Marketization of the employment relationship is a key causal factor explaining the adverse impact of subcontracting low-wage services on employment conditions. This article extends existing sociological theory by analysing the market-making and rule-breaking roles of client and subcontractor firms through qualitative data. It finds that client organizations construct different types and temporalities of marketized cost pressures, that clients and subcontractors exploit their power advantage over labour to evade institutional rules and that labour process and reputational concerns impose a degree of moderation towards socially desirable outcomes. The theoretical framework ‘unpacks’ marketization by distinguishing the interplay between contracts, regulation and labour process requirements as shaped by clients and subcontractors. In the UK cleaning sector, the potentially positive effects of client and subcontractor actions on employment conditions are marginal, focused on non-pay aspects and introduced primarily for reputational reasons. The evidence indicates the limits of voluntary action and the need for regulation.
AllenJHenryN (1997) Ulrich Beck’s risk society at work: labour and employment in the contract service industries. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers22(2): 180–196.
BachSGivanRK (2010) Regulating employment conditions in a hospital network: the case of the Private Finance Initiative. Human Resource Management Journal20(4): 424–439.
4.
BerlinskiS (2008) Wages and contracting out: does the law of one price hold?British Journal of Industrial Relations46(1): 59–75.
5.
BoltonSCWibberleyG (2014) Domiciliary care: the formal and informal labour process. Sociology48(4): 682–697.
6.
BowmanAFolkmanP, Froud J, et al. (2015) What a Waste: Outsourcing and How It Goes Wrong. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
7.
CampbellIPeetersM (2008) Low pay, compressed schedules and high work intensity: a study of contract cleaners in Australia. Australian Journal of Labour Economics11(1): 27–46.
8.
CampbellJL (2004) Institutional Change and Globalization. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
9.
CarrollMVincentSHassardJCookeFL (2005) The strategic management of contracting in the private sector. In: MarchingtonMGrimshawDRuberyJWillmottH (eds) Fragmenting Work: Blurring Organizational Boundaries and Disordering Hierarchies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 89–110.
CoeNJohnsJWardK (2009) Agents of casualisation? The temporary staffing industry and labour market restructuring in Australia. Journal of Economic Geography9: 55–84.
12.
CollingT (2005) Managing human resources in the networked organisation. In: BachS (ed.) Managing Human Resources. Oxford: Blackwell, 90–112.
13.
CunninghamIJamesP (2009) The outsourcing of social care in Britain. Work, Employment and Society23(2): 363–375.
14.
CunninghamIBainesDCharlesworthS (2014) Government funding, employment conditions and work organization in non-profit community services: a comparative study. Public Administration92(3): 582–598.
15.
DetertJRTreviñoLK (2010) Speaking up to higher-ups: how supervisors and skip-level leaders influence employee voice. Organization Science21(1): 249–270.
16.
DoellgastVBattRSørensenOH (2009) Introduction: institutional change and labour market segmentation in European call centres. European Journal of Industrial Relations15(4): 349–371.
17.
DoellgastVSarmiento-MirwaldtKBenassiC (2015) Union campaigns to organize across production networks in the European telecommunications industry. In: DrahokoupilJ (ed) The Outsourcing Challenge: Organizing Workers across Fragmented Production Networks. Brussels: ETUI, 177–198.
18.
DoellgastVSarmiento-MirwaldtKBenassiC (2016) Contesting firm boundaries: institutions, cost structures, and the politics of externalization. ILR Review69(3): 551–578.
19.
DrukerJWhiteG (2013) Employment relations on major construction projects: the London 2012 Olympic construction site. Industrial Relations Journal44(5-6): 566–583.
20.
FleckerJMeilP (2010) Organisational restructuring and emerging service value chains. Work, Employment and Society24(4): 680–698.
21.
GreerIBreidhalKKnuthMLarsenF (2017) The Marketization of Employment Services. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
22.
GrimshawDRuberyJMarchingtonM (2010) Managing people across hospital networks in the UK: multiple employers and the shaping of HRM. Human Resource Management Journal20(4): 407–423.
23.
GrimshawDVincentSWillmottH (2002) Going privately: partnership and outsourcing in UK public services. Public Administration80(3): 475–502.
24.
