Games of public good provision, collective action, and collusion share concern for
the free rider that shirks on its obligations. According to the folk theorem, the
free rider problem can be resolved through punishment mechanisms. Versions of the
folk theorem have been applied when monitoring is imperfect. Empirical evidence
contradicts this theory: while often subjects cooperate significantly, rarely is all
shirking eliminated. To reconcile theory with empirical evidence, I provide a
theoretical basis for the inability of participants in collective action problems to
attain full compliance. I construct a general class of compliance models with
imperfect monitoring through a common signal. I derive sufficient conditions
— on both the utility of agents and the monitoring capabilities
— under which slippage from full compliance is unavoidable, showing the
limits of the folk theorem logic. The results cover most cases of concern to
political scientists and political economists including public goods provision,
contract and treaty compliance, collective action, and even Cournot competition. The
article concludes with a discussion about institutional design.
Abreu, Dilip
,
David Pearce
and
Ennio Stacchetti
(1986)
‘Optimal Cartel Equilibria with Imperfect Monitoring'
, Journal of Economic Theory39:
251—69
.
2.
Abreu, Dilip
,
David Pearce
and
Ennio Stacchetti
(1990)
‘Toward a Theory of Discounted Repeated Games with Imperfect Monitoring'
, Econometrica58(5):
1041—63
.
3.
Axelrod, Robert
(1984) The Evolution of Cooperation.
New York: Basic Books
.
4.
Axelrod, Robert and Ross A. Hammond (2003) The Evolution of Ethnocentric
Behavior. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Political Science, University of Michigan.
5.
Banks, Jeff
,
Charles Plott
and
David Porter
(1988)
‘An Experimental Analysis of Unanimity in Public Goods Provision Mechanisms'
, Review of Economic Studies55(182):
301—22
.
6.
Bednar, Jenna (1998) The Federal Problem: The Political Economy of Federal
Stability. PhD Dissertation, Stanford University Department of Political Science.
7.
Bednar, Jenna
(2004)
‘Judicial Predictability and Federal Stability: Strategic
Consequences of Institutional Imperfection'
, Journal of Theoretical Politics16(4):
423—46
.
8.
Bendor, Jonathan
and
Dilip Mookherjee
(1987)
‘Institutional Structure and the Logic of Ongoing Collective Action'
, American Political Science Review81(1):
129—54
.
9.
Bendor, Jonathan
and
Piotr Swistak
(1997)
‘The Evolutionary Stability of Cooperation'
, American Political Science Review91(2):
290—307
.
10.
Bhaskar, V.
and
Eric van Damme
(2002)
‘Moral Hazard and Private Monitoring'
, Journal of Economic Theory102(1):
16—39
.
11.
Boyd, Robert
(1988)
‘Is the Repeated Prisoner's Dilemma a Good Model of
Reciprocal Altruism?'
, Ethology and Sociobiology9:
211—22
.
12.
Brown Weiss, Edith
and
Harold K. Jacobson
(1998) Engaging Countries: Strengthening Compliance with
International Environmental Accords.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
13.
Chayes, Abram
and
Antonia Handler Chayes
(1993)
‘On Compliance'
, International Organization47(2):
175—205
.
14.
de Figueiredo, Rui
and
Barry R. Weingast
(2005)
‘Self-enforcing Federalism: Solving the Two Fundamental Dilemmas'
, Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization21(1):
103–135
.
15.
Dougherty, Keith L.
(2001) Collective Action under the Articles of
Confederation.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
16.
Downs, George W.
and
David M. Rocke
(1995) Optimal Imperfection?Domestic Uncertainty and Institutions in International Relations.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
17.
Downs, George W.
,
David M. Rocke
and
Peter N. Barsoom
(1996)
‘Is the Good News about Compliance Good News about Cooperation?'
, International Organization50(3):
379—406
.
18.
Fearon, James D.
(1998)
‘Bargaining, Enforcement, and International Cooperation'
, International Organization52(2):
269—305
.
19.
Fearon,James D.
and
David D. Laitin
(1996)
‘Explaining Interethnic Cooperation'
, The American Political Science Review90(4):
715—35
.
20.
Feinberg, Robert
and
Christopher Snyder
(2002)
‘Collusion with Secret Price Cuts: An Experimental Investigation'
, Economics Bulletin3(6):
1—11
.
