C. Stewart (1991) `Common Property Resource Management in India', Oxford Forestry Institute, Department of Plant Sciences, Oxford University, Tropical Forestry Paper 24.
5.
Artz, Neal E.
, Brien E. Norton and James T. O'Rourke (1986) `Management of Common Grazing Lands: the Case of Timahdite, Morocco', pp. 259-281 in Proceedings.
6.
Ault, Warren Ortman
(1930) `Some Early Village By-Laws', English Historical Review45: 208-231.
7.
Ault, Warren Ortman
(1952) Open-Field Farming in Medieval England: The Self-Directing Activities of Village Communities in Medieval England. Boston: Boston University Press.
8.
Ault, Warren Ortman
(1954) `Village By-Laws by Common Consent', Speculum: A Journal of Medieval Studies29 (2: special issue on Medieval Representation in Theory and Practice): 378-394.
9.
Ault, Warren Ortman
(1965) `Open-Field Husbandry and the Village Community: a Study of Agrarian By-laws in Medieval England', Transactions of the American Philosophical Society (Philadelphia), new series 55 (7, October).
10.
Ault, Warren Ortman
(1972) Open-Field Farming in Medieval England: A Study of Village Bye-Laws. London: George Allen and Unwin/New York: Barnes and Noble Books.
11.
Axelrod, Robert
(1984) The Evolution of Cooperation. New York: Basic Books.
12.
Baden, John
(1977) `Neospartan Hedonists, Adult Toy Aficionados, and the Rationing of Public Lands', in Garrett Hardin and John Baden (eds) Managing the Commons, pp. 241-251. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman.
13.
Baden, John
and Richard Stroup (1977) `Property Rights, Environmental Quality, and the Management of National Forests', in Garrett Hardin and John Baden (eds) Managing the Commons, pp. 229-240. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman.
14.
Baker, Alan R. H.
and Robin A. Butlin eds (1973) Studies of Field Systems in the British Isles. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
15.
Befu, Harumi
(1968) `Village Autonomy and Articulation with the State', in John Whitney Hall and Marius B. Jansen (eds) Studies in the Institutional History of Early Modern Japan, pp. 301-314. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
16.
Berkes, Fikret
(1986a) `Local-Level Management and the Commons Problem: A Comparative Study of Turkish Coastal Fisheries', Marine Policy, July: 215-229.
17.
Berkes, Fikret
(1986b) `Marine Inshore Fishery Management in Turkey: Some Examples, Problems, and Prospects', in Proceedings, pp. 63-84.
18.
Blaikie, Piers
, John Harriss and Adam Pain (1986) `The Management and Use of Common Property Resources in Tamil Nadu, India', in Proceedings, pp. 481-504.
19.
Bromley, Daniel W. and Michael M. Cernea (1989) `The Management of Common Property Natural Resources: Some Conceptual and Operational Fallacies', World Bank Discussion Papers 57.
20.
Bromley, Daniel W.
and Devendra P. Chapagain (1984) `The Village Against the Center: Resource Depletion in South Asia', American Journal of Agricultural Economics66(5) December: 867-873.
21.
Buchanan, James M.
(1968) The Demand and Supply of Public Goods. Chicago: Rand McNally.
22.
Buchanan, James
(1975) The Limits Of Liberty: Between Anarchy and Leviathan. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
23.
Bullock, Kari
, and John Baden (1977) `Communes and the Logic of the Commons', in Garrett Hardin and John Baden (eds) Managing the Commons, pp. 182-199. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman.
24.
Campbell, Bruce
(1981) `Commonfield Origins - the Regional Dimension', in Trevor Rowley (ed.) The Origins Of Open-Field Agriculture, pp. 112-129. London: Croom Helm.
25.
Campbell, Bruce
and Ricardo Godoy (1986) `Commonfield Agriculture: The Andes and Medieval England Compared', in Proceedings, pp. 323-358.
26.
Chiba Tokuji
(1973) Hageyama no bunka [The Culture of Bald Mountains]. Tokyo: Gakuseisha.