HarveyMRamloganRRandlesS (eds) (2007) Karl Polanyi: New Perspectives on the Place of Economy in Society. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
25.
HolstH (2008) The political economy of trade union strategies in Austria and Germany: the case of call centres. European Journal of Industrial Relations14(1): 25-45.
26.
HolstH (2014) ‘Commodifying institutions’: vertical disintegration and institutional change in German labour relations. Work, Employment and Society28(1): 3–20.
27.
HowcroftDRichardsonH (2012) The back office goes global: exploring connections and contradictions in shared service centres. Work, Employment and Society26(1): 111–127.
28.
HymanR (1987) Strategy or structure? Capital, labour and control. Work, Employment and Society1(1): 25–55.
29.
JaehrlingKMéhautP (2013) Varieties of institutional avoidance: employers’ strategies in low-waged service sector occupations in France and Germany. Socio-Economic Review11(4): 687–710.
30.
JamesPWaltersDSampsonHWadsworthE (2015) Regulating the employment dynamics of domestic supply chains. Journal of Industrial Relations57(4): 526–543.
31.
KesslerICoyle-ShapiroJPurcellJ (1999) Outsourcing and the employee perspective. Human Resource Management Journal9(2): 5–19.
32.
KirovVHohnenP (2015) Trade unions strategies to address inclusion of vulnerable employees in ‘anchored’ services in Europe. International Journal of Manpower36(6): 848–873.
33.
LakhaniTKuruvillaSAvgarA (2013) From the firm to network: global value chains and employment relations theory. British Journal of Industrial Relations51(3): 440–472.
34.
LeeSMcCannD (2014) New directions in labour regulation research. In: LeeSMcCannD (eds) Regulating for Decent Work. London: Palgrave, 1–30.
35.
LittlerCRSalamanG (1982) Bravermania and beyond: recent theories of the labour process. Sociology16(2): 251–269.
36.
Lund-ThomsenPNadviK (2010) Global value chains, local collective action and corporate social responsibility: a review of empirical evidence. Business Strategy and the Environment19(1): 1–13.
37.
McCruddenC (2012) Procurement and fairness in the workplace. In: DickensL (ed.) Making Employment Rights Effective: Issues of Enforcement and Compliance. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 87–114.
38.
MacKenzieR (2000) Subcontracting and the re-regulation of the employment relationship. Work, Employment and Society14(4): 707–726.
39.
MarchingtonMVincentS (2004) Analysing the influence of institutional, organizational and interpersonal forces in shaping inter-organizational relations. Journal of Management Studies41(6): 1029–1056.
40.
MitchellIJamesP (2017) Outsourcing transitions and the employment relationship implications. Human Resource Management Journal27: 614–629.
41.
PattonMQ (2002) Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
42.
PerraudinCPetitHThèvenotNTinelBValentinJ (2014) Inter-firm dependency and employment inequalities. Review of Radical Political Economics46(2): 199–220.
43.
ReesGFielderS (1992) The services economy, subcontracting and the new employment relations. Work, Employment and Society6(3): 347–368.
44.
RuberyJGrimshawDHebsonGUgarteS (2015) ‘It’s all about time’: time as contested terrain in the management and experience of domiciliary care work in England. Human Resource Management54(5): 753–772.
45.
StreeckW (2009) Re-Forming Capitalism: Institutional Change in the German Political Economy. Oxford: OUP.
46.
ThiemannMLepoutreJ (2017) Stitched on the edge: rule evasion, embedded regulators, and the evolution of markets. American Journal of Sociology122(6): 1775–1821.
47.
WalshJDeeryS (2006) Refashioning organizational boundaries: outsourcing customer service work. Journal of Management Studies43(3): 557–582.
48.
WalshJO’FlynnJ (2000) Managing through contracts. Industrial Relations Journal31(5): 454–469.
49.
WarhurstCLloydCDuttonE (2008) The national minimum wage, low pay and the UK hotel industry. Sociology42(6): 1228–1236.
50.
WeilD (2014) The Fissured Workplace. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
51.
WillsJ (2009) Subcontracted employment and its challenge to labor. Labor Studies Journal34(4): 441–460.
52.
YinR (1994) Case Study Research: Design and Methods. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