21.
Fudenberg, Drew
and
Eric Maskin
(1986)
‘The Folk Theorem in Repeated Games with Discounting or with
Incomplete Information'
, Econometrica54(3):
533—54
.
22.
Fudenberg, Drew
,
David Levine
and
Eric Maskin
(1994)
‘The Folk Theorem with Imperfect Public Information'
, Econometrica62(5):
997—1039
.
23.
Gintis, Herbert
(2000) Game Theory Evolving: A Problem-centered Introduction
to Modeling Strategic Interaction.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
24.
Green, Edward J.
and
Robert H. Porter
(1984)
‘Noncooperative Collusion under Imperfect Information'
, Econometrica52(1):
87—100
.
25.
Greif, Avner
,
Paul Milgrom
and
Barry R. Weingast
(1994)
‘Coordination, Commitment, and Enforcement: The Case of the
Merchant Guild'
, The Journal of Political Economy102(4):
745—76
.
26.
Hardin, Garrett
(1968)
‘The Tragedy of the Commons'
, Science162:
1243—8
.
27.
Huberman, Bernardo A.
and
Natalie S. Glance
(1993)
‘Evolutionary Games and Computer Simulations'
, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences90:
7716—18
.
28.
Koremenos, Barbara
,
Charles Lipson
and
Duncan Snidal
(2001)
‘The Rational Design of International Institutions'
, International Organization55(4):
761—800
.
29.
Krasner, Stephen D.
(1991)
‘Global Communications and National Power: Life on the Pareto Frontier'
, World Politics43(3):
336—66
.
30.
Kreps, David M.
(1990) A Course in Microeconomic Theory.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
31.
Ledyard, John O.
(1995) ‘Public Goods: A Survey of Experimental
Research', in
John H. Kagel
and
Alvin E. Roth
(eds) The Handbook of Experimental Economics, pp.
111—94.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
32.
Mas-Colell, Andreu
,
Michael D. Whinston
and
Jerry R. Green
(1995) Microeconomic Theory.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
33.
Morrow, James D.
(1994)
‘Modeling the Forms of International Cooperation: Distribution
versus Information'
, International Organization48(3):
387—423
.
34.
Morrow, James D.
(2001)
‘The Institutional Features of the Prisoners of War Treaties'
, International Organization55(4):
971—92
.
35.
Olson, Mancur
(1965) The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the
Theory of Groups.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
36.
Ostrom, Elinor
(1990) Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions
for Collective Action.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
37.
Ostrom, Elinor
(1999)
‘Coping with Tragedies of the Commons'
, Annual Review of Political Science2:
493—535
.
38.
Ostrom, Elinor
,
James Walker
and
Roy Gardner
(1992)
‘Covenants with and without a Sword: Self-governance Is Possible'
, American Political Science Review86(2):
404—17
.
39.
Palfrey, Thomas R.
and
Jeffrey E. Prisbrey
(1997)
‘Anomalous Behavior in Public Goods Experiments: How Much and Why?'
, American Economic Review87(5):
829—46
.
40.
Rosendorff, B. Peter
and
Helen Milner
(2001)
‘The Optimal Design of International Trade Institutions:
Uncertainty and Escape'
, International Organization55(4):
829—58
.
41.
Saijo, Tatsuyoshi
and
Hideki Nakamura
(1995)
‘The “Spite'' Dilemma in Voluntary
Contributions Mechanism Experiments'
, Journal of Conflict Resolution39(3):
535—60
.
42.
Scholz, John T.
and
Mark Lubell
(1998)
‘Trust and Taxpaying: Testing the Heuristic Approach to
Collective Action'
, American Journal of Political Science42(2):
398—417
.
43.
Simmons, Beth A.
(2000)
‘International Law and State Behavior: Commitment and Compliance
in International Monetary Affairs'
, American Political Science Review94(4):
819—35
.
44.
Weesie, Jeroen
and
Reinhard Wippler
(1987)
‘The Cumulation of Incompetence in Organizations'
, Journal of Mathematical Sociology12:
347—82
.
45.
Weingast, Barry R.
(1997)
‘The Political Foundations of Democracy and the Rule of Law'
, American Political Science Review91(2):
245—63
.