27.
Cornell, Laurel
(1991) `A Reinterpretation of the Population History of Early Modern Japan', Chapter 1 in Cornell, Society Between Biology and Economy: The Role of Household Formation in Balancing Population and Resources in Early Modern Japan (manuscript), presented to the Triangle East Asia Colloquium, Durham, North Carolina, 9 November.
28.
Dahlman, Carl
(1980) The Open Field System and Beyond; A Property Rights Analysis Of An Economic Institution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29.
De Alessi, Louis
(1980) `The Economics of Property Rights: A Review of the Evidence', Research in Law and Economics2: 1-147.
30.
De Vany, Arthur
(1977) `Land Reform and Agricultural Efficiency in Mexico: A General Equilibrium Analysis', in Karl Brunner and Allan H. Meltzer (eds) International Organization, National Policies and Economic Development: Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series On Public Policy (volume 6), pp. 123-155. Amsterdam/New York/Oxford: North-Holland Publishing.
31.
Dodgshon, Robert
(1981) `The Interpretation of Subdivided Fields: A Study in Private or Communal Interests?' in Trevor Rowley (ed.) The Origins Of Open-Field Agriculture, pp. 130-144. London: Croom Helm.
32.
Feeny, David
(1992) `Where Do We Go From Here?: Observations on the Implications for the Research Agenda', In Making the Commons Work: Theoretical, Historical, and Contemporary Studies, co-edited by (in alphabetical order) Daniel Bromley, David Feeny, Jere Gilles, Margaret McKean, Ronald Oakerson, Elinor Ostrom, Pauline Peters, C. Ford Runge and James Thomson. San Francisco: Institute for Contemporary Studies Press (forthcoming).
33.
Fenoaltea, Stefano
(1988) `Transaction Costs, Whig History, and the Common Fields', Politics and Society16(2-3) September: 171-240.
34.
Fortmann, Louise
and Emery Roe (1986) `Common Property Management of Water in Botswana', in Proceedings, pp. 161-180.
35.
Fox, H. S. A.
(1975) `The Chronology of Enclosure and Economic Development in Medieval Devon', The Economic History Review, Second Series 38(2) May: 181-202.
36.
Fox, H. S. A.
(1981) `Approaches to the Adoption of the Midland System', in Trevor Rowley (ed) The Origins Of Open-Field Agriculture, pp. 64-111. London: Croom Helm.
37.
Frohlich, Norman
and Joe A. Oppenheimer (1970) `I Get By With A Little Help from My Friends', World Politics23(1) October: 104-120.
38.
Furushima Toshio
(1955) Kinsei iriai seido ron [On the Common Access System of the Early Modern Period]. Tokyo: Nihon hyôron shin shuppan.
39.
Gilles, Jere Lee
, Abdellah Hammoudi and Mohamed Mahdi (1986) `Oukaimedene: A High Mountain Agdal', in Proceedings, pp. 281-304.
40.
Gilles, Jere Lee
and Keith Jamtgaard (1981) `Overgrazing in Pastoral Areas: The Commons Reconsidered', Sociologia Ruralis21(2): 129-141.
41.
Glaser [Picht], Christina
(1987) `Common Property Regimes in Swiss Alpine Meadows', presented at the Conference on Comparative Institutional Analysis at the Inter-University Center of Postgraduate Studies, Dubrovnik, Yugoslavia, 19-23 October 1987.
42.
Gordon, H. Scott
(1954) `The Economic Theory of a Common-Property Resource: The Fishery', Journal of Political Economy62(2) April: 124-142.
43.
Harada Toshimaru
(1968) Kinsei iriai seido keitai katei no kenkyū: Yamawari seido no hassei to sono henshitsu [A Study of the Process of the Dissolution of the Early Modern Common Access System: Genesis and Change in the `Mountain-Division System']. Tokyo: Hanawa Shōbō.
44.
Hardin, Garrett
(1968) `The Tragedy of the Commons', now reprinted in many anthologies but originally in Science162(3859) 13 December: 1243-1248.
45.
Hardin, Russell
(1982) Collective Action. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press for Resources for the Future.
46.
Heilbroner, Robert
(1975) `What Has Posterity Ever Done For Me?', in R. Heilbroner (ed.) An Inquiry Into The Human Prospect, pp. 169-177. New York: W. W. Norton.
47.
Hoffman, Richard C.
(1975) `Medieval Origins of the Common Fields', in R. C. Hoffman (ed.) European Peasants And Their Markets: Essays In Agrarian Economic History, pp. 23-71. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
48.
Hōjō Hiroshi
(1977) Rin'ya iriai no shiteki kenkyū (jō) [Historical Research on Common Access to Forests (volume 1)]. Tokyo: Ochanomizu shobō, March.
49.
Hōjō Hiroshi
(1978) Mura no iriai no hyakunen shi: Yamanashi ken sonmin no iriai tōsōshi [A Hundred Years' History of a Village and its Common Access: the History of the Common Access Struggle of the Villagers of Yamanashi Prefecture]. Tokyo: Ochanomizu shobō.
50.
Hōjō Hiroshi
(1979) Kinsei ni okeru iriai no shokeitai [The Various Forms of Common Access in the Early Modern Period]. Tokyo: Ochanomizu shobō.
51.
Hōjō Hiroshi
and Fukushima Masao (1964) Meiji 26 nen zenkoku sanrin gen'ya iriai kankō shiryō shū: Yamanashi ken [Collected Documents from the Meiji 26 National Survey of Customary Common Access to Virgin Mountain Forests: Yamanashi Prefecture]. Tokyo: Rin'yachō.
52.
Jodha, Narpat S.
(1986) `Common Property Resources and Rural Poor in Dry Regions in India', Economic and Political Weekly21(27): 1169-1181.
53.
Jodha, Narpat S.
(1987) `A Note on Contribution of CPRs to PPR-based Farming Systems in Dry Tropical Regions of India', presented at the Common Property Resources Workshop in Sariska, Rajasthan.
54.
Jodha, Narpat S.
(1990) `Rural Common Property Resources: Contributions and Crisis', presented at the annual meeting of the International Association for the Study of Common Property, 27-30 September 1990, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina, later printed in Economic and Political Weekly/Quarterly Review of Agriculture 25(26).
55.
Kamimura Masana
(1979) Sonraku seikatsu no shūzoku, kanshū no shakai kōzō [The Social Structure of the Folkways and Customs of Village Life]. Tokyo: Ochanomizu shobō.
56.
Karpoff, Jonathan M.
(1987) `Suboptimal Controls in Common Resource Management: The Case of the Fishery', Journal of Political Economy95(1) February: 179-194.
57.
Kimber, Richard
(1981) `Collective Action and the Fallacy of the Liberal Fallacy', World Politics33(2) January: 178-196.
58.
Levi, Margaret
(1988) Of Rule and Revenue. Berkeley: University of California Press.
59.
Martin, K. O.
(1979) `Play by the Rules or Don't Play at All: Space Division and Resource Allocation in a Rural Newfoundland Fishing Community', in R. Andersen and C. Wadel (eds) North Atlantic Maritime Cultures: Anthropological Essays on Changing Adaptations, pp. 277-298. The Hague: Mouton.
60.
McCloskey, Donald N.
(1975) `The Persistence of English Common Fields', in William N. Parker and Eric L. Jones (eds) European Peasants and Their Markets: Essays in Agrarian Economic History, pp. 73-119. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
61.
McCloskey, Donald N.
(1976) `English Open Fields as Behavior Toward Risk', in Paul Uselding (ed.) Research in Economic History: An Annual Compilation of Research (Volume 1: 1976), pp. 124-170. Greenwich, Connecticut: JAI Press.
62.
McCloskey, Donald N.
(1985) `The Economics of Enclosure: A Market Analysis', in William N. Parker and Eric L. Jones (eds) European Peasants and Their Markets: Essays in Agrarian Economic History, pp. 123-160. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
63.
McKean, Margaret A.
(1982) `Japanese Experience with Scarcity: Management of Traditional Common Lands', Environmental Review6(2) Fall: 63-88.
64.
McKean, Margaret A.
(1986) `Management of Traditional Common Lands [iriaichi] in Japan', in Proceedings, pp. 533-589.
65.
McKean, Margaret A.
(1991) `Defining and Dividing Property Rights in the Commons: Today's Lessons from the Japanese Past', presented at the annual meeting of the International Association for the Study of Common Property, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, 26-29 September 1991, available as Duke University Program in Political Economy, International Political Economy Working Paper 150.
66.
McMillan, John
(1979) `The Free-Rider Problem: A Survey', The Economic Record55(149, June): 95-107.
67.
Messerschmidt, Donald A.
(1986) `People and Resources in Nepal: Customary Resource Management Systems of the Upper Kali Gandaki', in Proceedings, pp. 455-480.
68.
Netting, Robert McC.
(1972) `Of Men and Meadows: Strategies of Alpine Land Use', Anthropological Quarterly45(3): 132-114.
69.
Netting, Robert McC.
(1976) `What Alpine Peasants Have in Common: Observations on Communal Tenure in a Swiss Village', Human Ecology4(3) April: 135-146.
70.
Netting, Robert McC.
(1981) Balancing on an Alp: Ecological Change and Continuity in a Swiss Mountain Community. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
71.
Norberg, Kathryn
(1988) `Dividing Up the Commons: Institutional Change in Rural France, 1789-1799', Politics and Society16(2-3) September: 265-286.
72.
Olson, Mancur
(1965) The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
73.
Orwin, C. W.
and C. W. Orwin (1964) `The Open Fields', Past And Present29 (December): 3-25.
74.
Ōshima Mario
(1978) Kinsei ni okeru mura to ie no shakai kōzō [The Social Structure of Village and Household in Early Modern Japan]. Tokyo: Ochanomizu shobō.
75.
Ostrom, Elinor (1985a) `The Origins of Institutions for Collective Action in Common-Pool Resource Situations', manuscript, 4 September.
76.
Ostrom, Elinor
(1985b) `The Rudiments of a Revised Theory of the Origins, Survival, and Performance of Institutions for Collective Action', working paper for Workshop on Political Theory and Policy Analysis, Indiana University, December.
77.
Ostrom, Elinor
(1987) `Institutional Arrangements for Resolving the Commons Dilemma: Some Contending Approaches', in Bonnie J. McCay and James M. Acheson, The Question of the Commons: The Culture and Ecology of Communal Resources, pp. 250-265. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.
78.
Ostrom, Elinor
(1989) `Micro-constitutional Change in a Multiconstitutional Political System', Rationality and Society1(1) July: 11-50.
79.
Ostrom, Elinor
(1990) Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. New York: Cambridge University Press.
80.
Ostrom, Elinor
, Roy Gardner and James Walker (forthcoming) Rules and Games: Institutions and Common Pool Resources. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
81.
Partridge, Ernest
, ed. (1981) Responsibilities to Future Generations: Environmental Ethics. Buffalo: Prometheus Books.
82.
Peters, Pauline E. (1983) `Cattlemen, Borehole Syndicates and Privatization in the Kgatleng District of Botswana; An Anthropological History of the Transformation of a Commons', PhD Dissertation in Anthropology, Boston University.
83.
Proceedings of the Conference on Common Property Resource Management: April 21-26, 1985, Annapolis, Maryland. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences. Edited by (in alphabetical order) Daniel Bromley, David Feeny, Jere Gilles, Margaret McKean, Ronald Oakerson, Elinor Ostrom, Pauline Peters, C. Ford Runge and James Thomson.
84.
Rhoades, Robert E.
and Stephen I. Thompson (1975) `Adaptive Strategies in Alpine Environments: Beyond Ecological Particularism', American Ethnologist2(3) August: 535-551.
85.
Runge, Carlisle Ford
(1981) `Common Property Externalities: Isolation, Assurance, and Resource Depletion in a Traditional Grazing Context', American Journal of Agricultural Economics63(4) November: 595-606.
86.
Runge, Carlisle Ford
(1984) `Institutions and the Free Rider: The Assurance Problem in Collective Action', Journal of Politics46(1) February: 154-181.
87.
Schlager, Edella (1990) `Model Specification and Policy Analysis: The Governance of Coastal Fisheries'. PhD Dissertation in Political Science, Indiana University.
88.
Schlager, Edella
and Elinor Ostrom (1992) `Property-rights Regimes and Natural Resources: A Conceptual Analysis', Land Economics, August.
89.
Scott, Anthony
(1955) `The Fishery: The Objectives of Sole Ownership', Journal of Political Economy63(2) April: 116-124.
90.
Shute, Nancy
(1983) `The Movement to Sell America', Outside (September): 37-43 +.
91.
Smith, Thomas C.
(1959) Agrarian Origins Of Modern Japan. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
92.
Stigler, George J.
(1974) `Free Riders and Collective Action: An Appendix to Theories of Economic Regulation', Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science5(2) Autumn: 359-365.
93.
Tang, S. Yan
(1991) `Institutional Arrangements and the Management of Common-Pool Resources', Public Administration Review51: 42-51.
94.
Tang, S. Yan
(1992) Institutions and Collective Action: Self-governance in Irrigation. San Francisco: Institute of Contemporary Studies Press.
95.
Tate, William Edward
(1967) The English Village Community and the Enclosure Movements. London: Golancz.
96.
Taylor, Michael
(1987) The Possibility Of Cooperation. Cambridge/New York: Cambridge University Press.
97.
Thirsk, Joan
(1966) `The Origin of the Common Fields', Past and Present33 (April): in `Debates' section, pp. 142-147.
98.
Troost, Kristina Kade
(1985a) `Common Land in Late Medieval Japan', presented at the Triangle East Asia Colloquium, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, 13 April.
99.
Troost, Kristina Kade
(1985b) `The Medieval Origins of Common Land in Japan', presented at the American Historical Association, New York, 28 December.
100.
Troost, Kristina Kade (1990) `Common Property and Community Formation: Self-Governing Villages In Late Medieval Japan, 1300-1600'. PhD Dissertation in History, Harvard University.
101.
van de Kragt
, Alphons J. C., John M. Orbell and Robyn M. Dawes (1983) `The Minimal Contributing Set as a Solution to Public Goods Problems', American Political Science Review77(1) March: 112-122.
102.
Wade, Robert
(1988) Village Republics: Economic Conditions for Collective Action in South India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
103.
Wade, Robert
(1986) `Common Property Resource Management in South Indian Villages', in Proceedings, pp. 231-255.
104.
Wallace, Michael B.
(1983) `Managing Resources that are Common Property: From Kathmandu to Capitol Hill', Journal of Policy Analysis and Management2(2) Winter: 220-237.
105.
Watanabe Yōzō
and Hōjō Hiroshi (1975) Rin'ya iriai to sonraku kōzō: Kitafuji sanroku no jirei kenkyū [Common Access to Forests and Village Structure: A Case Study from the North Fuji Slope]. Tokyo: Tokyo University Press.
106.
Welch, W. P.
(1983) `The Political Feasibility of Full Ownership Property Rights: The Cases of Pollution and Fisheries', Policy Sciences16(2) November: 165-180.
107.
Wigen [Lewis], Kären (1985) `Common Losses: Transformations of Common Land and Peasant Livelihood in Tokugawa Japan, 1603-1868', MA Thesis in Geography, University of California at Berkeley.
108.
Wynne, Susan G.
(1986) `Information Problems Involved in Partitioning the Cultivation Commons', in Proceedings, pp. 359-389.
109.
Yelling, J. A.
(1977) Common Field and Enclosure in England 1450-1850. London: Macmillan/Hamden, CT: Archon Books.
